Key Takeaways
- Volume up, realization steady, costs easing: Cement volume grew 9.9% YoY while realization improved 2% QoQ to INR 4,843/ton, and per KCal fuel cost dropped from INR 2.34 to INR 2.05 sequentially, setting up a stronger Q3.
- Green power advantage is widening: The green power mix jumped from 50% to 58%, with a target of 63% by FY25 end; management argues this creates a 50% cost gap versus peers running at 30% renewable.
- East India is the margin drag: East utilization collapsed from 92% to 74% as new Purulia capacity came online into a heavy monsoon; East profitability ran roughly 40% below North last quarter.
- Capacity build-out is on track, mostly: The company reiterated 6.2 crore tons by March '25 and 8 crore tons in three years, though the Nawalgarh plant slipped by about three months and the fourth Chhattisgarh clinker line will take time.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the INR 200/ton October realization gain holds and combines with sub-INR 2/KCal fuel costs to deliver the promised margin expansion, and how fast East utilization recovers as Purulia ramps.
Realization & Pricing Strategy
- Realization improved modestly: Cement realization rose 1% YoY and 2% QoQ to INR 4,843 per ton, with October realization running INR 200/ton higher, suggesting the Q3 exit rate is stronger.
- Volume over price is not the playbook: Management explicitly prioritizes right pricing over volume at any cost, framing discounting for share as winning a sprint but losing the marathon.
- Premiumization is measured, not forced: The premium product mix sits at 9.5-10% with a target of 12% in six months, but management will not chase it by investing in higher-cost materials that dilute EBITDA.
- Lead distance rose as the East mix shifted: Average lead distance increased from 456 km to 472 km because Eastern India supply still draws base material from Chhattisgarh even after the Bengal plant started.
H M Bangur: "If the prices are diluted to get the volume much faster, then you win the sprint race but you lose the marathon race."
Costs & The Green Power Moat
- Fuel cost is falling and has further to run: Per KCal cost declined from INR 2.34 in June to INR 2.05 in September, and management expects approximately INR 1.90 for the coming six months; fuel is booked 3-4 months in advance, so the benefit phases in with a lag.
- Green power mix jumped to 58%: The increase came from new solar capacity and more efficient motors that lower overall power consumption per ton; the target is 63% by FY25 end, with solar plants added at roughly INR 5 crores per MW and a 14% expected return on capital employed.
- Management claims a structural cost lead: The company runs at 58% renewable power versus peers at roughly 30%, a gap management calls a 50% difference that should deliver cost leadership.
- Raw material costs eased sequentially: Gypsum cost fell from INR 90 to INR 75/ton and flyash from INR 200 to INR 190/ton, driving a 13% sequential decline in raw material costs.
- Power cost per ton is a composite number: The INR 259/ton figure includes coal used for power generation sold externally; power sales jumped from INR 46 cr to INR 343 cr, adding roughly INR 250 cr in coal costs to the power and fuel line, which obscures the per-ton benefit of green energy.
H M Bangur: "Which company has given 30% ratio? We are talking of not marginally lower; I'm talking about 50% difference. So any company, at least I don't know, you people track all the companies much better. So 30% renewable power, and we are 58% renewable power, that is quite a big advantage. That should give us cost leadership."
Regional Dynamics: East Drags, North Delivers
- East utilization cratered on new capacity and weather: East India utilization fell from 92% to 74% because the new Purulia grinding unit added capacity into a quarter hit by heavy rains; ramp-up will take time.
- East profitability is materially lower: North was roughly 40% more profitable than East last quarter, though management notes this gap fluctuates and has sometimes reversed in the past.
- Overall utilization dropped to 71%: The decline from 80% in the prior quarter reflects both lower demand and the new Purulia capacity; half-year utilization stood at 76%.
- Clinker capacity is deliberately kept loose: A 10% excess grinding capacity is purposely maintained to give the company flexibility to sell into the highest-realization market rather than being locked into any one region.
- Conversion factors vary by region: In the North, the blended cement conversion factor is 1.6-1.7x; in the East it exceeds 2x, so as the East share changes, the overall conversion factor shifts.
H M Bangur: "East profitability is quite low compared to North at present, but this keeps changing. Sometimes, East is better, North is not better. So right now, at this point of time or the last quarter, North was about 40% more than the East."
