Key Takeaways
- Strong volume, margin pressure: Volumes surged ~23% YoY on broad-based construction demand, but a sharp fuel cost increase (INR 1.69 to INR 2.53 per Kcal) compressed margins.
- Fuel cost relief is arriving: Pet coke costs have already softened to INR 2.35, and management expects this tailwind to support a repeat of Q3’s margin performance in Q4.
- Capacity build-out is accelerating: Completion timelines for the Nawalgarh and Guntur integrated units have each been pulled forward by one quarter, and FY24 capex is guided at INR 3,300–3,500 crores.
- A deliberate, not slowed, growth path: Management framed the 8 crore ton by 2030 target as a conservative floor it will try to beat, pushing back on the idea that its pace is constrained by limestone or ambition.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the guided Q4 margin recovery materializes as fuel costs fall, and any further pull-forward of the 8 crore ton capacity timeline.
Volume & Demand Environment
- Broad-based volume surge: Cement volumes grew ~23% YoY, driven by government infrastructure spending, new urban housing launches across metros, and elevated corporate capex.
- Utilization jump: Capacity utilization improved sharply from 61% to 72% YoY, absorbing the strong volume growth.
- Demand momentum expected to hold: Management cited upcoming state elections and the general election next year as catalysts, and expects the cement sector to see robust demand growth in coming years.
- Industry structure improving: Management sees demand growth at 6–8% against supply growth of 3–4%, leading to better demand-supply equations over time.
- Near-term pricing flat: Cement prices have been more or less flat since December through February, with no change observed.
Neeraj Akhoury: "So there have been several studies on this and what we know for sure is if the demand growth is in the range of 6% to 8%, the supply growth is in the range of 3% to 4%. And therefore, as we move forward, we will see a better demand-supply equations emerging, and that is how I see this industry."
Costs & Margins
- Fuel cost the margin culprit: Fuel cost per calorific value shot up from INR 1.69 in December 2021 to INR 2.53 in Q3 FY23, overwhelming a 2% YoY realization increase.
- Q4 relief in sight: Current pet coke cost has fallen to INR 2.35, and as high-cost inventory runs down, management believes it can repeat Q3’s margin performance in Q4.
- Cost-saving levers being pulled: Green power share rose to 53% from 47% YoY, lead distance decreased 5 km YoY to 450 km, and a target to raise the thermal substitution rate from 3% to 15% over the next year promises a per-Kcal gain (INR 1.50 for biomass vs INR 2.35 for pet coke).
- Raw material volatility: Q3 last year saw a transport strike in East India that forced outside clinker purchases at higher cost, plus elevated fly ash prices, creating a tough YoY comparison on raw material costs.
- EBITDA per tonne ambition: Management expects to be "close to a 4-digit figure" in coming quarters, but will not commit to a timeline for reaching INR 1,200–1,500, citing dependence on cement and fuel prices.
- Depreciation stepped up: QoQ depreciation rose because solar units commissioned at Q2-end attracted a full quarter’s charge in Q3; YoY increase reflects the Raipur plant (commissioned March 2022) and new solar units not present last year.
Capacity Expansion & Capex
- 8 crore ton target by 2030 is a floor: Management called it a conservative target and said it will "obviously try to do faster," though it declined to commit to 2028. The road map is 100% organic, with necessary limestone reserves already available.
- Project timelines pulled forward: The Nawalgarh integrated unit is now expected in Q3 FY24 (one quarter ahead), and the Guntur integrated unit in Q2 FY25 (one quarter ahead). The Purulia grinding unit is on track for the June quarter.
- FY24 capex guided at INR 3,300–3,500 crores: Most of the cash from the QIP is expected to be utilized in the journey to 8 crore tons.
- New locations identified: Kutch (limestone mine acquired, awaiting statutory clearances), Jaisalmer, plus brownfield additions from existing mines in North, East, and South. Central India is not currently targeted due to no limestone mines.
- Green capacity build-out: 84 MW of solar added during the year, another 42–43 MW to be commissioned in the next 2–3 months, and 45 MW of new WHR capacity to come up over two years.
Subhash Jajoo: "It is the conservative target, which we have given, we will obviously try to do faster."
Strategic Initiatives
- Brand and R&D push: Sales and marketing roles have been split, a new R&D function has been set up to study consumer and market behaviour, and the company aims to scale its premium product share from ~7% to at least 15% over the next 3–4 quarters.
- Logistics overhaul: Railway sidings are being set up across most units over the next two years to increase rail share from 12% and capture cheaper rail freight versus road.
- Cost leadership program (WeLead): Management described it as a journey to maintain optimal cost position, with new ideas and investments under evaluation, but declined to give any quantifiable savings targets.
