Key Takeaways
- Highest PAT in five years: Q3 FY23 PAT before exceptional items reached ₹78 crores, more than doubling YoY from ₹37 crores, driven purely by operational parameters.
- Balance sheet turns positive: Consolidated net worth turned positive after nine years following substantial debt reduction post rights issue, with ₹600 crores in pending call money still to strengthen it further.
- Finance costs halved: Net finance costs fell 56% YoY in Q3 (₹80 cr vs ₹181 cr) because of aggressive deleveraging, and management expects expeditious debt reduction to continue in coming quarters.
- Policy tailwind firms up: The government announced an 8 GW annual wind bid trajectory through 2030, and a CERC circular waived interstate transmission charges for corporate projects until June 2025, opening a new demand channel.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the first 8 GW bid materializes in the coming weeks, progress on working capital sanctions from 4–5 financial institutions, and closure of the first non-core asset sale.
Profitability & Operational Turnaround
- PAT milestone: Q3 FY23 PAT before exceptional items of ₹78 crores was the highest in over five years, with a YoY increase of more than 100% from ₹37 crores in Q3 FY22, driven purely by operational parameters.
- Nine-month delivery: Delivery volume reached 482 MW with revenue of ₹4,257 crores for the nine-month period, compared to 471 MW and ₹4,078 crores in the same period last year, reflecting consistent improvement.
- WTG manufacturing: The WTG segment yielded an operating profit for the nine-month period with modest EBITDA; contribution margin was about 16% for the nine-month period and is expected to be similar going forward.
- OMS strength: Domestic OMS EBITDA margins are approximately 44–45%, benefiting from scaled-up operations in India, while international OMS margins are single-digit and a little more than breakeven because the mix includes comprehensive maintenance and technical services agreements.
- WTG breakeven dynamics: WTG has a certain breakeven threshold resulting in single-digit operating margin currently; as volumes grow, WTG manufacturing margin adds to profitability.
- Cost control: Tight control on costs is reflected in profit margins; the positive impact of stabilizing commodity prices and supply chain issues is expected to become more apparent in coming quarters.
- Capacity utilization: Currently at 25–30% because the Indian wind market performed poorly over the last four years (FY18-19 through FY21-22); utilization is expected to become higher as the market grows, reflecting in better revenue and financial parameters.
Himanshu Mody: "we are maintaining the financial discipline of ensuring that the leverage keeps reducing on a significant basis and hope to see us a day soon where the balance sheet would be that net debt positive."
Balance Sheet & Deleveraging
- Net worth turns positive: Consolidated net worth turned positive after nine years because of significant debt reduction post rights issue; the balance sheet is further strengthenable with ₹600 crores in pending rights call money.
- Finance cost reduction: Net finance costs fell 56% YoY in Q3 (₹80 cr vs ₹181 cr) and 41% YoY in the nine-month period (₹321 cr vs ₹540 cr) because of substantial debt reduction and continued deleveraging focus.
- Leverage metrics: Net debt to EBITDA stands at 2.6x and net interest coverage ratio at 1.9x, described by management as very healthy parameters.
- Debt repayment pipeline: Approximately ₹300 crores from subsequent rights tranches is identified for debt repayment, leading to expeditious debt reduction in the coming few quarters.
- Debt-free timeline: Management declined to give forward-looking guidance on when the company might become debt-free, calling it "a bit too early" for such a projection.
- Trade receivables: No red flags; days outstanding have reduced as sales increased.
- Non-core asset sale: One of two identified non-core assets is expected to be concluded "fairly soon in the foreseeable future"; the second asset's timeline will be assessed after the first concludes.
Policy & Market Environment
- 8 GW annual bid trajectory: The government announced annual bids for 8 GW of wind projects during 2023–30 with a clear seven-year roadmap; the first big announcement under this plan is expected in the coming few weeks, if not a couple of months.
- Bidding format change: Tariff discovery will shift to a one-time big single-stage bid with no reverse auction, which management believes will prevent unviable tariffs and non-materializing projects.
- ISTS waiver for corporates: A CERC circular released on 7th February 2023 clarified that there are no interstate transmission charges up to June 2025, enabling a big push in the corporate market for wind, solar, and hybrid projects supplying manufacturing works, steel plants, and aluminum plants in non-windy states.
