Key Takeaways
- Earnings hit by election-led tender freeze: Revenue fell to ₹200 crore from ₹254 crore YoY as state and general elections delayed water-sector tenders, but JV earnings lifted PAT to ₹14 crore vs ₹0.5 crore.
- Balance sheet transformed by ₹346 crore raise: Net worth reached ₹622 crore, fixed deposits stand at ₹280 crore, and the full ₹460 crore war chest is earmarked entirely for business, not debt repayment.
- A ₹1,800 crore order book provides near-term visibility: All orders are pre-resolution legacy work with a two-year execution runway, while ₹1,400 crore of L1 positions in Rajasthan await conversion.
- Management is betting on a Q4 inflection: Q3 is guided flat, but tender openings worth ~₹5,000 crore over the next 1-3 months and expected L1 conversion this quarter underpin a Q4 pickup.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the Rajasthan L1 positions convert to LOI before the financial year closes, the pace of new order wins from the ₹5,000 crore pipeline, and any ICRA rating outcome that unlocks bank BG limits.
The Election-Led Revenue Gap
- Monsoon plus polls, a double hit: Revenue de-grew 21% YoY to ₹200 crore as the monsoon season and the model code of conduct across multiple states froze tender openings and slowed operations. H1 revenue fell 31% to ₹422 crore.
- Rajasthan L1 stuck in limbo: SPML holds L1 positions on two Rajasthan tenders worth ~₹1,400-1,500 crore, but financial bids remain unopened due to elections and a subsequent by-election with its own code of conduct. Management expects conversion this quarter.
- Peer comparison, deflected: When asked why peers won 1-3 orders despite the same election slowdown, management pointed to geography: peers had tenders open in states without elections like UP, while SPML's L1 was concentrated in election-bound Rajasthan.
- Q3 guided flat, Q4 the pivot: Q3 revenue will be "more or less in similar line" to Q2; Q4 should be better as new orders, JV orders, and JV commission begin contributing.
Digga: "Well, as I told you last time also, out of around Rs.1,500 crore, we are in L1, for two orders in Rajasthan. We are still L1 on this tender. In Rajasthan, there was an election issue, so the tender was not opened. Now there is a sub-election, there is Achar Sanhita, so again they are not opening the tender."
Fundraise & Balance Sheet Reset
- ₹346 crore raised, promoter backs it heavily: The preferential allotment closed on 24th October, with the promoter contributing ₹190 crore on top of ₹160 crore infused over the prior three years. Fixed deposits stand at ₹280 crore, with another ₹180 crore expected from warrants and Vivad se Vishwas settlements.
- All new money goes to business, zero to lenders: The full ₹460 crore (₹280 crore FD + ₹180 crore future inflows) is ring-fenced for business use. Debt repayment is tied exclusively to arbitration award receipts, of which 75% flows to lenders.
- Finance cost is almost entirely non-cash: The ₹8.98 crore reported finance cost is ~₹8.5 crore of IndAS adjustment; actual cash outgo is only ₹30-40 lakh per quarter in bank guarantee commission.
- ICRA rating process initiated: The company has appointed ICRA for a rating; once obtained, it will approach banks for BG limits, which would expand bidding capacity beyond the current ~₹4,000 crore supported by the FD alone.
Order Book & Pipeline
- ₹1,800 crore order book, all legacy: The current book (₹800 crore standalone plus JV share) consists entirely of pre-resolution orders with a two-year execution runway. New orders will be called only when received going forward.
- ₹5,000 crore of bids opening in 1-3 months: A tender pipeline of ~₹5,000 crore is set to start opening, and SPML is L1 on two Rajasthan tenders within it. Management expects to win ₹1,500-2,000 crore of orders annually.
- JV share averages 30%: In joint ventures, SPML's recognized top-line share averages ~30%, varying by JV structure.
- Conversion rate undisclosed: Management declined to provide a win rate or conversion percentage from the ₹5,000 crore pipeline, citing the unpredictability of competitive bidding.
Digga: "We are not in the mood to build up a huge order book. We would like to remain as a boutique. We will select orders which has a higher profitability, which is fully funded, which is in a good state, which are easy to execute."
Competitive Positioning & Bidding Strategy
- 43 years of water-sector pre-qualification: SPML pre-qualifies for 80-90% of water tenders, a moat management argues new entrants from roads or other EPC sectors cannot easily replicate. Those entrants must use the JV route to access water PQ.
- Boutique, selective, fully funded only: The company bids only for projects with completed DPRs, escrow comfort, pipe supplier backing, and full funding. It is not chasing order book size.
- Bidding capacity at ~₹4,000 crore: With the current ₹280 crore FD and a 5-7% BG requirement, SPML can bid for roughly ₹4,000 crore of projects. Warrants can be drawn anytime if more capacity is needed.
