Key Takeaways
- Transformation complete, pivot to growth: AUM decline has bottomed out after a deliberate derisking of wholesale assets; the company now targets 10% AUM CAGR in FY23 and 15% in FY24, driven by an asset-light co-lending and AIF model.
- Asset-light engine is built and firing: Co-lending and sell-down now fund 29% of the book, with tech integrations maturing and a ₹15,000 crore retail disbursal target set for FY23, of which only 30% stays on balance sheet.
- Legal overhang cleared: The Mumbai High Court quashed the FIR as an "abuse of the process of law," and the Supreme Court ruling on the ED investigation means management expects to put the entire matter behind it by August 2022.
- Profitability base formed, ROA recovery promised: Profitability has steadied over five quarters; credit costs are guided to 100-150 bps in FY23, halving from FY24, with ROA expected back above 2% by FY24.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the ₹1,200-1,300 crore monthly retail disbursal run rate materializes, progress on the two pending AIF fund approvals, and the formal conclusion of the de-promoterisation process.
The Asset-Light Pivot
- Co-lending at scale: Two partner banks are now fully integrated on the co-lending tech platform, with the rest expected to complete integration in H1 FY23. The ₹2,942 crores disclosed is only the co-lending portion; gross retail disbursals were approximately ₹2,900 crores in Q4 FY22 alone.
- Disbursal capacity ready: Physical infrastructure and credit teams were preserved through COVID, so capacity exists to disburse ₹2,500 to ₹3,000 crores monthly. The company plans to add ~1,000 salespeople in H1 FY23 to reach ₹1,500 crores monthly by September and ₹2,000 crores by March 2023 without a proportionate manpower increase.
- AIF platform emerging: SEBI approval received for a ₹2,000 crore fund with a global alternative investment firm; a second ₹5,000 crore fund approval is expected by end of May 2022, and a third ₹5,000 crore fund filing is imminent. The platform targets ₹10,000 crores in disbursals in FY23, scaling to ₹15,000 crores in FY24, with a 5%+ ROA potential.
- AUM-to-book multiplier: With only 30% of retail disbursals retained on balance sheet, the company expects an AUM of 3x to 4x of what it carries on its books.
- HDFC merger tailwind: Management views the HDFC-HDFC Bank merger as an opportunity on the wholesale side, expecting HDFC Limited to vacate the commercial real estate space in the medium term, which lets Sammaan partner with global funds via AIFs to capture good yields without compromising on credit.
Gagan Banga: "The focus at this point in time is completely in creating franchise value, on maximizing the number of relationships on our co-lending side, our presence in various cities, our disbursals per employee and to focus on a very homogenous kind of a book in terms of its ticket size, loan to value etc., rather than just blindly pursue growth."
Legal Resolution & Governance Reset
- FIR quashed: The Mumbai High Court on May 4, 2022 quashed the FIR, stating that "the lodgment of the complaint against the petitioners and continuity of the proceedings is an abuse of the process of law."
- ED investigation expected to end: The Supreme Court ruled on May 5, 2022 that if the underlying FIR is quashed, the Enforcement Directorate should discontinue its investigations. Management expects the Delhi High Court to quash the ED investigation when the matter is heard on August 23, 2022.
- De-promoterisation underway: Mr. Sameer Gehlaut reduced his stake from ~21% to ~9% in December 2021 and resigned as non-executive director in March 2022. Board and shareholder approvals for de-promoterisation are secured; lender approvals are mostly in, with some international lender queries being answered. Formal de-promoterisation is expected by end of calendar year 2022, after which there will be an effective change of control.
- Board independence strengthened: Mr. B. C. Patnaik, Managing Director of LIC, joined the board as a nominee director in April 2022; 60% of the board now comprises independent directors. Mr. Mundra was reappointed as Non-Executive Chairman with roughly two to two and a half years remaining in his term.[17-18]
- Auditor transition managed: A mid-year change from a single auditor to two auditors was completed seamlessly after EY hit the RBI-mandated three-year limit. Mazar, one of Europe's largest audit firms, was appointed alongside a joint auditor who is the statutory auditor for PNB and other large banks.
