Key Takeaways
- Record quarter, record year: Q4 revenue crossed ₹340 crores and PAT crossed ₹100 crores for the first time, capping a year where annual revenue passed ₹1,000 crores and PAT hit ₹330 crores.
- Proprietary engine is process-driven, not star-trader: Management describes prop income as an industrial-scale process of strategy design, back-testing and deployment, with over 1,500 employees involved and no permanent borrowings.
- uTrade Algos is the next growth bet: The retail algo platform launched in beta with millisecond latency, a full public launch set for end-June 2023, and a target of 2 lakh customers within two years.
- FY24 framed as a consolidation year: Management is conservative on near-term industry growth, citing more regulations, and plans to use its ₹1,000 crore net worth to acquire brokers and build new verticals while margins may stagnate.
- What to watch next quarter: The uTrade Algos public launch and pricing reveal, any broker acquisitions, and whether the institutional desk build-out begins to show early traction.
Proprietary Trading: The Core Engine
- Scale and sustainability: Proprietary trading is the largest revenue contributor, described as a capital-intensive scale business where deep pockets and a ₹1,000 crore net worth give an edge over competitors. The absolute amount has grown significantly over years, and management sees more headroom as Indian markets expand with new participants.
- Process-driven, not person-dependent: Income comes from multiple derivative-based algos deployed at smaller capital, with no single algo dominating. Strategies are designed, back-tested and deployed by separate intellectual teams, then executed by different traders, a process management likens to an industrial manufacturing line.
- Revenue mix shift underway: Proprietary trading will continue to grow in absolute terms, but its percentage share of total revenue will decline as client-related businesses, particularly uTrade algos, grow much faster.
Kamlesh Shah: "Our prop income is basically processed. It's just like a normal industry where there are people who are thinking about the strategies, they are back testing. They are testing those strategies. And then strategies are going live with different set of traders... So this is a complete process like a normal steel company. the buy a raw material, the process it inside and they sell it to their customers, right?"
uTrade Algos: The Retail Algo Bet
- Product and timing: The beta version launched in April 2023 with what management claims is the fastest latency for any Indian retail algo platform, bringing execution from seconds down to milliseconds. A full public launch with a "big bang marketing plan" is set for end-June 2023, with features allowing users to build their own algos or use in-built "uTrade originals."
- Pricing disruption: Management is designing a fixed monthly brokerage plus fixed product cost model to remove ambiguity on charges. The goal is to make algo trading viable for smaller traders with ₹5 lakh capital, undercutting a market where per-leg charges can run to ₹24,000 per month on ₹10 lakh of capital, a cost structure management says makes it impossible for retail to earn using algos.
- Target scale: The company is targeting 2 lakh customers within two years from now, aiming to create its own niche in retail algo trading where current broking structures have kept retail out.
Sachin Gupta: "nobody can earn money using algo reading if they put any number on the turnover side. So here, we are coming as a disruptive model. We want to make it viable for even the person"
Diversification & Subsidiary Build-Out
- Subsidiary contribution growing: Subsidiaries contributed ₹101 crores, or 30% of consolidated PAT of ₹330 crores, up from a ~25% share last year. All 11 subsidiaries are at a nascent stage, operating only 3–4 years versus the 29-year-old standalone broking business, and management expects long-term value unlocking as they develop and become eligible for listing.
- NBFC expansion: The loan book stood at ₹127 crores with 63,000 clients and 45 branches across 5 states as of March 2023. The company expects to open 25 more branches, target a client base above 1 lakh, and close the portfolio at around ₹200 crores.
- Insurance and merchant banking: The insurance business crossed ₹40 crores in premium in its third year of operation. Merchant banking will focus on SME IPOs, where listing volumes are much higher than the main board.
- Institutional desk: A large institutional desk is being set up in Mumbai over the next 3–4 months, with results expected in coming years.
Industry Backdrop & Consolidation Opportunity
- FY24 as a year of consolidation: Management is conservative on near-term industry growth, expecting more regulations and saying "not see huge growth coming in this year." The view is that brokers who consolidate now will see big profit potential in coming years.
