Key Takeaways
- Balance sheet restored, profitability returns: Consolidated net worth turned positive after 10 years at INR1,099 crores, and FY '23 PAT before exceptionals swung to a INR167 crores profit, driven by a 44% drop in finance costs after aggressive deleveraging.
- Market share slipped on execution timing: More than half of capacity added in FY '23 was not full-scope EPC, and turbines supplied earlier in the year had not been commissioned by March 31, pulling reported market share below the 25-30% target.
- Order book is not the constraint: Management stated the order book is no longer an issue and that it will now cherrypick orders for better margins and ease of execution, taking only what it can deliver in the next year.
- Margins guided to hold, not expand: H2 FY '23 contribution margins in the mid-teens are expected to be maintainable through FY '24, with no explicit step-up promised despite a richer mix of C&I orders.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the 50-60% of the order book slated for FY '24 execution actually converts to commissioned MW and reported market share, and any concrete progress on the flagged non-core asset sale.
Balance Sheet & Profitability Turnaround
- Net worth positive after a decade: Consolidated net worth reached INR1,099 crores, a milestone achieved through the rights issue and sustained bottom-line focus.
- PAT swing: FY '23 consolidated PAT before exceptional items was INR167 crores, compared with a loss of INR249 crores in FY '22.
- Debt nearly eliminated: Net debt fell from INR13,000 crores six years ago to just INR167 crores, a reduction of more than 90%.
- Finance cost halved: Net finance cost dropped 44% to INR401 crores, a direct result of continuous deleveraging.
- Working capital buffer in place: The company is sitting on close to INR1,000 crores of sanctioned working capital limits from institutions, a marked improvement that supports the delivery ramp-up.
- Tax shield remains: No tax outgo is expected at the consolidated level in FY '24, as the company still holds carry-forward losses exceeding INR2,000 crores.
- Net debt to fall further, but more slowly: Management expects net debt reduction in FY '24 through cash flow generation per the amortization schedule, though not at the same pace as recent years because working capital facilities are being drawn.
Himanshu Mody: "as we speak today, we are sitting on close to INR1,000 crores of sanctioned working capital limits available with the company from those institutions"
Market Share & The Execution Gap
- Reported share fell below ambition: The company targets a 25-30% market share and aims to be #1 or #2 in India, but FY '23 additions did not reflect that because more than 50% of capacity added was only turbine supply with erection and commissioning, where Suzlon has limited control over the final commissioning date.
- Turbines supplied but not commissioned: Even turbines supplied in Q2 had not been commissioned by the March 31 year-end, creating a gap between order intake and the COD-based market share metric.
- The country-level bet: Management explicitly tied its market share outlook to the country's total wind additions, stating it will maintain 25-30% of whatever India adds, and invited investors to form a view on the country rather than on Suzlon in isolation.
- Policy fixes expected to lift volumes: Two structural corrections, a shift from e-reverse auction to closed bidding and the introduction of state-specific bidding with a pooled tariff mechanism, are expected to stabilize tariffs and increase the volume of utility-scale additions after five subdued years.
J. P. Chalasani: "instead of taking a guess on me, take a guess on the country, and we will maintain 25% to 30% of whatever country adds, our market share will be to that extent"
Order Book & Selective Execution
- Order book no longer a concern: Management stated flatly that the order book is not an issue, with plenty of opportunities available, and that the binding constraint is now delivery capacity for the next year.
- Cherrypicking for margin and ease: The company will now pick and choose orders based on three criteria: better margins, ease of execution, and client quality that supports a long-term OMS relationship.
- C&I now half the book: Almost 50% of the current order book comes from the commercial and industrial segment, driven by steel, cement, and refining companies needing renewable power for exports and net-zero commitments.
- FY '24 execution visibility: 50-60%, maybe almost 60%, of the current order book is slated for execution in FY '24, with more orders to be booked during the year.
- ISTS waiver creates a deadline, not a panic: The ISTS waiver expiring in March '25 will cause a rush to complete projects, but management does not expect to be pressured beyond its manufacturing and supply capacity.
- EPC vs supply split: The order book is roughly 50% EPC and 50% pure turbine supply with erection and commissioning, without balance of plant.
J. P. Chalasani: "We will be pick and choose now on the orders of which would give us, one is good margins. And the second thing is easy to execute and the third is who is the client, so that we can have a long-term relationship in terms of OMS."
Margins & Profitability Levers
- WTG business profitable at EBITDA level: The wind turbine generator segment delivered INR96 crores of EBITDA for FY '23 with a healthy margin despite lower volumes than FY '22, though depreciation of roughly INR250 crores kept EBIT negative.
- H2 margin run-rate is the FY '24 guide: Management committed that H2 FY '23 contribution margins, described as mid-teens, should be maintainable going forward into FY '24, but declined to give EBIT margin guidance or per-MW realization numbers.
- Larger turbines help project economics, not turbine margin: Margins at the individual turbine level remain more or less the same; the economics of the new S144 3-MW series improve at the project level through lower balance-of-plant costs, reduced land area, and fewer operating constraints.
- Interest cost to fall further, but incrementally: Finance costs will decline from the INR401 crores base in FY '24, but the reduction will not approach the prior 44% drop because working capital facilities are being ramped up to support delivery.
- Capex stays light: Only normal maintenance capex of roughly INR100 crores is needed in FY '24; an additional INR100-150 crores may be required in FY '25 to augment capacities for the 3-MW platform, with advances and orders potentially placed in FY '24.
