Key Takeaways
- Strong headline growth, commodity drag: 9-month standalone PAT rose 49.47% and consolidated revenue grew ~36%, but the quarter was dented by a sharp NCDEX decline and MCX technology migration disruption.
- Diversification is the core thesis: Management is building NBFC, merchant banking, GIFT City, Singapore and strategy-based trading streams so that market downturns do not dry up group revenue, a deliberate hedge against stock-market dependence.
- Retail push is scaling, but still early: uTrade Algos has 20,000 trial users with a 7–8% activation rate, and the company is converting franchisees to branches to acquire retail customers offline at lower cost, though the offline mandate only began in Q3.
- Employee count doubled on a catch-up exercise: The jump from 1,500-plus to 3,500-plus reflects a half-year gap in reporting, branch expansion from 70 to 150, and franchisee conversions; management expects the number to stabilize in 2–3 quarters.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether MCX volumes recover once the TCS technology stack stabilizes, the pace of offline retail customer acquisition, and any inorganic deal that accelerates the 3-lakh-customer target.
Diversification & the Case Against Market Dependence
- The structural bet: Management is deliberately building revenue streams outside broking so that a 50% market fall does not cripple the group, with subsidiaries now operating across NBFC, merchant banking, GIFT City IFSC, Singapore, and strategy-based overseas trading.
- NBFC is the fastest-growing leg: The loan book doubled from INR127 crores (March 2023) to INR235 crores (December 2023), branches expanded from 42 to 57, and the portfolio is diversifying into SME and collateralized loans while keeping leverage and on-book risk to the parent low.
- Merchant banking and international presence are next: Management expects good growth in merchant banking, especially the SME segment, next year, and plans to establish a presence in different world markets within one year.
- Funding discipline: NBFC growth will be funded through internal accruals and equity, not excessive leverage; the pace is described as conservative, streamlined, and not at an unexpected clip.
Sachin Gupta: "we are trying to make Share India such a diversified company where market movement and all these things should not make any impact on the growth and the revenue of the company."
Commodity Segment: A Temporary Hit with a Bullish Post-Election Bet
- What broke in Q3: NCDEX business dropped drastically after government intervention shut down certain commodities over inflation concerns, while MCX volumes were hit by the technology stack migration from Financial Technologies to TCS, which management says is not yet stable.
- The damage is not permanent: On a 9-month basis, the commodity segment performed better YoY with ADT similar at ~INR1,500 crores, and the company is not losing market share despite the transition hiccup.
- The recovery timeline: Management expects MCX to pick up in one to two months and grow next financial year, while NCDEX is seen as offering no growth at all.
- Post-election thesis: Management holds a very strong bullish stand on commodity after this year's elections and is getting offices in Bombay, Jaipur and Ahmedabad ready to capture the anticipated growth.
- Options shift as a tailwind: As MCX matures, turnover is expected to shift from futures to options, and the company believes its edge in both instruments will let it gain market share in option turnover.
- FPI DMA opportunity: MCX has permitted DMA for FPIs, and Share India has relationships with more than 40 FPIs from Dubai, Singapore and elsewhere that are eagerly waiting for the facility.
Retail & Algo: Building the Customer Funnel
- The 3-lakh-customer target: Management has committed to reaching around 3 lakh retail customers in three years through both organic and inorganic routes, with aggressive acquisition plans and new innovative products.
- uTrade Algos is the lead product: Launched in June, it has drawn over 20,000 trial customers with a 7–8% activation conversion rate, which management considers good for an online product; offline adoption is expected to pick up.
- Channel mix is shifting to offline: Currently ~1,000 customers per month with 70–75% coming online, but offline customer acquisition mandates only started in Q3, and management expects offline growth to far exceed online at a much lower cost going forward.
- Algo market positioning: Retail algo adoption is still very low, and Share India sees itself as uniquely positioned to consolidate the unorganized market into the organized segment because it owns the full in-house tech stack across uTrade, Silverleaf and Algowire.
- MTS book ambition: The Margin Trading Scheme book is targeted to reach around INR500 crores in the next three years.
Abhinav Gupta: "we being the Share India and being regulated player with the tech stack in-house developed from uTrade, Silverleaf and Algowire, are at a uniquely positioned to consolidate this market from the market."
