Key Takeaways
- Foods recovery, Staples drag: Foods revenue grew ~10% YoY to INR103 crores, rebounding from a Q4 decline, but Premium Oils deflation pulled overall growth to roughly 1%.
- Gross contribution back to 46%: Foods gross contribution returned to its historical level, and the declining commodity price trend lifted oils to 36-37%, offsetting the mix shift toward lower-margin staples.
- Innovation-led volume push underway: The quarter saw launches of honey-roasted peanut butter, an INR10 blister pack, and maiden media investments in Breakfast Cereals and Duo chocolates, all aimed at accelerating distribution and trial.
- Chocolates capacity build-out is the big bet: Capex is concentrated on expanding Jhagadia chocolate capacity to support a INR100 crore-plus business, a cornerstone of the plan to double total revenue to INR1,000 crores.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the twin peanut butter actions (sweet variant and INR10 pack) lift growth as promised, the initial consumer response to first-time cereal and chocolate advertising, and any concrete chocolate strategy update in October.
Topline & Profitability Mechanics
- Foods rebound: Foods revenue grew about 10% versus the prior year, recovering from a 3% drop in Q4 FY23 that was driven by Omicron disruption in January and February 2022. The recovery was helped by a return to growth and some improvement in Ready to Cook, though spreads performance was a drag.
- Staples value decline: Premium Staples value fell 13% as lower edible oil prices passed through to realization, while Mass Staples volume was dialed up 49%. Total Staples declined 8%, nearly offsetting the Foods gain.
- Gross contribution recovery: Foods gross contribution returned to the 46% historical level. The declining commodity price trend elevated oils gross contribution to about 36-37%, and the overall impact of lower edible oil prices was largely offset by growth in foods, adjacencies in Premium Staples, and higher shipments of Mass Oils.
- Profit bridge: Profit before tax rose by about INR6 crores, reflecting roughly INR10 crores in gross margin improvement, less INR2 crores higher A&P and INR3.5 crores higher SG&A, plus a one-time INR1.1 crore business interruption claim from the Ola factory fire.
- SG&A pressure: SG&A was higher by about INR3.5 crores, partly due to a reversal of management incentives in the prior-year Q1 and partly due to higher secondary freight and travel expenses. Travel costs are now starting to find their right level.
- Manufacturing leverage opportunity: The biggest cost opportunity is improving low capacity utilization across relatively new categories. Chocolates, built from scratch and only 1-2 years old, is in early learning phases, while Ready to Cook popcorn, at 15-plus years, is the most efficient. Scale benefits will be much larger in manufacturing than in freight.
Sachin Gopal: "whereas in Center Filled Cereals, the runway for renovation is endless because you have a shell and you have a liquid chocolate inside that you can take and do anything with it... there's not limit to what you can do. So, I think this is beautiful. It's absolutely beautiful position for us to be in."
Category Momentum
| Category | Trend | Commentary |
|---|---|---|
| Ready to Eat Snacks | ▲ Strong volume growth | Driven by RTE popcorn benefiting from media support behind Ready to Cook; sweet share rose to 8% from 3% prior year. Greater scale is significantly enhancing profitability. |
| Breakfast Cereals | ▲ Solid growth | Powered by Popz Center Filled Cereals; pricing taken via grammage reduction without momentum loss. Maiden TV advertising started in June. |
| Chocolates | ▲ Volume up ~38% | Duo steadily gaining distribution and acquiring consumers; supply chain rhythm now established after Ukraine war and gas disruptions. |
| Ready to Cook | ▬ Recovering | Last year's decline from competing with high COVID bases is now largely behind; base effects becoming less significant. |
| Peanut Butter | ▼ Soft start | Addressed through launch of honey-roasted sweet variant at INR99 and INR10 blister pack; full impact expected in Q3 and Q4. |
| Premium Oils | ▼ Value decline | Lower price realization from commodity deflation; offset by entry into oats and mass oils adjacencies. |
Innovation & Portfolio Expansion
- Sweet peanut butter launch: Honey-roasted peanut butter launched at INR99 for 300g, with advertising support shifted onto this variant from July. The INR10 blister pack (30g) was also launched, described as the first blister pack for peanut butter outside the USA.
- INR10 blister pack moat: The INR10 SKU is positioned as impossible for competitors using third-party manufacturing without losing money, creating a structural cost advantage.
- Breakfast Cereals media debut: First-time spending on Breakfast Cereals, with television advertising for Popz Center Filled Cereals starting in June and running through July. A reworked shelf product at the INR10 price point has begun rolling out nationally.
- Chocolates capacity expansion: Expanding chocolate capacity at the Jhagadia factory to support a business of INR100 crore-plus; on track for completion during the year. The chocolate business is expected to play a very big part in the plan to reach INR1,000 crores total revenue.
- Cocoa and Plant Meats pipeline: Initiating launch of cocoa-based offerings and plant meats in FY24; equipment has been brought in for plant-based products.
- Almond expansion: Started in the last two weeks of the quarter, leveraging the fact that Sundrop already buys almonds for chocolate-based products and Granola, giving better pricing and P&L benefit for the foods business.
