Key Takeaways
- Normalization, not deterioration: EBITDA margin fell YoY because Q1 FY22 was an anomalous low-cost base when offices were shut for COVID; expenses are in line with pre-COVID levels, not a new cost problem.
- NBFC book growing but amortizing fast: AUM rose to ₹716 cr on ₹120 cr of disbursements, but monthly collections of ~₹36 cr mean the net book build is gradual. Credit quality improved, with GNPA down to 2.4%.
- Discount broking turned the corner: Stoxkart delivered its first profitable quarter (PAT ₹64 lakh) on revenue of ₹6 cr, driven by higher ARPU and a focus on revenue-generating clients.
- Gold loan is the new growth vector: A co-lending pilot launched in West Bengal, with plans for exclusive branches in Delhi NCR and an omni-channel "gold loan at home" push, betting on a large, under-penetrated market.
- What to watch next quarter: Pace of gold loan branch rollout and disbursement ramp-up, Stoxkart 2.0 app traction and revenue follow-through, and whether the NBFC book can outgrow its fast amortization headwind.
Margin & Cost Normalization
- YoY margin drop is a base effect: Administrative and office expenses rose because Q1 FY22 offices were shut and staff worked from home, eliminating electricity and staff-presence costs. Compared to pre-COVID quarters, expenses are normal, not elevated.
- Interest costs rose with the loan book: The NBFC arm borrowed to fund AUM growth from a low-leverage base, so interest expense increased YoY and QoQ; interest income moved up in parallel.
- Depreciation declining mechanically: QoQ depreciation fell because the WDV base shrinks after the high first-year charge (40% on new assets), not because of any asset sale or policy change.
- Provisions reflect ECL model, not fresh stress: Impairment provisioning includes NBFC customer NPAs plus statistical ECL provisions on large debtors outstanding; the underlying NPA level actually decreased a lot.
NBFC: Growth, Quality & the Amortization Drag
- AUM growth is a net number masking high churn: Disbursements of ~₹120 cr in the quarter were offset by ~₹108 cr of monthly collections, so the book inched up only ~₹26 cr QoQ. The rub-off effect means the book grows slowly even as business activity picks up.
- Credit quality is improving: GNPA improved from ~2.8% in March 22 to 2.4% in Q1, supported by better collections and a broader market trend. A restructured book of ~₹22–24 cr under RBI’s COVID policy remains standard.
- Yield is holding at 15–15.5% blended: Interest rate hikes in the market have been passed through to customers on floating-rate loans, protecting portfolio yield.
- Distribution expansion is the growth lever: The plan is to add sales team in locations opened last year and add spoke locations around existing branches to push the loan book higher.
Gold Loan: The New Growth Bet
- Pilot launched via co-lending: The gold loan product started in Q1 through a tie-up with an existing NBFC, initially in a few branches in West Bengal.
- Exclusive branch rollout planned: The company intends to open dedicated gold loan branches, starting in Delhi NCR, and expand to other locations after assessing progress.
- Omni-channel ambition: Management plans digital marketing and a "gold loan at home" offering, leveraging a low cost of funds to compete, especially against newer NBFCs entering the segment.
- Geographic strategy exploits a gap: Initial focus is Northern India, where larger incumbents like Muthoot and Manappuram are less concentrated, which management sees as an advantage.
Himanshu Gupta: "The cake is very big and there is share for everyone."
Discount Broking: Stoxkart Turns Profitable
- Profitability milestone reached: Stoxkart delivered PAT of ₹64 lakh (PBT ₹87 lakh) on revenue of ₹6 cr in Q1, driven by increased ARPU of ~₹4,000 per client and a focus on revenue-generating clients.
- Superr app is the Stoxkart 2.0 bet: The app launched in beta as the first milestone of a technological revamp, built on a new digital technology stack used by leading fintech firms.
- Differentiation strategy rests on three pillars: Lightning-fast, intuitive UX; a completely new digital stack; and leveraging SMC group’s legacy brokerage distribution and aligned digital products through a single app window.
Bhushan Sonkusare: "The third is, we want to leverage the legacy and the USP of SMC group into this play rather than just copycatting something, which is bringing the brokerage distribution and other aligned digital products through the single app window."
Proprietary Arbitrage & Trading
- Arbitrage book is hedged and strategy-diverse: Positions span cash-future arbitrage, conversion strategies, butterfly trading, volatility-based arbitrage, statistical arbitrage, and pair trading; most positions are hedged.
- Deployment is surplus-driven and scalable: Fund deployment ranges ₹200–350 cr depending on surplus availability. Management stated that even an additional ₹1,000 cr, ₹2,000 cr, or ₹5,000 cr could be deployed in these strategies.
