Key Takeaways
- Flat garment revenue, margin hit from forex reversal: Garment revenue was flat YoY at ₹219 crores as retailers pushed back orders to clear inventory pile-ups, while a ₹8.5–8.9 crore MTM forex loss dragged adjusted EBITDA margin from 20.2% to 17.7%.
- Spinning swung to a loss, but recovery is in sight: High cotton prices and lower realizations forced production cuts, making the spinning segment EBITDA-negative; with cotton and yarn prices now correcting, a margin contribution is expected to resume.
- Retail losses are a deliberate investment, not a structural problem: The ₹1.8 crore EBITDA loss in retail came entirely from fixed overheads of newly launched brands (Angel & Rocket, Head) that have not yet scaled; the core Crocodile brand is already profitable.
- Consolidation tailwind is real and timed for mid-2023: Retailers are reducing supplier counts and pushing volume to scaled manufacturers like SP Apparels; management expects aggressive order placement to begin from July onwards, with a soft Q1 before that.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the promised 25–30% Q4 volume growth materializes, the pace of spinning margin recovery, and any signed FPAs by the March deadline.
Demand & Order Book
- Retailer destocking froze Q3: Container issues in October 2022 created inventory chaos at retailers, who responded by holding everything and delaying purchase decisions; this pushed Q3 volumes down from 1.6 crore pieces to ~1.34 crore pieces QoQ.
- Kids and babies outperforming adults: Demand for childrenswear and babywear remains stronger than men’s and ladies’ wear, a structural advantage for SP Apparels’ core category.
- Consolidation is the demand catalyst: Retailers are actively reducing supplier counts and directing business to large manufacturers; SP Apparels is being asked to increase capacity and expand into adult wear as part of this shift. The benefit is expected to flow from July onwards, with a 2–3 month push-out from earlier expectations.
- Order book provides near-term visibility: The current order book stands at ₹364 crores, covering 4–5 months of production, with orders already closed for April. Management expressed clear visibility despite logistics and recession concerns.
- Europe and UK remain soft vs the US: Demand from Europe and the UK is "not that great" compared to the US, and management expects this nuisance to persist for another year; the Russia-Ukraine war is expected to settle down in about six months.
Sundararajan: "They really don't know which one to buy which one not to buy. That's the kind of a situation. They are just holding everything and gradually now they are releasing the orders."
Margin Walk
- Forex reversal was the main margin shock: The 250 bps YoY drop in garment EBITDA margin was driven by an ₹8.5–8.9 crore MTM forex loss, a reversal of gains booked over the prior 2–3 quarters triggered by currency moves around the UK Prime Minister candidate change. Management stressed the margin shown is without any forex impact: it is purely a reversal.
- Spinning swung from contributor to drag: Last year’s 21% EBITDA margin was partly supported by spinning; in recent quarters, spinning compressed margins as high cotton prices met lower realizations. With yarn price correction underway, spinning is expected to contribute again.
- Yarn-price pass-through mechanics compress spreads: When yarn prices rise 30%, only ~10% is passed through in sales realization, so spreads compress. Now that cotton and yarn prices have corrected, margins should realign with the 18% guidance.
- Adult-wear mix is a margin challenge to manage: Adult men’s and ladies’ wear carries lower margins than kids and babywear. As adult contribution rises toward ~20% of revenue, management acknowledges the margin percentage will face pressure but expects to offset it with better margins from fashion in the core kids and baby segment, maintaining 18–20% overall.
Segment Performance
| Segment | Trend | Commentary |
|---|---|---|
| Garments | ▬ Flat revenue, margin down | Revenue flat at ₹219 crores; EBITDA margin fell to 17.7% from 20.2% YoY on forex reversal; volumes declined QoQ on retailer pushbacks. |
| Spinning | ▼ Loss-making | EBITDA negative due to production cuts forced by high cotton prices and lower realizations; recovery expected as cotton and yarn prices correct. |
| Processing | ▲ Stable contributor | Maintained good utilization despite coal availability issues and input cost increases. |
| SPUK (UK subsidiary) | ▼ Revenue halved | Revenue fell to GBP 0.11 crore from GBP 0.21 crore YoY on supply chain disruptions; achieved EBITDA breakeven vs 2.9% QoQ. |
| Retail (SP Retail Ventures) | ▼ Loss-making | ₹1.8 crore EBITDA loss on ₹31 crore revenue; entirely from fixed overheads of new brands (Angel & Rocket, Head); Crocodile (~85% of retail) is already EBITDA-positive. |
Retail Business: Investment Phase
- New brands are the entire loss story: Angel & Rocket and Head added fixed overheads that the current top line cannot yet support; Crocodile, which accounts for ~85% of retail revenue, is already EBITDA-positive and sustainable.
