Key Takeaways
- Loan book flat, but green shoots visible: The loan book barely moved due to high prepayments, yet the annualized repayment rate fell from 21% to 18% sequentially, and business activity picked up across 80-85% of branches.
- Yield sacrificed for quality and growth: Reported spreads of 3.3% and margins of 4.6% remain healthy, but yield declined sequentially as the company chose to reprice loans to retain good customers, waive penal interest, and offer concessions to acquire new business.
- Asset quality is the central bet: Stage II assets fell sequentially, but GNPA guidance is withheld for Q2. Management is provisioning an extra ₹20 crores per quarter as a cushion while striving to bring GNPA down to ₹700 crores by year-end.
- Credit cost ceiling is the hard commitment: Full-year credit cost is capped at ₹100 crores, with management stating it will not exceed this budgeted amount. FY24 credit cost is expected to be lower.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the restructured book generates undue slippages, whether the repayment rate continues to moderate, and whether the ₹20 crore quarterly provisioning cushion proves sufficient or needs topping up.
Asset Quality & Provisioning
- GNPA spike was a one-time reset: GNPA rose from ~4.5% to ~7% in Q3 FY22 because the company recognized all accounts impacted by the RBI’s November 2021 circular, which removed the ability to upgrade accounts when overdues were less than 90 days. This impact is already factored in.
- Stage II assets declining: Stage II assets fell sequentially, indicating lower penalty generation and penalty appropriation. The exact Stage II number and the quantum of the standard restructured book as of June 2022 were not shared on the call.
- Provisioning cushion being built: An additional ₹20 crores provision was made in Q1 FY23 as a cushion, though not required by the RBI circular. Another ₹20 crores is anticipated in Q2 FY23.
- CIBIL profile improving: Over 90% of the book now has a CIBIL score above 650, against a minimum threshold of 550.
- Restructured book is the known risk: The OTR restructuring window closed in Q1 FY23 and regular billings have started. Asset quality outcomes from this pool will become clear in Q2 and thereafter, and management is trying to minimize slippages. No undue slippages are expected outside this pool.
Swaminathan: "I am still keeping my fingers crossed. I do not want to give any false hopes. Yes, ₹700 crores are there, but we are striving our best. We hope we will be able to contain the NPA percentage as much as possible, at least to an extent of 7% or something, but I am unable to give you any clear guidance as far as GNPA numbers are concerned for the 2nd Quarter."
Growth & Business Momentum
- Repayment rate moderating: The annualized repayment ratio fell from 21% to 18% sequentially, driven by interest concessions to retain customers, CIBIL monitoring for customers approaching other institutions, and sustained relationship contact with existing borrowers. Management expects the downward trend to continue.
- Broad-based activity pickup: Growth in Q1 was not concentrated in one center or branch; nearly 80% to 85% of the network participated, and momentum is continuing in the current quarter.
- Ticket sizes rising: Average ticket size improved from around ₹14.5 lakhs earlier to a range of ₹16 lakhs to ₹18 lakhs in Q1 FY23.
- Portfolio buyout executed: A small portfolio purchase of ~₹70 crores was made in Q1 FY23 as a commercial call to increase the book. Management declined to share the seller’s identity or deal-specific details, stating there is no collateral and it is a direct assignment. Primary focus remains branch-induced business.
- Network expansion restarting: Surveys for new branches and satellite centers have resumed, with openings expected in Q3 or Q4 of the current year. Numbers may be shared in the next call.
Swaminathan: "Why I am happy is, the good has happened, not just in one center or one branch, throughout the country, I am seeing some momentum, nearly some 80% to 85% has participated in the growth in the 1st Quarter. And I am seeing the momentum continuing in the current quarter as well."
Margins, Yield & Spreads
- Yield declined on deliberate choices: The sequential yield drop came from repricing loans to retain good-quality customers, a waiver of some penal interest in NPA cases, concessional fees to acquire new customers, and lower recoveries from technically written-off accounts compared to the March quarter. A lag in passing on Repo rate revisions to borrowers also contributed, since the company has no Repo-linked loans.
- Spreads and margins remain above band: Reported loan spreads were 3.3% and margins 4.6% above the debtor level of 3% and 4.3% respectively. Management expects both to remain higher than the allocated band for FY23.
- Interest cost benefit: Sequential reduction in interest paid came from the retainment of a few high-cost borrowings.
- Interest reduction may moderate: Management expects the interest reduction in coming quarters may not be to the level seen in Q1 FY23.
