Key Takeaways
- Volume-led quarter, deltas stabilizing: Domestic volumes grew 15.5% YoY in Q4, with all verticals except XPS contributing. Management sees delta spreads as having stabilized, though geopolitics clouds the forward view.
- Mass ABS delayed, but the thesis holds: Phase 1 commercial start pushed to Q4 FY25 on proprietary equipment delays. The import substitution story remains intact with 1.5 lakh tonnes of standard-grade ABS imports to displace.
- FY24 EBITDA per tonne is the new normal: Post-COVID supply chain disruptions created abnormally high deltas in FY22-23. With freight and supply chains normalized, management confirmed the FY24 figure is sustainable.
- Karnal greenfield anchors the next leg: A ~₹850 crore investment in North India, funded from the ₹1,100 crore liquid asset base, targets construction-linked downstream products and freight cost savings on 40% of domestic PS demand.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether Mass ABS equipment delivery stays on track for a December 2024 mechanical completion, and any delta movement from geopolitical shocks.
Volume Growth & Demand Drivers
- Broad-based domestic strength: Q4 domestic volumes rose 15.5% YoY, with EPS, masterbatch compounds and polystyrene all contributing. Full-year domestic growth was 7.5%. Exports resumed with full force as expanded capacity came online.
- Seasonal pattern intact: Appliance manufacturers drive higher demand in Q4 and Q1 and during festivals; monsoon months are lean; post-Diwali is generally weak. Non-OEM demand stays steady year-round. Management confirmed no one-off in Q4 product mix.
- Market growth anchored at 8-10%: The underlying market grows at this rate, with potential upside from EV adoption and appliance sector expansion.
- ABS demand pull is structural: Current demand of 3 lakh tonnes includes 1.5 lakh tonnes of imports, all standard grades. Domestic capacities also cater to standard grades, and 95% of applications use standard grades, so import substitution is a volume game, not a specialty one.
- Export arithmetic works on service, not price: The company exports to Europe, Asia, the Gulf, North America, South America and Japan. Competitiveness rests on specific grades, recipes, customer service and importers' internal logistics costs, not on undercutting on price.
Rakesh Nayyar: "Have we not been competitive, people would have not been buying from us or we would have not been producing and exporting if we were incurring losses. Our quality is good and we regularly supply to Europe, Asian countries, Gulf, North America, South America. We have customers in all the continents today and you would be surprised that we exported last year to Japan as well."
Delta Spreads & Margin Sustainability
- Deltas normalized from COVID-era highs: FY22-23 and FY21-22 saw abnormally high global deltas because plants were underutilized, freight rates were elevated and supply chains were disrupted. With freight rates and supply chains restored, deltas have returned to long-term averages.
- Q4 deltas expanded sequentially: Deltas have expanded QoQ and appear to have stabilized at the moment, though management cautioned that geopolitical issues make future prediction difficult.
- FY24 EBITDA per tonne is sustainable: Management explicitly confirmed the FY24 figure is sustainable given current circumstances, framing the prior two years as the aberration, not the new baseline.
- Export margins are additive, not dilutive: Export realizations are not as good as domestic, but they give a good contribution and are not loss-making. Domestic market remains the priority; exports fill the balance.
Rakesh Nayyar: "No, not now. But then they are fine. They certainly add to our, they give a good contribution to us, but they are not as good as the domestic market, but they are good."
Mass ABS Project: Delay & Outlook
- Phase 1 delayed by equipment, not demand: Commercial start has moved from June 2024 to Q4 FY25 because delivery of proprietary equipment was delayed by 4-5 months. Management still hopes to complete the project mechanically by December 2024 and be on stream in the last quarter of FY25.
- Mass ABS is a continuous process: Unlike conventional batch-process ABS, Mass ABS comes directly through the reactor. Management declined to estimate the conversion cost advantage until the plant is running, calling any pre-commissioning number a guess.
- First-year utilization pegged at +50%: Management expects over 50% utilization in FY26, the first full year. Profitability at that utilization level was not quantified: "Difficult to comment at this stage."
- Phase 2 timeline is open-ended: Phase 2 may come in FY26 or later; the schedule is not finalized.
- Chinese ABS overcapacity is a supply-chain reshuffle, not a direct threat: Management acknowledged 600,000 tonnes of new Chinese ABS capacity but framed the impact as a redirection of supply chains: countries that currently supply China will look for other markets, and some old, uneconomical plants may get mothballed. The company did not directly address whether Chinese cost advantage would pressure Indian pricing.
Rakesh Nayyar: "On the ABS side, yes supply chain would change in the sense that the countries who are supplying to China, they would have to look at other markets, they may look at the Western market, some of the old plants may get mothballed. So, that turnaround will happen once the Chinese are fully implemented, with their latest 600,000 tonnes of ABS capacity."
