Key Takeaways
- Balance sheet transformed, earnings inflection still loading: Net worth reached INR3,409 crores and net debt fell to INR600 crores, but the WTG segment posted an EBIT loss of ~INR7 crores as depreciation absorbed the modest EBITDA. The full benefit of debt reduction on finance costs will only hit from Q3.
- Order book is deep and de-risked, but execution is the bottleneck: The 1.6 GW order book covers FY24 and FY25, with two-thirds from C&I customers. Management insists it can get orders for whatever capacity it has through FY27, yet H1 deliveries were just 267 MW against 500 MW of installations.
- EPC mix is rising by necessity, not choice: EPC share has climbed to 43-47% because competitors have retreated from EPC and customers with stranded turbines are returning to Suzlon. This pulls more working capital into the business, an acknowledged issue management is working to optimize.
- The 3 MW turbine ramp is the FY25 story: Commercial supplies have begun, with a gradual pick-up through Q3 and Q4 and a significant ramp-up next year. Realizations per MW are the same as the 2 MW series for now, and the product mix in FY25 is expected around two-thirds 2 MW.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the sharp decline in finance costs materializes as promised, the pace of 3 MW turbine dispatches, and any working capital efficiency gains as a percentage of sales.
Balance Sheet & Financial Position
- Net worth inflection: Net worth stood at INR3,409 crores, driven by a strong bottom line and the QIP completed in August. Post-QIP, residual debt is only INR120 crores in SE Forge.
- Debt reduction journey: Debt has been reduced from INR13,000 crores in March 2020 to net debt of INR600 crores, delivering a 61% reduction in finance costs. The full benefit of debt repayment will be visible from Q3 FY24 onward because the QIP concluded only around end-August.
- Finance cost trajectory: Finance cost for H1 was about INR90 crores, largely because debt sat on the balance sheet until late August. Q3 will see a sharp decline in interest cost.
- WTG segment profitability: The WTG segment reported an EBIT loss of ~INR7 crores, largely because most of the INR50 crores in depreciation sits in that segment. WTG EBITDA was ~INR30 crores this quarter versus ~INR35 crores in Q1, on similar volumes.
- Working capital burden: Working capital is an acknowledged issue in the business. Management is working to further optimize it and expects it to be more efficient as a percentage of sales, though not necessarily lighter in absolute terms at March 2024 given investments for March 2025 deliveries.
Order Book & Demand Visibility
- Order book composition and horizon: The current 1.6 GW order book is for execution in FY24 and FY25; nothing extends beyond that. Two-thirds is from C&I customers including retail, and one-third is bid capacity.
- Capacity-led confidence: Management stated that for at least the next two to three years, guaranteed for FY25 and FY26 and presumably for FY27, Suzlon can get orders for whatever its capacity is. Competition was dismissed as not an issue.
- Significant but undisclosed pipeline: A significant order pipeline is under negotiation, but management declined to quantify it, citing client confidentiality.
- Incremental order timing: Small orders of ~50 MW received in the next 1-2 months can still be executed in FY25. Large orders of 200-300 MW received in the next two months would likely span FY25 and FY26.
- Karnataka concentration and transmission risk: A couple of substations in Karnataka are delayed, expected by end of this year or early next year. This can cause repeat clients to request supply rescheduling, which Suzlon obliges, potentially impacting topline, though other sites can fill the gap by switching supply schedules.
Chalasani: "I don't see in the next, at least for the next two years to three years, guaranteed for two years, FY '25 and FY '26, and also presumably for FY '27, whatever is our capacity, we can go and get the orders. Competition is not an issue."
EPC Mix Shift & Industry Dynamics
- EPC share rising: EPC share has increased to 43-47% from earlier levels. This is driven by market demand, not a strategic target: other OEMs have exited EPC, competitors only supply components, and customers with bad experiences from other EPC providers are returning to Suzlon.
- Industry commissioning gap: The government is monitoring the rising number of turbines lying on the ground uncommissioned. Management stressed that what the country needs is turbines commissioned and connected to the grid, not dumped on the ground.
- Chinese competition: Chinese suppliers have a price advantage because many assemble in India rather than manufacture, with raw materials completely imported. They supply only components (just the nacelle, not the tower or blade) rather than full EPC. RLMM listing allows either manufacturing or assembly, and PSUs have no restriction on buying assembled equipment as long as it is RLMM-listed.
- OMS business linkage: Every WTG supply contract is signed only with an accompanying OMS contract, so the OMS business, which now manages 14.3 GW in India, will continue to grow in line with WTG sales.
- Multi-make OMS expansion: Suzlon operates Inox and Siemens Gamesa machines, having acquired about 150 MW this year in multi-make OMS including 80 MW of Siemens Gamesa machines from O2 Power. The capacity is small but management will continue to look at expansion opportunities.
Chalasani: "Supplies can happen. People can dump the turbines on the ground. But at the end of the day, as a country, what we need is not the turbines dumped on the ground, but turbines commissioned, connected to the grid."
3 MW Turbine Ramp-Up
- Commercial supplies begun: Commercial supplies of the 3 MW turbine have started, with about five to seven turbines already dispatched. Three moulds are already in operation or in transit, with the rest expected to be in play by end of this quarter or early Q4.
- Ramp-up trajectory: A gradual pick-up is expected in Q3 and Q4, with a significant ramp-up next year. Reasonable capacity will go out this year, especially in Q4.
