Key Takeaways
- Volume beats peers, pricing bites: Total volume grew 8% YoY to 0.96 crore tons, gaining 1% sequentially while peers lost 9–21%, but realization fell 6% YoY and 5% QoQ as weak demand and a geographic mix shift to lower-priced East markets erased pricing power.
- Demand recovery pushed out: Management now expects Q2 to remain weak, Q3 to be uncertain due to festive-season working-day losses, and any vibrancy to concentrate in Q4 when government departments rush to exhaust budgets. The earlier 4 crore ton FY25 volume guidance has been withdrawn.
- New capacity costs are running ahead of revenue: Stabilization expenses from the newly commissioned Guntur and Nawalgarh plants added roughly ₹52 crores in stores and spares this quarter, while the Nawalgarh plant’s logistics advantage will not materialize until the Etah grinding unit commissions in Q4.
- Consolidation is itself a price headwind: Management argues that companies contending for acquisitions are deliberately keeping cement prices depressed to secure better target valuations, calling this a major factor behind the industry’s inability to raise prices.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the central budget’s passage and resource allocation by September actually translates into demand, whether stabilization costs at new plants begin to normalize, and whether the non-trade mix shift reverses as demand conditions improve.
Demand & Pricing Environment
- Q1 was a demand shock: Elections and extreme weather suppressed demand across the industry, with Ramco losing 21% volume, Dalmia 16%, and UltraTech 9% sequentially. Shree gained 1% but could not secure remunerative pricing as the demand and price scenario deteriorated through the quarter.
- Pricing power is absent: Realization fell 6% YoY and 5% QoQ, driven by moderate demand conditions and a geographic mix shift. Management is explicit that pricing is a function of demand, and with demand not reviving, the industry has no pricing power.
- Near-term outlook is grim: July demand has not revived, August till date remains weak. The central budget has not yet been passed; presidential assent is expected in the third week of August, resources allocated by September, and tenders by mid-to-late September. Q2 is definitively not going to be good for the industry, and Q3 is uncertain due to 10 days lost to Diwali and Chhath Puja festivities. All vibrancy should reflect in Q4 when government departments face pressure to exhaust budgets.
- Volume guidance withdrawn: The earlier FY25 volume guidance of 4 crore tons has been toned down. Management now says the company will grow in tandem with the market and will beat that if it can do better.
- Consolidation is suppressing prices: Management identifies a structural pricing headwind: companies contending for acquisitions are keeping cement prices depressed to secure better valuations for targets, calling this a major factor behind the industry’s inability to increase prices.
Ashok Bhandari: "Q2, for sure, is not going to be good for the industry. And I will take an insurance on Q3 also because in Q3, you lose about 10 days of working because Diwali and Chhath Puja and all other festivities. So Q3 will be about 80 days instead of 90 days of working. Q2, the writing is on the wall."
Volume Growth & Competitive Dynamics
- Volume outperformance came at a cost: Shree grew volume 8% YoY to 0.96 crore tons while peers lost significant ground, but the cost of taking additional volume was estimated based on April prices. As both price and demand deteriorated, the company got the volume but not the remunerative pricing it had budgeted for.
- North lost to powerful competitors: North region volume declined because two powerful competitors, UltraTech and Ambuja, made it difficult to gain advantage there. Selling more in North would have meant accepting even lower realizations.
- East grew because it was possible to sell: The geographic mix shifted marginally from North to East, where realization was the lowest among regions at ₹4,154 per ton versus ₹4,641 in North and ₹4,620 in South. East volume grew simply because it was possible to sell more there.
- South is performing very badly: Realizations in the South are poor, but management views the Guntur plant investment with a 50-year vision and is not concerned about one quarter of underperformance.
- Non-trade mix shift added to realization pressure: The non-trade component increased during the quarter, which had some impact on realizations. This shift could potentially reverse when demand normalizes.
Ashok Bhandari: "Mr. Agarwal, please appreciate that if you are growing at a greater pace than your peer group volume-wise, it will have some appertinent cost with it. Now the cost estimation for taking additional volume was at level x based on the price prevailing in April and as the price and demand scenario both deteriorated, though we could get the additional volume, we could not get remunerative or better pricing."
Costs & Margins
- Fuel cost benefit partially offset realization pressure: Average fuel cost reduced from ₹2.34 per kCal last year to ₹1.76 per kCal this quarter. Based on committed orders, the average stands at ₹1.74 per kCal, and declining pet coke prices may bring it lower as new orders are placed at reduced rates.
- New plant stabilization costs hit other expenses: The commissioning of two new plants, Guntur and Nawalgarh, added approximately ₹52 crores in additional stores and spares consumed during the quarter. General normalization time for new plants is 3 to 6 months, though some may take up to 12 months.
- Advertisement expenses rose: Spending increased due to the launch of a new brand identity along with the Bangur MAGNA premium brand.
- Lead distance increased marginally: The quarter-on-quarter increase in lead distance was driven by the geographic mix shift toward the East.
- Cash focus over net profit: Management emphasizes the company is cash-focused, not net profit-focused, operating on the principle that cash is real and the rest is myth. Depreciation guidance stands at about ₹2,600 crores with current capacity.
Ashok Bhandari: "We are basically a cash-focused organization. We are not net profit-focused organization. We run the company on the principle that cash is real, rest all is myth."