- Waste-to-fuel investment: Technologies imported from Europe to increase agricultural and industrial waste usage, with installation expected by March-end.
Neeraj Akhoury: "WeLead is a journey. It's a journey that we are taking on to ensure that Shree's position in terms of optimal cost is maintained... At this moment, giving a quantifiable number to my mind will be unfair."
Capital Allocation & M&A
- M&A is on the radar, but only on strict terms: Management pushed back on the idea that it has never been serious about inorganic growth, stating any deal must be value-accretive, profitable, and additive to shareholders. No actionable opportunity exists currently, and any deal would be additional to the organic 8 crore ton plan.
- No valuation benchmark offered: When asked what IRR, return ratios, or EV per ton it would find acceptable for M&A, management declined to give a benchmark, calling it dependent on asset type, location, and region.
- Dividend to rise progressively: The next 2–3 years are focused on aggressive capex; if surplus cash remains after that, a special dividend may be considered.
Neeraj Akhoury: "This is not a fair comment that Shree has never been serious about inorganic growth. We have been showing interest, but M&A growth has to be value-accretive. It has to add value to our shareholders. And it has to be profitable. We would not like to make a move, which is not favourable to our shareholders."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Full-year FY23 sales volume | Around 3.2 crore tons | FY23 close |
| Q4 margin performance | Repeat similar numbers as Q3, aided by softening fuel prices | Q4 FY23 |
| Nawalgarh integrated unit | Commissioning advanced by one quarter | Q3 FY24 |
| Guntur integrated unit | Commissioning advanced by one quarter | Q2 FY25 |
| Purulia grinding unit | Commissioning on schedule | June quarter FY24 |
| FY24 capex | INR 3,300–3,500 crores | FY24 |
| Capacity target | 8 crore tons (organic only); conservative floor, will try to do faster | By 2030 |
| Premium product share | Scale from ~7% to at least 15% | Next 3–4 quarters |
| Thermal substitution rate (TSR) | Increase from 3% to 15% using agri and industrial waste | Next one year |
| Rail share increase | Railway sidings across most units to lift share from 12% | Next 2 years |
| Solar capacity addition | 42–43 MW to be commissioned | Next 2–3 months |
| WHR capacity addition | 45 MW new capacity (one unit each year) | FY24 and FY25 |
| Dividend | Progressively increase; special dividend possible if surplus cash remains after capex cycle | After 3–4 years |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Cement and clinker sale volume | ~0.8 crore tons, +23% YoY |
| Realization per tonne | ₹4,854, +2% YoY from ₹4,739 and +1% QoQ from ₹4,805 |
| Capacity utilization | 72%, up from 61% YoY |
| Total sales 9M FY23 growth | +17% YoY |
| Expected full-year FY23 sales volume | ~3.2 crore tons |
| Average fuel cost per calorific value | ₹2.53, vs ₹1.69 in Dec '21 and ₹2.83 in Sep '22 |
| Current pet coke cost per Kcal | ~₹2.35, down from ₹2.53 in the December quarter |
| Trade mix | 78% to 80% of total sales, trend expected to continue |
| Average lead distance | 450 km, down 5 km YoY from 455 km and down 9 km QoQ from 459 km |
| Fuel mix | 58% pet coke, 28% coal, balance alternative fuel |
| Share of green power consumption | 53% of total power consumption, up from 47% YoY |
| Solar power capacity added in FY23 | 84 MW added; another 42 MW to be added in next few months |
| Premium product share | ~7% of total sales; target to scale to at least 15% over next 3–4 quarters |
| Rail dispatches share | 12% of total dispatches |
| Thermal substitution rate | 3% last year; targeting 15% over next one year |
| Capex in 9M FY23 | ~₹2,200 cr (including Shree Cement and subsidiaries) |
| Expected capex in Q4 FY23 | ₹700–800 cr more, taking full-year total to ~₹2,900–3,000 cr |
| Expected capex for FY24 | ₹3,300–3,500 cr |
| Net cash position | ₹5,700 cr; gross investments ~₹8,300 cr as on 31 Dec 2022 |
| 8 crore tons capacity target | By 2030, 100% planned on organic growth |
| Purulia grinding unit commissioning | ~0.3 crore tons, expected by June quarter FY24 |
| Nawalgarh integrated unit completion | Q3 FY24, one quarter ahead of earlier Q4 FY24 schedule |
| Guntur integrated unit completion | ~0.3 crore tons, advanced to Q2 FY25, one quarter ahead |
| Patas plant utilization | ~70% |
| Existing WHR capacity | 211 MW (India only) |
| New WHR capacity being added | 45 MW, one unit in FY24 and one in FY25 |
| Water positivity | 5x water positive |
| CDP climate change disclosure score | A- in 2022 |