Key Takeaways
- Investment income swing masks steady operations: A ₹38 crore YoY drop in investment income (₹46 cr to ₹8 cr) drove the headline revenue and margin decline. Excluding this, topline grew 18% and EBITDA margins held at 22–23%.
- NBFC is the standout performer: The loan book grew 30% YoY to ₹727 crores, EBIT rose 127% YoY, and asset quality improved with GNPA falling to 2.62%.
- Stoxkart on track to far exceed last year's revenue: H1 FY23 revenue of ₹11.05 crores has already neared the full-year FY22 total of ₹15 crores, driven by a 2,000+ partner sub-broker channel.
- Technology spend is the chosen growth lever: An annual ₹25 crore direct IT budget, a consolidated tech team under a new CTO, and an in-house mobile app build signal a bet that tech investment will lift future margins.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the NBFC can sustain its 12.88% NIM as leverage rises, the pace of Stoxkart's revenue acceleration in H2, and any timeline for the new mobile app launch.
The Investment Income Distortion
- Headline vs. underlying: Consolidated revenue and EBITDA margin declined YoY solely because H1 FY22 included a non-recurring ₹46 crores of investment income, compared to only ₹8 crores in H1 FY23. Stripping this out, the underlying business grew topline 18% and held margins steady.
- Broking segment optically weak: The broking, distribution and trading segment reported an 8% YoY revenue decline in Q2, entirely attributable to the investment income swing. Management stated market share and core margins were maintained.
- H2 clean comparison ahead: The investment income distortion will not repeat in the second half, setting up a clean base for year-on-year comparisons.
Vinod Kumar Jamar: "As I told you that we have been able to maintain our EBITDA margin, as well as growth in top line. So, the impact of investment income will not be there in the next half. So, we expect a robust result for the next half."
NBFC: Loan Book Growth and Margin Normalization
- Loan book expansion: The financing segment's AUM grew 30% YoY to ₹727 crores, up from ₹561 crores in the corresponding quarter last year, with a stated target to cross ₹1,000 crores.
- Asset quality improved: Gross NPA improved from 2.92% to 2.62% YoY, and net NPA from 2.18% to 1.5%. Collection efficiency held at approximately 99%, and the quarter saw a reversal in credit costs.
- Borrowing cost defended: Despite multiple RBI repo rate hikes, the NBFC maintained its average borrowing cost at a competitive ~9.25% by renegotiating with banks.
- NIM set to normalize from current highs: The reported NIM of 12.88% is far above the industry level of ~5%, a result of low leverage at a 1:1 debt-equity ratio. Management expects NIM to settle at an industry-level 3–3.5% as leverage increases.
- Floating-rate pass-through active: For products like loan against property, interest cost increases have already been passed on to customers, and management will do so again if needed.
Himanshu Gupta: "NIM, if you will see is about 12.88% as of in this period. However, that is very higher compared to the industry, which stands at about 5% kind of NIM. That is largely because we are very low leverage with just 1:1 of debt equity ratio. As we will increase the debt equity and NIM would settle at somewhere at around 3-3.5 which would be at the industry level."
Stoxkart: Revenue Run-Rate and Channel Mix
- Revenue trajectory: Stoxkart generated ₹5.08 crores in Q2 FY23 (vs ₹3.32 cr YoY) and ₹11.05 crores in H1 (vs ₹7.1 cr YoY). Full-year FY22 revenue was ₹15 crores, a figure management expects to exceed "by a huge margin" this year.
- Channel split: Approximately 60% of revenue comes through the sub-broker channel, which comprises over 2,000 business development partners, while 40% comes direct from retail clients.
- Revenue composition: The ₹7.28 crores reported as Fees and Commission income is gross brokerage and includes clearing charges, other client charges, and pass-through payments to sub-brokers. Interest income from the margin trading facility is booked separately.
- Pricing model as differentiator: The "no profit, no brokerage" model charges ₹15 per order only on the first leg of a profitable trade; if the trade is squared off at a loss, the brokerage on the second leg is foregone.
- Growth strategy gated on new app: Current focus is on maintaining ARPU. Once the in-house mobile app launches, the strategy will pivot to increasing market share through digital marketing and wider app distribution.
Pranay Aggarwal: "we have this pricing strategy, which was first introduced by us which is no profit, no brokerage, Rs.15 per order, only when you earn profit. We charge only on the first leg and on the second leg, if the trade is squared off in a loss, then we would forego our part of brokerage."
