Key Takeaways
- First operational PAT in five years: Q2 FY23 delivered a positive PAT on a purely operational basis, the culmination of a 30-month transformation that also cut debt from INR 13,000 crores to INR 2,139 crores.
- Volume is the margin lever: WTG/EPC EBITDA margins sat at just 2–3% in H1 because volumes hovered near breakeven; management expects margins to rise as execution volumes increase, since fixed costs are already covered.
- Debt reset complete, further levers identified: Post rights issue, consolidated debt fell to INR 2,139 crores (debt-to-EBITDA a little over 2x), and two non-core assets (Pune campus, SE Forge) are earmarked for monetization to reduce it further.
- Market share ambition is explicit: Management committed to a 30%-plus market share target in each of the next three years, anchored to a wind and hybrid bid pipeline of 3,000–4,000 MW annually.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether H2 execution volumes lift WTG margins off the floor, the pace of the 3.x MW turbine commercialization, and any concrete timeline on non-core asset monetization.
The Turnaround: From Survival to Operational Profit
- PAT milestone: Q2 FY23 was the first quarter in five years where the company reported a positive PAT on a purely operational basis, driven by the transformation executed over the prior 30 months.
- Revenue rebuild: Consolidated revenue grew to more than 2.5x FY20 levels, reaching about INR 6,520 crores in FY22, with H1 FY23 trending 15–20% above H1 FY22.
- EBITDA swing: The company moved from negative INR 423 crores EBITDA in FY20 to positive INR 828 crores in FY22, with H1 FY23 trending along similar lines.
- Debt demolition: Debt was reduced from INR 13,000 crores to INR 2,700 crores in H1 FY23, and further to INR 2,139 crores post the rights issue completed after 30th September 2022, driving significant finance cost savings directly to shareholders.
- Debt serviceability: Current debt levels can be more than comfortably serviced through free cash flow; debt-to-EBITDA is a little over 2x based on annualized and FY22 EBITDA.
- Further debt optimization: Further P&L optimization through interest cost reduction may be minimal; any increase in working capital and finance costs from a growing order book would only be linked to increased volumes.
- Cost of borrowing headwind: Interest rates have increased since the May 2022 refinancing, and the company might face the brunt of that in the short to medium term.
Himanshu Mody: "I'm happy to report that after a period of five years, Q2 of this financial year FY '23 is the first quarter wherein the company has been able to report a positive PAT on a purely operational basis."
Margins: The Volume Equation
- WTG/EPC margin mechanics: EBITDA margins were low at 2–3% in H1 because commodity price variations hit OEMs worldwide and because volumes were close to breakeven, limiting EBITDA; as volumes increase, EBITDA margin is expected to rise since fixed costs are covered by breakeven volume.
- Breakeven volume undisclosed: When asked for the specific volume beyond which WTG margins reach higher single digits, management deflected, stating analysts could calculate it from past quarterly numbers.
- AMC margin resilience: EBITDA margin in the AMC business has been over 40% over the last many quarters and the last few years.
- AMC growth lag: The AMC business has been stagnant in megawatt terms because the parent company did not supply many turbines in prior years; last year’s 800+ MW supply and continued good performance this year will automatically add to AMC growth.
- Capacity utilization: While capacity capabilities remained over 3 GW, the company cut costs over the last few years to reduce the breakeven point to a much lower level; utilization will grow as the market grows.
- Turbine pricing stability: The cost of wind turbines has not gone up from INR 5–6 crores per MW because of efficiencies by OEMs (larger turbine size means only one tower instead of 1.5 MW); some commodity cycle increases in steel occurred but are starting to look better.
Order Book & Market Opportunity
- H2 execution confidence: The execution team is confident of delivering good results in the next two quarters; management expects healthy performance but did not put a specific number on it.
- Post-quarter order wins: Subsequent to 30th September, 193 MW of additional orders were announced to the stock exchange.
- Wind and hybrid bid pipeline: The bid opportunity is expected to be close to 3,000 to 4,000 MW every year.
- Captive, retail and PSU demand: This segment is expected to be a very large market going forward, driven by inter-state transmission access and RPO obligations including specific wind obligations.
- 140 GW trajectory: The government target will not happen in a bulk chunk immediately but will have steady growth over the next two years and beyond.
- Manufacturing capacity expansion: Current capacity of ~3,000 MW based on the 2.1 MW turbine will increase automatically as turbine megawatt size increases, because the nacelle unit production rate of 50–60 per month can go up with larger turbines.
- OMS competitive moat: Most of Suzlon's customers continue to remain with Suzlon due to technical expertise, size of operations, better machine availability and energy availability, and a comprehensive OMS offering; new individual operators are not even one-tenth of Suzlon's size.
- OMS for other manufacturers: Suzlon has already started operating turbines of other manufacturers at a very small scale and will look at opportunities as and when people want to shift operators.
Ashwani Kumar: "It will happen, I would say, not in a bulk chunk starting immediately, but it will have a steady growth over the next two..."
