Key Takeaways
- Garment revenue surged 47% YoY, powered by a soft base, workforce ramp-up and richer product mix, while the spinning division swung to a loss and dragged consolidated margins.
- Order book contracted to ₹350 crores as recession made retailers delay placements; management is confident the book will fill because existing customers are consolidating their supplier base around scaled players like SP Apparels.
- Spinning turned from tailwind to headwind: the cotton-to-yarn spread flipped negative, producing a loss in the division that had boosted margins in Q1; management expects a gradual recovery as cotton prices correct.
- Retail stayed in the red on end-of-season discounting and new-brand launch costs; the division is still rebuilding from the loss of 100 Future Group stores and management declined to guide on a breakeven timeline.
- What to watch next quarter: whether the order book refills for March, the pace of spinning-margin recovery, and any sign that retail can narrow its losses as festival-season demand flows through.
Garment Division: Volume, Mix & Capacity
- Revenue growth unpacked: 47% YoY came from a low base (Q1 last year lost ~25 production days to the second wave), a 10–12% lift in average unit price from raw material pass-through and a shift toward higher-value products, plus extra output from workforce mobilisation.
- Sequential momentum: Sales rose ~24–25% QoQ on the same unit-price and capacity drivers.
- Second shift is scaling slowly: One line was added in Q2, with two more planned for Q3; the model is new to Indian garment manufacturing and requires operator training, so expansion is gradual. Management targets 200 machines on second shift by March 2024, noting that IRRs improve because fixed costs get diluted without the investment of adding new machines.
- Labour force growing steadily: Headcount rose every month despite attrition, adding 10–15% per quarter; the target of 15,000 people is expected by June 2023.
- Capacity utilisation is around 75% and expected to rise 10–15 percentage points going forward.
- Customer consolidation is the demand hedge: Existing retailers are not onboarding new suppliers during the recession, but they are concentrating orders with incumbents; SP Apparels is gaining share from smaller Indian and overseas competitors who are struggling to fill capacity. Two new customers began supplying in Q2, and no orders have been cancelled.
Sundararajan: "Getting new customers to enter, it's a difficult thing at the moment because they are looking at saving for their own existing suppliers. So, they are not looking for any new suppliers. At the same thing, the good news is that our existing customers are consolidating, so we are getting more differences from the existing customers."
Spinning: The Margin Swing Factor
- From boost to burden: In Q1, the cotton-to-yarn spread lifted margins; in Q2, it reversed. Cotton prices stayed high while yarn realisation fell, and because garment costing is pegged to market yarn price rather than cotton cost, the spread loss hit consolidated margins directly.
- Spinning plant ran at a negative EBITDA margin in Q2, which management identified as the main area of margin loss. Production was deliberately reduced over the preceding three months in response to the unfavourable spread.
- Recovery is underway but incomplete: Cotton prices have corrected and the spread is now more or less positive, though still not close to breakeven. Management hopes cotton prices will correct and steady and expects the spinning division to contribute to margins going forward.
Sundararajan: "See, this time, there is a loss of margin due to this cotton spinning division, but sometimes it can be the other way also. It will boost the margin sometimes. As it did in the first quarter."
Retail Division: Still in Reset Mode
- Q2 loss driven by seasonality and launch costs: Negative 16% EBITDA margin reflected end-of-season sale discounts in July–August and lower gross margins on new brands Angel & Rocket and Head, where smaller minimum order quantities pushed up unit costs. Overheads were maintained, not increased.
- The Future Group hole: Revenue remains below pre-COVID levels because ~₹50 crores of annual business from 100 brand-factory stores inside Future Group outlets was lost. EBOs and shop-in-shop wholesale have grown 25% like-for-like, and some former Future Group stores are relaunching under new operators from November.
- Cautious near-term posture: The next one-year plan is to sustain and grow organically rather than expand geographies or brands, with a focus on inventory discipline. EBO count is targeted to rise from 60 to closer to 100 over two years, through both COCO and FOFO formats.
- Q3 outlook is mixed: October was better, but December will bring another round of end-of-season sales, so Q3 will be a blend of Q1’s strength and Q2’s weakness. Management declined to guide on whether retail can break even in the quarter.
SP UK & Processing: Bright Spots
- SP UK turned the corner: Revenue rose from GBP 0.12 crore to GBP 0.21 crore QoQ, and EBITDA margin swung from a loss to a positive 2.9%. Management is confident Q3 will be better than Q2 and Q4 will be normal, and the UK recession will not have a big impact on the business.
- Processing division performed well: Utilisation was strong and the division contributed effectively to margins, even as coal availability issues and input cost rises created headwinds.
