Key Takeaways
- Broad-based 35% revenue surge: Operating income grew 35% YoY in Q3, with all segments contributing and 9M revenue nearly matching full-year FY23.
- Margin expansion on operating leverage: EBITDA margin improved 397 bps and PAT margin 210 bps, driven by volume growth against stable fixed costs.
- NBFC AUM up 35%, credit costs contained: Loan book reached ₹1,064 crores with GNPA at 2.63% and NNPA at 1.36%, while cost of funds held competitive at 9.8%-9.9%.
- Insurance broking is the breakout segment: Revenue grew 57% YoY and EBIT more than doubled, up 128% in Q3, as the business rides low insurance penetration.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the NBFC's ROE begins to inflect upward from ~10% as newer branches season, and any launch timeline for the promised super app.
Revenue & Profitability
- 35% top-line growth, all engines firing: Operating income grew 35% YoY in Q3 and 24% in 9M, with revenue across every segment growing. The first nine months' revenue already approached the full-year FY23 figure.
- Operating leverage drove margin gains: EBITDA margin expanded 397 bps and PAT margin 210 bps, as volume increases absorbed a largely fixed cost base.
- Trading profits are consistent and hedged: The trading book, which contributed 40% of broking segment revenue, deploys company liquidity into risk-neutral, hedged algo and high-frequency strategies.
Dr. DK Aggarwal: "There has never been a negative month in the history of SMC."
Financing Segment (NBFC)
- Loan book grew 35% YoY to ₹1,064 crores: Revenue in the financing segment rose 39% YoY in Q3, with EBIT up 35% in Q3 and 46% in 9M.
- Asset quality is manageable: GNPA stood at 2.63% and NNPA at 1.36%, against a loan book underwritten primarily on cash flow basis for SME customers with personal guarantees rather than hard collateral.
- Cost of funds is competitive but rising: At 9.8%-9.9%, the cost of funds compares well to similarly rated NBFCs, though RBI's latest risk-weight circular for bank lending to NBFCs has added pressure. Management believes interest rates have peaked.
- Gold loan is a small, early-stage book: AUM for gold loans, entered in January 2023, is ~₹20 crores (2% of total AUM), currently yielding ~14% with an expectation of ~18% once the vintage stabilizes.
- ROE is depressed by branch expansion: Full-year NBFC ROE is ~10%, held down by new branches opened in the last 1-2 years; management expects ROE to rise as those branches build AUM.
Himanshu Gupta: "what we believe is this is the peak interest rate that we have seen, in the coming years the expected interest rates will go down from here."
Insurance Broking
- Revenue jumped 57% YoY, EBIT more than doubled: Insurance broking delivered ₹150 crores in Q3 revenue, with EBIT up 128% in Q3 and 93% in 9M, making it the fastest-growing segment.
- Structural tailwind from low penetration: Management noted insurance penetration in India is just crossing 3%, with a government target of universal coverage by 2047, and SMC is positioned in retail insurance.
Stoxkart & Digital Initiatives
- Technology revamp over client acquisition this year: Stoxkart launched a new mobile app, website, logo, and e-KYC, with a deliberate focus on adding quality clients rather than pursuing large-scale acquisition.
- ARPU is above industry at ~₹6,500 per active client: The quality-over-quantity strategy shows in ARPU, which management says is higher than the industry average.
- A super app is in development: SMC is building an in-house single app for trading, mutual funds (including holdings bought elsewhere), insurance, IPOs, and research tools, with a launch expected "in a few months."
- Future products will drive acquisition spend: Once proprietary, first-in-industry products launch, Stoxkart plans to increase digital marketing spend and scale client acquisition.
Pranay Aggarwal: "our focus during the current financial year is to revamp our technology and not actually go on in client acquisition in such a big way, instead we are trying to add quality clients, so this will be seen in our ARPU, so our ARPU per active client is around Rs. 6,500, which is higher than the industry"
Balance Sheet & Liquidity
- Trading returns are capital-efficient: The trading business generates ~15%+ return on capital employed, deploying company liquidity into automated, hedged strategies.
- Client money dominates liquid investments: Of the ~₹1,700 crores in liquid investments, over ₹1,400 crores is client money that fluctuates daily.
- Bank guarantees are material but imprecise: Management estimated bank guarantees on the balance sheet at "more than ₹1,000 crores, around ₹1,500 crores," without providing an exact figure.
- Margin funding book is ~₹235 crores: The MTF book size was disclosed, but the split between own funds and borrowed funds deployed was not answered on the call.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| NBFC AUM scale-up | Leverage current equity of ~₹430 crores at 3.5x to reach ~₹2,000 crores AUM, then consider equity raise | When AUM approaches ₹2,000 crores |
| Gold loan yield improvement | Yield on gold loan AUM to rise from ~14% to ~18% | After stable vintage of the book |
| NBFC ROE improvement | ROE to rise from ~10% as new branches season | Over time, as AUM builds |
| Super app launch | Single app for trading, mutual funds, insurance, IPOs, and research | "In a few months" |
| Stoxkart client acquisition scale-up | Increase digital marketing spend and drive client acquisition | After proprietary product launches in coming years |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated operating income | ₹428 cr, +35% YoY |
| Consolidated operating EBITDA | ~₹113 cr, +58% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | ~27%, up 397 bps YoY |
| Net profit after tax | ₹52 cr |
| PAT margin | 12%, up 210 bps YoY |
| Broking, distribution & trading segment revenue | ~₹239 cr, +25% YoY |
| Financing segment revenue | ~₹53 cr, +39% YoY |
| Insurance broking segment revenue | ~₹150 cr, +57% YoY |
| Loan AUM | ₹1,064 cr, +35% YoY |
| GNPA | 2.63% as of Dec 2023 |
| NNPA | 1.36% as of Dec 2023 |
| Mutual fund AUM | ₹3,632 cr |
| Total clients | ~10 lakh |
| Active clients | ~2 lakh |
| Policies sold in Q3 | 298,323 |
| Interim dividend | ₹1.20 per share (60% of face value ₹2) |