Key Takeaways
- Acquisition masks organic resilience: Consolidated revenue grew 39.5% YoY on the Walter Pack consolidation, but organic auto growth of 6.3% still handily beat an industry that de-grew 0.3%, marking the 16th straight quarter of outperformance.
- Walter Pack margin shock is a one-off, not a reset: A major PV customer’s model changeover delayed volumes and stuffed Q2 with low-margin tooling sales, compressing Walter Pack’s EBITDA margin to ~12.5%. Management calls it a surprise event, with volumes already returning in October.
- The cross-sell thesis is working, visibly: A live example with a leading PV OEM shows SJS’s kit value per vehicle jumping 7x-8x by layering standalone parts, Exotech chrome, and Walter Pack interior trim, a playbook management intends to replicate across other customers.
- PAT growth guided down on transitory drags: Full-year PAT growth is now pegged at ~30% YoY, lowered by the Walter Pack Q2 hit, higher amortization of ₹2.89 cr per quarter, and muted industry volumes, but the core organic profit engine remains intact.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether Walter Pack’s margin recovery to normal levels actually materializes in Q3, the pace of new order conversion at Exotech now that chrome plating capacity is secured, and any progress on cover glass approvals with OEMs.
Walter Pack: The Quarter’s Disruption and the Recovery Case
- Model changeover blindsided results: Three models for which Walter Pack is the exclusive supplier underwent a generation change. The OEM’s SOP slipped by 2–2.5 months due to multi-part launch issues, causing automotive component sales to drop to just one-third of Walter Pack’s mix, down from the normal two-thirds.
- Tooling sales filled the revenue hole but crushed margin: Roughly ₹10–11 crore of tooling sales for the new-generation parts replaced the lost component revenue, keeping the top line stable at ~₹39 crore. These were first-time-in-India, highly complex parts with negligible margins, which combined with the adverse mix to compress overall profitability.
- Recovery is already underway: October volumes have returned as the models ramp up. Management expects Walter Pack to reach ~80% of expected revenue in Q3 and 100% by Q4, with margins normalizing alongside. The new models have a ~7-year lifecycle with no further part changes foreseen.
- Customer concentration is lower than feared: One OEM contributes about 40% of Walter Pack’s annual sales, not the 90% some analysts had assumed, reducing single-customer dependency risk.
Sanjay Thapar: "This is a one-off event that we were taken by surprise. Let me explain the situation to you. I will not name the OEM. As Walter Pack was doing robust sales — in fact, they are the only suppliers to this company for these category of parts."
Organic Business: Outperformance Despite a Muted Industry
- Auto segment beat a declining market: SJS’s automotive business grew 25.2% YoY (organic: 6.3%) against an industry that de-grew 0.3%. Two-wheeler sales rose 8.4% YoY vs industry growth of 1.5%, while PV sales jumped 51.3% YoY vs 5.6% for the industry.
- Exports sustained momentum: Exports grew 25.6% YoY in Q2 and 54.1% in H1, reaching 7% of consolidated sales, with new business wins partly offsetting a slow recovery in Europe and Brazil.
- Organic PAT grew modestly, weighed by structural shifts: Organic adjusted PAT rose 5.1% to ₹20.97 cr, with margins at 16.9%. The lower growth rate reflects the loss of ₹2.5–3 cr in quarterly interest income that surplus cash used to generate before the Walter Pack acquisition, plus ₹2.89 cr in higher amortization on intangibles.
- Exotech capacity bottleneck addressed: A partnership with a chrome plating manufacturer, operational since October 2023, has booked their capacity for Exotech orders, clearing a near-term growth constraint while a revised internal expansion plan is finalized.
The Cross-Selling Thesis: 7x-8x Kit Value in Action
- One OEM, one vehicle, a transformed wallet: For a specific PV model, SJS standalone moved from ₹250–300 per vehicle (logos only) to ₹750–800 by adding steering wheel parts, illuminated logos, and appliques. Exotech and Walter Pack together add another ₹1,500–1,600, taking the total kit value to over 7x–8x the original.
- The playbook is meant to be repeatable: Management intends to execute the same cross-selling strategy across other OEM customers, layering SJS standalone, Exotech, and Walter Pack products onto shared vehicle platforms.
- Walter Pack opens consumer appliance doors: SJS is now approaching its long-standing global consumer appliance customers with Walter Pack’s IML/IMD technology, a channel that was previously inaccessible to the standalone decorative business.
Sanjay Thapar: "Hence, the total kit value supplied has increased not just 2x within SJS standalone itself, but overall it has increased to over 7x to 8x already with the cross-selling opportunities that we are playing out in favour of the consolidated SJS."
Cover Glass: The Next Leg of Premiumization
- A structural trend toward digital cockpits: Management believes more than 50% of cars in India will feature cover glass within four to five years, with screen sizes trending larger. Cover glass requires specialized coatings (anti-reflection, anti-glare, anti-fingerprint) that play to SJS’s 35+ years of precision printing expertise.
- Localization tailwind is real: Post-COVID, OEMs want to localize display assembly in India. While TFT screens may continue to be imported, the cover glass component is a candidate for domestic sourcing, and SJS is positioning itself to capture that shift.
