Key Takeaways
- Tough quarter, prolonged headwinds: Non-automotive demand took a severe hit from US housing and interest rates, while the UAW strike and weak two-wheeler segment added pressure; management sees the non-automotive softness lasting at least two more quarters.
- Controls division margin erosion is structural, not just cyclical: SCD margins fell sharply on non-automotive deceleration, but the restructuring playbook that returned PLD to double-digit EBITDA is now being applied, with India cost-base migration as the core lever.
- Electronics division turned EBITDA positive in its first year: The division clocked strong growth, started EV actuator deliveries, and management is now focused on execution over further order-book build.
- Export cable orders won but launches postponed: New order wins are strong, yet existing volumes fell as large customers pushed launch dates out by three months to a year, a pattern management calls postponed, not lost.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether Q3 domestic strength offsets UAW strike impact on Wescon, any sign of non-automotive bottoming, and the pace of SCD restructuring cost taper into year-end.
Demand Environment
- US non-automotive: severe and prolonged hit: Housing market weakness, high inflation and high interest rates crushed discretionary spending on lawn mowers and power sport vehicles. Severe summer conditions did not help. Management expects this to be prolonged, with customer feedback pointing to no change this year or next quarter.
- UAW strike scar on automotive: The strike is behind the company but left a scar; October was badly affected and Q3 will carry the impact after losing 7-8 weeks. Wescon is also historically weak in Q3, making Q2 and Q3 tough quarters.
- Two-wheeler segment still struggling: Entry-level and commuter segments remain weak, possibly from monsoon failure. October was not great, but November shows some potential with OEMs picking up.
- Europe yet to recover: Post-Ukraine war stability has not helped demand settle, though new business continues to be won in the region.
- China non-automotive hit by Russia sanctions: One specific non-automotive customer was hit by restrictions on sales to Russia, impacting Suprajit alongside the ongoing Shanghai Lone Star relocation.
- Export cable postponements, not cancellations: Order wins from SEL have been strong, but existing volumes fell as big customers reduced offtakes and pushed new launch dates by three months, six months, some by almost a year due to global uncertainties.
Rai: "It is not lost business, but I think it's a postponed decision as I see it."
Suprajit Controls Division: Restructuring & Margin Recovery
- Margin erosion driven by non-automotive deceleration: The major part of SCD margin erosion came from non-automotive weakness, significantly at Wescon and also at LDC, which had nearly 30% non-automotive business.
- Single-division operating model now in place: The company is shedding the legacy SENA, LDC, SAL, SEU entity colors and working as one division. Synergies include moving the PMI warehouse into LDC's Brownsville facility, shifting Wescon plastic parts to underutilized LDC molding capacity, and relocating stressed Hungary parts to India.
- India cost-base migration is the margin lever: Hungary business was moved to India because employee and operational costs were much higher and margins were low. Customer approval takes a long time and customers demand a share of the savings. US-based engineers are becoming front-end for customer interactions while backend engineering and design work moves to Indian teams at FTC or SEL engineering.
- Matamoros plant deeply underutilized: The plant is doing 0.4 crore per month against 0.8-1 crore capacity. As volumes grow, fixed overhead amortization alone will lift margins.
- Restructuring costs taper by year-end: Ongoing restructuring costs will run till the end of this fiscal year, then taper off.
- SCD margin trajectory follows the PLD playbook: Management explicitly draws the parallel: PLD was at low single-digit EBITDA with doubters questioning recovery, then returned to double digits through restructuring and its "last man standing" position. SCD is expected to follow the same path, with margin improvement coming as volumes grow and restructuring completes, whether in a year, three quarters, or five quarters.
- Two growth drivers for SCD's next phase: US-based cable businesses coming to India, and actuator businesses where Suprajit can be among the first few actuator knowledge and capability companies operating out of India. Management expects good updates on these lines in the next couple of quarters.
Rai: "It's the same thing... those who are good manufacturer, value for money product, capable suppliers who had the reasonable balance sheet to fight this kind of a battle in this what I would call as a dog-eat-dog market. I think they come out well."
Phoenix Lamps Division: The Proof Case
- Double-digit EBITDA achieved in a shrinking market: PLD returned to double-digit margins through a restructuring plan that is not yet complete, with the tail end continuing till March. The division grew business despite continued LED penetration, driven by team performance and the company's global "last man standing" position.
- Margins expected to sustain: Management expects PLD margins to continue at double-digit levels consistently going forward, with the business stable and likely growing because of global requirements.
- LED retrofit range expanding: After testing the two-wheeler bulb market and learning about pricing elasticity, the company launched new retrofits for passenger car vehicles about a month before the call. The plan is to cover two-wheeler, three-wheeler, passenger car, and finally CV segments for a complete Phoenix aftermarket range.
Rai: "When we are in a low single digit EBITDA, everybody questioned our ability to grow the business or our ability to go to double digit. And I think that is the wonderful team work that we have been able to do by our Phoenix Lamps Division and it is now not only growing in a shrinking market, but also the margin improvement."