Karnal Greenfield & Capacity Expansion
- Karnal is a ~₹850 crore bet on North India: The company acquired land in the Panipat-Karnal area for a new greenfield center. Rationale: proximity to IOCL's styrene monomer (raw material) and proximity to the North market, which consumes 40% of India's polystyrene demand. Freight savings come from moving finished goods from West to North and from port to plant, not from raw material price discounts since domestic raw material is linked to global prices.
- Product slate goes beyond polystyrene: Plans include downstream units related to construction: 3D panels, sheeting and extruded polystyrene.
- Funding is internal: Cash and liquid assets of ~₹1,100 crores will cover Karnal and further expansions.
- Asset turns to match existing business at maturity: Management expects Karnal's asset turns to be similar to current operations once mature.
- Near-term capacity adds are back-end loaded: EPS, masterbatch and compounds expansions come through only towards end of FY25 or in Q3, so they will not add much to FY25 top line or volume growth. Mass ABS also only towards year-end. These products will add to volume growth in FY26.
- Peak revenue on current gross block: ₹6,500 crores at 100% utilization and current prices. New capacities will add on top. Practically, 90% utilization is easily achievable if demand is flat through the year.
- New capacity absorption timeline: Management hopes to fully utilize new EPS and compounds capacity within two years.
Competitive Position & Trade Dynamics
- Domestic premium over imports is earned, not given: Polystyrene is imported from Korea, Taiwan, Thailand and Iran, yet Supreme Petrochem commands a premium over imported prices. The moat is customer service and application support, not price.
- Chinese polystyrene overcapacity has not hurt: Minimal polystyrene exports from China to India have been seen so far, and no significant impact has materialized.
- Product-wise ROCE hierarchy: XPS earns the best returns, followed by polystyrene (with lines of various vintages), then EPS and SPC. ABS is capital-intensive and new, so initial ROCE will not match depreciated polystyrene assets; at peak maturity in a couple of years, similar ROCE is possible.
- Employee costs are rising with scale: Expansion, new verticals, expanded capacities, general wage increases and periodic revisions are all driving employee cost higher.
Rakesh Nayyar: "Today even polystyrene, why would anybody buy polystyrene from us when the polystyrene can be imported also, but whereas we command a premium over the imported price. It is customer service, it is helping the customer in using the material."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Volume growth | 8% to 10% growth in volumes | FY25 |
| Mass ABS Phase 1 commercial start | On stream commercially | Q4 FY25 |
| Mass ABS Phase 1 mechanical completion | Project complete mechanically | December 2024 |
| Mass ABS Phase 1 first-year utilization | Over 50% utilization | FY26 |
| EPS Phase 2 implementation | Fully implemented | FY25 |
| Masterbatch/compounds capacity benefit | Benefit accrues | FY26 |
| New EPS and compounds capacity absorption | Fully utilized | Within two years |
| Karnal greenfield project cost | ~₹850 crores, funded from cash and liquid assets | No completion date given |
| Peak revenue on current gross block | ₹6,500 crores at 100% utilization and current prices | No date; new capacities add on top |
| Export policy | Domestic market first; exports fill balance | Ongoing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Operating income | ₹1,563 cr, grew ~32% QoQ and ~13% YoY |
| Total EBITDA | ~₹194 cr, increased ~76% QoQ, decreased ~1.6% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | ~11.2% |
| Net profit after tax | ~₹132 cr, increased 93% QoQ, decreased 1.8% YoY |
| Operating income (full year FY24) | ₹5,253 cr, flattish YoY despite volume increase of 13.7% |
| Total EBITDA (full year FY24) | ₹535 cr |
| Net profit after tax (full year FY24) | ₹347 cr |
| Sales volume of manufactured products | Increased 17.6% YoY |
| Domestic volumes | Increased 15.5% YoY |
| Export volumes | Surged 44% YoY |
| Capacity utilization across all products | 75%, including expanded capacity |
| Volume growth guidance for FY25 | 8% to 10% |
| Investable surplus | ₹1,080 cr at end of March 2024 |
| Final dividend recommended | ₹7 per equity share for FY24, total dividend for the year ₹9 per share, total outflow ₹169 cr |
| Mass ABS Phase 1 CAPEX | ~₹850 cr |
| Mass ABS peak top line at full capacity utilization | ~₹2,200 cr on current market prices, asset turnover of almost 1 to 2.75 |
| Current gross block peak revenue | ~₹5,500 cr at current market prices, ₹6,500 cr at 100% utilization |
| India ABS demand | Over 300,000 tonnes, projected closer to 340,000–350,000 tonnes minimum by end of FY26 |
| India ABS domestic production | ~140,000–150,000 tonnes, balance imported |
| Total company volume (full year FY24) | 3,25,250 |
| Trading revenue share | ~23% to 24% of overall revenue |
| Karnal project estimated cost | ~₹850 cr |
| Employee cost increase | ~16% to 17% compared to last year |
| Polystyrene capacity | 300,000 tonnes |
| EPS capacity | 110,000 tonnes |
| SPC capacity | 35,000 tonnes installed, effective ~25,000 tonnes |
| XPS capacity | 72,000 meter cube |
| ABS first-year utilization expectation | ~+50% |