Gagan Banga: "We have been at the receiving end of blackmailing attempts by extortionists. We appreciate that as frivolous as these attempts maybe, they are inevitable in a democracy. Our entire focus has been to emerge out of such conflicts with our detractors on the basis of our merit."
Asset Quality & Provisioning
- Gross NPA optics are denominator-driven: The percentage increase in gross NPA reflects a shrinking denominator from wholesale consolidation, not fresh slippage. The overall portfolio quality is strong: restructured loans are only 0.26% of the loan book, and government guarantee scheme top-up loans are only 0.36%.
- Proactive wholesale management: The strategy on the wholesale side is to provide for assets needing correction, take control of the project, then hand control to a stronger developer. This has brought a substantial portion of the book to a stage where projects will achieve occupancy certificates over the next 12 to 18 months, keeping headline gross NPA numbers in a tight range.
- Recovery momentum: Strong recoveries over the last three quarters are expected to continue through FY23, supported by the pickup in the real estate sector.
- Credit cost trajectory: Credit costs are guided to 100-150 bps for FY23, halving from FY24 onwards. Gross NPAs are expected to remain in the 3% to 3.5% range for some time.
Funding, Liquidity & ALM
- Liquidity planning is self-sufficient: ALM management and liquidity planning does not assume refinance of domestic or international bonds or term loans. The company fully prefunded its USD bond repayment obligations into a trust and irrevocably instructed the trustee well in advance of the maturity date.
- Cash coverage rationale: The balance sheet has shrunk significantly, and the company has not done any chunky bond issuance for almost three years, so ALM has no chunkiness. Cash requirements reduce accordingly, and there is still a massive negative carry on cash held. The company will continue to maintain cash coverage for the next 6 to 12 months of repayments.
- Funding mix diversified: Funding through loan sell-down, securitization, and co-lending is at an all-time high of 29% of the funding mix. The company also intends to do nine more public bond issues in FY23, cumulatively raising ~₹2,000 crores, and plans a ₹3,000 crore sustainable bond issuance program in calendar 2023.
- Bond buyback programme: The board has decided to announce a bond buyback programme at the start of every quarter on a regular basis; the next announcement is expected in early July 2022.
- Rating outlook revised to stable: Crisil, ICRA, Brickwork and Moody's all revised the company's outlook to stable, with Moody's citing strong capital levels, high liquidity, and stabilization in funding access.
- Spreads unharmed: The spread reduction from the lead bank (100 bps over reference rate) is now coming through with other banks as well; from a spread perspective, the company is "pretty much unharmed." Funding flow in May was undisrupted and is expected to accelerate as full-year earnings are shared with lenders.
Gagan Banga: "The company's ALM management and liquidity planning does not assume refinance of domestic or international bonds or term loans and all of our lenders should make particular note of this."
Portfolio Mix & Income Dynamics
- Interest income pressure is structural: As the wholesale book consolidates, the impact on the interest line is larger than the actual AUM reduction because wholesale assets are more remunerative. The same interest income numbers cannot be maintained as wholesale runs off.
- CRE share inching up: Commercial real estate increased from 26% to 29% of the loan book, while retail mortgage decreased from 59% to 57%. This is because the company continues to disburse to underlying projects to ensure construction continues and projects reach completion, positioning to benefit from the real estate rebound. The CRE share is expected to stay broadly in the 25% to 30% range. [18-19]
- Assets held for sale jump: The increase from ₹1,400 crore to ₹3,000 crore is largely driven by junior NCDs held as an outcome of various structured transactions (PTCs).
