Key Takeaways
- Asset-light pivot is working: Retail disbursements hit nearly ₹8,000 Crores under the co-lending model, over 2.5x FY2022, making Sammaan the third-largest non-bank originator of retail mortgages in India.
- Asset quality is the quiet victory: Gross NPAs fell to their lowest level in six quarters on a percentage basis and 12 quarters in absolute terms, while the co-lending pool shows 90+ dpd below 0.10%.
- A reorganization unlocks the next chapter: The company will split into a retail-focused NBFC and a wholesale AIF, a structure management says makes the story more investable, with a new brand expected in ~120 days.
- Recovery engine is delivering: ₹2,500 Crores already recovered from a ₹10,000 Crore NPA and write-off pool, with another ₹2,500 Crores confidently targeted over the next six quarters.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the reorganization and rebranding stay on schedule, the pace of retail disbursement acceleration toward the ₹1,300–1,400 Crore monthly run-rate, and any dividend decision from the Board.
The Reorganization & Rebranding
- Structure designed for investor appetite: The company will consolidate its balance sheet into one large NBFC focused on asset-light retail origination, while wholesale loans move into an AIF structure, a split management says came directly from investor feedback to make the entity more investable.
- Timing tied to a market gap: The exit of the country's largest housing finance company from the non-bank space by end-Q1 FY2024 creates what management calls a unique opportunity for Sammaan to step into.
- Brand reset underway: Subject to approvals, a new brand is expected to be unveiled in about 120 days, with depromoterization now behind the company and ESG goals the next institutionalization priority.
- Execution risk is real: The reorganization requires approvals from shareholders, lenders, and regulators, and the company is simultaneously scaling branches, headcount, and a co-lending tech platform, all while managing a legacy wholesale rundown.
Gagan Banga: "The exit of the country's largest housing finance company from the non-bank space by the end of the current quarter, which is Q1 FY2024, provides the company with a unique opportunity."
Asset-Light Retail: The Growth Engine
- Scale-up is accelerating: The company now sources close to ₹800 Crores of loans per month and disbursed ₹7,800 Crores for the full year, working with eight partner banks.
- Disbursement target set: The goal is to disburse at least ₹12,000 Crores in FY2024 while retaining only 20% of those loans, keeping the balance sheet asset-light.
- Ramp-up trajectory: Management expects Q1 FY24 to match FY23's full-year small-business volumes, with acceleration in Q2 and a second-half run-rate averaging ₹1,300–1,400 Crores per month.
- Net book growth lags disbursements: The loan book will stay flattish in H1 FY24 and only begin growing on a net basis in H2, with FY2025 set for further expansion, a lag that reflects the 20% retention rate.
- Asset quality in the new pool is pristine: The co-lending book's 90 days past due is below 0.10% on a concurrent basis, though management cautions that on a static basis it is closer to 20 bps and will likely drift to 100–150 bps by the time the book reaches 60 months seasoned.
- Tech platform ambition: The company aims to build a co-lending marketplace tech platform where sourced loans are made available seamlessly to all partner banks, a move meant to improve efficiencies and support the FY2026 ROE goal.
Gagan Banga: "what is 10 basis points this is on concurrent basis. If you look at it on a static basis this will probably be closer to 20 basis points, this is a book with a blended average of about 12 to 14 months on our book. By the time it is 60 months on book it will get to between 100 to 150 basis points and then we will start the process of recovery on the static book"
Asset Quality & the Wholesale Rundown
- Legacy cleanup is working: The wholesale book continues to run down and has performed as a 5% ROA asset class, with strong repayment traction also aiding recoveries from previously written-off loans.
- NPA stock at multi-quarter lows: Gross NPAs are at their lowest percentage level in six quarters and lowest absolute level in 12 quarters at ₹1,918 Crores, while stage 2 loans have collapsed from 31% to 8% of AUM.
- Provisioning is heavy: Imputed provisions of ₹6,559 Crores cover gross NPA 3.4 times, and stage 2 plus stage 3 loans carry an implied provision of 88%, a buffer built through the stress period.
- Recovery momentum is tangible: Of a ₹10,000 Crore pool of NPAs and written-off wholesale loans, ₹2,500 Crores has already been recovered, and management is confident of recovering another ₹2,500 Crores over the next six quarters at a pace of roughly ₹400–500 Crores per quarter.
- Wholesale liquidation path: Another ₹4,000–5,000 Crores on a net basis is expected to liquidate through FY2024, with AIF disbursals from Q2/Q3 materially contributing, and dedicated co-lending vehicles being created to partner with foreign institutions.
Gagan Banga: "over the next six quarters, we are now confident that we will recover another ₹2,500 Crores so of the ₹10,000 Crores ₹2,500 Crores is already recovered and on the basis of the success we are confident that in the next six quarters itself over the next one-and-a-half years we will recover another ₹2,500 Crores."
Financial Resilience & the Balance Sheet
- A deliberate shrink that built equity: The balance sheet has contracted 43% from ₹1,32,000 Crores at end-FY2018 to ₹57,000 Crores, and the loan book is down 45%, all through loans coming back rather than write-offs, a fact management points to as evidence of underlying borrower quality.
- Net worth grew through the storm: Net worth is up 30% (over ₹4,000 Crores) despite absorbing ₹10,000 Crores in NPAs and technical write-offs, and rose over ₹650 Crores in FY2023 alone even as the balance sheet shed ₹7,000 Crores.
