Key Takeaways
- India profitability recovers, international drags: India standalone EBITDA grew 17% with margin expansion, but consolidated EBITDA declined 2% YoY as international profits fell 39% on inflation, currency, and delayed pricing.
- Tea volumes under pressure, early signs of recovery: India tea revenue fell 5% on both price corrections and a 5% volume decline, driven by rural weakness and a late North Indian winter; December was decent, January better.
- Foods top line surges on salt pricing: India Foods revenue grew 29%, overwhelmingly from a 33% salt price increase; underlying volume grew 4%, while the growth portfolio (Sampann, Soulfull, NourishCo) expanded over 50%.
- Distribution restructuring underway to close competitive gap: Management is splitting food and beverage routes in large urban towns and converting sub-distributors to distributors in semi-urban and rural areas, aiming to close a ~10-12% distribution gap versus the large competitor.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the January tea volume uptick sustains into Q4, the pace of international margin recovery as US and UK price increases land, and any material development on the confirmed Bisleri acquisition discussions.
India Beverages: Volume Weakness and Recovery Signals
- Revenue and volume decline: India tea revenue fell 5% YoY, driven by both pricing corrections as tea prices softened and a 5% volume decline; the volume drop was led by continued rural market pressure and a delayed winter up North that did not set in until early to mid-December.
- Market share mechanics: Management described the share loss as "largely a mathematical calculation" because the company is stronger in North India; when the North does not fire, the regional mix mechanically pulls reported share down.
- Early recovery signs: December volumes were decent, January was better than December; management is "hoping that we are off to a good quarter" but remains cautious.
- Competitive dynamics: Both large branded tea players lost share to loose and local tea; management views this as a temporary phenomenon that should correct as stability returns, noting the three-year CAGR is still ~140-150 bps above the starting point.
- Category growth expectation: Once stability returns, management expects mid-single-digit category volume growth for India Beverages, consistent with the historical ~5% volume growth trend.
Sunil D'Souza: "I would still keep my fingers crossed before saying that we are back on track. But December was decent, January was better than December. So we are hoping that we are off to a good quarter."
International Business: Margin Restoration in Progress
- Profit decline and drivers: International segment profit fell 39% YoY (INR 88 cr vs INR 144 cr), driven by inflationary pressures, adverse currency movements, and a lag in passing through pricing; Q3 was an improvement over Q2.
- Pricing actions: Price increases have been taken in the UK and are now hitting the market; US price increases are expected to reflect in Q4 and beyond.
- Cost restructuring: Further cost restructuring opportunities are being worked on and will unfold over the next couple of quarters.
- Sequential margin improvement: International EBIT margins already improved 240 bps QoQ; management stated "this quarter, you will see substantially more," referring to the quarter ahead (Q4).
- Margin ambition: Management expects the international business to return "very strongly" to being accretive to India business margins within the next couple of quarters, restoring a position it held 12-15 months ago before commodity, currency, and demand softness reversed it.
- Currency mechanics: Currency impacts the business both transactionally (tea bought from Kenya in USD, and the drop in the British Pound made quick UK pricing difficult) and translationally (GBP depreciation vs INR).
- US coffee volumes: A pack-price exercise, taking up price via pack-size changes rather than headline price increases, impacted volumes; management noted that in international markets, revenue top line matters more than volume.
- Bright spots: Canada was a star performer with 5% revenue growth in both specialty and black tea, maintaining very strong market shares; international tea volumes were about flat, which management called "good news" given prior quarters.
Sunil D'Souza: "You've already seen some moves of the pricing with 240 bps improvement in EBIT margins. But I think this quarter, you will see substantially more."
India Foods: Salt Dominates the Top Line, Growth Portfolio Scales
- Revenue surge driven by salt pricing: India Foods revenue grew 29% YoY, overwhelmingly driven by price increases; salt gained 90 bps market share despite a 33% price increase during the year, which management called "very unnatural historically."
- Volume growth obscured by mix: Reported volume growth was 4%, but this is overwhelmingly a salt story because tonnage comes almost entirely from salt (ratio ~1:100,000 or 1:10,000 vs other categories); the growth portfolio tells a different trajectory.
- Growth businesses momentum: The growth portfolio grew over 50% YoY, with Sampann growing >35%, Soulfull delivering triple-digit value growth, and NourishCo near triple digits; overall growth business salience moved from 6% to 13% over three years.
