Key Takeaways
- A quarter of accounting noise, not operating decline: Revenue grew +6.1% YoY to ₹70.9 crore, but the EBITDA margin drop to 59.3% is almost entirely a GST-driven electricity reimbursement reclassification, not a business deterioration.
- Vodafone Idea is now the entire growth story: The order book is 700+ tenancies in ET and rising daily, with 150 already converted in June at a pace management calls one of the fastest IP companies in the industry.
- BSNL remains a deliberate holdout: Management has stopped rollout until billing is confirmed, despite BSNL's public ₹77,000 crore, 2-lakh-site plan, because past payment issues burned them.
- Zinc battery launch is the near-term differentiator: First batch for 10–15 sites lands mid-September, and management frames it as the biggest CapEx-saving item this quarter, with no competitor even in trials.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the 700-tenancy VI backlog converts despite monsoon impact, whether BSNL billing for 186 pending sites actually starts, and whether lithium price inflation forces a CapEx rethink.
Vodafone Idea: The Sole Engine
- Order flow started mid-June: VI began loading orders around 15–16 June, and Suyog converted 95 sites / 150 tenancies in 13–15 days, a pace management claims makes them one of the fastest IP companies delivering to VI.
- The backlog is real and growing: As of the call, 700+ tenancies sit in ET excluding the 150 already completed, with ET increasing every day as Vodafone loads sites.
- Funding is the swing factor: VI has secured ₹6,400 crore from SBI out of a targeted ₹45,000 crore, and is in final stages with the SBI consortium for another ₹25,000–₹30,000 crore in phases. Management says the 3,000-tenancy target is "100% doable" if the next tranche lands.
- The 3,000-tenancy target is deliberately conservative: Management calls it a floor, not a ceiling, and says they can add 4,000–5,000 sites in the next three quarters from VI alone if funding clarity improves.
- Customer concentration is acknowledged, not hedged: When pressed on dependence, management's answer is that every company depends on its customers, and the MSA is a framework with fixed commercial charges, not a minimum revenue commitment.
Shah: "We are very confident. We have execution capacity. We have enough funds. So, 3,000 should not be a challenge for us."
BSNL: Optimism Without Confirmation
- The opportunity is enormous on paper: BSNL's CMD publicly declared a ₹77,000 crore CapEx plan for 2 lakh sites over five years, with government budget already allocated.
- But Suyog has stopped work deliberately: Existing BSNL orders are not being executed because of unresolved Tejas equipment issues that have delayed rollout for 1–1.5 years. Management will not restart until billing is confirmed at the CMD level.
- 186 sites are stuck in billing limbo: No additions this quarter, and revenue recognition for these sites is expected to start in Q2, though the Tejas resolution is still only "news" rather than confirmed.
- The trust deficit is explicit: Management is optimistic about BSNL as a company but refuses to quote numbers publicly until BSNL gives a confirmed rollout start date and billing start, because past declarations that missed due to operator issues damaged credibility.
Shah: "Once they confirm my billing started, we will start rollout for BSNL. So, obviously you can expect big numbers from BSNL but as of now, unless we get some confirmation from BSNL, we are not giving any projects as of BSNL right now."
Margins: Accounting Change Masks the Real Picture
- The EBITDA margin drop is a reclassification, not a cost blowout: From Q1 FY27, electricity reimbursement is added to the top line per GST department guidance, which mechanically lowers the EBITDA margin from ~70% to 59.3% without changing underlying profitability.
- IndAS adds a second layer of distortion: For 10-year rental agreements, the first five years carry a larger notional loss under IndAS, muting EBITDA margin now, with notional profit increasing in the back half of the contract.
- Real cost pressure exists: Total expenditure rose due to April-quarter salary increases and CapEx, and lithium battery prices jumped ~50% in 2.5 months (₹33,500 to ₹48,000 for Grade H) because China removed subsidies and the rupee weakened against the dollar.
- PAT margin normalization is real: The YoY decline from 25% to 20% is because last year's Q1 included a VI reversal of vendor's provision; normalized PAT margin is around 20–21% with EV, and management expects that to sustain.
- Management's margin commitment: ~59% EBITDA margin with EV for coming quarters, and 20% PAT margin for the year.
Sharma: "When you do a 10-year long term rental agreement then as per IndAS, for the first five years your notional loss is somewhat bigger... in the next five years your notional profit increases. So, due to that your EBITDA margin is slightly muted."
Zinc Battery: The CapEx Hedge
- First-mover claim: Suyog has tied up with GBB Batteries, whose promoter is the ex-battery head for Apple, and will be the first IP company to launch zinc battery on a site in September, with the first batch for 10–15 sites by mid-September.
- The economics matter because lithium is inflating: Zinc battery prices are the same as VRLA or old lithium prices, so the switch keeps CapEx within budget at a time when lithium costs are spiking.
- Management declined to quantify the benefit: When asked for revenue and EBITDA projections from the zinc project, management refused, citing listed-entity constraints on financial guidance, and instead pointed to the 3,000-site VI plan for analysts to model themselves.
Shah: "As of now no one has even started trials, while we are in phase of launching zinc battery on sites. So, this will be one of the biggest CapEx saving item for us in current quarter and it's one of the biggest take for current quarter."