Electronics & New Business Lines
- Electronics division turned EBITDA positive in year one: The division clocked very good growth, with the team working 24/7 to manage it. It turned EBITDA positive in Q2 despite high fixed costs, with just one year of operations.
- EV actuator deliveries started: The division began deliveries of actuators for two large EV two-wheeler customers. It also won actuator business for seating actuators, steering lock actuators, and charging gun actuators for two-wheelers, despite having no past actuator experience in India, leveraging LDC's actuator experience.
- Passenger vehicle actuator pipeline building: The company is now working with a few passenger vehicle customers for seating actuators for new models, similar to LDC's business.
- Instrument cluster strategy is EV-first: The long-term vision is to be in pole position in the EV segment, working with multiple nascent OEMs and targeting a predominant market share. In ICE, acceptance will take more time but the company expects a reasonable, not predominant, market share. Current business includes one running TFT cluster program and a couple in pipeline, plus LCD and semi-digital clusters for two-wheelers.
- Focus now on execution, not order-book build: Management's complete focus is on execution rather than building the order book further, with great growth expected this year.
- Braking products capacity being built: A plant freed up from aftermarket restructuring is being converted into space for braking products. The company is also looking for additional infrastructural facilities for projects in late-stage negotiation with customers for commercial offer orders.
Domestic Cables & Two-Wheeler Business
- Domestic cables: three growth drivers beyond the core: The division will follow two-wheeler market growth with some market share gains, expand into cables beyond two-wheelers (passenger cars, CVs), and move beyond cables into mechanisms for two-wheelers.
- H2 expected slightly better than H1: October sales were ahead of industry growth and November sales are picking up. Q3 domestic business has been strong so far, leading to optimism for a good second half.
- Multiple infrastructural assets being pursued: The company is actively pursuing facilities to house beyond-cable projects.
- DCD and PLD expected to continue performing well: Both divisions are flagged as steady performers within the portfolio.
Managing Uncertainty
- Risk committee and unified systems as the response: The company uses risk analysis with a risk committee, assesses risk priority numbers, and prepares action plans. The shift to a single ERP and PLM system across the group, with licenses finalized with SAP and PTC in the previous quarter, will make responses faster and enable better monitoring.
- Management declined to quantify restructuring costs: When asked for one-off expenses in H1 and expected H2 costs for China plant relocation and restructuring, management said they do not have the number and directed the analyst to the CFO offline. On potential impairment of restructured plants, management said it is difficult to say until restructuring is complete, possibly by end-March.
- Subsidiary support: a deflection: When asked about the need for infusion or lending support to subsidiaries, management answered "not really" but then added "if they need a few million here and there, we'll always support."
Mohan: "One thing about running a business is uncertainty. And I would say that at the end of the day, there is an area of concern and there is an area of influence."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Non-automotive demand revival | At least two quarters before any change, based on customer feedback; postponement typically a year in this business | At least Q4 FY24 or later |
| SCD restructuring costs | Ongoing costs will run till end of this fiscal year, then taper off | FY24 year-end |
| PLD margins | Double-digit EBITDA to continue consistently going forward | Ongoing from Q2 FY24 |
| CAPEX FY24 | Budget of about ₹140 crores; well within that ballpark | FY24 |
| Trifa liquidation | Expected to be concluded | By Q4 FY24 |
| LED retrofit full range | Cover two-wheeler, three-wheeler, passenger car (started), then CV segment in aftermarket | Phased; passenger car launched |
| SCD margin improvement | Margin profile has to improve and will improve as volumes grow and restructuring completes | Whether in a year, three quarters, or five quarters |
| Electronics division growth | Great growth expected this year; complete focus on execution | FY24 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue (H1 FY24) | ₹1,389 cr, growth of 2% vs ₹1,361 cr in H1 FY23 |
| Consolidated operational EBITDA (H1 FY24) | ₹144 cr, growth of 6% vs ₹136 cr in H1 FY23 |
| Standalone revenue (H1 FY24) | ₹719 cr vs ₹723 cr in H1 FY23 |
| Standalone operational EBITDA (H1 FY24) | ₹125 cr, growth of 6% vs ₹118 cr in H1 FY23 |
| Total debt | ₹629 cr as on 30th September 2023 |
| Cash surplus balance | ₹517 cr as on 30th September 2023, invested in mutual funds and bonds |
| Suprajit Controls Division EBITDA margin | ~3% |
| Subsidiary-level losses (ex-standalone, last two quarters) | ₹17–20 cr per quarter |
| Phoenix Lamps Division EBITDA margin | Double-digit, sustained over last three to four quarters on average |
| Electronics Division sales growth | ~150% Q2 over Q1 |
| Electronics Division EBITDA | Turned positive in Q2, with just one year of operations |
| Electronics Division order book | ₹150 cr annualized value at full production, disclosed last quarter |
| CAPEX budget FY24 | ~₹140 cr, part of which spills into FY25 |
| Matamoros plant utilization | ₹0.4 cr/month current output vs capacity of ₹0.8–1.0 cr/month |