Key Takeaways
- Balance sheet transformed, execution still lumpy: Net cash swung to INR719 crores from net debt of INR1,180 crores in nine months, but Q3 delivered only 170 MW as non-EPC order book timing depends on client site readiness.
- Order book is deep but delivery is back-end loaded: The 3.2 GW order book stretches across FY25 and FY26, with a significant portion next year; management declined to quantify the split, citing shifting schedules.
- WTG manufacturing margin normalizes to mid-teens: Contribution margin dipped to 17.5% from 20% in Q1 (called an aberration), and management says mid-teens is the steady-state range.
- Industry commissioning is the bottleneck, not turbine supply: Management flagged that capacity addition depends on converting supplied turbines into commissioned MW, and the sector lacks large BOP/on-ground execution players.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether Q4 deliveries push the WTG segment to standalone operating profit, the pace of PSU tender qualification post-May, and any firming of FY25 industry commissioning toward the 5–6 GW estimate.
Order Book & Delivery Visibility
- 3.2 GW order book, well-diversified: Cumulative orders stand at 3,157 MW from marquee customers; the 642 MW Evren order (a Brookfield entity) is the single-largest order Suzlon has won in India.
- Long-tenure orders: Supply completion timelines now run 18 to 24 months from order date, with a small portion in the current year, a significant portion in FY25, and some in FY26.
- Non-EPC mix creates timing risk: A significant portion of the order book is non-EPC, meaning delivery depends on the customer's site readiness and project execution capability; some equipment supplied three or four quarters ago is still awaiting commissioning.
- 22–23% of the order book is still for the 2 MW turbine: The older S120 platform remains in the mix even as the 3 MW ramp continues.
- Equipment supply share set to rise: Management expects the quantity of equipment supply (versus full EPC) to increase in the order mix going forward.
Chalasani: "The order book that we have, 3.2 GW now that you're seeing, is partly small capacity is this year, significant portion is for the next year, that is by FY '25 and also for FY '26."
Execution & the Commissioning Bottleneck
- Q3 execution of 170 MW was low: Management attributed this to delivery as per project-site requirements and the high share of non-EPC orders where timing depends on the client.
- Supply does not equal commissioning: The binding constraint on the sector is converting supplied turbines into commissioned capacity; management called this "the concern we're facing today in the country."
- BOP execution capacity is thin: There are hardly any large players in project execution for balance-of-plant and on-ground work, which creates headwinds for capacity buildup.
- Manufacturing capacity is gated by offtake: Suzlon's 4 GW manufacturing capacity is achievable only if offtake at project sites is smooth; if supplies are made ready but not dispatched, manufacturing cannot continue.
- WTG segment approaching standalone profitability: At 437 MW delivered in nine months, a large part of fixed costs is already absorbed; break-even is about 600 MW per year at the EBITDA level, so Q4 deliveries should produce reasonably decent standalone operating profit.
Chalasani: "What would decide is not the supply of equipment. The capacity addition would purely depend upon how much can we convert the supply turbines into commission capacity. That's where the concern we're facing today in the country."
Industry Commissioning Outlook
- FY24 industry commissioning estimate: 3.2–3.5 GW: Management pegged the current year at sub-4 GW, with a maximum of 3.5 GW.
- FY25 estimate: 5–6 GW: A step-up is expected next year, but still well below the 8 GW aspiration.
- 8 GW per year is an FY26–FY27 story: Management was definitive that 8 GW will not happen in FY25; it may arrive in FY26 or FY27, "we will wait and see."
- Repowering is years away from moving the needle: Management called it "a good wish" but not something that will matter within the next couple of years.
- Bid pipeline is deep at roughly 15 GW: Government continues to issue bids; if any are undersubscribed, the next bid will come again.
Chalasani: "Whether that will happen in FY -- definitely not in FY25. It will happen in FY26 and FY27 is what we will wait and see."
Margins & Profitability
- Consolidated contribution margin dipped ~2% QoQ: The decline is a mix effect: WTG manufacturing contribution margin was 17.5% (mid-teens is the steady-state target), while O&M contribution margin runs north of 60%; the blend shifts with the revenue mix.
- WTG manufacturing margin normalizing: Q1's 20% contribution margin was called an aberration; management's direction is that mid-teens will continue as the norm for the manufacturing business.
- Finance costs collapsed 94% YoY: Quarterly net finance costs fell to INR5 crores, driven by the improved balance sheet.