Employee Count & Branch Expansion
- The surge is a reporting catch-up, not a single-quarter spike: The employee count exercise had not been done for the last half-year, so the jump from 1,500-plus to 3,500-plus captures branch expansion from 70 to 150, conversion of franchisees to a branch model for retail acquisition, and continued hiring in the traditional business, all accumulated over that period.
- Stabilization expected soon: Management expects the employee count to stabilize in the next two to three quarters as the branch and franchisee conversion wave normalizes.
Guidance Philosophy & the Conservative Stance
- 20%-plus CAGR is the floor, not the ceiling: Management prefers to be conservative and guides to upwards of 20% CAGR for the next five years, but 9-month performance already shows healthy growth upward of 25%, and the company expects to grow organic business at a 25–30% CAGR.
- PAT margin anchor: The company has maintained a PAT margin of around 30% for the last nine months and commits to sustaining that level.
- The India macro tailwind: Management ties its growth thesis to India's journey from a INR3.5 trillion to INR7.5-odd trillion economy in the next five to seven years, which it believes should reflect in financial markets performance and benefit all participants.
Kamlesh Shah: "We always would like to be conservative. If you see the -- I mean, the performance for the 9 months, it is already showing the healthy growth of upward of 25%. So, I mean this is what we believe we have discounted all the unforeseen events and the global turmoil or any other events."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue CAGR | 20%-plus (organic business trending 25–30%) | Next 5 years |
| PAT margin | Maintain around 30% | Ongoing |
| Retail customer count | Reach ~3 lakh customers organically and inorganically | Next 3 years |
| MTS book size | Reach ~INR500 crores | Next 3 years |
| NBFC loan book growth | Grow organically at a decent, streamlined pace; diversify into more collateralized loans | Next 3 years |
| Employee count | Stabilize from current surge | Next 2–3 quarters |
| MCX volume recovery | MCX business to pick up and grow | Next 1–2 months; next financial year |
| International presence | Start having presence in different world markets | Next 1 year |
| Offline customer acquisition | Offline growth to far exceed online at lower cost | Going forward |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | ₹374 cr, +35% YoY from ₹277 cr |
| Consolidated PAT | ₹115 cr, +25% YoY from ₹93 cr |
| Consolidated EPS | ₹35.27 |
| Consolidated networth | ₹1,405 cr as of Dec 31 |
| Standalone revenue | ₹284 cr, +46% YoY from ₹194 cr |
| Standalone PAT | ₹83 cr, +49% YoY from ₹56 cr |
| Standalone EPS | ₹25.45 |
| Standalone networth | ₹1,140 cr |
| 9-month consolidated revenue growth | ~36% YoY, from ₹748 cr to ₹1,017 cr |
| 9-month consolidated PAT growth | 39% YoY, from ₹223 cr to ₹310 cr |
| Revenue CAGR guidance | 20%-plus for next 5 years, management noted conservative stance vs prior 25-30% |
| PAT margin guidance | ~30%, maintained over last 9 months, expected to continue |
| Retail revenue share | 10% to 15% of revenue from retail specifically, excluding NBFC and institutional AD revenue |
| NBFC loan book | ₹235 cr as of Dec 31, up from ₹127 cr as of Mar 31, 2023; ₹169 cr entrepreneur loans, remainder SMB loans |
| NBFC active customers | ~68,000 across 57 branches, up from 42 branches |
| Commodity ADT (MCX) | ~₹1,500 cr, consistent for last 4-6 quarters |
| MCX market share | More than 10% |
| Employee count | 3,500-plus, up from 1,500-plus last quarter; jump partly due to employee count exercise not done in prior half-year |
| Branch count | ~150, up from ~70 in last few quarters |
| uTrade Algos trial customers | Over 20,000 since June launch, with 7-8% activation conversion rate |
| Retail customers acquired (last 1.5 years) | ~13,000 to 14,000 KYC-registered customers |
| Monthly customer acquisition run-rate | ~1,000 customers on average, 70-75% via online mode |
| Retail customer target | 2.5 lakh to 3 lakh organically and inorganically in next 2-3 years |
| MTS book target | ~₹500 cr in next 3 years |