- Realizations and margins: Realization per megawatt remains the same as the 2 MW series for the time being. Management declined to give model-wise margin guidance, calling it an overall portfolio.
- RLMM listing imminent: The process for RLMM listing for the 3 MW turbine has been completed from Suzlon's side and is expected as early as next week.
- Product mix in FY25: Management expects to continue with both 2 MW and 3 MW turbines in FY25, with a ratio of roughly two-thirds 2 MW to one-third 3 MW, or slightly different. The 2 MW competes better on some sites, and what matters to customers is cost per kilowatt hour, not turbine size.
Chalasani: "It is not the question of more generation with less land. At the end of the day, for anybody... what matters is the cost per kilowatt hour. Which model gives you the lowest cost per kilowatt hour? For the larger turbines in India today, the cost per kilowatt hour is higher."
Execution & Sector Outlook
- H1/H2 seasonality: H1 to H2 difference is normal for the wind sector. H2 is expected to be anywhere close to double H1. The country did ~1.5 GW in H1, with expectations of 4.5-5 GW for the full year. Suzlon's performance would be in a similar line, with H1/H2 distribution between one-third/two-thirds and 40:60.
- Sector capacity growth: Management expects a minimum of 4 GW and maximum of 5 GW for the sector in FY24, with a midpoint of 4.5 GW. For FY25, the expectation is 6-7 GW.
- Installations vs deliveries gap: Installations were 500 MW while deliveries were 267 MW in H1. MNRE reports new wind capacity added, which is how the 33% market share is calculated.
- Manufacturing capacity flexibility: Capacity will not be a constraint if orders are consistent over 2-3 years. If FY26 can sell more, Suzlon will quickly add moulds in existing plants to increase capacity.
- Client rescheduling mechanics: Contractually, transmission delays do not affect revenue, but repeat clients ask to reschedule supplies 10 months in advance. Suzlon obliges, which can impact topline, though other sites can fill the gap.
Margins & Competitive Positioning
- Margin guidance maintained: Management sticks to the margin guidance given and explicitly declined to raise margins despite increasing demand, saying it does not want to tell repeat customers it is a supplier's market.
- OMS competition: In OMS for Suzlon's own fleet, independent service providers are setting what management called unsustainable benchmarks in pricing and performance parameters. Some large IPPs think they can operate turbines themselves.
- Offshore wind posture: Offshore is a completely different ballgame and will take a long time to come in India. Suzlon has another technology under development for various turbines but would only go ahead with offshore if it is not a one-off project and offshore in India proves substantial. For now, Suzlon does not participate directly in tenders; it has a pre-bid tie-up with someone who will participate.
Chalasani: "For the repeat customers, we really don't want to go and say that the demand is higher. It's now a supplier's market. We want to improve our margin significantly. That's not the way to work with the repeat customers."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Finance cost reduction | Sharp decline in interest cost as full benefit of debt repayment flows through | Q3 FY24 |
| 3 MW turbine RLMM listing | Process completed from Suzlon's side; listing expected | As early as next week |
| 3 MW turbine ramp-up | Gradual pick-up; reasonable capacity going out | Q3 and Q4 FY24, significant ramp-up next year |
| 3 MW turbine moulds | Rest of the moulds in play | End of this quarter or early Q4 FY24 |
| Sector capacity FY24 | Minimum 4 GW, maximum 5 GW; midpoint 4.5 GW | FY24 |
| Sector capacity FY25 | 6 GW to 7 GW | FY25 |
| Product mix FY25 | Continue both 2 MW and 3 MW; ratio of two is to one, or slightly different | FY25 |
| Karnataka substations | A couple of delayed substations expected to come online | End of this year and early next year |
| Manufacturing capacity | Will add moulds in existing plants if orders are consistent over 2-3 years | Conditional on sustained order flow through FY26-27 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated PAT before exceptional items | ₹136 cr, against ₹53 cr in Q2 FY23 |
| H1 FY24 consolidated PAT before exceptional items | ₹230 cr |
| Finance cost | ₹36 cr, down 61% YoY from ₹92 cr in Q2 FY23 |
| H1 FY24 finance cost | ~₹90 cr |
| Consolidated net worth | ₹3,409 cr as of 30th September 2023 |
| Net debt | ~₹600 cr, down from ~₹13,000 cr in March 2020 |
| Residual subsidiary debt (SE Forge) | ₹120 cr |
| Order book | 1,613 MW as of 30th September 2023 |
| Order book composition (C&I vs bid) | Two-thirds C&I (including retail), one-third bid capacity |
| EPC share in order book | 47% to 53%, increased from earlier periods |
| H1 FY24 turbine deliveries | 267 MW |
| H1 FY24 installations by Suzlon | ~500 MW |
| H1 FY24 market share (installations) | ~33% |
| India H1 FY24 wind installations | ~1.6 GW |
| FY24 sector capacity addition guidance | 4.5 GW midpoint, 4 GW minimum to 5 GW maximum |
| FY25 sector capacity addition expectation | 6 GW to 7 GW |
| WTG segment EBITDA | ~₹30 cr, compared to ~₹35 cr in Q1 FY24 |
| Average realization | ~₹6 cr per MW for equipment supply scope |
| Manufacturing capacity | 3 GW to 4 GW, natural capacity at 4 GW |
| OMS capacity under management | 14.3 GW in India |
| Multi-make OMS capacity | ~200 MW, plus 150 MW acquired this year |