Key Takeaways
- Strong FY22 recovery, but Q4 optics muddy: Full-year revenue grew 30% to INR 2,255 crore on a low base, yet management declined to quantify value-added sales growth or margins, citing customer-mix distortions that make reported revenue an unreliable guide.
- Legislation is the structural growth engine: TREM 4, RDE and TREM 5 norms will sequentially expand the addressable market through FY25, with TREM 5 in 2024 emissionising the entire tractor market and RDE in 2023 increasing content per vehicle in LCVs.
- CV JV is a drag that should self-correct: The Eberspächer JV is near breakeven at INR 200 crore annual value-added sales but has stalled because the two or three engines it supplies are disproportionately hit by semiconductor and precious-metal shortages.
- Export ambition is real but unquantified: Management sees a China-plus-one tailwind and claims in-house technology for CEV/CPCB/TREM norms, yet declined to size the opportunity or give timing, calling it a potential "very positive surprise."
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the CV JV's supply-side headwinds ease and revenue begins tracking toward breakeven, any confirmation of a customer switching to value-added sales, and initial TREM 4 production volumes starting in September.
Legislation Tailwinds & the 80% Mix Target
- Three-stage regulatory unlock: TREM 4 (April 2022) gives a marginal increase in tractors requiring aftertreatment; RDE (April 2023) increases content per vehicle for PV and LCV plus some CV market share opportunity; TREM 5 (2024) emissionises the entire tractor and construction equipment market, which is the biggest step-change for Sharda.
- 80% non-PV revenue by FY25: Management expects off-highway, CV and LCV to contribute 80% of revenue, driven by TREM 5 expanding the tractor addressable market and RDE increasing content per truck on the LCV side.
- TREM 4 contribution starts small: The market is very small right now, expected to contribute only 2–3% of sales initially, with acceleration in full FY24; TREM 5 is where "really good growth will be seen."
- CEV norms this year are limited: TREM 4 and the manual regulation for construction equipment vehicles do not cover a big part of the market; significant addressable-market expansion comes next year with RDE and the year after with TREM 5.
- Technology already in-house: R&D investment need not rise substantially for new norms because the IP for the next five to seven years, both domestic and export, is already developed; the task now is to "sweat that asset."
- Market share expectations: In PV/LCV/CV where Sharda already plays, no substantial market share change is expected; in CV, a little bit of market share increase is possible from programs not held in the prior cycle; in the new TREM 5 market, management is "very hopeful" of good market share given existing customer relationships on export products.
Relan: "So, we gave the guidance that 80% of our revenues will come from the off highway, commercial vehicle, and LCV segment together. And that is largely due to two things. One in 2024, we will be getting the TREM 5 norms in India, which emissionises the complete tractor market. So that is going to be an expansion of our addressable market."
CV Joint Venture: Stalled but Structurally Sound
- Revenue stagnation despite customer addition: Value-added revenue in the JV was fairly similar to FY21 even after adding another customer, because one customer faced severe supply-side issues with its engine model, hit by both semiconductor and precious-metal shortages.
- Breakeven threshold is clear: The JV breaks even at INR 200 crore annual value-added sales; performance will improve as soon as the two or three underperforming engine models see an uptick.
- Consolidation treatment: JV numbers are consolidated only at the profit-after-tax level; all reported revenue numbers are standalone Sharda Motor, so the JV's top-line stagnation does not dilute reported group revenue.
- Expansion deferred: Full focus is first to bring the JV to profitability; only then will management look at the next phase of expansion.
Revenue Quality & the Reporting Distortion
- Value-added vs brick sales mix creates optical noise: Roughly half of customers make Sharda buy the catalyst, while half give it free of cost; blend shifts between these customer types can substantially swing reported revenue without any change in underlying activity or market share.
- Management declined to quantify value-added growth: An analyst asked for color on how the value-added piece grew YoY and how margins behaved; management said commenting on margins would allow reverse calculation of value-added numbers and is working with customers to enable such disclosures in future.
- No qualitative issues behind the revenue-production gap: Management confirmed no loss of market share and no value-addition changes with OEMs; the divergence is purely optical, driven by SIAM/FADA reporting lags versus OEM production dynamics and semiconductor-related yard-holding.
- Competitive position stable: Ex-Maruti, Sharda is generally first, an American company second, and a French company third; positions are very close and keep shifting, with no significant change seen.
- One customer may switch to value-added sales: A customer is considering switching to a value-added sales basis starting this financial year, but confirmation is yet to be received; management is "not wanting to push too hard."
Relan: "We are very actively working at different options to make this more predictable and transparent. And we are working along with our customers to enable us to share these kinds of numbers."