Capacity Expansion & Strategic Projects
- New capacity commissioned: An integrated cement unit in Guntur district, Andhra Pradesh, with 0.3 crore tons per annum capacity was commissioned during the quarter. The company also achieved 1 GW of installed power capacity with the commissioning of a 19.5 MW solar plant in Andhra Pradesh, taking total power capacity to 1,003 MW.
- Ongoing projects on schedule: Projects in Jaitaran (0.6 crore tons), Kodla (0.3 crore tons), Baloda Bazar (0.34 crore tons), and Etah (0.3 crore tons), totaling about 1.5 crore tons, are progressing satisfactorily and as per schedule. The company is also working on further capacity expansions in different geographies to reach its target ahead of schedule.
- Nawalgarh logistics advantage delayed: The Nawalgarh plant is entitled to an industrial subsidy from Rajasthan state, restricted to GST collected within Rajasthan. Selling to NCR or Delhi would forfeit this subsidy. The plant’s logistics advantages will only materialize when the Etah grinding unit commissions in Q4 of this year. Currently, Nawalgarh is primarily catering to Rajasthan.
- Solar power expansion underway: The company is increasing solar power capacity by 135 MW at manufacturing locations in Rajasthan, Panipat, Jharkhand, Uttarakhand, and Uttar Pradesh. By June 2025, the renewable energy power mix is expected to reach 62%, up from the current 54%.
- RMC business in early stages: A greenfield ready-mix concrete plant was launched in Hyderabad in Q1. Management plans to set up almost 100 Bangur concrete plants over the next 3 to 5 years, operating in over 50 cities, but will first learn the nuances of the business with the current 5–6 plants before expanding.
- Annual capex run rate: Capital expenditure of ₹4,000 crores continues for the next year.
Disclosure Changes & Pushback
- Power business disclosure discontinued: Management has decided to stop providing a breakdown of EBITDA into grey, white, RMC, and others. Only blended EBITDA will be reported going forward, and power revenues and power EBITDA will not be disclosed separately.
- Geographic mix split not quantified: When asked for the contribution of realization decline specifically attributable to geographic mix shift versus overall market decline, management did not provide a quantified split, instead giving region-wise realizations and volume percentages for the analyst to calculate independently.
- No price or EBITDA guidance: Management reiterated that it has never in 40 years given any guidance on price or EBITDA, only on cost. When asked for cash tax rate guidance, management called it an infructuous question since PBT depends on EBITDA, which they do not guide on.
- Subsidy run rate unpredictable: Management declined to estimate the annual run rate of cash incentives for FY25 and FY26, citing state governments’ tight financial positions and unpredictable release timing.
- Bangladesh turmoil dismissed as irrelevant: Management stated that Bangladesh is a surplus market and any turmoil there will have no impact on India, as only small quantities reach a few districts of Northeast India, not even a full state.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Capacity expansion | 1.5 crore tons under construction (Jaitaran, Kodla, Baloda Bazar, Etah) progressing as per schedule | Etah grinding unit in Q4 FY25; others as per schedule |
| Renewable energy mix | RE power mix to reach 62% from current 54% | By June 2025 |
| Solar power expansion | 135 MW additional solar capacity across Rajasthan, Panipat, Jharkhand, Uttarakhand, Uttar Pradesh | As new plants are commissioned |
| Annual capex | ₹4,000 crores | Continues for next year |
| Dividend trend | Increasing dividend trend | Ongoing |
| RMC expansion | Plans for ~100 Bangur concrete plants across 50+ cities | Over next 3 to 5 years |
| Water positivity | Improve water positivity level to more than 7x | For the full year |
| Volume growth | Grow in tandem with the market; beat if possible (prior 4 crore ton guidance withdrawn) | FY25 |
| Demand recovery | Central budget passage expected third week of August, resources allocated by September, tenders by mid-to-late September; Q4 vibrancy expected as government departments exhaust budgets | Q4 FY25 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Total volume | 0.96 crore tons, +8% YoY and +1% QoQ |
| Capacity utilization | 76% |
| Realisation per ton | ₹4,469, -6% YoY from ₹4,771 and -5% QoQ from ₹4,721 |
| Average fuel cost per kCal | ₹1.76, down from ₹2.34 YoY |
| Average fuel cost net of alternative fuel | ₹1.74 per kCal |
| Total EBITDA | ₹916 cr, -2% YoY from ₹933 cr and -31% QoQ from ₹1,327 cr |
| EBITDA per ton | ₹950, down from ₹1,046 YoY and ₹1,392 QoQ |
| Cash profit | ₹957 cr, up from ₹898 cr YoY |
| Cash EPS | ₹259, up from ₹248 YoY |
| Additional stores and spares (stabilisation cost) | ₹52 cr in the quarter, for Guntur and Nawalgarh plants |
| Volume growth by region (YoY) | North +7%, East +15%, South -5% |
| Volume growth by region (QoQ) | North -3%, East +11%, South -4% |
| Average realisation by region | North ₹4,641, East ₹4,154, South ₹4,620 |
| Sales mix by region | North 55%, East 35%, South 10% |
| Green power share in total electricity consumption | 54%, target 62% by June '25 |
| Installed power capacity | 1,003 MW (1 GW milestone achieved) |
| RMC plants | 7 plants, total capacity 624 cubic meters per hour |
| Water positivity | >6x in Q1, target >7x for full year |
| Annual capex guidance | ~₹4,000 cr annually |
| Dividend per share | ₹105, up from ₹100 last year |