Technology Investment and the Margin Bet
- Consolidated IT function: The entire IT team has been brought under a CTO hired in the prior year, with additional IT hires and purchases of the latest servers completed.
- Annual tech budget: Direct technology spend runs at ₹25 crores per year, covering servers, switches and technology equipment, but excluding salaries and office expenses.
- In-house mobile app build: A new mobile app is being developed on new technology, targeted for launch "early next financial year."
- Margin thesis: Management believes the current sustainable EBITDA margin of 22–23% can be raised in the future as technology spending yields benefits, though no specific figure or timeline was given for the increase.
- Depreciation headwind: Heavy investment in technology and IT equipment, which attract high depreciation rates, has already increased the depreciation charge.
Subhash Aggarwal: "we are doing our best to achieve the height in technology and I think very soon we will improve our old"
Other Segment Movements
| Segment | Trend | Commentary |
|---|---|---|
| Insurance broking | ▲ Growth | Revenue rose 34% YoY in Q2, driven by increasing vehicle sales leading to higher insurance premiums. |
| Wealth AUM | ▼ Decline | AUM fell from ₹540 crores to ₹512 crores due to ~₹40 crores in client redemptions from alternate investment funds (AIFs) that were investments made a few years back. |
| Interest cost | ▲ Higher | Increased because the NBFC loan book grew substantially, but interest income rose much more than the interest cost increase. |
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Sustainable EBITDA margin | Maintain at 22–23%, with potential to raise as tech investment pays off | No timeline given for increase |
| H2 FY23 results | Robust results expected with no investment income distortion | H2 FY23 |
| Stoxkart full-year revenue | Exceed last year's ₹15 crores "by a huge margin" | FY23 |
| NBFC AUM | Cross ₹1,000 crores | No timeline given |
| NBFC NIM | Settle at industry-level 3–3.5% as debt-equity leverage increases | As leverage rises |
| New mobile app launch | In-house app on new technology | "Early next financial year" |
| NBFC interest rate pass-through | Pass on further rate hikes to floating-rate customers if needed | As required |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated operating income | ₹301 cr, up ~5% YoY |
| Consolidated operating EBITDA | ~₹65 cr, down ~22% YoY from ₹83 cr |
| EBITDA margin | ~22%, sustainable range 22-23% |
| Net profit after tax | ₹30 cr, vs ₹52 cr in Q2 FY22 |
| PAT margin | 10% |
| H1 FY23 consolidated operating income | ₹592 cr, up 9% YoY |
| H1 FY23 net profit after tax | ~₹67 cr, down 33% YoY from ₹99 cr |
| Broking, distribution & trading segment revenue | fell 8% YoY in Q2; down 1% YoY for H1 |
| Broking, distribution & trading segment EBIT | ₹39 cr, declined from ₹68 cr YoY |
| Insurance broking division revenue | ₹83 cr, up 34% YoY and ~13% QoQ |
| Financing division segment revenue | ₹29 cr, up ~21% YoY, decreased 12% QoQ |
| Financing loan book | ₹727 cr, up 30% YoY from ₹561 cr |
| Financing GNPA | 2.62%, improved from 2.92% YoY |
| Financing NNPA | 1.5%, improved from 2.18% YoY |
| Financing EBIT | rose 127% YoY in Q2 and 77% for H1 |
| Investment income (extraordinary item) | ₹8 cr in H1 FY23, vs ₹46 cr in H1 FY22; ₹38 cr deficit impacted topline and bottom line |
| Topline growth excluding investment income | 18% (H1 FY23), margins maintained at prior-year level |
| Stoxkart revenue | ₹5.08 cr in Q2, vs ₹3.32 cr in Q2 FY22; H1 FY23 ₹11.05 cr vs ₹7.1 cr in H1 FY22 |
| Stoxkart fees & commission income | ₹7.28 cr (H1 FY23), includes brokerage, clearing and other client charges; excludes interest on margin trading facility |
| NBFC AUM | ₹727 cr at Sep-end, up from ₹690 cr at Mar-end and ₹561 cr YoY |
| NBFC average borrowing cost | ~9.25%, described as very competitive for the NBFC's size |
| NBFC NIM | 12.88%, expected to settle at 3-3.5% as leverage increases |
| NBFC average lending rate | ~15%, spread of ~5-6% |
| NBFC collection efficiency | ~99% |
| Wealth management AUM | ₹512 cr, declined from ₹540 cr over six months due to ~₹40 cr AIF redemptions |
| Technology direct investment budget | ₹25 cr annually; ₹11 cr spent in H1 FY23 |