Portfolio Mix & Revenue Quality
- Macro sites dominate the quarter: Most tenancies added were macro sites, with a 1.8x tenancy ratio on the 95 towers converted, driven by operator preference for macro rollout over HPIC/small cell sets which carry only 1–1.1x tenancy.
- Revenue per tower is stable: Maintained above ₹31,000 even in a stagnant quarter, constant at ₹31,000–₹31,500 for the last four quarters excluding EV, and ~₹50,000 with EV.
- Fibre remains marginal: Only 5–8% of revenue, because more sites are coming in rural villages on microwave rather than fibre, and Vodafone lacks the on-ground fibre network of Jio or Airtel. No major jump expected in FY27.
- Tenancy expansion is the margin lever: Management targets 1.8x tenancy by end of FY28 or early FY29, and notes that payback drops from 3.5–4 years for single tenancy to 24 months for double and 18 months for triple.
- The MSA is not a revenue guarantee: Management confirmed the 15-year Vodafone MSA is a framework with fixed commercial charges, not a minimum revenue commitment, so volume depends entirely on VI's rollout execution.
Funding & Balance Sheet
- No immediate fundraise: Management has enough internal accruals for the 3,000-tenancy rollout and is repaying bank funds monthly. No major fundraising is planned right now.
- Triggers exist but are vague: A fundraise may happen if a bulk BSNL order comes, if VI adds two more states (Bihar, MP), or if a "huge number" materializes, but no decision has been taken and management will return to investors "whenever right time comes."
- The revenue ambition is explicit: Targeting ₹100 crore quarterly revenue from Q4, ₹400 crore annual top line, and bottom line growth from ~22% to 24%.
- FY28 visibility extends the story: Management eyes another 5,000 sites from Vodafone in FY28, totaling 8,000–10,000 tenancies over two financial years, but refuses to give numbers beyond FY28 because the telecom industry is too dynamic.
Shah: "There is no point, saying some numbers after FY28 because telecom industry is very dynamic. It keeps changing their plans every now and then."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| VI tenancy additions | 3,000 tenancies from Vodafone Idea, "very confident" and "100% doable" if next SBI tranche lands | FY27 |
| VI site additions | 4,000–5,000 sites from VI, achievable | Next 3 quarters |
| VI FY28 additions | Another 5,000 sites from Vodafone, totaling 8,000–10,000 tenancies over two years | FY28 |
| Revenue target | ₹100 crore quarterly revenue, ₹400 crore annual top line | Q4 FY27 / FY27 |
| EBITDA margin | Maintain ~59% with EV | Coming quarters |
| PAT margin | Sustain 20% | FY27 |
| Tenancy exit | End FY27 with 10,000+ tenancies (7,000+ existing plus 3,000 additions) | FY27 exit |
| Tenancy ratio | 1.8x tenancy | End FY28 / early FY29 |
| BSNL billing | Start revenue for 186 pending sites | Q2 FY27 |
| Zinc battery launch | First batch for 10–15 sites | Mid-September |
| Fundraise decision | No decision taken; will return "whenever right time comes" | Undated |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY27 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | ₹70.9 cr, +6.1% YoY from ₹66.8 cr and up from ₹68.5 cr QoQ |
| EBITDA | ₹42 cr, vs ₹41.8 cr QoQ and ₹41.1 cr YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 59.3%, revised to include electricity in top line from 1 April; earlier basis was around 70% |
| EBIT margin | 74% |
| PBT | ₹19.5 cr |
| Net profit | ₹14.5 cr |
| Net profit margin | 20%, constant with electricity cost included; PAT has been 20% to 25% over last 4 years |
| EPS | ₹12.37 |
| Revenue per tower per month | Above ₹31,000, constant at ₹31,000 to ₹31,500 for last four quarters, excluding electricity |
| Towers | 6,103 at Q1 exit |
| Tenancies | 7,468 at Q1 exit |
| Tenancy ratio | 1.2x, targeting 1.8x in 3 to 4 years |
| Vodafone Idea tenancies added | 150 tenancies on 95 towers converted in June within 13 to 15 days of receiving orders |
| Vodafone Idea order book | 700+ tenancies in hand as of call date, plus 150 already completed, close to 850 total |
| FY27 tenancy addition target | 3,000 tenancies from Vodafone Idea, conservative basis |
| FY27 ending tenancy estimate | 10,000+ tenancies, from 7,000+ existing plus 3,000 additions |
| FY28 tenancy addition target | 5,000 sites from Vodafone Idea; 8,000 to 10,000 tenancies from VI over two financial years |
| Revenue share by operator | Airtel 48.1%, Vi 27%, Jio 22.6%, BSNL 2.3% |
| Vodafone Idea revenue contribution target | 30% to 32%, eyeing around 32% once 3,000 or more VI sites are done |
| BSNL pending billing sites | 186 sites, down from close to 1,000 sites 1 to 1.5 years ago |
| Fibre revenue share | 5% to 8% of total revenue, no major jump expected in FY27 |
| Lithium battery cost, 100H | ₹48,000, up from ₹33,500, roughly 50% increase in last 2.5 months |
| Zinc battery cost, 100H | ₹33,000, similar to old lithium pricing, first batch expected mid-September for 10 to 15 sites |
| Quarterly revenue target | ₹100 cr, expected from Q4 FY27 |