Key Takeaways
- A ransomware attack compounded a demand-led miss: Revenue fell 9% YoY as weak consumer demand was exacerbated by a ~25-day systems outage, costing an estimated Rs. 150–175 cr in lost sales and Rs. 70–80 cr in EBITDA.
- Recovery hinges on an early booking signal, not yet proven demand: Secondary sales and bookings are showing 12–13% growth over last year, but management cautions this is an early trend and not a full-year guarantee.
- The store expansion bet is underwater: 350 stores opened in three years now need 36–40 months to break even, not 24, and Ethnix stores older than two years have missed sales expectations. The pivot to a franchise-led model is a cost fix, not a growth fix.
- Garmenting has a structural tailwind but a near-term drag: A ~30% tariff advantage over China and a new UK FTA promise 30–40% growth over two years, but FY25 profitability was wiped out by customer renegotiations and training costs for new lines.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the 12–13% booking growth converts to sustained secondary sales, the pace of cost rationalization in the store network, and any margin recovery in Branded Apparel from its near-zero Q4 level.
The Ransomware Hit: Quantifying the Damage
- Scale of disruption: IT systems were unavailable for approximately 25–26 days, halting production, sales and supply chain operations. Normalcy was restored with support from external cyber security experts.
- Sales impact: Management estimates Rs. 150–175 cr in lost revenue attributable to the attack, calling it a "wide probable guess." Roughly 50% of the lost sales were recovered within the quarter; the balance is expected to be recovered over the next six to eight months, though a marginal portion may be permanently lost.
- Profitability hit: The EBITDA impact is pegged at Rs. 70–80 cr, a direct drag on an already demand-pressured quarter.
- Systemic vulnerability: The attack exposed operational fragility: with IT systems down, the company could not produce, sell or move goods, amplifying the damage from what was already a weak demand environment.
Agarwal: "I think anything between you can say Rs. 150 crores to Rs. 175 crores, again, it's a wide probable guess, you cannot put it exact number is on account of a ransomware. So, roughly Rs. 70 crores, Rs. 80 crores you can easily quantify in terms of profitability, the EBITDA should have been better."
Demand & The Recovery Bet
- What broke in FY25: High inflation squeezed consumer demand across the portfolio. Prolonged heat waves, general elections, fewer wedding dates and inflationary pressures compounded the weakness. In Branded Textile, dealers remain hesitant to rebuild inventory despite a second-half pickup in secondary sales.
- The early signal: Bookings for the new season show 12–13% growth versus last year, and EBO sales have performed well in March, April and May. Downstream inventory at wholesalers, franchisees and MBOs has come down, creating restocking potential.
- The caution: Management explicitly refuses to extrapolate the booking trend to the full year, calling it a "good early trend" but not a given. The recovery narrative rests on a few weeks of positive data.
- External tailwinds: The Union Budget's tax cuts are expected to put ~Rs. 1 lakh crore into taxpayers' hands, benefiting the mid-income segment. Wedding demand is expected to continue, and broader CAPEX spending should support consumption.
- The admission: Management acknowledged it should have read the weakness in last year's bookings and recalibrated the Branded Textile business earlier. That failure to act on early signals is now cited as a key learning.
Agarwal: "the bookings compared to last year to this year, we are seeing clearly a growth of anything between 12%, 13% vis-à-vis last year's bookings. And I think that is a good early trend. Can I say that the whole year is given? The answer is no."
Store Network: Expansion at the Wrong Time
- The numbers: Total retail network stands at 1,688 stores, with 35 new stores opened in Q4 including 9 Ethnix stores. Ethnix has crossed 150 operational stores and the Rs. 100 cr revenue threshold, but achieved only 75–80% of the anticipated threshold.
- Breakeven stretch: Stores that normally take 24 months to break even are now taking 36–40 months due to sustained demand weakness. Rentals and manpower costs are sitting on the P&L without delivering the expected efficiency or profitability.
- Ethnix underperformance: Stores older than two years have not achieved expected sales levels. Management attributes this to the weaker demand scenario and notes the category is largely wedding-led, making it sensitive to the wedding calendar. Only 10 stores have been closed so far.
- The pivot: Future store openings will be increasingly franchise-led rather than company-owned, a shift that transfers capital and operating risk to partners. This is a structural cost fix, not a demand solution.
- Portfolio stretch: The company has entered three new categories (Ethnix, Sleepz, Park Avenue Innerwear) and is pushing casualization in Branded Apparel. Each new category adds complexity and investment demand at a time when core profitability is strained.
Agarwal: "I think we have achieved close to 75%, 80% of the threshold which we had anticipated. As far as the stores which are older than two years, obviously, our expectation at that point of time was much higher that the stores should do well, much better sales, but that has not been achieved considering the weaker demand scenario."
Segment Scorecard
| Segment | Revenue Trend | Margin | Commentary |
|---|---|---|---|
| Branded Textile | ▼ –21% YoY | 7.0% (vs 21.8%) | Demand weakness plus ransomware-driven scale deleverage; steady-state margin target of 20–22% remains the aspiration. |
| Branded Apparel | ▼ Slight decline | 0.4% (vs 13.5%) | Store investments continued but EBO sales missed expectations, crushing store-level profitability. |
| Garmenting | ▬ Nearly flat | –2.9% (vs +12%) | Global customers renegotiated pricing; training costs for new product lines added to the drag. Tariff advantage and UK FTA provide structural upside. |
| High Value Cotton Shirting | ▼ Declined | 33.1% (vs 11.3%) | Margin inflated by a one-time Rs. 53 cr subsidy; underlying demand was weaker. |
- Garmenting tailwinds: A ~30% tariff differential versus China makes Raymond more attractive to global buyers. The UK FTA, where Raymond already does 20–22% of its garmenting business, is expected to drive 30–40% growth over the next two years, though new customer commercial orders take 12–15 months to materialize.