Swaminathan: "I think we maintain that 4.3% and 3% spread that we maintain. We will be maintaining. Hopefully in the coming quarter this interest reduction may not be to this level, hopefully."
Operating Costs & Infrastructure
- Employee costs elevated year-on-year: The YoY increase reflects the previous year’s lower base, when the first two quarters had more work-from-home, less travel, and less salary encashment. A small sequential reduction of ₹2 to ₹3 crores was seen in Q1.
- Salary revision ahead: A small increase in employee costs is expected in the current quarter, with bigger increases in the next two quarters due to salary revision. Management expects anticipated income growth to absorb this.
- Attrition easing: Attrition has come down, though exact numbers were not available. All-India recruitment was conducted in April and May, and local-level recruitment is ongoing at branches and centers.
- Process decentralization underway: Regional heads in some of the seven regions have been given sanctioning powers up to a particular limit, so loans need not come to the head office. A two-tier sanctioning structure has been implemented at the head office: one person recommends, another sanctions. Pre-disbursement verification by the head office remains mandatory.
- DSA channel being scaled: The DSA recruitment process has been simplified, and the DSA proportion is expected to reach 20% to 25% by year-end.
- Legal threshold raised: The legal requirement threshold for loans was raised from ₹15 lakhs to ₹25 lakhs, simplifying processes.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Loan book growth | 10% to 11% growth, reaching ₹13,000 crores | FY23 end |
| Credit cost ceiling | Will not exceed ₹100 crores for the full year | FY23 |
| GNPA absolute target | Bring GNPA down to ₹700 crores | FY23 end |
| Spread floor | Maintain spread at least above 3% | FY23 |
| Margin floor | Maintain margin of 4.3% | FY23 |
| ROA aspiration | 2.2% | FY23 |
| ROE aspiration | 12%, assuming ₹100 crores credit cost and 4.4x leverage; higher if actual credit cost is lower | FY23 |
| PAT estimate | Around ₹275 crores | FY23 |
| DSA channel mix | DSA proportion to reach 20% to 25% | FY23 end |
| FY24 credit cost | Expected to be less than FY23, given the quality of present assets | FY24 |
| Additional provisioning | Another ₹20 crores anticipated as cushion | Q2 FY23 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Loan book | ₹11,862 cr, +1% QoQ |
| Loan sanctions | ₹692 cr, +6% QoQ and +236% YoY |
| Disbursements | ₹642 cr, +7% QoQ and +168% YoY |
| Profit after tax | ₹62.1 cr, +93% YoY and +48% QoQ |
| ROA | 2.1%, vs 1.6% in Q4 FY22 |
| ROE | 11.9%, vs 9.6% in Q4 FY22 |
| Loan spread | 3.3%, above debtor-level 3% |
| Loan margin | 4.6%, above debtor-level 4.3% |
| Average yield | 10.23%, down from 10.3% QoQ |
| Cost-to-income ratio | 23.9% |
| GNPA | 6.4%, declined ~60 bps QoQ |
| NNPA | 4.2%, declined 70 bps QoQ |
| GNPA provision coverage | 37%, +5 ppt QoQ |
| Overall ECL provision | ~4% of loan book |
| Annualized repayment ratio | 18%, moderated from ~21% in Q4 FY22 |
| Slippages | ₹104 cr; recoveries ₹165 cr |
| Capital adequacy ratio | 34.2%, Tier I 33.2% |
| Self-employed / salaried mix | 51% / 48.8% |
| Non-housing loan share | 19.4% of loan book |
| Retail network | 158 branches, 22 satellite centers |
| Cash and cash equivalents | ₹273 cr |
| Unutilized lines of credit | ₹1,900 cr |
| DSA proportion | ~18%, expected 20–25% by year-end |
| Portfolio buyout | ~₹70 cr |
| FY23 loan book growth guidance | 10–11%, to ~₹13,000 cr |
| FY23 credit cost guidance | ₹80–100 cr |
| FY23 PAT estimate | ~₹275 cr (per management estimate) |
| ROA aspiration | 2.2% |
| ROE aspiration | 12% |
| Spread guidance maintained | 3% |
| Margin guidance maintained | 4.3% |
| Contingency provision for restructured book | ₹20 cr created in Q1; another ~₹20 cr anticipated in Q2 |
| Slippages from restructured book | ~₹15–20 cr out of ₹104 cr total slippages |
| Average ticket size | ₹16–18 lakhs, up from ~₹14.5 lakhs earlier |
| CIBIL score above 650 | >90% of book |