Key Takeaways
- AUM contraction, but capital quality is the real story: AUM fell at least 15% this year as the company deliberately ran down wholesale, yet net worth is up 21% over five years and provisions exceed risk.
- Asset-light pivot is delivering 3%+ ROA: Retail disbursals grew 3.3x YoY in 9M, and the co-lending/sell-down model is generating well above 3% ROA with only 10 bps delinquency.
- Stage 2 book collapsed from 30% to 6% of AUM: Two large, stubborn NCR exposures were fully resolved in Q3, and the remaining Stage 2 pool shrank by ₹17,400 crores in one year.
- Provision pool depth is the margin of safety: The ₹10,000+ crores write-off and NPA pool carries an 11.6% total provision cover, and management expects at least 50% recovery over 2–3 years.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the reorganization and rebranding announcement lands with clarity, the pace of retail disbursal doubling, and any drawdown on the new AIF.
The Asset-Light Pivot
- Transformation defined: The company has shifted from an asset-heavy model to what management calls a "smart origination machine," originating retail mortgages and then selling them down or co-lending them out, keeping capital light.
- Scale already visible: Retail disbursals hit ₹6,261 crores in 9M FY23, a 3.3x YoY jump, making Sammaan the third-largest mortgage lender in the NBFC/HFC category.
- Unit economics are compelling: On ₹9,400 crores of cumulative asset-light disbursals since FY22, the company is realizing ROA well above 3% with delinquency of just 10 bps.
- Co-lending share rising: Co-lending and loans sold down grew from 10% of AUM in Q3 FY18 to 33%, creating a granular book with co-terminus repayments.
- Infrastructure build-out: The company added almost 60 branches and continues to grow manpower, with a 6-month lag to productivity; tech integration with most partner banks is done, with the balance expected by fiscal year-end.
- Partner bank expansion: Seven partner banking relationships are in place, with a plan to expand to 10 over the next 3–4 months.
- Not affordable housing: Management clarified the company does prime lending, not low-ticket-size affordable housing.
Gagan Banga: "This signifies the transformation of the company from an asset-heavy model where a lot of capital was put to work to a smart origination machine, which is focusing on low-cost high-tech origination versus looking around for more and more capital."
Wholesale Book Rundown & Asset Resolution
- AUM contraction is deliberate: AUM shrank more this quarter because two stuck Stage 2 NCR developer exposures were resolved, generating healthy IRRs of 12% and over 14%.
- Stage 2 collapse: Stage 2 loans fell from nearly ₹22,000 crores (30% of AUM) at end-December '21 to ₹4,520 crores (6% of AUM) at end-December '22, a ₹17,400-crore reduction in one year, even while adopting RBI's daily days-past-due recognition.
- Stage 3 provision rationalization: Empirically validated loss given default is lower than the Stage 3 provisions previously carried, so Stage 3 provision levels have been reduced; management now carries 100% provision on all Stage 3 and Stage 2 assets.
- Recovery pool is deep: The write-off and NPA pool exceeds ₹10,000 crores, built over 4–5 years; management expects at least 50% cash recovery over the next 2–3 years, with a conservative 40% implying ~8% of the loan book returning.
- Project-level progress: The highest tower in India achieved OC for 60% of units; a super-premium Worli project is at 90% civil structure with part OC received; Prabhadevi last-mile financing saw its first facility fully repaid, with the second expected over the next 1.5 years.
- Joint developments as a resolution tool: Four joint developments were entered in Q3 for stuck or slow projects, with loan recovery expected over the next 3 financial years.
- Wholesale book trajectory: Management expects a material rundown in the wholesale book over the next 2 years via loan repayments and will continue to wind up this line of business as soon as possible.
Gagan Banga: "By all the numbers that I have run you through, I hope the implication in this question, which is that we will have to pay significant write-downs from the wholesale book is today, once and for all, completely closed out."
Capital Strength & Provisioning
- Net worth resilience: Despite a 44% balance sheet rundown and ~43% loan AUM decline over ~5 years, net worth is up 21% (~₹3,200 crores) because provisions more than effectively cover risk and recoveries have supported capital.