- Capacity ambition: Garmenting capacity expansion is underway; once complete, Raymond would become one of the largest suit makers globally. Over 20 new clients were added in FY25 across the US, UK and Europe.
Agarwal: "And I am saying for newer customers. The expansion with the existing customers will continue to happen. So, that is why it takes almost 12 to 15 months before they get into the commercial order, so to speak, a larger quantity order."
Margin & Cost: The Path Back
- The hole: Branded Apparel EBITDA margin collapsed to 0.4% from 13.5%, and Branded Textile fell to 7% from 21.8%. The overall lifestyle business is far from management's steady-state target of 14–15%.
- The steady-state promise: Management reiterated that Branded Textile margins should return to the 20–22% range and the overall lifestyle business to 14–15%, but declined to put a timeline or guidance on the recovery, saying only that "there will be an improvement."
- Cost rationalization underway: Management acknowledged delivery performance has been weaker and is being worked on. More cost rationalization is promised, though specifics were not provided.
- Working capital: Net working capital days improved marginally from 89 to 87, driven by reductions in trade receivables and inventory.
Agarwal: "in a Branded Textile we have always mentioned that it is a margin in the range of 20%, 21%, 22%, that's the kind of margin we have always been maintaining. Overall, if I look at the business, I think if I take lifestyle as a business, anything between 14% to 15% you can consider as a decent margin."
Unanswered Questions & Pushback
- Ethnix revenue specifics: When pressed for the exact Ethnix revenue figure and how short it fell of the Rs. 100 cr expectation, management confirmed the threshold was crossed but declined to provide the precise number or the shortfall.
- Inventory days: Asked for system-wide inventory in days versus normal, management offered only a qualitative description of downstream destocking and an anecdote about dealer behavior, not a number.
- Margin guidance: An explicit request for a FY26 margin range (10–12%) was met with a refusal to guide: "margin, obviously, there will be an improvement, but we would not be able to put guidance on this call."
- Discounting trend: A question about the competitive discounting environment in Branded Apparel and whether Raymond is focused on full-price sell-through went unanswered; management pivoted to discussing cost learnings instead.
- Value fashion: Asked whether Raymond should enter the value fashion segment given its manufacturing capability and that segment's growth, management deflected, stating the company has enough opportunity in existing segments and is focused on current brands.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue recovery | Return to growth trajectory in FY26, supported by positive booking trends | FY26 |
| Ethnix store expansion | Reach 300 stores, predominantly franchise-led | Over next 36 months |
| Garmenting growth from UK FTA | 30–40% growth from the UK market | Over next two years |
| New customer commercial orders (UK FTA) | Larger quantity commercial orders from new customers | 12–15 months |
| Ransomware sales recovery | Balance of lost sales recovered | Next 6–8 months |
| Cost rationalization | Continued cost rationalization across the business | Ongoing (no end date) |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹1,580 cr, down 9% YoY from ₹1,728 cr in Q4 FY24 |
| Full-year revenue (FY25) | ₹6,360 cr total net income |
| Full-year EBITDA | ₹651 cr, EBITDA margin of 10.2% |
| Branded Textile revenue | ₹727 cr, down 21% YoY from ₹920 cr in Q4 FY24 |
| Branded Textile EBITDA margin | 7.0%, down from 21.8% in Q4 FY24 |
| Branded Apparel revenue | ₹391 cr, down from ₹409 cr in Q4 FY24 |
| Branded Apparel EBITDA margin | 0.4%, down from 13.5% in Q4 FY24 |
| Garmenting revenue | ₹248 cr, down from ₹250 cr in Q4 FY24 |
| Garmenting EBITDA margin | -2.9%, down from 12% in Q4 FY24 |
| High Value Cotton Shirting revenue | ₹185 cr, down from ₹213 cr in Q4 FY24 |
| High Value Cotton Shirting EBITDA margin | 33.1%, up from 11.3% in Q4 FY24; includes one-time subsidy of ₹53 cr |
| Net cash position | ₹90 cr as of March 31, 2025 |
| Net working capital | 87 days (₹1,473 cr), improved from 89 days (₹1,553 cr) in December 2024 |
| Total retail store network | 1,688 stores as of March 31, 2025; 35 new stores opened in Q4 including 9 Ethnix stores |
| Ethnix by Raymond stores | 150-plus operational stores |
| Ethnix revenue | Crossed ₹100 cr threshold in FY25 |
| Ransomware impact on sales | ₹150–175 cr estimated sales loss in Q4; roughly ₹70–80 cr EBITDA impact |
| Bookings growth (early FY26 trend) | 12–13% growth vis-à-vis last year's bookings |
| FY26 revenue growth outlook | 10–15%, possibly slightly higher (per management commentary) |
| Steady-state Branded Textile margin | 20–22% (management guidance) |
| Steady-state overall lifestyle margin | 14–15% (management guidance) |
| Garmenting UK exposure | 20–22% of garmenting business; expect 30–40% growth over next two years from UK FTA |
| Stores opened in last three years | 350 stores |
| Store breakeven timeline | 24 months normally; extends to 36–40 months in weaker demand |