Product & Technology: The Next Turbine Cycle
- 3.x MW turbine commercialization: The next product (3 to 3.15 MW, 144-meter diameter, 160-meter height) is now being commercialized; the prototype will be installed in the next couple of months, and turbines will be up and running in the next calendar year.
- India-specific design advantage: Suzlon’s turbines are designed for Indian wind conditions, unlike some competitors who make turbines for the entire world and therefore different wind regimes.
- Market shift to hybrid: Management noted that the government has realized the future is hybrid, round-the-clock and peak power.
- Repowering opportunity: The government came out with a draft repowering policy last month and asked for views; once established, each state will start selecting sites, creating a good opportunity for Suzlon as the largest player with an inherent sense of the 20–25 GW repowering potential.
- Offshore wind: Offshore in India is still at a very nascent stage; nothing will come up in the next six months to one year, though the government has given a specific offshore target as part of the 140 GW by 2030 goal. Suzlon will use its design and technological expertise from previous history contributing to offshore turbine installation outside India as and when the market opens up.
Ashwani Kumar: "unlike some of our competition, who make turbine for the entire world and therefore, different wind regimes, our turbines are designed for Indian wind conditions."
Balance Sheet & Capital Allocation
- Rights issue completed: The rights issuance was completed post 30th September 2022, with close to INR 600 crores of debt reduced as of 4th November 2022.
- Working capital facilities: In-principle sanctions have been received from bankers for working capital facilities, and existing lenders have a project-specific funding policy permitting working capital support for manufacturing activity.
- Non-core asset monetization: Two assets have been identified: the corporate office in Pune (an 11-acre campus) and SE Forge. Management stated both assets combined will take care of a significant portion of current debt, but declined to give a valuation range, noting it would signal expectations to prospective bidders.
- Rights issue second call: It is difficult to commit a timeline; the Board can give shareholders 14 days' notice to call subsequent calls at any point, and management will discuss with the Board as the company gets close to FY24 and budgeting exercises.
- Guidance policy: Internal targets are pretty strong but the company has decided not to give guidance numbers; going forward, it will start sharing with analysts. When asked for production and sales targets for FY23, FY24 and FY25, management declined to provide them.
Ashwani Kumar: "It will take care of a significant portion of our debt current debt today, both these assets combined."
Stakeholder Engagement & Sentiment
- Investor relations reset: An active investor relations team has been put in place, and management commits to engage actively with investors and shareholders beyond quarterly calls, acknowledging a quiet period for Suzlon over the last few years.
- Management conviction: Leadership expressed strong confidence in the renewable energy opportunity in India and a commitment to utilize it for the benefit of all stakeholders and shareholders.
- Subsidiary question deflected: When asked about the Suzlon Gujarat Wind Power Park subsidiary leaking INR 300 crores and whether losses are expected to continue, management attributed it to intercompany transactions and said merger schemes will streamline the balance sheet, but did not directly answer whether losses will continue.
Himanshu Mody: "On part of the management, I can assure you that there has been a quiet period for Suzlon for the last few years. But now we will engage actively with all our investors and shareholders."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Market share | Achieve 30%-plus market share of whatever the country installs | Each of the next three years |
| 3.x MW turbine prototype | Prototype installed and turbines up and running | Prototype in next couple of months; turbines running in next calendar year |
| Non-core asset monetization | Monetize Pune campus and SE Forge to reduce debt | No specific timeline; management will watch for right timing |
| PAT trend | PAT positive trend expected to continue or further improve | From Q2 FY23 onward |
| WTG/EBITDA margin | Margin expected to grow as volumes increase beyond breakeven | Forthcoming quarters |
| AMC growth | Step up automatically as recent turbine supplies add to portfolio | Ongoing, linked to prior-year supplies |
| Capacity utilization | Achieve much better utilization given recent bid volumes | Going forward |
| Rights issue second call | Board to decide on subsequent call timing | As company gets close to FY24 and budgeting exercises |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ~15% to 20% growth in H1 FY23 over H1 FY22 |
| EBITDA | Positive, trending along similar lines to FY22 H1 |
| Net profit | Positive PAT on a purely operational basis, first quarter in five years |
| Consolidated debt | ₹2,139 cr as of 4th November 2022, post rights issue reduction of ~₹600 cr |
| Debt-to-EBITDA ratio | A little over 2x, based on annualized EBITDA and FY22 EBITDA |
| Cost of borrowing | ~10%, refinancing done in May 2022 |
| Order book | 759.2 MW as of 30th September 2022, plus 193 MW announced subsequently |
| Manufacturing volume | Higher in H1 FY23 than H1 FY22 |
| AMC business EBITDA margin | Over 40% over the last many quarters in the last few years |
| Turbines under active maintenance | ~12 GW, with average life of ~13 years and contract validity over five years for most |
| Installed wind energy capacity | ~19,500 MW cumulative, with 33% market share in India |
| Manufacturing capacity | Over 3,000 MW per year, current utilization around 800 MW per year |
| Captive retail PSU orders in order book | ~285 MW |
| New generation turbine PLF | 35% to 40% given the sites |
| Repowering opportunity size | 20 to 25 GW |