- Early traction with Foxconn: SJS is already supplying cover glass for two-wheeler displays to Foxconn for one of their end customers, with pilot lots moving into production.
- Approvals are the gating factor: SJS is in discussions with OEMs to secure cover glass approvals, which management describes as a potential “complete game changer” for the business.
Sanjay Thapar: "I firm believe that, in the next four to five years, more than 50% of the cars in India are likely to have cover glass and the size will tend to be bigger and bigger."
Financial Health: Leverage, Returns, and Cash Flow
- ROCE dipped on acquisition, recovery path is gradual: Consolidated ROCE stood at 17.9%, pulled down by the Walter Pack acquisition. Management expects a gradual improvement over the next one to two years as asset utilization rises.
- Operating cash flow optically weak due to consolidation: Cash flow appears muted because of the first-time inclusion of Walter Pack’s balance sheet and working capital. Excluding Walter Pack, the underlying number is healthy, with receivables rising on higher sales and exports.
- Amortization drag will persist: The ₹2.89 cr quarterly depreciation charge on intangibles (non-compete with Walter Pack Spain and acquired customer relationships) was determined by an independent valuer and will continue for a couple of years.
- Everstone exit removes an overhang: Everstone Capital sold a 29.53% stake in the secondary market in August 2023, reducing its holding to 4.63% and eliminating a large block that could have pressured the stock.
Strategy & Capacity Building
- Business mix transformation is complete: SJS was once 70% two-wheeler focused (FY19). Post-acquisition, four-wheelers now account for ~33% of sales and two-wheelers 37%, achieving the stated goal of becoming a mainstream PV player.
- Walter Pack acquisition was opportunistic: Walter Pack Spain divested its Indian subsidiary due to post-COVID pressures in Europe (energy costs, financing) while committing capital to Mexico expansion. SJS had been tracking the asset and moved when it became available.
- Key talent retained: Roy Mathew, who managed Walter Pack India’s customer relationships for 12–13 years, has joined the SJS team and retains a ~9.9% equity stake, aligning incentives for the integration.
- Capex is ramping for growth: ₹20 cr has been placed for Walter Pack expansion, land has been acquired for Exotech expansion, and FY25 capex is estimated at ₹40–50 cr. A revised combined capacity expansion plan for Exotech and Walter Pack is expected to be finalized within calendar year 2024.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue growth | Close to 45% YoY | FY24 |
| Organic revenue growth | Closer to 20% YoY (moderated from 20–25% on muted industry) | FY24 |
| PAT growth | ~30% YoY, excluding higher amortization and one-time acquisition costs | FY24 |
| Walter Pack revenue recovery | ~80% of expected run rate in Q3, 100% by Q4 | Q3FY24 / Q4FY24 |
| Walter Pack margin normalization | Margins return to normal levels | Q3 and Q4 FY24 |
| ROCE improvement | Gradual recovery toward pre-acquisition levels | Next 1–2 years |
| Combined Exotech + Walter Pack capacity plan | Finalized and accelerated | Calendar year 2024 |
| FY25 capex | ₹40–50 cr | FY25 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | ₹163.2 cr, +39.5% YoY |
| Organic revenue growth | 6.3% YoY |
| Adjusted consolidated EBITDA | ₹39.87 cr, +19.4% YoY, margin 24.2% |
| Organic adjusted EBITDA (SJS + Exotech) | ₹34.92 cr, +4.6% YoY, margin 27.7% |
| Adjusted consolidated PAT | ₹20.81 cr, +4.3% YoY, margin 12.8% |
| Organic adjusted PAT | ₹20.97 cr, +5.1% YoY, margin 16.9% |
| FY24 consolidated revenue growth guidance | Close to 45% YoY |
| FY24 organic revenue growth guidance | Closer to 20% YoY |
| FY24 PAT growth guidance | About 30% YoY, excluding higher amortization cost of ₹2.89 cr per quarter and one-time acquisition cost of ₹2.15 cr |
| Automotive business growth (2W + PV combined) | 25.2% YoY, vs industry degrowth of 0.3% |
| Organic auto growth | 6.3% YoY |
| Passenger vehicle revenue growth | 51.3% YoY, vs industry production growth of 5.6% |
| Two-wheeler revenue growth (consolidated) | 8.4% YoY, vs industry production growth of 1.5% |
| Exports growth | 25.6% YoY; exports constituted roughly 7% of consolidated sales |
| Revenue mix: 2W / PV / Consumer & other | 39% / 33% / 28% |
| Net debt | ₹59.94 cr; cash and cash equivalents ₹23.85 cr as of Sep 30, 2023 |
| Consolidated ROCE | 17.9%; return on equity 13.7% |
| SJS standalone capacity utilization | 65% to 70% |
| Exotech capacity utilization | Close to 95% |
| Walter Pack India Q2 revenue | ₹39 cr, including ~₹10-11 cr of tooling costs billed |
| Walter Pack India EBITDA margin | 12.5% to 13%, impacted by lower auto component sales and higher tooling mix |
| Intangible amortization impact (Walter Pack) | ₹2.89 cr pre-tax per quarter, to continue for a couple of years |
| Goodwill from Walter Pack acquisition | ₹144.5 cr |