- Debt repayment track record is extreme: Since September 2018, the company has repaid over ₹1,52,242 Crores gross and over ₹70,000 Crores net, described as probably the largest debt repayment by any corporate entity in India across financial and non-financial companies.
- Liquidity is being rationalized: On-balance sheet liquidity of approximately ₹4,500 Crores is being drawn down to minimize negative carry as access to funding has eased, with the liquidity coverage ratio at a comfortable 108% versus the mandated 60% for HFCs.
- Regulatory scrutiny was exhaustive: The company has undergone 15 inspections by regulators and statutory auditors since October 2019, concurrent audit by lenders of every rupee in and out, and adopted stricter NPA recognition and upgradation policies, all while navigating COVID and a liquidity squeeze.
Gagan Banga: "We have gone through a perfect storm much more than the most stringent stress test and believe now that FY2024 should be a period where we reorganize, rebrand and restart the growth journey such that we can get back to a respectable ROE over the course of the next three years."
Margins, Opex & the Path to ROE
- NII grew despite a shrinking book: Net interest income rose to ₹3,089 Crores from ₹2,752 Crores, supported mainly by income from the asset-light model and sale of investments, while margins were preserved so that pre-provisioning operating profit came in strong at ₹2,270 Crores.
- PAT dipped on opex investment: Profit after tax was marginally lower by about ₹50 Crores as opex rose 12% to ₹819 Crores, driven by an ₹86 Crore increase in spending on people and branches.
- Investment cycle has further to run: The company added almost 15% to its workforce and 30% to its branch network last year and will continue expanding both through FY2024 and FY2025, keeping the cost-to-income ratio at 20%+ until FY2026 when it should start declining.
- ROE target is explicit: Management expects the current sub-10% ROE to double to mid-teens by FY2026, supported by an ROA that expands from the current 1.4% toward 3% as the flow of asset-light loans scales.
- Dividend is technically possible but not committed: The company is technically able to pay a dividend even for FY2023, but the decision rests with the Board and shareholders at the AGM, with no commitment given on timing or amount.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Retail disbursements | At least ₹12,000 Crores in FY2024, retaining only 20% | FY2024 |
| Monthly disbursement run-rate | Average ₹1,300–1,400 Crores per month | H2 FY2024 |
| Net loan book growth | Flattish in H1, begin growing on net basis in H2 | H2 FY2024 |
| Wholesale recoveries | Recover another ₹2,500 Crores at ~₹400–500 Crores per quarter | Next six quarters |
| Wholesale liquidation | Liquidate another ₹4,000–5,000 Crores on net basis | Through FY2024 |
| ROE target | Expand to about 15% | FY2026 |
| ROA target | Expand toward 3% where flow of loans is happening | "Very shortly" |
| Cost-to-income ratio | Remain at 20%+ through FY2025, then start declining | FY2026 |
| New brand unveiling | Subject to approvals, new brand launched | ~120 days |
| Branch and headcount expansion | Continue adding to workforce and branch network | Through FY2025 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Net interest income | ₹3,089 cr, versus ₹2,752 cr in FY22 |
| Pre-provisioning operating profit | ₹2,270 cr, versus ₹2,019 cr in FY22 |
| Profit after tax | Marginally lower, about ₹50 cr lower YoY |
| Opex | ₹819 cr, +12% YoY from ₹733 cr; includes ~₹86 cr on people and branches |
| Net interest margin | 4% |
| ROA | 1.4%, expanded from prior year |
| ROE | 7.7% |
| Balance sheet size | ~₹75,000 cr, slight growth over Q3 FY23 |
| Loan book | Over ₹54,000 cr, slight growth over Q3 FY23 |
| Gross NPA | 2.86% (₹1,918 cr), lowest in 6 quarters on percentage basis, lowest in 12 quarters on absolute basis |
| Net NPA | 1.9% |
| Stage 2 loans | 8% of AUM, down from 31% in Q4 FY22 |
| Provision coverage | 3.4x gross NPA; implied provision of 88% on stage 2+3 loans |
| Consolidated capital adequacy | Over 31%, with Tier-1 of 26.6% post-reorganization |
| Net debt to equity | 2.2x |
| Retail disbursements (FY23) | ~₹8,000 cr, 2.5x of FY22; FY24 goal of at least ₹12,000 cr |
| Co-lending and sell-down contribution | 34% of AUM, up from 10% in Q4 FY18 |
| Liquidity coverage ratio | 108%, against mandated 60% |
| Cash liquidity | ~₹4,500 cr, excludes sanctioned but undrawn lines |
| 90+ dpd on co-lending pool | Below 0.10% (10 bps) |
| Workforce addition | ~15% added in FY23 |
| Branch network expansion | ~30% added in FY23 |
| Cost-to-income guidance | 20%+ through FY24 and FY25, declining by FY26 |
| ROE target | ~15% by FY26 |
| Recoveries from wholesale NPA/written-off pool | ₹2,500 cr recovered to date; another ₹2,500 cr expected over next 6 quarters |
| ECB repayment reserve | ₹966 cr deposited, 50% of $270 mn ECBs due August 2023 |
| FCCB repayment reserve | ₹314 cr deposited, 25% of $170 mn FCCBs due FY24-FY25 |