- State auction activity: Maharashtra, Gujarat, Madhya Pradesh, and Rajasthan have been active in their auctions.
- SECI bid backlog: SECI 12 and 13 are in discussion with some winners; these are in the new regime at good rates and "should definitely happen," though the PSA signing process between SECI and DISCOMS can take two to three months and sometimes extends to nine months.
Ashwani Kumar: "everybody welcomed the idea that everybody does their own calculation, submits"
Order Book & Competitive Position
- Order book stability: The order book was kept almost at the same level despite a reduction of approximately 50 MW; management described performance as doing "fairly well" given market conditions.
- Customer diversification: The current order book is well diversified with no customer concentration.
- Quality over volume: Management's stated priority is to pursue only quality orders with higher value and better margins, focusing on both top line and bottom line.
- Market share: Suzlon held a 42% installations market share last year, which is better than its installed base market share.
- Competitive landscape: Management's personal opinion places the three largest players in the Indian market as Siemens Gamesa, Suzlon, and Envision, noting that the other two international players are not that focused on the Indian market.
- Order book monetary value: Management declined to disclose the order book in monetary terms when asked by an analyst.
- Market share in current orders: Management declined to provide a market share number for orders placed this year, stating no reliable public database exists and they cannot claim any number with seriousness.
- SECI discussions: Management stated, "Clearly, with our turnaround, we are a party which most people will have their discussions with," expressing confidence in winning SECI-linked business.
Ashwani Kumar: "our order book growth will continue to be robust as and when people start awarding and finalizing their OEM suppliers. In terms of working capital, as Himanshu said, we are already on our way and working capital not restricting our order book as of now."
Working Capital & Capex
- Working capital sanctions: The company is in very advanced dialogue with 4–5 financial institutions; by the exit of Q4 FY23 or early Q1 FY24, significant progress is expected to deliver on next year's business plan.
- Early sanction received: An early sanction on a small working capital limit was received from one financial institution; management declined to disclose the name or amount.
- No capex requirement: No major capex is envisaged over the next few quarters to fulfill existing and future order books; even if capacity utilization substantially increases, no substantial capex is required.
- Maintenance capex: The requirement is low for the next three years and will be funded through normal costs.
- Working capital not a constraint: Management explicitly contradicted the suggestion that order book growth will be constrained until all bank sanctions are done, stating working capital is not restricting the order book currently.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| First 8 GW bid announcement | First big announcement under government's 8 GW annual plan expected | Coming few weeks to a couple of months |
| Working capital progress | Significant progress from 4–5 financial institutions to deliver next year's business plan | By exit of Q4 FY23 or early Q1 FY24 |
| Debt repayment | ~₹300 crores from subsequent rights tranches identified for debt reduction | Coming few quarters |
| First non-core asset sale | One of two identified non-core assets to be concluded | Very near future |
| SECI 12 and 13 execution | In discussion with winners; PSA signing takes 2–3 months, sometimes up to 9 months; then 24 months to execute | Post-PSA: 24 months |
| Margin improvement | Positive impact of commodity price and supply chain stabilization to become apparent in P&L | Coming quarters |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated PAT before exceptional items | ₹78 cr, highest in over five years on operational parameters, up more than 100% YoY from ₹37 cr in Q3 FY22 |
| Nine-month FY23 revenue | ₹4,257 cr, versus ₹4,078 cr in nine-month FY22 |
| Nine-month FY23 delivery volume | 482 MW, versus 471 MW in nine-month FY22 |
| OMS revenue (Q3) | ₹476 cr |
| OMS revenue (nine-month FY23) | ₹1,386 cr |
| OMS EBITDA margin | 44% to 45% |
| WTG manufacturing contribution margin (nine-month FY23) | About 16% |
| WTG manufacturing operating margin | Single-digit, currently |
| Net finance costs | ₹80 cr, down 56% YoY from ₹181 cr in Q3 FY22 |
| Nine-month FY23 interest cost | ₹321 cr, down more than 41% YoY from ₹540 cr in nine-month FY22 |
| Net debt to EBITDA | 2.6x, on a trailing 12-month basis for December '22 |
| Net interest coverage ratio | 1.9x, for this year |
| Order book | Reduced by around 50 MW compared to previous quarter |
| Market share in installations (last year) | 42% |
| Capacity utilization | 25% to 30% |