Key Takeaways
- Spread expansion signals pricing power: Book spread widened from 2.7% to 3.1% as repo rate hikes passed through, demonstrating the NBFC's ability to hold spreads in a rising-rate environment.
- Balance sheet stabilized, growth promised: AUM and loan book flattened after three quarters of deliberate degrowth; management now projects 10–15% AUM growth in H2 FY23.
- Retail disbursements surged 9x YoY in H1: The asset-light origination model, backed by distribution investment, made Sammaan the third-largest HFC by retail disbursals, with incremental ROA at ~300 bps.
- Gearing collapsed from ~7x to 2.5x: The deliberate balance-sheet shrink, combined with conservative liquidity (200% LCR) and term-deposit buffers for ECB and FCCB lenders, has made the company materially safer for debt investors.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the promised 10–15% H2 AUM growth materializes, the pace of the developer loan book's 20% degrowth, and any dividend declaration against a "tricky" macro backdrop.
Business Model Transformation
- From leveraged balance-sheet play to asset-light originator: The company deliberately shrank its balance sheet over seven quarters, cutting gearing from near 7x to 2.5x, while building a retail franchise that adds ~20,000 prime mortgage customers a month.
- The cost of transformation: Shareholder capital halved during this period, which management attributes to "motivated battles" and "abuse of law" against the company.
- Wholesale book is unwinding into strength: Real estate projects that serve as collateral are selling well; key Mumbai projects (25-South, Minerva) are achieving or nearing occupancy certificates, and some stressed loans in South and North India are attracting bids at 120 cents on the dollar due to steep land price appreciation.
- Developer loan book will shrink further: Management guided for a ~20% degrowth in the developer loan book during H2 FY23.
- The wholesale-to-platform pivot: The wholesale business is being transformed from an NBFC balance-sheet model to a platform model, with team restructuring to right-size the organization and move people accordingly.
- Execution bandwidth is now freed up: With regulatory transitions largely behind it and legal battles quashed or stayed, management says it can now focus on execution rather than fighting "motivated battles."
Gagan Banga: "We do not want to be a company or a management team which is known to shock or surprise. We would like to state things upfront. We said upfront that we would like to de-grow, we degrew. Sometimes in life to transform you have to dig deep, we dug deep."
Retail Franchise Build-Out
- Disbursement growth was explosive: Retail disbursements grew 9x YoY in H1 FY23, driven by distribution investment and the asset-light model; the company became the third-largest HFC by retail disbursals.
- The run-rate is now institutional: The company is adding ~20,000 customers a month and targeting $300–350 million in absolute retail granular loan disbursals per month.
- Incremental ROA is attractive: Retail disbursals earn ~300 bps ROA, and management expects this to add 10–15 bps to company-wide ROA every quarter.
- Disbursal growth guidance is tempered but still strong: Management expects at least 2x year-on-year disbursal growth for the next two years, not the 9x seen in the last year.
- Technology is being positioned as a moat: A pilot with a large public-sector bank achieved a completely hands-off, no-human-intervention loan-buying process, with documents read by bank systems and loans purchased automatically.
- Cost-to-income benefits are back-end loaded: Investments in people (1,500 added in FY23, 16% average increment) and technology will keep costs elevated through FY23; efficiency gains and a declining cost-to-income trajectory are expected starting FY24.
Asset Quality & Provisioning
- Gross NPAs have been stable for 4–5 quarters: Absolute GNPA at ₹2,123 crore and the ratio at 2.94% have held steady; retail collection efficiency stands at 98.8%.
- Stage 2 is improving rapidly: Stage 2 assets are down almost 30% since the start of the year and almost 50% from the end of FY21, trending well with the real estate cycle.
- Provisioning is deliberately conservative: Total provisions stand at 3% of the loan book, or 2.7x regulatory requirements; Stage 3 provisions are at 42%. Management continues to take high provisions when PPOP is high to avoid a volatile earnings picture.
- Stressed loan recovery is running ahead of assumptions: Some stressed loans are seeing bids at 120 cents on the dollar due to steep land price appreciation, versus an earlier provision assumption of 80–90 cents recovery.
- Credit cost guidance implies a sharp fall: Credit cost is expected to be 100–150 bps for FY23, then halve from next year onwards.
Gagan Banga: "If after this crisis in the last quarters, if one is to believe me then our credit cost should come down at half of these levels next year onwards."
Liquidity, Liability Management & Regulatory Positioning
- Gearing reduction is the headline safety improvement: Leverage has been brought down from ~7x to 2.5x, and management expects it to remain in the 2.5x–3x range going forward.
- Liquidity is run conservatively: The company operates at ~200% LCR against a 50% minimum prescribed, and ALM remains positive.
- Term-deposit buffers are being built for foreign-currency lenders: The board approved a term-deposit buffer for ECB lenders (to be triggered in 7–8 days), and management committed to following suit for FCCB lenders, assuming the bonds will not convert to equity.
- A large rupee bond redemption was pre-funded: Management proactively created reserves for a ~$1 billion rupee bond maturity and bought back mutual fund bonds.
- Upper-layer NBFC transition is not expected to hurt: A board deep dive confirmed no significant P&L or balance-sheet impact, and no capital charge is expected from the reclassification.