- Oats price ladder: Building a comprehensive presence across price points including low-unit packs at INR10, leveraging popcorn facilities. Entry price of about INR7.50 (two for INR15) is unmatched by competitors.
Sachin Gopal: "they are impossible, I think, for anybody to do using a third party, unless we lose money. And that's -- and that's tough. So, we see as a great benefit."
Distribution & Competitive Moat
- 0.05 crore store reach: The distribution network spanning 0.05 crore stores is described as the core moat, built through a delicate balance of portfolio, price points, people, distributors, and daily retail execution. Management calls it near impossible to replicate.
- ATFL walls build-out: The company has started building ATFL-branded walls in stores, similar to Kellogg's in-store walls, to increase visibility and facings.
- Chocolate spreads facing advantage: Sundrop claims a giant share of facings in chocolate spreads, which management argues will translate into a giant share of transactions, consumers, and ultimately market share over time.
- INR5 SKU portfolio: Four SKUs now exist at the INR5 price point: two in chocolates (Duo peanuts, Duo coconut), one in Ready to Eat Snacks, and one in Breakfast Cereals (shelf product).
- Competitive spending landscape: In snacks, FritoLay and ITC increased spending while Sundrop remained steady behind ACT II. In edible oils, mass oil players continue to dominate spending while Premium Oil share of spending continues to decline.
Sachin Gopal: "It's very difficult to accomplish. Because it requires a great delicate balance of having the right portfolio, having the right price point, having the right people in the organization, getting on those, the distributors, making sure the retailing happens, managing large productivity of large numbers of people who are out on the street every day, it's a very, very -- it's a very time intensive and it's a very painstaking process."
Category Pathways to Scale
- INR200 crore per category ambition: Each category is expected to reach INR200 crore in sales, which management identifies as the main driver of future margin improvement. Spreads and chocolates will both get there, with chocolates growing much faster than Spreads.
- Spreads growth trajectory: Spreads is expected to grow at roughly 10% (11-14% in a good year) over the coming years toward the INR200 crore target, though no specific year was committed.
- Chocolate spreads vs Nutella: Management stated the ambition to be larger than Nutella in the future, anchored on the giant share of facings already achieved.
- Sweet Snacks target: On track toward about 15% share for Sweet Snacks in the current year, with further innovation work underway for the balance of the next three quarters.
- Cereals portfolio near completion: The only missing segment is Muesli, which is ready but awaiting prioritization in the go-to-market sequence.
- Protein segment: Gym detailing and selling is underway as a long-haul, steady process to cover the protein segment.
Sachin Gopal: "We won't be as large as Nutella today, but we will be larger than Nutella tomorrow, tomorrow means in the future. And the reason is, if we have the giant share of facings, it means that we are getting the giant share of transactions. And if you're getting the giant share of transactions, we're getting the giant share of consumers. And if we're getting giant share of consumers, we'll have giant share of share."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Peanut butter growth acceleration | Twin actions (sweet variant and INR10 pack) to lift growth; Q2 will see positive impact | Full impact in Q3 and Q4 FY24 |
| Chocolate capacity expansion | Expand Jhagadia factory capacity to support INR100 crore-plus business | During FY24 |
| Sweet Snacks share | Reach about 15% share of RTE | Current year (FY24) |
| Cocoa-based offerings and Plant Meats | Initiate launch | FY24 |
| Chocolate strategy update | Will discuss strategy given high competitor spending | Q2 call in October |
| Gross contribution | Foods to remain healthy in the region of 46% | Ongoing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Foods revenue | ₹103 cr, up 10% YoY |
| Total company gross contribution | 38%, foods at historical level of 46% |
| Gross margin | 23%, improved by 500 bps YoY; added ₹10 cr of gross margin |
| A&P investments | ₹2 cr incremental spend vs prior year |
| SG&A | ₹3.5 cr higher than prior year |
| Profit before tax | Up ~₹6 cr vs prior year |
| Profit after tax | Up ~₹5 cr vs prior year |
| Business interruption claim (Ola factory fire) | ₹1.1 cr one-time benefit |
| Foods volume growth | 10% in Q1 FY24, up from 3% in Q3 FY23 |
| Total company net revenue growth | ~1% (foods ~50-55% of business grew ~10%, staples ~45-50% declined ~8%) |
| Premium Staples value growth | -13% YoY |
| Mass Staples volume growth | +38% YoY |
| Total Staples volume growth | +9% YoY |
| Total Staples value decline | ~8% YoY |
| Chocolates volume growth | 38% YoY |
| Sweet Snacks share of RTE | 8% in Q1 FY24, up from 3% in Q1 FY23 |
| Peanut butter large pack share with largest customers | More than 80% |
| Chocolate spreads value share | More than 10% of category; transaction share north of 20-25% |
| Breakfast Cereals distribution | ~100,000 stores |
| Total store coverage | A little under 500,000 stores |
| INR5 SKUs in portfolio | 4 SKUs: 2 chocolates, 1 RTE snacks, 1 Breakfast Cereals |