Margins, Costs & Balance Sheet
- Consolidated margin pressure was concentrated in spinning (negative EBITDA) and retail (negative 16% EBITDA margin), partially offset by garment strength and processing performance.
- Management sticks to 18–20% EBITDA margin target, acknowledging acute competition from factories desperate to fill capacity but arguing that supplier-base consolidation gives SP Apparels preference.
- Finance cost rose from ₹5 Cr to ₹8 Cr QoQ, driven entirely by a ~₹4 Cr notional restatement loss on foreign currency packing credit as the rupee depreciated to ~82.
- Working capital improved: Cotton inventory consumed, reducing inventory days from 95–100 in March to ~30 days now, as seasonal cotton buying at season-end unwound.
- Solar investment begun: A 1 MW solar plant was commissioned at the spinning plant, with plans to add 1 MW every year, expected to contribute to margins going forward.
Sundararajan: "See, because of the recession, there are many factories even within India are not fully booked. So, they are desperate to book their orders to fill their capacity. So, there is definitely acute competition, which we are prepared to chase it."
UK FTA: The Structural Opportunity
- Timing hope: Management is looking for the UK FTA to be signed by end-December 2022; the change in UK Prime Minister is seen as improving the odds of a favourable outcome.
- The math: Pre-FTA, India carries a 9–9.5% landed-cost disadvantage versus Bangladesh, Sri Lanka and Pakistan. Post-FTA, India’s landed cost would be at par, removing the structural handicap.
- The payoff: Big retailers are ready to shift volume once the FTA is through; management expects margins could increase slightly due to better negotiating power in a level playing field.
Sundararajan: "Now the landed cost of India after post-FTA is at par with Bangladesh, Sri Lanka and Pakistan."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Garment division revenue growth | 25% YoY for FY23; same 25% target for FY24 | FY23, FY24 |
| Consolidated EBITDA margin | Maintain 18% to 20% | Ongoing |
| Capacity utilisation increase | Rise by 10–15 percentage points from current ~75% | Going forward |
| Labour force | Reach 15,000 people | By June 2023 |
| Second-shift machines | Reach 200 machines in second shift | By end of March 2024 |
| Sivakasi factory | Completion | By end of June 2023 |
| Solar capacity | Add 1 MW every year | Annual |
| Retail EBO count | Grow from ~60 to closer to 100 | Over next two years |
| Q3 FY23 volumes | At par with Q2 FY23 (Diwali holidays reduce production days) | Q3 FY23 |
| SP UK trajectory | Q3 better than Q2; Q4 normal | Q3, Q4 FY23 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | ₹314 cr, +41% YoY |
| H1 FY23 consolidated revenue | ₹567 cr, +60% YoY |
| Consolidated adjusted EBITDA | ₹44 cr, flat YoY |
| H1 FY23 consolidated adjusted EBITDA | ₹96 cr, +39% YoY; cotton price pressure reduced margin by 140 bps |
| Consolidated PBT | ₹30 cr vs ₹31 cr YoY |
| Consolidated PAT | ₹23 cr, flat YoY |
| H1 FY23 PAT | ₹48 cr, +40% YoY |
| Garment division revenue | ₹269 cr, +47% YoY |
| Garment division adjusted EBITDA margin | 17.9% |
| SP UK revenue | GBP 0.21 cr vs GBP 0.12 cr QoQ |
| SP UK EBITDA margin | 2.9% vs a loss QoQ |
| SP Retail Ventures revenue | ₹17 cr, EBITDA loss of ₹2.5 cr |
| SP Retail adjusted EBITDA margin | negative 16% |
| Order book | ₹356 cr, down from ~₹400 cr last quarter |
| Capacity utilisation | ~75%, expected to increase by 10% to 15% going forward |
| Total exported quantity | 1.64 crore pieces |
| Average unit price increase | 10% to 12% due to raw material cost and product mix change |
| Labour force increase QoQ | ~500 people |
| Machines in operation | ~3,700 out of 5,100 total |
| Gross debt | ₹154 cr; net debt ₹87 cr; cash ₹67 cr |
| Finance cost | ₹8 cr, including ~₹4 cr notional restatement loss on foreign currency packing credit |
| Cotton inventory carry | ~30 days, down from 95–100 days in March |
| FY23 full-year growth target | 25% YoY |
| FY24 garment division growth target | 25% (per management) |
| SP Retail store count | 65 stores across all brands |
| SP Retail EBO count | 60, target closer to 100 in next two years |
| Second-shift machine addition target | 200 machines by end of March 2024 |
| Hedging level | 80% to 90% |
| Pound share of currency mix | ~45% |