Governance Overhang & De-Promoterization
- The founder is exiting the promoter role: Mr. Gehlot's stake fell to 9.5% after a sale to large global financial institutions; the de-promoterization process has 80–90% approval from relevant authorities, with the balance expected within 30 days.
- The board is already independent: Mr. Gehlot is not on the board, which has been led by Mr. Mundra for two years.
- Legal proceedings have been quashed: The Bombay High Court quashed the underlying predicate offence, and the Delhi High Court quashed the ED proceedings themselves; no proceedings remain against the company.
- A PIL remains outstanding but is not progressing: The PIL is not getting listed despite efforts; various regulators have examined the books and filed affidavits stating the books appear to be in order.
- Rebranding is on the roadmap: Once de-promoterization is complete, the company will logically move away from the Indiabulls brand; the path will be step-by-step.
Gagan Banga: "We must salute the founder to say that the institution is more important than him and for him to have taken this initiative."
Return Profile & Capital
- Book ROA is inching up: Company-wide ROA improved 10 bps this quarter, driven by the profitable mix shift toward retail disbursals.
- The target is 200–250 bps ROA, implying ~14–15% ROE: Management expects book ROA to settle at that level and ROE to reach ~14–15% by the middle of FY24.
- The AIF platform is a future profit contributor: The platform should reach ~₹5,000 crore by the end of this fiscal year and start contributing to profitability from next year onwards.
- Book value recovery is expected: Management stated there is "no reason" why book value and past book value should not be achieved over the next two to three quarters.
- A dividend is an intention, not a commitment: Management wants to pay a dividend this year and is technically enabled at the half-year mark, but the second half is "tricky" due to geopolitics, inflation, interest rates, and possible rapid input-cost increases.
Gagan Banga: "Your capital has halved, my blood pressure has increased. So, both of us are sufferers, but today I am quite sure that the management team will focus on execution and recoup your capital and slowly my blood pressure will also get okay."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| AUM growth | 10% conservatively, 15% optimistically | H2 FY23 |
| Gearing range | 2.5x to 3x | Going forward |
| Retail disbursal growth | At least 2x YoY | Next two years |
| Monthly retail disbursals | $300–350 million absolute | Run-rate target |
| Customer addition | ~20,000 per month | Run-rate |
| Credit cost | 100–150 bps | FY23 |
| Credit cost reduction | Half of FY23 levels | Next year onwards |
| Book ROA | Settle at 200–250 bps | By middle of FY24 |
| ROE | ~14–15% | By middle of FY24 |
| Developer loan book degrowth | ~20% (~₹2,000 crore) | H2 FY23 |
| Stage 2 reduction | Down another 30% | By end of FY23 |
| AIF platform size | ~₹5,000 crore | By end of FY23 |
| AIF profitability contribution | Start contributing | Next year onwards |
| Term-deposit buffer for ECB lenders | Creation triggered | Next 7–8 days |
| FCCB term-deposit buffer | Follow ECB buffer | Over 4–5 quarters |
| De-promoterization approvals | Balance 10–20% expected | Next 30 days |
| Cost-to-income improvement | Efficiency gains begin | Starting FY24 |
| Technology-driven cost benefits | Reflect in cost-to-income | By FY25 |
| Attrition target | Single-digit attrition | Through FY25–26 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| AUM | ~₹70,000 cr (handle), flattish QoQ; 10% growth guided for H2 FY23 |
| Balance sheet | Stabilized, marginally grew QoQ |
| Gearing | 2.5x, down from near 7x historically; floor level, expected range 2.5x–3x |
| Capital adequacy | 34% total, Tier-1 at 28% |
| ROA (company-wide) | Inched up 10 bps, driven by retail disbursements earning ~300 bps ROA |
| Incremental retail disbursal ROA | 3% |
| ROE guidance | 14%–15% expected by middle of fiscal 24 |
| Gross NPA | 2.94% (₹2,123 cr absolute), flattish for 4–5 quarters; net NPA at 1.70% |
| Stage 3 provisions | 42% of stage 3 assets |
| Total provisions | 3% of loan book, 2.7x regulatory requirements |
| Retail collection efficiency | 98.8% for Q2 FY23 |
| Credit cost guidance | 100–150 bps for FY23, trending within range; expected to halve next year onwards |
| Retail disbursements (H1 FY23) | 9x growth vs H1 FY22 |
| Asset-light disbursals (prime segment, H1 FY23) | ₹4,600 cr |
| Developer loan book guidance | Degrow ~20% (₹2,000 cr) in H2 FY23 |
| AIF platform | ₹3,500 cr, expected to reach ₹5,000 cr by fiscal year-end |
| Stage 2 | Down ~30% since start of year, ~50% from end of fiscal 21 |
| LCR | ~200% against minimum prescribed 50% |
| Employees added (FY23) | Over 1,500 |
| Annual increment | Averaged ~16% |
| Affordable housing book | $200 million, average ticket size ₹10 lakh |
| Disbursal target (fiscal 24) | ~$2 billion |
| Monthly retail disbursal target | $300–350 million, adding ~20,000 customers per month |