Key Takeaways
- Volume-led revenue surge, margin collapse: Revenue jumped ~73% YoY on new capacity volumes, but EBITDA margin halved to 8% as fuel costs stayed 2x vs 18 months ago and price hikes failed to stick.
- Andhra Cement acquisition is the quarter's defining event: Sagar was declared the successful bidder, adding 0.26 crore tons of installed capacity and potentially saving a year to a year and a half on the path to the 1 crore ton target.
- Pricing power is absent despite strong demand: Management could not sustain attempted price hikes and now believes prices will stay flat through Q4, with any uptick delayed until Q1 FY24.
- Fuel cost relief is real but incomplete: Domestic fuel costs are moderating sequentially, but the current drop is not below Sagar's average cost, and other input costs remain sticky.
- What to watch next quarter: The NCLT order on Andhra Cement (due 9th February), the pace of Jajpur's ramp-up toward EBITDA breakeven, and whether Q1 price hikes actually materialize.
Andhra Cement Acquisition
- Deal status: Sagar was declared the successful bidder by the resolution professional, and the Amravati Bench of NCLT has admitted the matter; the final order is awaited, with a hearing date set for 9th February 2023.
- Asset profile: The plant has an installed capacity of 0.26 crore tons and has been non-operational for the last three years.
- Restart timeline: If the NCLT order arrives before February end, management is hopeful of starting cement operations by the middle of Q1 FY24 and clinker operations by the end of Q1 FY24.
- Utilization target: Andhra Cement is expected to align with other regional players at 55% to 60% capacity utilization over the next couple of quarters once restarted.
- Net debt impact: Post-acquisition net debt should not cross ₹1,250 crores on the higher side, with the Andhra Cement transaction alone adding roughly ₹150 crore from current levels, including working capital and startup costs till Q1.
- Interest cost benefit: Once the transaction closes, current structured debt of roughly ₹450–500 crore at a higher interest rate will be rolled into a term loan, reducing interest costs.
- Strategic significance: The acquisition saves a year to a year and a half from the previously stated target of reaching 1 crore tons by 2025.
- Details withheld: Management declined to disclose valuation, capital infusion requirements, debottlenecking plans, or any scope for further expansion, citing that the matter is sub judice pending the NCLT order.
Sreekanth Reddy: "Since it's in the NCLT, at this point of time, it is sub judice for us to discuss anything in detail. We would be very happy to come back to you pertaining to the Andhra Cement acquisition contours in due course of time."
Margins & Costs
- Margin compression: EBITDA margin fell to 8% in Q3 FY23 from 14% in Q3 FY22, driven primarily by higher fuel and freight costs; management noted margins have compressed by more than 50% versus sustainable levels.
- Fuel cost trajectory: Average fuel costs rose to ₹1,866 per ton from ₹1,452 per ton YoY, though sequential moderation was observed; freight costs increased to ₹795 per ton from ₹751 per ton YoY.
- Q4 cost savings: Around ₹100 to ₹125 per ton in cost savings is expected from Q3 to Q4, driven by a favorable shift in fuel mix and operating leverage from achieving 0.14 crore tons volume.
- Fuel mix shift: Pet coke proportion increased to 76% from 66%, with a target mix of 40% pet coke and 60% domestic coal going forward; the company is currently using no imported coal at all.
- Fuel inventory buffer: Stock levels of domestic coal stand at four to four and a half months, providing healthy cover beyond Q4 and halfway through Q1.
- Sticky non-fuel costs: Management cautioned that other material and service costs have risen significantly with inflation and are not expected to come down as fast as fuel, sustaining pressure on margins even if fuel moderates.
- Power generation economics: At \$135, using RB2 imported coal for power generation would be significantly more expensive than grid power, so the company is not using it.
- Bottom line: The company reported a loss after tax of ₹27 crores in Q3 FY23 versus a profit of ₹10 crores in Q3 FY22.
Sreekanth Reddy: "The margins have always been compressed by more than 50% and then what the sustainable margins have been. In spite of that, we are not in a situation to sustain the price hike, what we attempted. I wish I had a direct answer."
