Key Takeaways
- Growth masked by margin pain: Revenue grew double digits across segments, but EBITDA fell sharply as new automotive die casting projects and flat India sales drained profitability.
- One bleeding segment explains the miss: 80% of the margin gap traces to new EV project launches in aluminum die casting, a known and quantified problem management says will stabilize in 6–9 months.
- Solar inverters are real but early: Revenue grew 20x+ YoY to 5–6% of the top line, yet the business only covers G&A at current scale and carries structurally low margins.
- Guidance held, recovery promised: Management maintained its 18% adjusted EBITDA target for FY24 and FY25, betting on a seasonally strong Q4 and stabilization of draining projects.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the 1–2% Q4 EBITDA uptick materializes, any progress on the die casting stabilization timeline, and deployment of the untouched ₹66 cr IPO CAPEX.
The Margin Story: One Segment Bleeding
- Die casting is the problem, not the company: The aluminum die casting plant runs at 50% automotive exposure, and roughly half of that automotive book (25% of the plant) consists of new project launches that have not reached stabilization. Management calls it "one Company, one product segment of one industry which is bleeding."
- New project economics: These EV projects carry 4–8 year revenue visibility and were bid assuming ideal cycle times and sub-10,000 PPM rejections. In reality, first batches generate ~10% scrap, require rework and design changes with customer engineers, and take far longer to stabilize than the two weeks typical for mature products.
- The value-add mix matters: Only 10% of die casting output is raw casting; 90% goes through machining and further processing. Products that run through the full value chain carry margins comparable to the electronics business, so the drag is concentrated in the ramp-up phase of technically challenging new work.
- India flat quarter added pressure: Standalone India revenue was flat YoY at ₹45.8 cr in Q3, contributing roughly 20% of the margin pressure. 9M performance was stronger at 23% growth, and management expects government infrastructure spending to pull Q4 and beyond higher.
- Other expense creep: Higher manufacturing costs from increased volumes, wage rate inflation for subcontractors in Poland, a tax provision in Lumel Alucast, and elevated power and fuel rates in Lumel all added to the cost base.
Dinesh Musalekar: "The only stress we have now is on the automotive business which is 50% of our business in aluminum die casting plant. Out of which, about half of them we have a new project launch. So, they are having stress on the margins. So, we know exactly it's one Company, one product segment of one industry which is bleeding, and we know that it will take 6 to 9 months to fix it."
Q3 EBITDA: The Bridge
- Headline EBITDA masked by two non-operational items: ESOP costs of ₹5.1 cr (nil last year) and a withholding tax provision of ₹3.6 cr taken as abundant precaution. Adjusted EBITDA excluding both rose 42% YoY on a 9M basis, with margin up 141 bps.
- Operational drag is the real story: Even after stripping out ESOP and the tax provision, the core operational EBITDA was pressured by new product development costs in die casting and flat India absorption. Management pegs 80% of the gap to new automotive projects and 20% to the India top-line stall.
- No quantified bridge yet: When pressed for an exact split of the ~₹12–12.5 cr gap, management acknowledged "not all of it" is product development cost and cited higher operational expenses, but did not provide a breakdown. A commitment was made to present an EBITDA bridge in future releases.
- Q4 expectation: Management expects a 1–2% EBITDA notch-up from higher electronics sales and stabilization of the draining costs, with no further significant product development costs anticipated in the quarter.
Dinesh Musalekar: "See, we are, this is the first year of we being in the market. We have been a very conservative Company, private limited Company. We always wanted to expense out whatever we could. That's the way we run the Company. So, we have to moderate. We are learning it quarter by quarter now."
Solar Inverters: Early Stage, Structurally Low Margin
- Explosive growth from a tiny base: The solar string inverter business grew revenue 20x+ YoY and now contributes 5–6% of the consolidated top line, up from 1–2%. The product range (3kW to 20kW in three-phase) is tailor-made for India's 1 crore solar houses scheme.
- Margins are thin by design: At current volumes, the business only covers G&A expenses (14–15% of turnover) and contributes nothing to PAT or EBITDA. Gross margins top out at 15–20% because the company competes against Chinese manufacturers who produce in millions and have forced many global competitors to shut down.
- Scale is the thesis: Management targets crossing ₹100 cr in revenue in 2–3 years as a first milestone, at which point margins would reach 5–6% max. ROI improves with volumes because the business requires lower incremental investment. The company declined to endorse analyst projections of ₹400–500 cr in 3–4 years.
- Product roadmap expanding: Single-phase products (2kW to 12kW) are in development for next year, and an upper range up to 120kW is in R&D. A marketing campaign in Varanasi aims to capture share from a 25,000-inverter deployment running through April.
Dinesh Musalekar: "We are competing against Chinese manufacturing cost, so, which is really, really challenging to tell you very honestly, because Chinese make them in millions and supply to the whole world. So, they have forced a lot of companies which were manufacturing inverters around the world to close down."