- Returns multiply vs mutual fund arbitrage: Intraday churning, leverage, and strategy flexibility unavailable to mutual funds (constrained by their IM and margin rules) drive higher returns.
- Market-size question went unanswered: When asked for the total market size of the arbitrage opportunity and the number of players, management said “I would not have the number” and pivoted to capacity to deploy more capital.
DK Aggarwal: “I would not have the number but I can tell you, if somebody gives me another 1000 crore or 2000 crore, or 5000 crore even that can be deployed.”
Business Model & Other Verticals
- Diversified, low-cost franchisee model: The group spans brokerage, investment banking, insurance broking, NBFC, real estate broking, and third-party distribution, which management expects to deliver consistent growth barring unforeseen circumstances.
- Insurance broking is seasonal: The business grew 37% YoY (June 22 vs June 21), but Q4 is always the strongest quarter; Q1 cannot be compared to Q4.
- US subsidiary wound down: SMC Global USA became inoperative after the local manager performed poorly and incurred losses; the branch is closed and the subsidiary is being wound down, with a ~₹5 cr provision made and formal write-off awaiting RBI permission.
- TCM/clearing income is negligible: The business serves 200+ trading members but clearing income in the P&L is “very negligible”; management wants to focus on TCM as a brand and sees it becoming remunerative in time.
- Debt desk gaining HNI traction: A full-fledged debt desk in Delhi and Mumbai offers G-Sec purchases on the portal for sale to individual investors in Demat form; momentum from HNI investors has been higher over the last 2–3 years, particularly when interest rates were declining.
DK Aggarwal: “Our model is quite stable and quite diversified and it is a low cost model, which will ensure that there will be consistency in the business, of course unforeseen circumstances nobody can judge but otherwise we believe that we are going to grow consistently and continuously.”
Valuation Disconnect
- Management declined to diagnose the discount: An analyst asked why the stock trades at a low valuation despite a full-value brokerage, discount brokerage, NBFC (including gold loan), and a buyback at ₹115. Management responded that the market is not in its control and valuation is not where it focuses, without addressing what the company might be lacking or what the market is seeing.
DK Aggarwal: “In our control whatever is there we are doing that, when you do the right things, the valuation will automatically happen this is what we believe so, because valuation is not something where we focus, we focus on our business and our business is doing well.”
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Buyback completion | Spend up to ₹75 cr (maybe ₹10–20 lakh less); over ₹53 cr spent, 60 lakh+ shares bought to date | By buyback close |
| Gold loan branch rollout | Open exclusive gold loan branches, initially in Delhi NCR region | After assessing pilot progress |
| Stoxkart product pipeline | Launch additional products enhancing customer experience as part of Stoxkart 2.0 revamp | "Shortly" |
| NBFC distribution expansion | Increase sales team in locations opened last year; add spoke locations around branches | Ongoing |
| Southern India presence | Increase branches and franchisees in Southern region; more banking tie-ups expected | "Near future" |
| US subsidiary write-off | Formal write-off of ~₹5 cr provision awaiting RBI permission | Upon RBI approval |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated operating income | ₹291 cr, +13.8% YoY |
| Consolidated operating EBITDA | ₹71 cr, -26.3% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 24.4% |
| Net profit after tax | ₹37 cr, -22.6% YoY |
| PAT margin | 20.74% |
| Broking, distribution and trading revenue | ₹199 cr, +7% YoY |
| Broking, distribution and trading EBIT | ₹47 cr |
| Insurance broking revenue | ₹74 cr, +37% YoY |
| Insurance broking EBIT | ₹1.5 cr |
| NBFC segment revenue growth | ~47% YoY |
| NBFC segment EBIT | ₹18 cr, +43% YoY |
| NBFC loan book (AUM) | ₹716 cr, up from ₹690 cr at Mar 22 |
| NBFC gross NPA | 2.58%, improved from 4.75% in Q1 FY22 |
| NBFC net NPA | 1.49%, improved from 3.05% in Q1 FY22 |
| NBFC gross yield on portfolio | ~15% to 15.5% blended |
| NBFC quarterly disbursements | ₹120 cr |
| NBFC restructured book (standard, under RBI COVID policy) | ₹22–24 cr as of Mar 22 |
| Stoxkart (discount broking) revenue | ₹5.97 cr |
| Stoxkart profit after tax | ₹64.47 lakh |
| Stoxkart ARPU | ~₹4,000 per client |
| Proprietary arbitrage book size | ~₹300 cr as of Jun 30 |
| Buyback spent to date | ₹53 cr, over 60 lakh shares purchased |
| Total buyback size | ₹75 cr |
| Impairment of financial instruments | ₹3.4 cr in Q1, vs ₹16 cr full year FY22 |
| SMC Global USA investment provision | ~₹5 cr provided for, pending RBI permission for write-off |