Pricing & Demand Environment
- Demand strength: Demand improvements were witnessed during the quarter, driven by a pick-up in construction activity post-monsoon and the festive season; the demand outlook remains encouraging on the back of government infrastructure push and urban housing.
- Regional growth: AP and Telangana grew over 25%, Karnataka roughly 24%, Tamil Nadu roughly 20%, and Kerala 25% over the last nine months; Maharashtra was flat at roughly 3%, and Orissa was flat.
- Pricing stagnation: Prices have remained static with a slightly negative bias over the last few months, and January has been the same; small price hikes were attempted but the average remains flat over the first 1.5 months of Q4.
- Q4 pricing outlook: Management's internal belief is that prices will remain very similar for this quarter.
- Q1 price hike expectation: Management strongly believes price hikes are likely to start from the start of Q1 rather than from middle of Q4, based on historical experience, though they acknowledge they could be wrong.
- South demand forecast: After growing close to 25% over the last nine months, southern demand is expected to grow at 8% to 10% per year over the next couple of years, partly in anticipation of election-related spending by governments.
- Supply-side pressure: Significant new supply has entered and will continue to enter southern markets over the next few quarters, with new capacity commissioning expected from Shree Cements (Guntur), Chettinad (Vizag grinding plant ramp-up), Ramco, and likely UltraTech and Dalmia Bharat's commissioning.
- East region outlier: Prices in the East have been surprisingly better compared to other regions, with the last couple of months being fairly strong.
Sreekanth Reddy: "Internally, our belief is that prices probably would remain very similar for this quarter. And we think that the prices are likely to start inching up only from the start of Q1 next year."
Operations & Capacity Utilization
- Group volume: Q3 FY23 revenue growth of roughly 73% YoY was largely volume-driven following the commissioning of new capacities; FY23 full-year volume is likely to end between 0.49 crore to 0.5 crore tons.
- FY24 volume target: The initial target is to achieve 0.55 crore tons, excluding Andhra Cement volumes, with both Jeerabad and Jajpur units expected to contribute.
- Utilization skew: Capacity utilization varies widely across plants: Gudipadu at 95%, Mattampally at 65%, Bayyavaram at 68%, Jeerabad at 57%, and Jajpur at just 15%; group level stands at 60%.
- Jajpur ramp-up: The unit is operating at only 15–20% utilization because realizations were lower; management was not in a hurry to ramp up, but expects EBITDA breakeven by the middle of Q1 FY24 if current East pricing trends continue.
- Jeerabad progress: The unit is already above EBITDA breakeven.
- Blended cement shift: Blended cement share has increased sharply in absolute numbers; the mix has moved from 60-40 OPC-blended at 0.36 crore tons to 50-50 at close to 0.49 crore tons, with a target of 55–60% blended next year.
- Utilization comparability: Quarter-to-quarter utilization comparisons can be misleading because the off-season to peak-season shift alone moves utilization from 35–45% to 65–70%.
- Fuel sourcing stability: Singareni Collieries has not revised FSA coal prices and no indication of major changes is expected for at least another quarter; supply from SCCL has been very healthy with no issues in recent months.
Balance Sheet & Capital Allocation
- NCD investment closure: Past NCD investments are expected to close in Q4 FY23, with significant upside anticipated; this is expected to either generate an exceptional gain or a significant increase in other income, wiping off past losses in the current quarter.
- Net debt guardrail: Post-acquisition net debt is capped at ₹1,250 crores on the higher side.
- Capital structure philosophy: Management believes in a balanced equity-debt portfolio and has never crossed a 1:1 debt-to-equity ratio; most debts are structured very long-term.
- Deleveraging stance: It is too soon to take a call on post-acquisition capital allocation; the company may underuse working capital to save on interest cost rather than significantly deleverage.
- Maintenance CapEx: FY24 and FY25 CapEx, excluding Andhra Cement, will be limited to maintenance at not more than ₹30 crores per year across the entire group.
