Key Takeaways
- Inventory loss overshadows volume growth: A steep fall in Styrene Monomer prices triggered an estimated Rs. 90-100 crores inventory loss, compressing margins even as overall volumes grew 9% YoY.
- Exports reawaken as domestic demand softens: Exports surged to 16%-17% of volumes, compensating for a 4% YoY drop in domestic sales driven by a 20% slump in appliance-maker offtake.
- Margins are at a cyclical floor: Management stated spreads between Styrene and Polystyrene are at pre-COVID or long-term average levels, with limited scope to fall further, though recovery depends on global demand.
- Volume growth target trimmed: Full-year volume growth guidance was lowered to +12% from an earlier 15-16%, reflecting the weak appliance sector.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the theoretical margin bounce to 14-15% materializes absent another inventory loss, the pace of export order flow toward the 50,000-ton target, and any recovery in OEM offtake after the monsoon.
Margin Mechanics & the Inventory Loss
- The 45-60 day pipeline trap: A purchase order commits the company to a price, but the full cycle from order to sale spans 45-60 days, not just the 10-15 days of raw material at the plant. When Styrene Monomer prices fell over 22% in the quarter, the loss hit both in-transit raw material and finished goods stock.
- Commodity exposure limits value-added protection: Even though 40% of volumes are Value-Added grades commanding 25% to 100% better margins, profitability still suffers in a downturn because the base raw material is the same Styrene Monomer. When Styrene prices fall, selling prices across all grades get impacted.
- Spreads at a floor: Current spreads between Styrene and Polystyrene are almost at pre-COVID levels or the average of previous many years. Management believes the scope to go down further is limited, and upside depends on demand growth globally.
- Theoretical recovery path: If prices remain at current levels and no further inventory loss occurs, margins could recover from 7% to around 14-15% in the coming quarter, per an analyst's math. Management called this a fair assumption on paper but deflected from confirming it, citing dependence on the demand cycle and external factors.
Nayyar: "I only said that the margins are now, they are bottom down because they are at the pre-COVID levels at the same level and if you look at the long term averages also, so the margins of the spreads are almost at the same level. So the scope of these to go down further is limited."
Demand & Volume Drivers
- Domestic weakness concentrated in appliances: Domestic sales volumes declined 4% YoY, with OEM offtake down almost 20% compared to the same quarter last year. July and August are seasonally lean months due to rains, making Q3 OEM sales difficult to project.
- Exports fill the gap: Exports jumped to 16%-17% of volumes after being dormant for 2-3 years, when domestic demand was strong and capacity was insufficient. With new capacity online, the company revived old client relationships and restarted exports, driving all of the quarter's 9% overall volume growth.
- EPS market stagnant: The Expandable Polystyrene market was flat YoY, also impacted by low offtake from appliance manufacturers.
- SMMA sidelined for Polystyrene: SMMA demand in India remains very limited. With rising Polystyrene demand, the SMMA line is now being used more for Polystyrene production instead, and SMMA compounds are made by importing SMMA material.
- Volume growth target trimmed: The company was targeting 15% volume growth, but with low appliance-sector offtake, volume growth may go down to 12% for FY24.
Nayyar: "See the steep decline, if you notice that in this quarter, all polymer prices dropped, all building blocks dropped. It is the slow growth in China and the slowdown in Europe, which impacted the demand and with the demand going down everything fell."
Value-Added Grades & Mix Shift
- 40% share with a premium: Value-Added grades command 25% to 100% better margins than commodity grades, defined as any grade earning more than 25% above the normal margin. The company is working to increase this share, but acceptability by appliance manufacturers requires approvals that take time, making a timeline difficult to give.
- Absolute growth even without mix shift: When the balance 25% of unutilized capacity comes online, the overall percentage of Value-Added Grades remaining the same will still increase in absolute terms.
- No segment-level margin disclosure: Management declined to provide margin percentages for the Value-Added segment versus the commoditized segment, or a segment-wise volume breakup of Polystyrene out of total volumes.
Capacity & CAPEX
- Polystyrene utilization at 75%: The facility now has 2 lines for GPPS, 2 lines for HIPS, plus a swing line, allowing 100% utilization on individual lines depending on demand.
- Mass ABS project on track: The first phase with capacity of 70,000 tons per annum is progressing as per schedule and expected to be commissioned by Q3 FY25.
- Rs. 1,250 crores CAPEX nearing completion: The plan (set in 2021) includes Polystyrene and EPS expansion (phase 1), ABS at the Maharashtra complex, phase 2 of Expandable Polystyrene, addition of compound lines, and a new line for Extruded Insulation Board. All plants are targeted for commissioning and completion by March 2025.
- SPC volume growth outlook: Expecting around 20% volume growth in FY24, driven by new compounds and new approvals from appliance manufacturers.
Nayyar: "Post that we will be certainly doing some new activities and new projects will come up, but then I can't really give you the details of those at the moment please."
External Factors & Structural Risks
- No direct crude-Styrene link: Styrene Monomer prices depend on benzene and ethylene, with benzene availability being the major factor. There is no direct relation between crude oil and Styrene Monomer.
- Inventory loss is structural, not exceptional: The Rs. 90-100 crores inventory loss is a normal occurrence when prices fall sharply. Because it is a globally traded commodity product, it is very difficult to protect against unless the government provides some protection mechanism.
- No antidumping protection: There is no antidumping duty on Styrene Monomer as there is no manufacturer in India. On Polystyrene, the application was cleared by DGTR but the Ministry of Finance did not approve it.
- Freight costs normalized: Containerized cargo freight costs, which were very high in FY22, have now become normal.
Nayyar: "This will always happen and unless there is some other protection mechanism provided by the government or anybody, it is very difficult because it is a commodity product globally importable and the trade happens globally."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Volume growth | +12% for FY24 (revised from 15-16%) | FY24 |
| Export volumes | Close to 50,000 tons | FY24 |
| SPC volume growth | Around 20%, driven by new compounds and approvals | FY24 |
| Mass ABS plant commissioning | First phase, 70,000 tons per annum capacity | Q3 FY25 |
| All CAPEX plants commissioned | Rs. 1,250 crores plan: Polystyrene, EPS, ABS, compounds, Extruded Insulation Board | By March 2025 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Operational income | ₹1,225 cr |
| EBITDA | ₹91 cr |
| EBITDA margin | 7.39% |
| Net profit after tax | ₹69 cr |
| PAT margin | 5.66% |
| Total sales volume growth (manufactured products) | +9% YoY, including exports |
| Domestic sales volume growth | -4% YoY, due to low off-take by appliance manufacturers |
| Polystyrene capacity utilization | 75% |
| Value-Added grades share of total volumes | 40% |
| Exports share of total volumes | 16%-17% |
| Inventory loss (estimated) | ₹90 cr to ₹100 cr, due to Styrene Monomer price fall |
| Styrene Monomer price movement | Dropped from ~$1,100 to $850 during the quarter |
| Full-year volume growth guidance | +12% |
| Full-year export volume guidance | ~50,000 tons |
| Mass ABS Project Phase 1 commissioning timeline | Q3 FY25, capacity of 70,000 tons per annum |