- Acquisition pipeline: Share India raised over ₹800 crores partly to be a preferred destination for smaller and midsize brokers looking to merge their businesses. The company is in touch with a new set of brokers who can shift business or merge.
- Long-term market conviction: Management sees India's GDP reaching ₹7–8 trillion as achievable in the next tenure, with a regulated environment boosting investor confidence. New products like Midcap Nifty and commodity contracts on NSE are expected to add momentum.
Sachin Gupta: "I am a bit conservative for this year only, but in a longer term, of time we must meet all the compassions."
Margins & Capital Deployment
- Margin trajectory: Margins have improved over the last 5 years because costs have not increased proportionally with revenue as technology took over most functions. Management states margins are "definitely going to go up only" long-term, with "no chance" of coming down because the company is not cost-heavy.
- FY24 margin pause: This year may see some stagnation in margins because the company is investing in creating new verticals including retail, insurance and merchant banking, and will put more cost and effort there.
- Capital deployment plan: The ₹800 crore fundraise, of which ₹200 crores has been received so far with the balance collectible over 18 months via partly paid warrants at ₹700 conversion price, will primarily fund the MTF book. Under SEBI's restricted leveraging norms, the broker must put ₹25 of own funds for every ₹100 of client capital, and MTF cannot be refinanced. The capital will service retail and HNI clients over the next 2–3 years.
Sachin Gupta: "we believe these margins are definitely going to go up only. There is no chance that margins will come down because we are not a much cost-heavy company."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| uTrade Algos full public launch | Full launch with "big bang marketing plan" | End of June 2023 |
| uTrade Algos pricing | Finalize and publish pricing on website | Within 15 days (from call date) |
| uTrade Algos user target | 2 lakh customers | Within 2 years |
| 5-year revenue CAGR | 25% to 35% CAGR | Next 5 years |
| NBFC portfolio target | Close at around ₹200 crores | Unspecified, expansion underway |
| NBFC branch expansion | Open 25 more branches | Unspecified |
| Institutional desk | Set up large Mumbai office for institutional clients | Next 3–4 months |
| MTF capital deployment | Deploy raised funds to service retail and HNI MTF book | Next 2–3 years |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | More than ₹340 cr, compared to ₹293 cr in Q4 FY22; highest quarterly revenue ever |
| Profit after tax | More than ₹100 cr, +40% YoY and +15% QoQ; first ever quarterly PAT above ₹100 cr |
| EPS | ₹1,100 cr (as stated) |
| FY23 annual revenue | More than ₹1,000 cr, first ever annual revenue above this mark |
| FY23 annual PAT | ₹330 cr, against ₹201 cr in FY22; highest ever annual PAT |
| FY23 PAT margin | More than 30% |
| FY23 EBITDA margin | More than 45% |
| Net worth | More than ₹1,018 cr, versus ₹458 cr in FY22 |
| 7-year CAGR | Close to 77% |
| Revenue from proprietary trading | Around 60% of total business |
| Revenue from client business | Around 30% of total revenue |
| Revenue from NBFC | Around 10% of total revenue |
| Revenue from service-related businesses | Around 2–3% of total revenue, including insurance, technology, and capital services |
| Client base | Around 28,000 clients |
| Average daily turnover | More than ₹12,000 cr |
| Market share of option trading | Around 5% |
| Employee strength | More than 1,500 employees |
| Subsidiary contribution to consolidated PAT | ₹101 cr, 30% of consolidated PAT of ₹330 cr |
| NBFC loan book | Around ₹127 cr in March '23 |
| NBFC clients | Almost 63,000 |
| NBFC branches | 45 across 5 states |
| Insurance premium | More than ₹40 cr in FY23, third year for the company |
| Fundraising completed | More than ₹800 cr, combining shares and partly paid warrants |
| uTrade Algos customer target | 2 lakh customers within 2 years |
| Q4 standalone PAT | ₹85 cr |
| Q4 consolidated PAT | ₹106 cr |
| Q3 standalone PAT | Close to ₹55 cr |
| Q3 consolidated PAT | ₹92 cr |
| FY18 to FY23 PAT growth | 2,100% |
| FY18 to FY23 net worth growth | 1,295% |