Export Opportunity: Early Stage, China-Plus-One Tailwind
- China-plus-one trend is the core thesis: Management sees the trend as "extremely strong" and believes it will benefit companies like Sharda that play in the sub-component and small-engine emission markets.
- Technology is the differentiator: Sharda claims to be one of the few companies globally with in-house technology to meet CEV, CPCB, TREM 4 and TREM 5 norms, positioning it as "a great alternative towards this China thing."
- Targeting tier-ones and small engine manufacturers: The export strategy does not target OEMs directly but rather tier-one suppliers for sub-components and small engine manufacturers; target geographies are mainly North America and Europe.
- Proprietary backward-integrated components: Components developed in-house have usefulness beyond Sharda's own products, broadening the addressable export basket.
- No sizing or timing given: Management called the opportunity vast and scattered, declined to put a number on it, and said it will provide broad guidelines only once things firm up; the development cycle has started with RFQs rolling.
Relan: "This China plus one trend is extremely strong all over the world. And that is going to benefit companies like us who will play in the sub-component market as well as the small engineer emission market."
Capital Allocation: M&A Hunt & Dividend Policy
- M&A search is active but disciplined: Management is "very actively" looking at M&A opportunities focused on the domestic market or a company that can enable the export strategy, to strengthen the core or add to a powertrain-agnostic strategy; global market acquisitions are not being considered.
- Prudence over speed: Capital will be deployed only if an opportunity fits the right strategy and right terms; management is "being very careful and not just going for any M&A opportunity."
- Dividend policy maintained: A dividend of 15% of PAT for FY22 was proposed, equivalent to 408% on face value; the policy of distributing 10% to 30% of PAT will be maintained for the coming year.
Relan: "We want to be very careful also while deploying this capital, but we are very active on the M&A front. And of course, if it pitch with the right strategy and at the right terms, we will definitely be deploying this capital there, but in a prudent fashion."
EV & Adjacent Bets
- Kinetic Green partnership is Phase 1 only: Sharda is focusing completely on battery assembly and BMS for Kinetic Green's two-wheeler segment; only after successful implementation will it go beyond to other contracts.
- No contribution yet: SOP has not started, so there is no contribution in current numbers.
- TREM 4 production timeline: Norms come into effect from 1 October 2022; production is likely to start in September.
- Customer acquisition on new norms: Good customer acquisition has been done on TREM 4 and Stage V; some customers are already utilizing Stage V products to export to other countries.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue mix target | 80% of revenues from off-highway, CV and LCV segments combined | By FY25 |
| CV JV breakeven | Breakeven at INR 200 crore annual value-added sales; recovery contingent on supply-side normalization for two or three engine models | As engine models see uptick |
| TREM 4 production start | Production likely to begin in September, norms effective 1 October 2022 | September 2022 |
| TREM 4 revenue contribution | ~2–3% of sales initially, accelerating in full FY24 | FY24 |
| Dividend policy | Maintain 10% to 30% of PAT distribution | FY23 |
| Five-year growth outlook | Confident to maintain historical growth rates or better, outperforming the market substantially | Next five years |
| M&A deployment | Capital will be deployed if an opportunity fits the right strategy and terms; no global acquisitions | No timeline given |
| Export business scale-up | Business development ongoing; RFQs rolling; no sizing or timing provided | No timeline given |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY22 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹2,255 cr (full year FY22), +30% YoY; Q4 +2% YoY and +7% QoQ |
| EBITDA including other income | ₹72 cr, +24% YoY from ₹58 cr |
| EBITDA margin including other income | 11.6%, up from 9.6% in Q4 FY21 |
| PBT margin | 9.8%, up from 7.4% in Q4 FY21 |
| Consolidated PAT | ₹45 cr, +73% YoY from ₹26 cr |
| Full year FY22 consolidated PAT | ₹150 cr, +127% YoY from ₹66 cr |
| Proposed dividend | 408% on face value, equivalent to 15% of PAT |
| Dividend policy | 10% to 30% of PAT |
| Consolidated cash | ~₹450 cr, completely free and unencumbered |
| CV JV value-added sales | ₹100–120 cr (full year FY22), breakeven at ₹200 cr annually |
| CV JV capacity utilization | 40–50% |
| CV JV combined market share | 10–15% |
| Revenue mix: PV and LCV | 40–45% each of standalone revenue |
| Revenue mix: exhaust systems | 90% of revenue; suspension 6%, procurement/other 2–3% |
| RDE content per vehicle increase | 10–15% blended; gasoline ~10%, diesel ~25% |