Capacity Expansion Progress
- The big targets are intact: Capacity will reach 6.2 crore tons by 31 March 2025, with a three-year ambition of 8 crore tons.
- Nawalgarh slipped by roughly three months: The plant is now expected in Q4 FY24 rather than the original timeline.
- Guntur is on the cusp: The Andhra plant should be completed in Q4 FY24, around March or possibly April/May.
- Etah has just begun: The UP grinding unit has received permissions and work is starting; it will add another 0.6 crore tons by 31 March 2025.
- The fourth Chhattisgarh clinker line will take time: No specific timeline was given, and the current 10% excess grinding capacity is meant to bridge the gap.
- Nawalgarh has a novel water strategy: The company purchased the obligation to clear all municipal waste water of Nawalgarh, making the plant water surplus by a large margin; this sits alongside five years of rainwater harvesting at Beawar and Ras.
Power Business & Tax
- Power EBITDA is thin by design: The power unit runs on 100% imported fuel from Gujarat port, keeping margins at only 8-9%; power EBITDA was INR 30 crores this quarter.
- Power sales surged but details are thin: Power sales jumped from INR 46 cr to INR 343 cr; management declined to provide unit-level detail on the call, deferring to email.
- Tax payments will stay elevated for years: The company follows a conservative policy of paying taxes aggressively and then fighting cases; tax paid will be continuously higher for the next 2-3 years until refunds arrive.
- The cash tax vs effective tax rate gap was not explained: An analyst noted a 5% differential over FY17-FY23; management called it a highly technical question and gave a general policy explanation without addressing why the gap persists or when it might converge.
- Incentive booking was not disclosed: Full-year incentives are guided at INR 130-140 cr, but management declined to provide the Q2 or H1 figure, saying incentives are merged into realization and not tracked separately.
H M Bangur: "Our power unit is based on imported fuel, 100% imported fuel. And this is coming from Gujarat port, cost of the fuel is higher. So average EBITDA will be only 8% to 9%."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Fuel cost | Per KCal cost approximately INR 1.90 | Coming six months |
| Green power mix | Reach 63% | By end of FY25 |
| Full-year volume growth | Approximately 12% | FY24 |
| Capacity | 6.2 crore tons | By 31 March 2025 |
| Capacity | 8 crore tons | In next three years |
| Premiumization mix | Reach approximately 12% | In six months |
| Nawalgarh plant completion | Commissioned | Q4 FY24 (delayed ~3 months) |
| Guntur plant completion | Commissioned | Q4 FY24 (March-April-May) |
| Etah grinding unit addition | 0.6 crore tons added | By 31 March 2025 |
| TSR (thermal substitution rate) | Increase to 15% | By year-end (slight delay) |
| Receivables | Normalize, only proportionate increase with sales | Next 6 months |
| Tax payments | Continuously higher until refunds arrive | Next 2-3 years |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Cement realization | ₹4,843 per ton, +1% YoY and +2% QoQ |
| EBITDA per ton (cement) | ₹1,062 per ton |
| Power business revenue | ₹343 cr; H1 FY24: ₹822 cr |
| Power business EBITDA | ₹30 cr, 8–9% margin; H1 FY24: ~₹75 cr |
| Cement volume growth | +9.9% YoY; H1 FY24: +14% YoY |
| Full-year volume growth guidance | ~12% YoY |
| Blended cement share | 75% of production, vs 76% last year |
| Trade sales mix | 80%, unchanged YoY |
| Power and fuel cost per kCal | ₹2.05, down from ₹2.34 in Q1 FY24 and ₹2.80 in Q2 FY23; next six months expected at ₹1.90 |
| Green power mix | 58%, up from 50% last year; target 63% by end FY25 |
| Capacity utilization | 71% in Q2 FY24, vs ~80% in Q1 FY24; H1 FY24: ~76% |
| East India utilization | 74% in Q2 FY24, down from 92% in Q1 FY24 |
| Lead distance | 472 km, up from 456 km in Q1 FY24 |
| Premium product share | 9.5–10%; expected ~12% in six months |
| Clinker production | 59.61 lakh tons, +30% YoY and +11% QoQ |