Key Takeaways
- A tale of two businesses: Electronics (ex-India) and solar are growing strongly, while aluminium die casting automotive losses and Rishabh India’s export slump dragged consolidated revenue down ~1.8% YoY.
- Alucast is the margin villain: Negative 6–7% EBITDA in the automotive die casting segment is the single biggest drag on consolidated margins; management says even breaking even would make numbers “much better.”
- Solar is the breakout story: Revenue grew 204% YoY and 126% QoQ, with manufacturing costs already down 5–6% and a further 10–15% reduction targeted through redesign.
- Guidance reset, not abandoned: FY25 revenue growth cut to ~8–10% from 18–20%, with bottom line now expected flat; the electronics side is still guided to 15–18% growth.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the two EV OEM renegotiations deliver price increases or terminations by the Q3 deadline, and whether Lumel SA’s 22% growth momentum holds.
The Alucast Problem: Contracts, Costs and a Bumpy Ride
- Long-term contracts became traps: Large EV OEMs signed long-term agreements with stringent price escalation and termination clauses, preventing Rishabh from passing through increased power costs and minimum wages.
- One OEM partially resolved: One-third of projects with the first large EV OEM got price increases, one-third will relocate to another supplier by end of October, and the remaining one-third is expected to reach resolution in two to three months.
- Second OEM still in play: Renegotiation has started; management expects either a price increase or termination, with consensus in the next one or two quarters. Until then, these projects “continue to pinch our pockets.”
- EV business was a miscalibration: The EV line, added in the last year, was expected to behave like the legacy automotive business but proved “more challenging”; management says “we are learning. We have learned it.”
- Non-automotive die casting is stable: Roughly 50% of the die cast business serves automation customers and generates sustainable EBITDA margins, providing a floor under the segment.
- Portfolio management, not growth-at-all-costs: The focus has shifted from driving both top line and bottom line to prioritizing bottom line; management will “scale up, guide our top line based on how we perform on the bottom line.”
Musalekar: “We are yet to reach consensus until then these projects will also continue to pinch our pockets. But we are of the firm belief that we will be able to reach consensus in the next one or two quarters. In actual, we will have some bumpy rides until Q3 from this part of the business and we are really working hard to stabilize the same.”
Electronics: Lumel SA Powers Ahead While India Stumbles
- Lumel SA delivered standout growth: Revenue up 22.4% YoY and 14.5% QoQ, EBITDA up 47.6% YoY, driven by industrial sector expansion, value-added automation and turnkey projects, and higher government spending on energy transition infrastructure.
- Rishabh India electronics de-grew: Standalone revenue down 7.2% YoY and EBITDA down 47% YoY, hit by subdued export demand particularly from Germany and Spain.
- India recovery expected: Management expects double-digit growth in the India business, citing spillover of export orders from Q1.
- Lumel SA won a strategic energy project: In February 2024, it secured a project to develop control and protection devices for strategic areas of the energy industry under the European Funds for Modern Economy program, with execution over the next three years.
- Capacity expansion underway: New assembly lines and SMT lines are being finalized for Lumel SA’s EMS business, and a third SMT line investment has already been made.
- China operations beginning to contribute: The Chinese setup is now sourcing raw materials and electrical components for Lumel SA and Indian companies, while China-made products have been launched through Rishabh’s global sales network with a ₹3 crore target this financial year that management is “confident of beating.”
Solar: The Breakout Business
- Revenue exploded: Solar business grew 204% YoY and 126% QoQ, with management targeting ~₹100 crore turnover in three to four years and expecting to “almost double year after year.”
- Cost competitiveness improving fast: Manufacturing costs reduced 5–6% in the last quarter through product redesign; a further 10–15% reduction is targeted, with an eventual ambition of another 15–20% beyond that to compete with Chinese supply.
- Product pipeline filling the lower end: Single-phase UNO inverters covering 2.5 to 6 kilowatts are at an advanced stage of development and expected by end of December, aimed at PM KUSUM schemes; the range is also expanding from 50 kilowatt to 150 kilowatt.
- Government budget tailwind: Management cited robust momentum and government budget support as underpinning its confidence in the solar trajectory.
Strategic Moves: SCADA Acquisition, New Products and Facilities
- Microsys acquisition adds software layer: Rishabh acquired 100% of Microsys, spol. s r.o., a 33-year-old Czech Republic company with the PROMOTIC brand of SCADA software, three days before the call. The ~15-person team (about 12 senior software engineers) provides forward integration for IIOT products.
- System-selling unlocks value: Management sees the ability to sell products bundled with software and applications as a margin lever, citing the difference between a EUR400–500 individual product sale and a system sale.
- Global distribution planned: PROMOTIC software will be taken to market through Rishabh’s entire global network, including Sifam Tinsley in the US and UK.