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| AUM growth | Compound AUM by 10% | FY23 |
| AUM growth | Compound AUM by 15% | FY24 |
| Retail co-lending disbursals | ₹15,000 crores through co-lending with partner banks | FY23 |
| Retail disbursals (total) | ₹15,000 crores (30% on-book) | FY23 |
| Retail disbursals (total) | ₹20,000 crores | FY24 |
| Monthly disbursal capacity | ₹1,500 crores per month | By September 2022 |
| Monthly disbursal capacity | ₹2,000 crores per month | By March 2023 |
| Co-lending tech integration | Complete with all partners | H1 FY23 |
| AIF disbursals | Begin disbursing from first and second AIF funds | H1 FY23 |
| AIF disbursal capacity | ₹10,000 crores | FY23 |
| AIF disbursal capacity | ₹15,000 crores | FY24 |
| Legacy wholesale book | Reduce by a further 20% from March 2022 level | By end of calendar year 2022 |
| Gross NPA range | 3% to 3.5% | Through FY23 |
| Credit cost | 100 to 150 bps | FY23 |
| Credit cost | Halve from FY23 levels | FY24 onwards |
| ROA | Greater than 2% | By FY24[14-15] |
| ROE | 11% to 12% | By FY24 |
| Dividend | Up to 40% of PAT | FY23 onwards |
| De-promoterisation | Formal conclusion, effective change of control | By end of calendar year 2022 |
| Legal proceedings | ED investigation quashed, matter behind company | August 23, 2022 (Delhi HC hearing) |
| Bond buyback programme | Announced at start of every quarter | Next: early July 2022 |
| Sustainable bond issuance | ₹3,000 crore program | Calendar 2023 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY22 |
|---|---|
| AUM | ₹72,211 cr, decline now ended, base for growth from FY23 |
| Loan book | ₹59,333 cr |
| PAT | ₹307 cr, +11% YoY (₹276 cr in Q4 FY21) |
| Full-year PAT | ₹1,178 cr |
| Net gearing | 2.6x, down from 7x in FY2018 |
| Consolidated capital adequacy | 32.6%, tier one 27.2% |
| Spread on book | 2.4%, cost of funds 8.1%, book yields 10.5% |
| Gross NPA | ₹2,318 cr, down from ₹2,350 cr; percentage higher as denominator declined |
| Net NPA | 1.89% |
| Stage 3 provision coverage | 41%, vs 40% in Q4 FY21 |
| Restructured loans (1.0 + 2.0) | 0.26% of loan book |
| Liquidity buffer | ₹9,107 cr, 15% of loan book |
| LCR (RBI HQLA definition) | 241% |
| Funding via sell-down, securitization, co-lending | 29% of funding mix, an all-time high |
| FY23 AUM growth guidance | 10% |
| FY24 AUM growth guidance | 15% |
| FY24 ROA guidance | greater than 2% |
| FY24 ROE guidance | 11% to 12% |
| FY23 credit cost guidance | 100 to 150 bps |
| Gross NPA range expectation | 3% to 3.5% for some time |
| FY23 retail disbursal target | ₹15,000 cr through co-lending and sell-down |
| FY24 retail disbursal target | ₹20,000 cr through co-lending and sell-down |
| Q4 FY22 gross retail disbursal | ~₹2,900 cr |
| Q4 FY22 co-lending disbursals | ₹2,942 cr |
| Monthly retail disbursal run rate | ~₹900 cr, expected to reach ₹1,200–1,300 cr |
| Employees added in FY22 | 1,200 |
| Total funds raised in FY22 | ₹24,497 cr |
| Securitization and loan sell-down funding in FY22 | ₹5,214 cr |
| Retail NCD issues in FY22 | ₹1,345 cr across two issues |
| Equity/quasi-equity capital raised in FY22 | ₹1,517 cr via FCCB and OakNorth stake sale |
| Reference rate increase on home loans and LAP | 40 bps, effective June 1, 2022 |
| Commercial real estate share of loan book | 29%, up from 26% QoQ |
| Retail mortgage share of loan book | 57%, down from 59% QoQ |
| Stock price to book value | 0.5x |