- Lower depreciation helped: Depreciation of INR38 crores reflects lower amortization of moulds for the S120 (2.1 MW) models.
Mody: "Our direction always has been that for the WTG manufacturing, contribution margin will be in the mid-teens."
Balance Sheet & Capex
- Net cash of INR719 crores at December 2023: This is a swing of over INR2,000 crores in nine months from net debt of INR1,180 crores at March 2023.
- Sustenance capex runs ~INR100 crores annually: Historically, this is the base level.
- Delta capex for 3 MW ramp-up: ~INR250 crores per year: This covers moulds for the new platform and will be met from internal accruals.
Tender Participation & Qualification
- Not yet participating in PSU tenders: Suzlon has not started bidding for PSU OEM tenders (NTPC, SJVN, NLC, GAIL) because of qualification criteria related to net worth.
- Qualification expected post-May: Once March 2024 audited numbers are out and show positive net worth, management said there will be no doubts about qualification under all parameters.
- Qualification does not guarantee participation: Even if qualified, Suzlon will evaluate each bid against alternative opportunities to book its entire capacity; participation is not automatic.
- Hybrid and FDRE projects are an opportunity: If an IPP is developing an FDRE or hybrid project, Suzlon will develop the wind component and is willing to coordinate the whole project if approached.
- Proactive land development underway: Suzlon has started working with state governments in Andhra Pradesh and Rajasthan to identify land, and with clients for joint development to secure project sites.
- Pooling tariff system now notified: The operating agency and notification have been issued, with a date from which it becomes applicable; it covers pure wind, pure solar, and pure hybrid models.
Chalasani: "Even if we get qualified, it is not necessarily that we'll participate in the bid. We will evaluate the options, what will be the best option for us to book our entire capacity."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| WTG standalone operating profit | Reasonably decent operating profit on a stand-alone basis, driven by Q4 deliveries | Q4 FY24 |
| PSU tender qualification | Positive net worth after March '24 audited numbers; will qualify under all parameters | Post-May 2024 |
| Industry commissioning | 3.2–3.5 GW for FY24; 5–6 GW for FY25 | FY24 and FY25 |
| 8 GW per year industry run-rate | Definitely not in FY25; may happen in FY26 or FY27 | FY26–FY27 |
| WTG manufacturing contribution margin | Mid-teens will continue as the norm | Ongoing |
| Repowering impact | Not going to move the needle | Next couple of years |
| 3 MW platform capex | ~INR250 crores per year for moulds, met from internal accruals | Annual |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue recognition (deliveries) | 170 MW in Q3 FY24 |
| Revenue recognition (9M FY24) | 437 MW in 9M FY24 |
| Consolidated PAT before exceptional items | ₹203 cr, growth of 2.6x YoY vs ₹78 cr in Q3 FY23 |
| Consolidated PAT before exceptional items (9M) | ₹433 cr in 9M FY24, 4.4x YoY growth vs ₹98 cr in 9M FY23 |
| Net finance costs | ₹5 cr, down over 94% YoY vs ₹80 cr in Q3 FY23 |
| Depreciation | ₹38 cr, lower on account of lower amortization of moulds for S120 (2.1 MW models) |
| Net worth | ₹3,626 cr as of December 2023 |
| Net cash position | ₹719 cr as of December 2023, a swing of over ₹2,000 cr from net debt of ₹1,180 cr as of March 2023 |
| Cumulative order book | 3,157 MW as of call date, comprising 2,290 MW as of Dec 31 plus 867 MW subsequently announced |
| EPC order book share | 28% of order book |
| 2 MW turbine share in order book | 22% to 23% of 3.1 GW order book |
| WTG manufacturing contribution margin | 17.5% in Q3 FY24, vs 20% in Q1 FY24 (called an aberration) |
| OMS business contribution margin | a little north of 60% |
| OMS capacity under management | 14.5 GW of wind capacity |
| Suzlon market share in commissioning | 30% maintained consistently quarter-on-quarter |
| India wind commissioning (9M FY24) | 2.1 GW in first 9 months of fiscal year |
| India wind commissioning estimate (FY24) | 3.2 to 3.5 GW full-year estimate, max 3.5 GW |
| India wind commissioning estimate (FY25) | 5 to 6 GW industry estimate |
| WTG segment break-even | ~600 MW annual deliveries for EBITDA break-even after fixed costs |
| Sustainance capex | ~₹100 cr annually, historically |
| Delta capex for 3 MW ramp-up | ~₹250 cr per year for 3 MW molds |