- Distribution is scaling through LFS channels: The new brands are now placed in Lifestyle, Shoppers Stop, Central, and Pantaloon through the large-format store channel, alongside two new Angel & Rocket stores in Bangalore and new Head brand stores.
- FY24 is the targeted turnaround year: Management expects the current year’s efforts to yield results next year, with retail revenue close to ₹120 crores and 8% EBITDA for the full year. Angel & Rocket and Head need minimum time to break even, which is happening now. Natalia will take more time to operationalize.
Capacity & Expansion
- Utilization headroom is significant: Current utilization is 74%, with room to improve by another 20% through second-shift operation of ~500 machines; next financial year utilization is expected at around 80% to 85%.
- Sivakasi project nearing completion: The new project is in progress and could come by March.
- FY24 effective capacity: Management expects 4,200 machines on average, with machine count rising from 3,900 in April to 4,500 by March.
- New factory delayed by approvals: The new factory project is now expected to be completed and running by April 2024, with building work starting from April onwards; the delay was caused by approvals from competent authorities.
- Employee count dip is seasonal, not structural: Q3 headcount fell because of Diwali-related out-migration and fewer working days; this is normal across the industry and picks up again from April. Employee growth of 15% is expected alongside 15% to 20% revenue growth next year.
Sundararajan: "In this current scenario, the retailers are trying to consolidate it. So, naturally they want to reduce the number of suppliers and push the business to the big manufacturers. They are asking us to increase the capacity."
Adult-Wear & Customer Diversification
- Consolidation is pulling SP Apparels into adult wear: Existing customers are asking the company to expand into men’s and ladies’ wear as they consolidate their supplier base; adult contribution is expected to reach ~20% by end of next year, up from the current 7–10%.
- Two new customers added: The company started working with one customer from the US and one from Russia, with traction expected in coming quarters. Management noted this is not the right time to aggressively add new customers because everyone is consolidating.
- Demand for own capacity is not an issue: For SP Apparels’ existing capacity, demand is sufficient; the additional increase from consolidation is expected from July onwards.
Sundararajan: "While consolidation is happening, they are asking us to do even the adult business."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Q4 FY23 volume growth | 25–30% growth | Current quarter (Q4 FY23) |
| Full-year FY23 production | 5.8 to 6 crore pieces | FY23 |
| FY23 top-line growth | 25–30% | FY23 |
| FY24 top-line growth | 15–20% | FY24 |
| EBITDA margin | Maintain 18% | Ongoing |
| Capacity utilization | Improve to 80–85% | Next financial year |
| Adult-wear contribution | Reach ~20% of revenue | By end of next year |
| Retail revenue and margin | Close to ₹120 crores at 8% EBITDA | Next year (FY24) |
| New factory operational | Up and running | April 2024 |
| Consolidation-driven order increase | Aggressive order placement begins | From July onwards |
| FPA signing | Signed | By end of March |
| Spinning margin recovery | Contribute to margin again | Q4 should be better; by March things should be back |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Total adjusted revenue | ₹258 cr |
| EBITDA | ₹38 cr |
| PBT | ₹19.43 cr |
| PAT | ₹13.2 cr |
| Garment division revenue | ₹219 cr, flat YoY |
| Garment division adjusted EBITDA margin | 17.7%, vs 20.2% YoY |
| Retail division revenue | ₹20.87 cr |
| Retail division EBITDA margin | -8.96% |
| UK subsidiary revenue | ₹11.15 cr, EBITDA breakeven |
| FY23 full-year revenue growth guidance | 25% to 30% |
| FY24 revenue growth guidance | 15% to 20% |
| Order book | ₹364 cr, covers 4–5 months |
| Capacity utilization | 74%, expected to rise 10–15 ppt going forward |
| Export volumes | 1.33 cr pieces |
| Net debt | ₹84 cr as of 31 Dec |
| Net working capital | ₹274 cr as of 31 Dec |
| Store count | 65 across all brands |
| Adult wear revenue contribution | 7–10%, anticipated ~20% by end of next year |
| Pound exposure | ~45% of revenue |
| Employee count | ~12,500 targeted for next quarter |