Key Takeaways
- 9% revenue growth, 220 bps margin expansion: The shift to BS-VI RDE products without catalyst (supplied FOC) moved revenue to value-added sales, lifting EBITDA margin to 13%.
- Gross profit, not volume, is the new compass: Management declined to share volume data due to the catalyst supply change and instead pointed to 20%+ gross profit growth as the proxy for content-per-vehicle gains.
- EV venture is in testing, not launching: Products are stuck in a regulatory testing queue with no commercialization timeline; management intends to move "very, very cautiously" given battery risk.
- Capital allocation pivot is underway: A narrower, upward-revised dividend policy is being drafted, and M&A for powertrain-agnostic products is the stated first preference for surplus cash.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the TREM5 nomination balance concludes by February, any notification on tractor regulation timelines, and the final shape of the new dividend policy.
The Catalyst Phaseout & Margin Story
- Structural shift in revenue mix: All new BS-VI RDE products launched from 1 April come without catalysts, which are now supplied free of cost as a strategic choice. This moves the revenue line to the value-added sales component, mechanically expanding margins.
- Q2 as the first clean read: This was the first full quarter with the new products ramped up, making it a good indicator of the streamlined product profile. Further optimization is still possible as products mature along the learning curve.
- Gross profit as the volume proxy: Management will not disclose unit volumes because the catalyst change distorts the comparison; it back-tested gross profit and found it a reliable indicator of business growth. Gross profit grew roughly 20%+ this quarter against a blended market growth of 5%-7%, signaling content-per-vehicle gains.
- Catalyst phaseout end-state: Progress on phasing out catalyst from revenues is "very good," and as new businesses replace old ones, catalyst could eventually disappear from the sales front entirely, though no specific timeline was given.
- Margin sustainability caveat: The quarter benefited from a very good product mix; management sees further scope for improvement but did not commit to a steady-state margin level.
Relan: "So as a strategy, we are looking to make the catalyst FOC basis. So the new products are basically on the value-added sales part."
Regulatory Pipeline & Triggers
- TREM5 timeline slipping: Implementation is likely delayed past the general election; no government notification has been issued. Half of the business nomination is concluded, with the balance expected by February, and a finite date is expected only post-election.
- Tractor regulation also in limbo: The next regulatory trigger for tractors faces a possible delay with no notification issued yet.
- Construction equipment opening: The next regulatory series for construction equipment would likely be equivalent to tractors, and a niche but attractive market has already opened and is live.
- EV testing bottleneck: The company's EV products are in the testing queue with the agency, but a large backlog has built up due to multiple regulatory changes and strategy shifts in the 2-wheeler EV market. No launch timeline was offered.
Growth Bets & Business Development
- 3-liter to 4-liter CV segment: A new product is being developed for this segment, which management calls a "fairly large market" for the company's content if it can break in.
- Suspension and EV programs: Management flagged "surprise good news" in suspension, covering all EV programs, as part of its optimism for FY24 and FY25.
- Export ambition: Establishing an export business for emission systems (smaller tractors, gensets, subcomponents) is part of the five-year plan and described as a "very large area" that could be a "very positive surprise," though no timeline or quantum was disclosed.
- Five-year plan anchors: Maintain or increase market share in LCV and PV RDE domestic exhaust; enter the 3-4 liter CV market; attain #1 or #2 leadership in domestic tractors; build or buy a powertrain-agnostic product via M&A; build smaller businesses like suspension; focus the JV on 2-wheeler and 3-wheeler EV.
- PLI scheme conservatism: Management called it "very early to comment," citing ambiguity and changes, and is treating any benefit as an added positive rather than a base-case assumption.
Relan: "If we could break into that segment, that is a fairly large market when it comes to our content."
Capital Allocation & Shareholder Returns
- Dividend policy revision in motion: The current policy (10%-30% of PAT) is being revised upward, with the band narrowed to make payouts more predictable. Internal consensus is being sought and the matter will be taken up "shortly."
- M&A as first call on cash: Surplus reserves are earmarked first for acquiring a powertrain-agnostic product, though management stressed a conservative, long-term orientation and said many interactions are underway with no fixed timeline.
- Management bandwidth being augmented: The company is adding bandwidth to enable better investor interactions and more strategic value creation, though no specifics or timeline were given.
Relan: "Our first preference is to utilize it for an M&A opportunity in powertrain agnostic products, but we also want to be conservative and long-term oriented when it comes to M&A."
EV & JV: Cautious, Incremental
- JV contribution still negligible: The JV benefited from higher heavy commercial vehicle sales and improved on a percentage basis, but absolute profit contribution was only ₹1 crore, or 1-2% of consolidated PBT.
- EV approach is deliberately slow: Management will wait for full testing and full approval before commercializing EV products, citing the risk associated with battery as a field product. Investment will be incremental.
- Tractor market positioning: Only three companies in India and perhaps four or five globally can participate in tractor emission regulations; Sharda is one of them, which underpins its ambition for #1 or #2 domestic leadership.
Relan: "So we will be very, very cautious on this and will move steadily rather than dive into this, given that the risk associated with it, and we will also incrementally invest on this side."
Disclosure Boundaries
- Volume data is off the table: Management repeatedly declined to share volume growth figures, quarterly or YTD, citing the catalyst supply change and a philosophy against quarterly matching. Gross profit is the offered alternative.
- Catalyst revenue percentage withheld: The company will not disclose the catalyst content in revenue due to customer commitments. An analyst's assumption of 30% no-catalyst revenue was neither confirmed nor denied.
- Export quantum and customer names undisclosed: Exports are "not a very large percentage" of turnover, but no exact number or customer identity was shared.
- No revenue target: Management declined to endorse an analyst's suggestion of a ₹10,000 crore revenue target in three years.
- Gross profit index still in development: The company is working on a formal gross-profit-based disclosure index using a pre-BS-VI base year, but it remains a work in progress and will be shared only once management is comfortable.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| TREM5 nomination conclusion | Balance half of business nomination to conclude | By February (post-election for finite regulatory date) |
| Dividend policy revision | Upward revision with narrower band for predictability | To be taken up "shortly"; no date given |
| Gross profit disclosure index | Formal index using pre-BS-VI base year, shared publicly | Once management is comfortable; no date given |
| EV product commercialization | Full testing and full approval required before launch | No timeline; dependent on testing queue clearance |
| M&A for powertrain-agnostic products | First preference for cash surplus; conservative approach | No fixed timeline; "many interactions happening" |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹763 cr, +9% YoY |
| H1 FY24 revenue | ₹1,417 cr, +7% YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹99 cr, +31% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 13%, +220 bps YoY |
| H1 FY24 EBITDA | ₹168 cr, +23% YoY |
| H1 FY24 EBITDA margin | 12%, +155 bps YoY |
| PBT | ₹106 cr, +44% YoY |
| PAT | ₹80 cr, +47% YoY |
| H1 FY24 PAT | ₹135 cr, +35% YoY |
| Cash and cash equivalents | ₹658 cr as on 30th September 2023 |
| JV and associates profit | ₹1.1 cr, vs ₹0.6 cr in Q2 FY23 |
| Revenue mix (emission side) | 40% PV, 60% LCV and others |
| Gross profit growth (indicator of volume) | ~20% to 23% YoY (per an analyst's math) |
| H1 gross profit growth (indicator of volume) | ~15% to 18% YoY (per an analyst's math) |
| Dividend policy | 10% to 30% of PAT, upward revision under consideration |