Key Takeaways
- Resilient quarter, pivot to brands: Despite subdued demand in core markets, profitability improved, driven by high-margin D2C and a strategic exit from the low-margin plain gold business to focus on branded jewellery.
- D2C is the margin engine: Direct-to-Consumer gross margins sit at 55%-65%, with a clear path to 15%-20% EBITDA margins in 2-3 years as scale builds and customer acquisition costs fall.
- Lab-grown diamonds are a margin tailwind, not a risk: Retail prices have not fallen as fast as wholesale, so the company is seeing gross margin expansion in D2C while consumers upgrade to bigger stones, keeping average order values stable.
- The order book supports a growth inflection: The factory order book is up 25%-30% YoY, backing management's FY25 guidance of 10%-15% studded revenue growth and 25%-30% PBT growth.
- What to watch next quarter: The pace of the gold business exit and the associated ~INR75 crore working capital release, the margin trajectory in U.S. D2C brands after a marketing agency switch, and whether the Customer Brands turnaround sustains its Q4 momentum.
Strategic Pivot: Exiting Plain Gold to Focus on Brands
- The exit: The company is exiting the plain gold manufacturing business acquired in 2016, a commodity operation with very low gross margins and 10%-13% ROCE that sold to large retailers with limited pricing power. The exit will streamline operations, reduce debt, and drive margin expansion.
- The rationale: Management wants to evolve into businesses with pricing ability and pricing power, centering strategy on building brands rather than contract manufacturing for large retailers.
- Working capital unlock: Inventory is temporarily elevated due to a strong order book, but working capital will reduce as the gold business exits, freeing up approximately INR75 crore over the next two quarters.
- No write-downs expected: Management does not currently anticipate any write-downs or capital provisions from the exit, though discussions with potential buyers are in early stages.
Sumit Shah: "I think we want to evolve the company into businesses where we've got some pricing ability and pricing power. And we did not feel strategically as a company we would be able to make a greater than cost of capital in the plain gold business selling to large retailers with limited pricing power."
Direct-to-Consumer: The Margin Story
- Gross margin profile: D2C carries high gross margins of 55%-65%, and as the business scales, management targets EBITDA margins of 15%-20% over the next 2-3 years.
- U.S. brands growing fast: The U.S. D2C segment is expected to sustain high double-digit growth in the coming year, with a substantial margin increase over a 12-month period as customer repeat rates improve and acquisition costs decline.
- Q4 marketing inefficiency: A change in digital marketing agency during Q4 caused some inefficiencies, so higher gross margins did not fully flow through to the bottom line. That drag is temporary.
- Irasva still loss-making: The India D2C brand Irasva is still in investment mode, with a plan for 50% revenue growth this year and an expectation of close to breakeven or slight profitability before expanding the store network further.
- Lab-grown diamond tailwind: In D2C, retail prices for lab-grown diamond jewellery have not dropped as steeply as wholesale prices, leading to gross margin expansion. Consumers come with a fixed budget, around $3,000 for an engagement ring, and have upgraded to slightly bigger stones rather than trading down, so average order value has not declined.
Sumit Shah: "So, I would say that on a blended basis, the realization decline has not been meaningful. And in our Direct-to-Consumer businesses, we have not seen any reduction in average order value."
Lab-Grown Diamonds: Brand Play, Not Commodity Play
- Asset-light strategy vindicated: The decision not to enter lab-grown diamond manufacturing proved prudent given the steep price fall. Instead, the company built brands around customer preferences and hosts a marketplace with hundreds of manufacturers and suppliers.
- Brand building over manufacturing: Management believes building a brand around lab-grown diamonds is harder in the short run but will be highly accretive to margins over the long run.
- Expanding across channels: Lab-grown diamonds are being introduced across all Licensed Brands and will launch in all Irasva stores in India on July 1st, giving the company a toehold in the Indian market through its four retail stores.
Sumit Shah: "While this approach is harder in the long run, we believe truly that building a brand in the long run will be the correct decision and highly accretive to the margins of the company."
Segment Performance & Brand Portfolio
- Customer Brands turnaround: The legacy segment posted 13% YoY revenue growth in Q4, with EBITDA margin improving to 8% in Q4 and 6.2% for the full year. Margins had declined from 7.5% to 6% over two years due to operating deleverage, so the recovery in demand should lift them further.
- License portfolio expansion: The company added Warner Bros. and DC to its roster, alongside existing agreements with Enchanted Disney Fine Jewellery, Hallmark, NFL, Star Wars, and Disney Treasures.
- Wonder Fine Jewellery scaling: After a successful debut with a major retail partner last quarter, the collection was introduced with another significant retailer.
- Barbie collection testing: A test with one large retail partner ran over Mother's Day; results have been received but are yet to be fully evaluated for how meaningful the opportunity will be.
Balance Sheet & Capital Efficiency
- Inventory elevated for a reason: Current inventory levels are high because of a strong factory order book that supports significant revenue growth in FY25. Working capital will reduce during the year as the gold business exits and the elevated order book normalises.
- ROE target: Management expects to reach a 15%-20% return on equity within the next two years, targeting 17%-18% over that period.
- Double-digit EBITDA aspiration: The company aims to reach double-digit EBITDA margins over the next 2-3 years, driven by mix improvement toward higher-margin branded jewellery and D2C scale.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue growth (studded business) | 10% to 15% growth ex-plain gold | FY25 |
| Profit before tax growth | 25% to 30% increase ex-plain gold | FY25 |
| Plain gold business exit | Full exit, ~INR75 crore working capital release | Next 6 months (2 quarters for WC) |
| D2C EBITDA margin | 15% to 20% | Next 2 to 3 years |
| U.S. D2C margin improvement | Substantial increase as repeat rates rise and CAC falls | Over a 12-month period |
| Irasva profitability | Close to breakeven or slight profitability before store expansion | FY25 (current year) |
| Return on equity | 15% to 20%, targeting 17% to 18% | Next 2 years |
| Double-digit EBITDA margins | Company-wide aspiration | Next 2 to 3 years |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Total income | ₹540 cr, +7.5% YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹45.4 cr, +18.5% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 8.4%, vs 7.9% in FY24 |
| Profit after tax | ₹21 cr, vs ₹19.7 cr in Q4 FY23 |
| Customer Brands revenue growth | +13% YoY |
| Customer Brands EBITDA margin | 8%, vs 6.2% in FY24 |
| Licensed Brands revenue | ₹64.3 cr, FY24: ₹437 cr |
| Licensed Brands EBITDA margin | 16.1%, vs 15.4% in FY24 |
| D2C (Owned Brands) revenue | ₹47 cr, +10.9% YoY |
| D2C (Owned Brands) EBITDA margin | 6.3%, vs 6% in FY24 |
| D2C gross margin | 55% to 65% |
| Lab-grown diamonds share of D2C sales | 48% |
| Net debt to equity ratio | 0.28 as of March 2024 |
| Total net debt | ₹322 cr, cash & bank balances: ₹188 cr |
| FY25 revenue growth guidance (ex-plain gold) | 10% to 15% |
| FY25 PBT growth guidance | 25% to 30% |
| Factory order book increase vs prior year | 25% to 30% |