Key Takeaways
- Broking soft, insurance and financing strong: Consolidated revenue grew 5.5% YoY to ₹306 crores, but the mix shifted: broking declined 3.6% while insurance grew 21.9% and financing grew 24%.
- Financing AUM up 31%, asset quality improved: Loan book reached ₹901 crores with disbursements nearly doubling YoY, while GNPA fell to 2.27% from 2.83%.
- Insurance premium growth at 30% outpaced the 17% industry average, driving 26% revenue growth and a 44.6% EBIT jump in Q4.
- Technology overhaul underway: Heavy investments in apps, back office, DR site, CRM and low-latency trading are the foundation for management's qualitative growth confidence, though specific guidance was declined.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the new broking apps and website launch in Q2 FY24 reverse the broking revenue decline, and the pace of gold loan branch openings against the ~20-branch target.
Segment Performance
- Broking: revenue declined on sluggish markets and regulatory shifts. Q4 FY23 revenue fell 3.6% YoY, which management attributed to a ~5–6% industry-wide decline, lower cash market volumes, and SEBI's move from a quarterly nil policy to single-day settlement for all clients. Full-year broking revenue still grew ~6%.
- F&O volumes doubled while cash market volumes declined; the company held its ~2% market share.
- Stoxkart turned profitable: the discount broking arm swung from a ₹35 lakh loss in FY22 to a ₹1.17 crore profit in FY23, with revenue up 40–45%.
- Online penetration split: discount broking runs at >98–99% online, while full-service broking is >50% online with a target to exceed 75% in coming years.
- Insurance: premium growth drove the quarter. The 30% premium growth, well above the 17% industry average, translated to 26% revenue growth and a 44.6% Q4 EBIT increase. Management is confident of sustaining the ~25–26% revenue growth pace.
Pravin Agarwal: "I am thrilled to report a remarkable 30% growth in premium surpassing the industry's average growth rate of 17%, which shows actually 26% growth in revenue."
- Financing: loan book and disbursements surged. Revenue grew 24% YoY in Q4 and 39% for the full year. Loan AUM rose 31% YoY to ₹901 crores, while disbursements nearly doubled to ₹858 crores. EBIT grew 10.7% in Q4 and 65.1% for FY23.
- Asset quality improved: GNPA fell to 2.27% from 2.83% and NNPA to 1.44% from 1.99% YoY.
Financing Strategy & NIM Outlook
- SME remains the core lending focus across all products: loan against property, equipment finance, business loans, and now gold loans.
- Gold loan expansion is brick-and-mortar only. Two new branches opened in April, bringing the total to three; management plans ~20 branches in the current year, initially concentrated in Delhi NCR. Digital gold lending is explicitly off the table, with management citing operational cost challenges that hurt Fintech players last year and benefited traditional NBFCs.
- Co-lending tie-up with Central Bank of India was added in Q4 FY23 at an 80:20 ratio; management expects it to generate large AUM and is seeking more bank partnerships.
- NIM expected to compress with leverage. As the NBFC increases leverage toward 3.5–4x, NIM percentage will come down; the long-term floor is pegged at a minimum of 4%.
- Equity headroom of ₹400 crores is sufficient to support debt-funded AUM growth at the targeted >30% pace for the next year or two.
Himanshu Gupta: "You see with the increasing leverage, the NIM percentage is bound to come down and we believe on long term basis, it would be minimum 4% once we achieve the full leverage, which we expect to be around 3.5 - 4 times."
Technology & Digital Build-Out
- Two new apps launched in beta: "Super Evo" for the Stoxkart discount broking arm and "SMC Trade Online Nxt" for full-service broking, both developed in-house. One or two more apps are planned for coming quarters after testing.
- New website expected in Q2 FY24, still under development at the time of the call.
- Broader technology revamp spans back office, front office, DR site, CRM software, low-latency trading infrastructure, and Fintech tie-ups. Management frames these investments as the basis for its qualitative growth confidence.
- Branch network expanded from 83 to 119 YoY, complementing the digital push with physical distribution.
Margins & Guidance Constraints
- Management declined to provide specific revenue, margin, or profit guidance for FY24 and FY25, citing advisor advice, and offered only qualitative confidence in good growth driven by technology and network investments.
- Broking EBITDA margin band set at 22% to 27–28%, with the lower end in less volatile markets and the higher end when exchange turnovers are strong.
- Broking revenue growth ambition: management expects to sustain more than 25% growth in broking revenue in coming years, a target that will require a reversal of the Q4 decline.
Subhash C. Aggarwal: "Mr. Shah basically we were guided by the advisors that we cannot comment on the future numbers but we can say one thing our growth will be good this year since we have invested heavily in technology, we have expanded our network by way of sub brokers and branches so we are very confident..."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Insurance revenue growth | Sustain ~25–26% pace | Ongoing (no end date) |
| Broking revenue growth | Maintain >25% growth | Coming years |
| Broking EBITDA margin | 22% to 27–28% range, market-dependent | Sustainable range |
| Full-service broking online penetration | Exceed 75% | Coming years |
| NBFC AUM growth | >30% pace | Next year or couple of years |
| NBFC long-term NIM floor | Minimum 4% | Once leverage reaches 3.5–4x |
| Gold loan branch expansion | ~20 total branches | Current year (FY24) |
| New website launch | Go live | Q2 FY24 |
| Co-lending AUM scale-up | Generate large AUM via Central Bank of India tie-up | Coming times |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated operating income | ₹306 cr, +5.5% YoY |
| Consolidated operating EBITDA | ~₹63 cr |
| Consolidated EBITDA margin | 20.48% |
| Consolidated net profit after tax | ₹22 cr |
| Consolidated PAT margin | 7.17% |
| Broking, distribution & trading segment revenue | ~₹182 cr, -3.6% YoY |
| Insurance division revenue | ~₹95 cr, +21.9% YoY |
| Financing division segment revenue | ~₹36 cr, +24% YoY |
| Loan AUM | ₹901 cr, +31% YoY from ₹690 cr |
| GNPA | 2.27%, down from 2.83% last financial year |
| NNPA | 1.44%, down from 1.99% last financial year |
| Disbursements (FY23) | ₹858 cr, +99% YoY from ₹431 cr |
| Active client base (broking) | ~2 lakhs |
| Total client base including discount brokerage | >9 lakhs |
| Market share in broking | ~2% |
| Stoxkart profit | ₹1.17 cr, turned around from a marginal loss of ₹35 lakhs in FY22 |