- Management deflected on several quantification requests: Specific EBIT margin potential, per-MW realization, FY '24 interest cost number, and foundry/forging growth were all declined, with answers limited to the EBITDA margin guide and directional commentary.
OMS, Foundry & Adjacent Businesses
- OMS growth stalled by the industry cycle: OMS revenue has been flat because the low capacity additions of FY '20 and FY '21, whose turbines enter commercial OMS after two years, have not yet fed through; growth depends on the number of turbines added each year and will become visible as last year's and this year's installations come online.
- Multi-brand O&M explored cautiously: The company is exploring opportunities to service non-Suzlon turbines but is moving carefully to ensure it can deliver the same service level as on its own fleet.
- Foundry and forging demand rising: The foundry division is seeing significant order inputs from both Suzlon and competitors and is working on debottlenecking to increase capacity; SE Forge also has export business.
- Repowering as a retail win-win: For 20-25 year old turbines, mostly with retail clients, Suzlon offers life extension through refurbishment at a one-time price, allowing clients to keep running even without a PPA by selling into the merchant market.
- OMS monetization not on the table now: Management has no current plans to monetize the OMS business and will make a public disclosure as per SEBI norms if the situation develops.
Competitive Landscape & Policy Tailwinds
- Chinese competitors acknowledged but not engaged: When asked about Goldwind and Envision's domestic market share and any regulatory hurdles they face, management deflected, saying it is "hands full with our own affairs" and that a 10 GW annual bidding market provides a pie for everyone.
- C&I demand set to expand further: Green hydrogen and ammonia are expected to drive the next leg of C&I growth in the coming years, building on the current base of steel, cement, and refining demand.
- Offshore wind: preparing, not predicting: Management is aware of the country's offshore program and is building capability internally so that "we don't miss the bus," but the timeline for the first project is "anybody's guess work."
- Non-core asset sale flagged, not quantified: One substantial non-core asset is expected to be sold in FY '24, but management declined to give any number or indication of value.
J. P. Chalasani: "Obviously, we are hands full with our own affairs. So therefore, I don't want to get into whether they have a regulatory hurdle. But only thing I want to say is that the market is going to be what we're envisaging i.e., a 10 GW bidding every year, I think there is a pie for everyone."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Market share | Maintain 25-30% of whatever India adds in wind capacity | Ongoing |
| Order book execution | 50-60% of current order book delivered | FY '24 |
| EBITDA margin | Maintainable at H2 FY '23 levels (mid-teens contribution margin) | FY '24 |
| Net debt | Further reduction, but slower pace than prior years | FY '24 |
| Maintenance capex | ~INR100 crores | FY '24 |
| Capacity expansion capex | Additional INR100-150 crores over maintenance capex for 3-MW platform | FY '25 (advances in FY '24) |
| Tax outgo | Nil at consolidated level, utilizing >INR2,000 crores of carry-forward losses | FY '24 |
| Non-core asset sale | One substantial asset to be sold | FY '24 (value not disclosed) |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹6,000 cr (FY23 full year), for 664 MW executed |
| Consolidated PAT before exceptional items | ₹167 cr (FY23 full year), vs negative ₹249 cr in FY22 |
| Consolidated net worth | ₹1,099 cr (FY23 full year), turned positive after 10 years |
| Net debt | ₹167 cr as of 31st March 2023, reduced from ₹13,000 cr 6 years ago, reduction of more than 90% |
| Net finance cost | ₹401 cr (FY23 full year), down 44% from ₹712 cr in FY22 |
| Net debt to EBITDA (pre-forex) | 1.4x (FY23 full year), vs 7x in FY22 |
| Net interest coverage ratio | 2.1x (FY23 full year), vs 0.9x in FY22 |
| WTG business EBITDA | ₹96 cr (FY23 full year), with depreciation of close to ₹250 cr |
| WTG business EBITDA margin guidance | Single high digits in percentage terms, 8% to 9% |
| Contribution margin guidance | Mid-teens at the contribution level |
| Cumulative orders | 1,542 MW, highest since 2019 |
| Order book as on March 31, 2023 | 652 MW |
| Orders secured subsequently | 890 MW |
| Confirmed order book | Close to 1,500 MW, of which about 55% is for FY24 |
| OMS business revenue | ₹1,900 cr (FY23 full year), almost flat for the year |
| OMS capacity under maintenance globally | Over 16 GW, close to 14 GW in India |
| Sanctioned working capital limits | Close to ₹1,000 cr available with the company |
| Carry forward losses | Exceeding ₹2,000 cr on the balance sheet |
| Maintenance capex for FY24 | Close to ₹100 cr |
| Additional capex for FY25 capacity augmentation | ₹100 cr to ₹150 cr delta over maintenance capex |
| FY24 wind bid plan | 10 GW (2.5 GW each by SECI, NTPC, NHPC, SJVN) |
| Wind installations needed per annum | Roughly 8 GW over the next 7 years to reach 100 GW by 2030 |
| FY17 peak execution | 1,780 MW |
| Execution capacity | More than 2,000 MW |
| Q4 per MW realization | Around ₹6.10 cr, vs ₹5.65 cr in Q3 |
| Working capital LC/BG commission range | 2% to 3% |
| SE Forge non-Suzlon business share | 60-70%, Suzlon business 30-40% |