Key Takeaways
- Worst believed to be behind, recovery in sight: Management sees the past two quarters as a consolidation period and expects to return to first-half FY25 performance levels within the next 2 to 3 quarters.
- Prop trading hit by investment book, not strategy: A fair value loss of INR42 crores on the investment book skewed returns; hedged strategies were only slightly impacted by regulatory changes, and prop numbers are expected to bottom in Q4.
- Regulatory pivot from volume to margin: Post-November SEBI regulations, the strategy has shifted from volume-based to better margin-based trading, with stability already visible in sequential ADTO.
- Algo trading for retail is the next big bet: With SEBI allowing retail Algo from August 1, the company aims to own the category with a "think Algo, think Share India" push, alongside an AI-based product rollout by end-Q3.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether prop trading numbers actually bottom in Q4, the pace of NBFC stabilization after the shift to secured SME loans, and early traction on the PMS rollout scheduled for July.
Performance & The Downturn
- Below-standard year: The past year saw uncertainties, significant FPI selling, regulatory measures moderating derivative volumes, and a correction in investment values; performance was below usual standard, consistent with peers who reported losses or considerable drops.
- Revenue decline was anticipated: Management foresaw the decrease in revenue and profitability over the past two quarters and has implemented strategies for a strong rebound as the environment improves.
- Prop book skew: The prop book consists of hedged strategies and an investment book; the INR42 crores fair value loss came entirely from the investment book (equities in other companies), not from unhedged positions. Hedged strategies saw only a slight drop due to regulatory reasons.
- NBFC trouble and pivot: The NBFC faced difficulty over three quarters, especially in personal loans in villages; the company shifted focus to secured SME loans while maintaining the book size at INR260 crores.
- Sequential stability emerging: Q3 and Q4 ADTO were more or less similar, showing green shoots sequentially; the past two quarters were a consolidation period.
- Insurance distribution bright spot: Insurance distribution delivered INR75 crores premium, a 35-40% YoY jump, with bottom line also performing well.
Sachin Gupta: "I personally believe where I am into the day-to-day operations of the company, I believe the worst is behind us now. And we will see that things have started improving from here on."
Regulatory Landscape & Strategic Response
- Expiry day clarity: SEBI released a circular yesterday allowing exchanges to choose either Tuesday or Thursday for their benchmark indices weekly contracts, clarifying the earlier two-expiry-per-exchange rule.
- Position limit revisions proposed: Detailed discussions have happened on revising position limits: the end-of-day limit of INR500 crores will be revised to INR1,500 crores on a delta basis, with gross position monitoring at INR10,000 crores on both sides.
- Retail Algo trading greenlit: SEBI has allowed retail participation in Algo trading from August 1, which management sees as a major opportunity.
- New futures stocks: SEBI has been adding more stocks to the futures list, expanding the addressable market.
- Strategy shift to margin over volume: After the November 1 SEBI regulations, the company changed its strategy from volume-based to better margin-based trading, relying on better margins rather than high volumes.
- BSE options edge: BSE options market share grew from 3.5% to 5.8%, giving a good edge to the overall business.
- Surplus fund deployment: With net worth exceeding INR2,300 crores, a recent SEBI clarification enables investment in group companies and other businesses, potentially enhancing overall return on investment.
Sachin Gupta: "Not everything has to get consolidated and then start to go up. We need to stay relevant; we need to stay positive. And the success is not in achieving growth in one year. Success is growing continuously year-on-year basis. So consistency is what we require."
Algo, AI & Technology Bets
- "Think Algo, think Share India" ambition: The company wants to make this its tagline and go very hard for Algo trading for retail, leveraging the August 1 SEBI approval as a catalyst.
- AI-based product coming: An AI product that recommends stocks and generates technical charts will roll out at the end of the third quarter.
- Customer behavior focus: The company is now focusing on changing customer behavior (trading more in stocks, AI-based strategies, better platforms) rather than depending only on new customer flow.
- Consolidation welcomed: Management views industry consolidation as 100% welcome and is preparing to accept the shift in customer behavior that comes with it.
Diversification & New Initiatives
- PMS license obtained and rolling out: The license was received during the year, and the PMS will roll out in July; management expects it to start showing positive growth over the next three years.
- Silverleaf Securities acquisition: The subsidiary aimed at leveraging HFT capability and expanding proprietary trading internationally is expected to close this year; its numbers will be added to Share India's book and the acquisition will be EPS accretive within the fiscal year.
- AIF plans: Once PMS stabilizes, the company will also pursue an AIF.
- Metropolitan Stock Exchange investment: A key milestone achieved during the year, though MSE's entry into the equity market may take 1 to 2 years as they must develop the cash market first.
- New retail branches: Branches opened in Connaught Place (Delhi), Kolkata, and Ahmedabad in the last six months.
- Insurance expansion: This year the focus is on the northern part of India and entering the real estate/builder space for insurance distribution, with an internal target to touch INR100+ crores premium (30-35% YoY growth).
- Wealth management approach: The company is not setting aggressive AUM targets for wealth management, preferring to let the business stabilize and focus more on distribution first.
Sachin Gupta: "Yes, our business is highly regulated, so challenges are always there. But as we see the basket, if we go into -- if we see the retail side, wealth side, not PMS, addition of institution, AIF, MTF, prop desk and addition of Silverleaf, this makes our company well diversified and sustainable."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue and profit recovery | Achieve same numbers as first half of last financial year | Next 2 to 3 quarters |
| MTF book growth | MTF book not less than INR1,000 crores | Next 3 years |
| Retail client acquisition | Reach 2 lakh to 2.5 lakh clients | Next 3 years |
| PMS rollout | PMS goes live | July |
| AI product launch | AI-based stock recommendation and charting product | End of Q3 |
| Prop trading bottom | Prop numbers start improving from Q4; Q4 is the bottom | Q4 FY25 |
| NBFC stabilization | NBFC stabilizes and gives much better returns | This financial year |
| Insurance premium target | Touch INR100+ crores premium (30-35% YoY growth) | This year |
| Silverleaf acquisition close | Acquisition completed, numbers added to Share India book | This year |
| Silverleaf EPS accretion | Acquisition is EPS accretive | Within the fiscal year |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue from operations | ₹239 cr, down 30% QoQ |
| Consolidated profit before tax | ₹23 cr, down ~79% QoQ |
| Consolidated profit after tax | ₹19 cr, down ~77% QoQ |
| Consolidated EPS | ₹0.71 on face value of ₹2 per share |
| Standalone revenue from operations | ₹188 cr, down 28% QoQ |
| Standalone profit before tax | ₹17 cr, down 79% QoQ |
| Standalone profit after tax | ₹16 cr, down 73% QoQ |
| Standalone EPS | ₹0.63 on face value of ₹2 per share |
| Consolidated net worth | ₹2,300 cr-plus |
| Fair value loss booked in Q4 | ₹42 cr |
| Prop trading share of revenue | ~62%, rest from broking and NBFC |
| Prop trading share of profitability | ~47%, rest from other businesses |
| Retail clients | 46,252, up 30% YoY |
| Institutional clients | 137, up 250% YoY |
| MTF book | ₹239 cr, up over 330% YoY |
| BSE options market share | 5.8% in FY25, up from 3.5% in FY24 |
| NBFC book size | ₹260 cr, broadly flat YoY |
| NBFC branches | 80, up from 61 |
| Insurance distribution premium | ₹75 cr in FY25, up 35–40% YoY |