Key Takeaways
- Garment growth, spinning drag: Garment revenue grew 6% YoY to ₹232 crores, but spinning losses of ₹30–40 crores and retail losses pulled consolidated PAT slightly down to ₹82 crores.
- Margin compression is temporary, management says: Garment EBITDA margin fell to 17.8% from 20.2% YoY on input costs; management is confident of sustaining 18%–20% going forward as cotton stabilizes and spinning normalizes.
- The China-plus-one order book is real: A ₹365 crore order book, strong anti-China sentiment among US and EU retailers, and long-term customers consolidating more business underpin a planned 14%–15% FY24 garment growth.
- Retail and spinning are the swing factors for PAT: Management expects consolidated retail EBITDA breakeven and spinning to at least stop losing money in FY24; if both normalize, PAT growth will substantially outpace revenue growth.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the promised FTA with UK and Canada materializes by June 2023, the pace of spinning margin recovery, and any sign that the two new retail brands are closing their losses.
Garment Division: The Core Engine
- Revenue and volume: Q4 garment revenue of ₹232 crores, up 6% YoY, on export volumes of 1.44 crore pieces; full-year garment revenue reached ₹960 crores, driving consolidated revenue to a record ₹1,098 crores.
- Order book composition: The ₹365 crore order book is solid through August 2023, though average price has fallen from ~₹140–₹150 to ~₹120–₹130 per piece, meaning the book would have been closer to ₹400 crore at prior prices.
- Customer consolidation: Long-term customers of two-plus decades are consolidating more business with SP Apparels; demand for baby garments in Europe and the UK is stronger than expected.
- No price pressure from cotton decline: Customers are not pressing for price reductions on falling cotton because they had been unable to pass through yarn cost increases when cotton prices rose.
- Capacity utilization: Currently at ~70%, expected to rise 10%–15% going forward; the company is also evaluating second-shift operations to add capacity without additional capital employed.
- New customer pipeline: Many inquiries from new customers in the US and EU; the company is scrutinizing suitable ones, though existing customer demand is growing fast enough that there is limited room to onboard new accounts immediately.
Sundararajan: "our long-term customers who were associated with this for more than 2 decades are so much confident in our association. And they are consolidating more and more businesses to us. ... there is a big demand for the baby garment, which is generally, everyone expected there would not be much demand in Europe and the U.K., but that's not the case."
Spinning Division: The Margin Drag
- Loss magnitude: The spinning segment lost nearly ₹30–40 crores in FY23 due to an erratic mismatch between cotton costs and yarn realizations; the mills made no margins.
- Cotton price stabilization: Cotton prices have declined ~₹5,000 per candy in the last 2–3 months and stabilized; management does not foresee further fluctuations.
- Recovery expectation: Management is confident the spinning unit will contribute to margins from Q1 FY24 onwards; even breakeven would represent a big saving relative to FY23.
- Inventory policy shift: Cotton carrying cost has fallen 40% (from ₹1 lakh to ₹65,000 per candy) and storage days have been cut from 95 to 45; the company plans to hold 45–60 days of stock going forward, enabling a just-in-time working model.
Sundararajan: "And I think to the tune of about -- we lost nearly about INR30 crores to INR40 crores we lost in the last financial year because of this erratic situation of cotton versus yarn realization."
Retail Division: Breakeven Promise, Unanswered Questions
- FY23 performance: S.P. Retail Ventures posted a Q4 EBITDA loss of ₹3.37 crores; the Crocodile brand was profitable, but new brands Angel & Rocket and Head dragged on margins through fixed overheads and expansion costs.
- Store actions: Non-performing stores have been closed and 4 new stand-alone stores opened in premium locations, plus 1 new Angel & Rocket store in Hyderabad; 2 of the new stores are doing very well, 2 are improving.
- FY24 commitment: Management firmly expects consolidated retail EBITDA breakeven in FY24, with Crocodile generating enough EBITDA to cover the other two brands' losses; the two new brands will still not be out of losses individually.
- Capital allocation question deferred: When asked whether the company plans to allocate more capital to retail or seek external investors, the CFO declined to answer, stating the Board must decide and the question can only be addressed after the Board meeting.
- Unanswered loss composition: An analyst asked about the nature of the ₹7–8 crore EBITDA loss on the ₹80 crore retail business and what is being done to ensure right economics before further capital allocation; the call dropped before management could answer, and the subsequent reply addressed COVID impact and store consolidation but not the specific loss-composition question.
Sundararajan: "But for next year, we'll definitely, on a consolidated level among all the 3 brands, it will be EBITDA breakeven. Brand-wise, the other 2 will still not be out of it, but Crocodile would be making enough EBITDA to make up for the other 2 brands EBITDA losses."
Factory Consolidation & Capacity Expansion
- Consolidation completed: Four small factories of ~100 machines each were closed and workers moved to larger factories for better efficiency and administrative control; roughly 50% of workers transferred, the rest left due to distance.
- Rationale: The consolidation was executed during a period of lower order inflow, making it cost-effective; customers are reluctant to approach small-size factories, so larger units improve the company's competitive positioning.
- Capacity restored: Despite losing 150–200 operators who could not relocate, the company made up the capacity through existing factories and is now at more than pre-consolidation levels.
- Sivakasi greenfield: Construction to start in July 2023 after government clearances were received; expected to be up and running in 12 months, adding ~20% capacity.