- Provision cover depth: Total provision and implied provision pool stands at 11.6%, against Stage 2 plus NPAs of ~9.5%.
- Provisioning strategy: As Stage 2 comes off, management continues to keep provisions; Stage 3 provisions were reduced because loss given default does not justify even 15%, let alone the 40% previously held; accelerated write-offs are the only tool used to create provisions.
- One-off income used for provisions: A spike in net gain on de-recognition came from securitization of assets and a one-off repricing of the entire back book in line with repo rate increases; this was used to create provisions, not to bump up profits.
- No provision releases ahead: Management stated there will be no release in provisions in the foreseeable future; the focus is on dealing with assets to give financial flexibility to run down the wholesale book on an accelerated basis.
- Dividend intent: The company did not qualify for dividends last year under new RBI upper-layer NBFC guidelines; it will assess qualification at year-end and would like to continue the dividend practice if eligible.
Gagan Banga: "The net worth is as real as it gets, and the provisions more than effectively cover the risk."
Liquidity & ALM
- ALM positive across all buckets: Net cash is positive by almost ₹8,000 crores at the end of the first year; LCR stands at 246% against a 60% requirement.
- Liquidity rationalized: As funding access eased, on-balance-sheet liquidity was rationalized to minimize negative carry; cash stands at ~₹4,000 crores excluding undrawn lines.
- Bond prepayment: ₹1,000 crores of bonds were prepaid last quarter.
- Reserve pool creation: In Q4, the company will create a second tranche for ECB and a first tranche for FCCB reserve pools; management believes FCCBs will eventually convert to equity but cannot assume so.
- YES Bank AT-1 bonds: A positive order has been received, and the company is awaiting Supreme Court confirmation.
Reorganization, De-promoterization & Rebranding
- De-promoterization near completion: All requisite approvals from shareholders, bankers, and regulators have been received; the process is expected to complete before 31st March 2023, with the founder-promoter reclassified as a public shareholder very shortly.
- Reorganization to simplify structure: Management and the Board are working on simplifying the HoldCo/OpCo/subsidiary structure to reflect only two businesses: retail origination via the NBFC and wholesale origination via an AIF; an announcement is expected before fiscal year-end.
- Rebranding underway: A rebranding exercise has been undertaken to reflect the company's institutionalized character and retail mortgage focus, moving away from the Indiabulls Housing identity.
- AIF partner secured: SEBI approval for the fund house has been received; the partner is one of the largest international funds operating out of Southeast Asia, with whom the company has done business in the past; capital has not yet been drawn.
- AIF focus timeline: Between Q3 and Q4, the focus remains on growing the retail base; from Q1 onwards, work on the AIF will begin, with wholesale financing via AIF becoming a focus next fiscal, especially as space gets vacated with the HDFC and HDFC Bank merger.
Gagan Banga: "Therefore, it is my request that please evaluate us today as a strong capital company, where the capital is as real as it can get with adequate provisions to take care of any exigency and a very, very large retail originator, generating a 3% ROA on the assets that it is originating on the retail side on an incremental basis."
Profitability & Earnings Quality
- PAT maintained despite contraction: PAT of ₹867 crores for 9M and ₹291 crores for Q3 was maintained despite reductions in book, AUM, and gearing.
- ROA expansion: ROA has been rising for the last three quarters and expanded to 1.5% at end-December '22.
- Net gain on de-recognition trajectory: As more co-lending and securitization happens, this line item will keep going steadily up; occasional quarters may see larger numbers from reference rate changes, but management expects to manage on a flow basis even without rate increases.
- NPA trend improving: In the last year, despite the new RBI circular on daily DPD recognition kicking in, NPAs went down from ₹2,350 crores to ₹2,302 crores.