- JV route puzzle, unanswered: An analyst noted that most of the ₹5,000 crore bid was via JV despite management's claim of strong independent PQ. Management answered with a theoretical explanation of qualification percentages but did not directly address why the JV route was chosen.
Digga: "Since we are into the water sector from the beginning, our pre-qualification in the water sectors are enormous. We are pre-qualifying for atleast around 80-90% of the tenders. Company which is in the road sector and wants to start working the water sector, will not get any PQ in the water sector and they will not get the business."
Arbitration Awards & Lender Repayment
- ₹268 crore recovered via Vivad se Vishwas: A ₹25.06 crore settlement with Power Grid Corporation was reached in Q2 under the Vivad se Vishwas II scheme, taking total arbitration recoveries to ₹268 crore. Another ₹26 crore is expected this financial year.
- Arbitration does not touch EBITDA: Awards are received from debtors and flow through the balance sheet; any excess over debtor recovery goes to the profit and loss account, not through operating profit.
- 75% to lenders, a structured clean-up: All arbitration receipts are split 75:25 between lenders and the company. A ₹180 crore award from the Supreme Court of Arunachal Pradesh is expected in the current financial year.
Margin & Profitability Outlook
- Current margins at target, but on depressed revenue: EBITDA margin of 13% and PAT margin of 7% in Q2 are at par with targeted levels, though the absolute EBITDA of ₹26 crore reflects the low revenue base.
- New orders targeted at 10-12% margin: Management expects margins to inch up as higher-margin new orders begin contributing, with FY'26 EBITDA margin "should be" above 8% per an analyst's math.
- PAT guidance declined: When asked if FY'25 PAT could reach ₹60+ crore (requiring ₹40+ crore in H2), management said it is "difficult to say what amount will come into the full year at this moment."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Rajasthan L1 conversion | ~₹1,400-1,500 crore L1 positions converted to LOI | This quarter (Q3 FY25); by financial year-end at latest |
| Arbitration receipt | ₹26 crore balance from Vivad se Vishwas | Within current financial year |
| Arbitration receipt | ₹180 crore award from Supreme Court of Arunachal Pradesh | Current financial year |
| Warrant proceeds | Balance ₹180 crore from warrants and Vivad se Vishwas | Within 18 months |
| Order inflow | New order wins begin | By December or early January |
| Q4 revenue | Higher than Q2/Q3 run-rate | Q4 FY25 |
| Annual order win rate | ₹1,500-2,000 crore per year | Going forward |
| FY25 closing order book | At least ₹1,500-2,000 crore (old + new) | Next 6 months |
| FY26 EBITDA margin | 8%+ (per analyst's math, management said "it should be") | FY26 |
| ICRA rating and BG limit | Rating process underway; clarity on BG limit | Next conference call |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY25 |
|---|---|
| Standalone revenue | ₹200 cr, vs ₹254 cr in Q2 FY24 |
| H1 FY25 revenue | ₹422 cr, de-growth of 31% vs ₹608 cr in H1 FY24 |
| EBITDA | ₹26 cr, vs ₹3 cr in Q1 FY25 |
| EBITDA margin | 13%, at par with targeted margins |
| PAT | ₹14 cr, vs ₹0.5 cr in Q2 FY24 |
| PAT margin | 7% |
| H1 FY25 EBITDA | ₹53 cr, vs ₹6.5 cr in H1 FY24 |
| H1 FY25 PAT | ₹27 cr, vs ₹1.2 cr in H1 FY24 |
| Net worth | ₹602 cr as of September 30, 2024 |
| Net worth (with NARCL debt) | ₹622 cr, NARCL debt of ₹376 cr |
| Order book | ₹1,800 cr, including SPML Infra and JV; standalone ~₹900 cr |
| L1 position in bids | ₹1,400–1,500 cr, across two Rajasthan tenders |
| Total bids participated | ₹5,000 cr, against total available tenders of ₹11,000 cr |
| Cash and fixed deposits | ₹280 cr as on date of call; expected to reach ₹460 cr with further warrant and Vivad se Vishwas inflows |
| Funds raised via preferential allotment | ₹346 cr total, ₹290 cr in cash and balance via NARCL loan conversion; ₹170 cr already issued |
| Arbitration award received in Q2 | ₹25.06 cr, settled with Power Grid Corporation under Vivad se Vishwas II scheme |
| Total arbitration received under Vivad se Vishwas | ₹268 cr, with ₹26 cr balance expected within FY25 |
| Total arbitration awards | ₹620 cr, against which ~₹430 cr payable to banks |
| Finance cost | ₹8.98 cr in Q2, of which ~₹8.5 cr is IndAS adjustment and ~₹30–40 lakh is actual BG commission |
| Target new order EBITDA margin | 10–12% |
| Expected order book by March 31, 2025 | ₹2,000–2,100 cr (old and new combined) |
| Revenue expectation for FY25 | ₹1,000–1,200 cr (per an analyst's math) |