- Annual capex run-rate: Roughly ₹50–60 crores per year for new garment factories, year-on-year.
Sundararajan: "we made use of this opportunity to consolidate because it is very cost effective and administratively much better and easier. And third one is the customer for small-size factories, they're very reluctant to approach those factories."
Geopolitical Tailwinds & FTA Catalyst
- Anti-China sentiment: Management states the anti-China shift among American and European retailers remains very strong, with retailers serious about transferring as much business as possible from China to India.
- FTA with UK and Canada: Expected by end of June 2023 per inside association information; the EU is also pushing quickly; management believes the FTA should be through in the next two months.
- Duty-free benefit: When the duty-free structure arrives, the company sees a possibility of gaining another ~4%–5%, with a net gain after sharing with customers expected at roughly 5%.
- Forex tailwind: The euro, pound, and dollar are very much in favor, helping competitiveness; however, 88% of orders are already booked or hedged, so headroom for further gains from appreciation is limited.
Sundararajan: "So generally, the apparel industry has started doing well and especially the American customers, as well as the European customers and the U.K., they are the retailers are insisting to I mean, they are very serious about transferring as much business as possible from China to India as they would see a lot of potential in India. So still that anti-China thing is still very strong."
Margin & Profitability Outlook
- Garment margin confidence: Management is confident of sustaining 18%–20% EBITDA margins in garmenting; raw material changes will not affect this, and the cotton price decline provides more cushion for negotiation.
- PAT growth leverage: PAT growth in FY24 is expected to be substantially more than revenue growth because spinning and retail losses normalize; the garment division alone maintained 18% EBITDA despite a ₹30 crore spinning loss in FY23.
- Wage inflation: Management does not envisage any wage inflation in India beyond routine ~5% year-on-year.
- Working capital improvement: Inventory and receivables reduced materially through lower cotton carrying costs, reduced storage days, and a planned just-in-time working model.
Balaji: "See, whatever happens with respect to raw material, the management bandwidth is working towards the 18% EBITDA margins, which we have guided for. And I don't think any change in the cotton prices, or margins would affect the EBITDA. We still see that 18% EBITDA margins can be sustained."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Garment revenue growth | 14%–15% value growth; volume growth to cross 20%–22% | FY24 |
| Garment EBITDA margin | Sustain 18%–20% | FY24 |
| Consolidated retail EBITDA | Breakeven at consolidated level across all 3 brands | FY24 |
| Spinning division | Contribute to margins; at minimum stop losing money | From Q1 FY24 onwards |
| PAT growth | Substantially more than revenue growth | FY24 |
| Sivakasi factory | Construction start July 2023; operational in 12 months | By mid-2024 |
| FTA with UK and Canada | Duty-free structure expected | By end of June 2023 |
| Capacity utilization | Increase by 10%–15% from current ~70% | Going forward |
| New customer additions | Add 2–3 new customers | Within 1 year |
| Annual capex | ₹50–60 crores per year for new garment factories | Year-on-year |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | ₹272 cr, vs ₹258 cr YoY |
| Consolidated EBITDA | ₹40.48 cr, vs ₹45 cr YoY |
| Consolidated PBT | ₹25 cr, vs ₹36 cr YoY |
| Consolidated PAT | ₹20 cr, vs ₹25 cr YoY |
| Full-year FY23 consolidated revenue | ₹1,098 cr, highest in company history, vs ₹867 cr YoY |
| Full-year FY23 consolidated EBITDA margin | 15.7%, vs 17.6% YoY |
| Full-year FY23 PAT | ₹82 cr, vs ₹84 cr YoY |
| Garment division Q4 revenue | ₹232 cr, 6% YoY growth |
| Garment division Q4 adjusted EBITDA margin | 17.8%, vs 20.2% YoY |
| Garment division full-year FY23 EBITDA margin | 18.7%, vs 20.9% YoY |
| Garment division FY24 growth target | 14% to 15% value growth, volume growth expected to cross 20% to 22% |
| Garment order book | ₹365 cr, would have been ~₹400 cr at earlier average prices |
| Garment capacity utilization | ~70%, expected to increase by 10% to 15% going forward |
| Garment average realization per piece | ₹115–₹120, reduced from ~₹140 last year due to yarn price decline |
| Total exported quantity | 1.44 crore pieces |
| Spinning division FY23 loss | ~₹30–40 cr, due to cotton vs yarn realization mismatch |
| S.P. Retail Ventures Q4 revenue | ₹25 cr, EBITDA loss of ₹3.37 cr |
| S.P. Retail Ventures full-year FY23 EBITDA | ₹7.5 cr negative, vs ₹5.1 cr negative previous year |
| SPUK Q4 revenue | GBP 0.14 cr, vs GBP 0.22 cr YoY; EBITDA breakeven vs 5.5% YoY |
| Standalone net debt as of March 31 | ₹40 cr, gross debt ₹161 cr, cash and cash equivalents ₹121 cr |
| Cotton inventory days | 45 days, vs 95 days last year |
| Cotton price per candy | ₹65,000, down from ~₹1 lakh per candy, a ~40% reduction |
| Planned annual capex for new garment factories | ₹50–60 cr per year |
| Wage inflation expectation in India | ~5% routine increase year-on-year |
| FTA duty reduction on landed cost | 9.5%–10%, management expects net gain of ~5% |