- New products stacking up: UL certified NC current transformers for the US market launched with orders from the US subsidiary; DIN mounted DC energy meters for EV charging stations; digital earth testers, compact insulation testers, recorders, and the KD10 series. About 15 product lines are in the industrial automation pipeline for this financial year.
- MID certified energy meters near launch: 27 types are ready and going through final certification.
- Nashik construction on track: Two facilities (R&D centre and main factory) with basement, ground and six storeys are under construction, expected operational by January 2026.
- IIT Mumbai R&D centre: Being set up to develop breakthrough products with access to the IIT ecosystem.
- 10% incremental revenue target: Management aims to generate 10% of revenue from products added in this year and the last two years.
Musalekar: “This software product will help us to boost sales of our IIOT… this will help to integrate those with the software, and our customers will have a higher value addition. We will also use our global network to promote and sell this SCADA in all possible industrial automation projects around the world.”
Margins: Alucast Drag Obscures the Underlying Picture
- Alucast EBITDA turned negative: At minus 6–7%, it is the biggest drag on consolidated margins; management stated that even bringing it to zero would make the numbers “much better.”
- Two to three quarters to improvement: Management expects Alucast to improve over the next two to three quarters and is confident about the business on a one-to-two-year horizon.
- Previous margin recovery targeted: The plan is to return to previous consolidated EBITDA margins of 15–16% by next financial year.
- Scenario planning is live: If automotive customers agree to price increases (even if not to the level asked), the business grows; if they source from China instead, the automotive die casting business may shrink and management will increase non-automotive focus.
- India Alucast acquisition on the back burner: Due diligence was completed but time lapsed without meeting conditions precedent; the company is not actively pursuing it now but keeps looking for opportunities, and has no divesting strategy for Alucast “as of now.”
Goliya: “It’s only this new business, this EV is a completely new line which has come in the last one year. And we thought it would be similar to our other automotive business, but unfortunately it has been more challenging. But we are learning. We have learned it.”
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| EV OEM 1 renegotiation completion | Remaining one-third of projects resolved | Next 2–3 months |
| EV OEM 2 renegotiation completion | Price increase or termination agreed | Next 1–2 quarters |
| Alucast improvement | Segment to improve from current negative EBITDA | 2–3 quarters |
| Consolidated EBITDA margin recovery | Return to 15–16% EBITDA margins | Next financial year |
| FY25 revenue growth | ~8–10% consolidated (electronics 15–18%, die casting flat) | FY25 |
| FY25 bottom line growth | Flat | FY25 |
| Single-phase UNO inverters launch | 2.5–6 kW range ready | End of December |
| Nashik facilities operational | R&D centre and main factory | January 2026 |
| Solar business turnover | Reach ~₹100 crore | 3–4 years |
| Lumel SA energy project execution | Control and protection devices development | Over next 3 years |
| New product revenue contribution | 10% of revenue from products added this year and last two years | This financial year |
| China products revenue | ₹3 crore target (management confident of beating) | This financial year |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | ₹169.3 cr, down 1.8% YoY |
| Consolidated adjusted EBITDA | ₹10.9 cr, down 59% YoY |
| Consolidated adjusted EBITDA margin | 6.4% |
| Consolidated PBT | ₹4.6 cr, down 59% YoY |
| ESOP expense | ₹3.3 cr in Q1; another ₹8.2 cr expected in FY25 |
| Net cash and cash equivalents | ₹107.2 cr as on 30 June 2024 |
| Electronics business revenue | ₹93.9 cr, 55% of consolidated top line |
| Electronics business adjusted EBITDA margin | ~16% |
| Rishabh India standalone revenue | ₹52.7 cr, down 7.2% YoY |
| Rishabh India standalone EBITDA margin | 14.4% |
| Rishabh India domestic business growth | 10% YoY |
| Lumel SA revenue | ₹49 cr, up 22.4% YoY and 14.5% QoQ |
| Lumel SA adjusted EBITDA | ₹8.3 cr, up 47.6% YoY |
| Lumel SA EBITDA margin | 17% |
| Alucast revenue | ₹68.4 cr, flat YoY |
| Alucast adjusted EBITDA | minus ₹4.6 cr, turned negative from ₹0.5 cr in Q1 FY24 |
| Solar string inverter revenue growth | 204% YoY and 126% QoQ |
| Solar business cost reduction achieved | 5% to 6% in the last quarter; target to add another 15% to 20% |
| R&D investment | ~2% of revenues |
| Revenue guidance (FY25) | 8% to 10% growth, revised from initial forecast of 18% to 20% |
| Electronics business growth guidance (FY25) | 15% to 18% |
| Solar business revenue target | ₹100 cr in next three to four years |
| China products revenue target | ₹3 cr for FY25 |
| New products incremental revenue target | 10% of revenues from products added this year and last two years |