Electronics & Lumel: The Bright Spot
- Lumel SA thriving despite European slowdown: The Polish electronics operation is growing through penetration into medium voltage, industrial automation, and green energy segments. Management says the clean energy product portfolio more than offsets shrinkage in weaker European end markets.
- New products are margin-accretive here: Unlike die casting, where new products are OEM designs with complex ramp-ups, the electronics business develops its own products that carry higher margins. Twenty-five new products were added in 9M FY24, and new products from the last two years contributed ~10% of incremental top-line growth.
- EMS business nearing capacity: A dedicated SMT line for the EMS business in Lumel SA is running at 90% utilization, supported by a new state-of-the-art line costing ~€0.5 million. Management may invest further as the business develops.
- China operations recovering post-COVID: The Shanghai V&A acquisition (2019) lost three years to extended lockdowns and is now in its first or second year of reorganization with R&D and infrastructure investment. The entity will also serve as a strategic sourcing hub for electronic components, with an expected 5–10% reduction in component prices for Lumel SA and Rishabh India.
Narendra Goliya: "Everybody has this question, but since we have so many products in the clean energy sector, we more than make up for this shrinkage of some of the markets."
Capital Allocation & Expansion
- IPO CAPEX still untouched: The ₹66 cr raised for expansion at the Nasik, India facility remains undeployed pending MIDC clearances. Management expects to deploy the majority in the coming financial year (FY25) over a 2–3 year horizon.
- Aluminum die casting capacity expansion: Preliminary planning is underway for one additional production hall (football-field-sized) at the Poland plant, which already has four such halls. Expected CAPEX is €4–5 million with a ~2-year timeline.
- Potential India acquisition: The company is evaluating an acquisition of approximately ₹100 cr in the aluminum die casting space in India, with due diligences ongoing. No timeline was committed.
- Customer concentration strategy: Management deliberately organizes around ~20 customer groups (not individual customers) to achieve economies of scale. Examples include ABB (12 factories), Endress+Hauser (4 locations), Siemens (4 locations), and MAHLE and VALEO (multiple entities each).
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Adjusted EBITDA margin | Reach ~18% (excluding ESOP and withholding tax provision) | Q4 FY24 |
| Adjusted EBITDA margin | Maintain 18% guideline | FY25 |
| Die casting margin recovery | Stabilize new automotive projects currently draining margins | 6–9 months |
| Solar inverter revenue | Cross ₹100 cr | 2–3 years |
| Solar inverter margin at scale | 5–6% max at ₹100 cr turnover | At ₹100 cr scale |
| China component sourcing | 5–10% reduction in electronic component prices | "In the coming year" |
| IPO CAPEX deployment | Majority of ₹66 cr deployed at Nasik | FY25, over 2–3 years |
| Withholding tax provision | Settlement of ₹3.6 cr provision | 1–2 quarters |
| EBITDA bridge disclosure | Present quantified bridge in future press releases | No specific date committed |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | ₹159.3 cr, +19% YoY |
| 9M FY24 consolidated revenue | ₹511.8 cr, +30% YoY |
| Consolidated adjusted EBITDA | ₹13.7 cr, -41% YoY |
| Consolidated adjusted EBITDA margin | 8.6%, vs 16.3% in 9M FY24 |
| Consolidated PAT | ₹7.3 cr, -59% YoY |
| 9M FY24 consolidated adjusted EBITDA | ₹83.5 cr, +42% YoY |
| 9M FY24 consolidated PAT | ₹37.6 cr, +9% YoY |
| 9M FY24 adjusted EBITDA margin (excl. ESOP and withholding provision) | +141 bps YoY |
| ESOP cost | ₹5.1 cr in Q3 FY24, vs nil in Q3 FY23 |
| Withholding tax provision | ₹3.6 cr |
| Electrical automation segment growth | +19% YoY in Q3 FY24 |
| Metering and control devices segment growth | +11% YoY in Q3 FY24 |
| Aluminum die casting segment growth | +16% YoY in Q3 FY24 |
| Portable test and measurement instruments growth | +53% YoY in 9M FY24 |
| Solar string inverters growth | +460% YoY in 9M FY24 |
| Lumel SA (Poland electronics) revenue | ₹48.5 cr, +37% YoY |
| Lumel Alucast revenue | ₹85.9 cr, +16% YoY |
| Lumel Alucast EBITDA | ₹0.8 cr |
| Standalone India revenue | ₹45.8 cr, flat YoY |
| China operations growth | +29% YoY in 9M FY24 |
| US business growth | +25% YoY in 9M FY24 |
| UK business growth | +16% YoY in 9M FY24 |
| New products added in 9M FY24 | 25 |
| New products pipeline for FY25 | 20 |
| Revenue contribution from new products added in last two years | ~10% of incremental top-line growth |
| Solar inverter revenue contribution | 5–6% of total revenue, up from 1–2% |
| Solar inverter gross margin | 10% to 15% |
| SMT line capacity utilization (Lumel SA) | 90% |
| ESOP cost guidance FY24 | ₹20 cr |
| ESOP cost guidance FY25 | ₹11.4 cr |
| IPO capex raised and unspent | ₹66 cr still untouched |