Gagan Banga: "We've gone through a perfect storm. And this has been far tougher than the most stringent stress tests that we could have possibly gone through in the good times."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| De-promoterization completion | Reclassification of founder-promoter to public shareholder | Before 31st March 2023 |
| Reorganization announcement | Simplify structure to retail NBFC + wholesale AIF | Before fiscal year-end |
| Tech integration completion | Balance of tech integration with partner banks | By fiscal year-end |
| Partner banking relationships | Expand from 7 to 10 | Next 3–4 months |
| Retail disbursal growth | At least 200% to 250% YoY; Q3 next year at 2–2.5x Q3 this year | Next 12 months |
| Monthly retail disbursal doubling | Double the monthly run-rate | Next 12 months |
| Wholesale book rundown | Material rundown via loan repayments | Next 2 years |
| Write-off/NPA pool recovery | At least 50% cash recovery on ₹10,000+ crores pool | Next 2–3 years |
| Worli project write-back | Massive write-back expected | Next 2 financial years |
| Prabhadevi loan repayment | Company's loans fully repaid | Next 1.5 years |
| Joint development loan recovery | Loans from 4 JDs entered in Q3 to come back | Next 3 financial years |
| AUM trajectory | Net AUM may contract for a quarter or 2 more; at least 15% lower for FY23 | FY23 |
| ECB reserve pool | Second tranche created | Q4 FY23 |
| FCCB reserve pool | First tranche (25%) created | Q4 FY23 |
| AIF wholesale financing focus | Begin focusing on wholesale financing via AIF | Next fiscal (FY24) |
| Dividend | Assess qualification under RBI guidelines; pay if eligible | Year-end FY23 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Net interest income | ₹950 cr, vs ₹688 cr in Q3 FY22 |
| Profit after tax | ₹291 cr, vs ₹303 cr in Q3 FY22 |
| Annualized net interest margin | 4.1% |
| ROA | 1.5%, expanded over last 3 quarters to December '22 |
| Gross NPAs | 3.3%, at ₹2,302 cr |
| Net NPAs | 2.18% |
| Net debt to equity | 2.3x |
| Capital adequacy | ~34%, Tier 1 capital at 28.5% |
| Retail disbursals (9M FY23) | ₹6,261 cr, 3.3x vs ₹1,900 cr in 9M FY22 |
| Retail disbursals monthly run-rate | ₹700–800 cr per month under asset-light model |
| Co-lending and loans sold down as % of AUM | 33%, up from 10% at Q3 FY18 |
| Stage 2 loans | ₹4,520 cr, 6% of AUM, down from ~₹22,000 cr (30% of AUM) at Q3 FY22 |
| Stage 2 plus Stage 3 loans | 9.7% of AUM, down from 32.8% |
| Implied provisions (including write-offs and recoveries) | 11.6% of loans, fully covering Stage 2 plus Stage 3 loans of ~10% |
| LCR | 246%, against RBI requirement of 60% |
| Cash on balance sheet | ~₹4,000 cr, excluding sanctioned but undrawn lines |
| Positive net cash (ALM, end of first year) | ~₹8,000 cr |
| Net worth | ₹17,269 cr, up 21% or ~₹3,200 cr from ₹14,000 cr at FY18 end |
| Balance sheet size | ₹74,000 cr, down 44% from ₹132,000 cr at FY18 end |
| Wholesale book as % of AUM | ~20% of AUM, ~30% of loan book as at 31 December |
| AUM growth guidance for FY23 | At least 15% lower AUM (management withdrew earlier 10% growth target) |
| Recovery IRR on 2 resolved NCR Stage 2 exposures | 12% on one, over 14% on the other |
| Delinquency on retail loans sourced since FY22 | 10 bps |
| ROA on asset-light disbursals since FY22 | Well upwards of 3% |
| Bonds prepaid in the quarter | ₹1,000 cr |
| Branch network increase | ~60 branches added |
| Partner banking relationships | 7, expected to expand to 10 over next 3–4 months |
| AIF size | ~₹7,000 cr |
| Gross repayments to lenders (cumulative) | Over ₹1 lakh cr gross, over ₹80,000 cr net |
| Additional impairment in the quarter | ₹266 cr |