- Growth philosophy: The company aims to double every 10 years; the 10-year clock could be from when the current phase concludes.
Sreekanth Reddy: "We always believe that there should be a balance between equity and the debt... we have never crossed 1:1 on a debt-to-equity ratio."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Andhra Cement NCLT order | Hearing date set; final order awaited | 9th February 2023 |
| Andhra Cement restart (cement ops) | Start cement operations | Middle of Q1 FY24, if NCLT order before Feb end |
| Andhra Cement restart (clinker ops) | Start clinker operations | End of Q1 FY24, if NCLT order before Feb end |
| Andhra Cement utilization | Reach 55–60% capacity utilization | Next couple of quarters after restart |
| Post-acquisition net debt ceiling | Not to exceed ₹1,250 crores | Post Andhra Cement acquisition |
| FY23 full-year volume | 0.49 to 0.5 crore tons | FY23 |
| FY24 volume target (ex-Andhra) | 0.55 crore tons | FY24 |
| Q4 cost savings | ₹100 to ₹125 per ton reduction from Q3 | Q4 FY23 |
| Blended cement mix target | 55–60% blended | FY24 |
| Jajpur EBITDA breakeven | Achieve breakeven | Middle of Q1 FY24, if East pricing holds |
| Price hikes | Start inching up | Beginning of Q1 FY24 |
| NCD investment closure | Closure with significant upside; past losses wiped off | Q4 FY23 |
| Maintenance CapEx (ex-Andhra) | Not more than ₹30 crores per year | FY24 and FY25 |
| South demand growth | 8–10% per year | Next couple of years |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹576 cr, +73% YoY from ₹334 cr |
| EBITDA | ₹48 cr, vs ₹47 cr in Q3 FY22 |
| EBITDA margin | 8%, vs 14% in Q3 FY22 |
| Loss after tax | ₹27 cr, vs profit of ₹10 cr in Q3 FY22 |
| Average fuel cost per ton | ₹1,866, vs ₹1,452 in Q3 FY22 |
| Freight cost per ton | ₹795, vs ₹751 in Q3 FY22 |
| Gross debt | ₹1,391 cr, of which ₹1,222 cr long-term, remainder working capital |
| Net worth (consolidated) | ₹1,554 cr |
| Debt-equity ratio | 0.79:1 |
| Cash and bank balances | ₹313 cr |
| Overall capacity utilization | 60% |
| Mattampally plant utilization | 65% |
| Gudipadu plant utilization | 95% |
| Bayyavaram plant utilization | 68% |
| Jeerabad plant utilization | 57% |
| Jajpur plant utilization | 15% |
| Trade vs non-trade mix | 60% trade, 40% non-trade |
| Blended cement vs OPC mix | 50-50, target 55-60% blended next year |
| Pet coke proportion in fuel mix | 76%, up from 66% |
| Weighted average Kcal | 2.17, expected close to that in Q4 |
| FY23 full-year volume target | 0.5 cr tons, Q4 expected 0.49–0.5 cr tons |
| FY24 volume target (excl. Andhra) | 0.55 cr tons |
| Post Andhra acquisition net debt ceiling | ₹1,250 cr, increase of ~₹150 cr from current |
| Q4 expected sequential cost savings | ₹100–125 per ton |
| FY24 maintenance CapEx (excl. Andhra) | ≤₹30 cr across group |
| AP & Telangana demand growth (9M) | >25% YoY |
| Karnataka demand growth (9M) | ~24% YoY |
| Tamil Nadu demand growth (9M) | ~20% YoY |
| Kerala demand growth (9M) | 25% YoY |
| Maharashtra demand growth (9M) | ~3%, flat to positive bias |
| Orissa demand growth (9M) | flat |
| Imported pet coke spot price | \$170/ton, down from \$180–\$200 |
| Imported coal RB2 benchmark | \$135/ton, down from \$160 |
| Finance cost run rate (Q4 FY23) | ₹51 cr |
| Andhra Cement installed capacity | 0.26 cr tons, idle for 3 years |