- NourishCo scale-up: Revenue reached INR 119 cr for the quarter (66% growth) and is on track for INR 600 cr for the full year, up from INR 180 cr in May 2020.
- Sampann competitive posture: Management sees a "huge, huge, huge runway" in pulses (an INR 1 lakh+ crores category where branded play is under 1%) and is focused on execution rather than competitor moves.
- Sampann margin profile: Gross margins vary by sub-category: ready-to-eat is accretive to the base business, pulses are at the lower end, spices are in the ballpark; as mix shifts toward more value-added products, continued margin expansion is expected.
- Sampann ROCE: Significantly high because the business involves no capital, with completely outsourced manufacturing and distribution.
Sunil D'Souza: "I mean there is a huge, huge, huge runway in all the Sampann categories, right? Pulses, if I remember, is an INR 1 lakh plus crores category and the whole branded play is less than 1%. So I -- today, I would worry more about how I would execute and I would move."
Distribution Restructuring: Splitting Routes to Unlock Depth
- The bandwidth problem: The company originally built a common distribution system with ~3,500+ DSRs carrying both food and beverage from a common distributor, reaching ~0.27 crore outlets individually for tea and salt; as the portfolio expanded (Sampann, Soulfull, salt variants), the salesman could not sell the whole range, limiting depth.
- Split routes in large urban areas: The company is moving to separate food and beverage routes in all 10 lakh+ population towns to increase depth and assortment per outlet in large urban areas.
- Semi-urban and rural push: A significant movement from sub-distributors to distributors is planned over the next 2-3 months to improve direct coverage; this is part of a nationwide thrust on semi-urban and rural distribution.
- DSR base expansion: The total DSR base (~4,000 today) will expand by 35-40% via split routes and extra feet-on-street for semi-urban expansion.
- Direct outlet target: The company is targeting 0.15 crore (0.15 crore) direct outlets by March 2023, currently at close to 0.14 crore (0.14 crore), and is "more or less on track."
- Competitive gap to close: Management is ~10-12% behind the large competitor on both distribution and market share; closing the distribution gap is expected to help close the market share gap, with specific focus on rural Tamil Nadu (value gap), Eastern UP (volume gap), and parts of Maharashtra.
- Urban outlet ceiling: Total urban outlets might not increase dramatically (0.36 to 0.4 crore); growth will come from throughput per outlet, portfolio, and assortment per outlet via route splitting.
- Soulfull and Sampann distribution ambition: Soulfull is currently indexed at ~40% of the other large competitor's distribution and is slightly below 10% of the ~0.4 crore outlet universe; Sampann should be at an 80-90 index to tea distribution given kirana stores sell similar products.
Portfolio Expansion, Innovation, and Channel Shifts
- Innovation cadence: The company is targeting to exit FY23 at 3%+ of revenue from innovation (up from 0.8% at the start), with launches including Tata Salt Immuno, iron and vitamin fortified salt under Shuddh, Tata Premium tea range, Coffee 2-in-1 and 3-in-1, NourishCo Juice-Jelly, Chef Style masala sprinklers, Tata Raasa RTEs and RTCs in Western markets, and Tata Soulfull Ragi Bites relaunch.
- Tata Copper Plus: Running at 2x of last year for the third consecutive quarter.
- E-commerce and Modern Trade: Both channels have doubled as a percentage of business over the last three years; e-commerce revenue grew 34% YoY, Modern Trade grew 17% YoY.
- Starbucks: Added 11 net new stores in Q3, reaching 311 stores across 38 cities; the business is EBIT positive, and store additions "will keep climbing as we go forward."
- Global simplification: The Tata Coffee NCLT process shareholders' meeting is complete; the broader global entity simplification aims to reduce operating entities from 43 to ~23-25, with pieces already being moved while the process is underway.
- R&D integration: Consolidated into three centers: Bangalore (center of excellence), Sri City (process excellence for food and beverage), and Mumbai (sensory and kitchen expertise for food).
Bisleri Discussions and Capital Allocation
- Active discussions confirmed: Management confirmed "we are in active discussions" regarding Bisleri and stated they will come back and explain the rationale if and when something materializes.
- Acquisition philosophy: The company looks at acquisitions through the lens of value building, growing total addressable market, and growing total shareholder returns; management declined to comment further on Bisleri specifics.
Sunil D'Souza: "Whenever we look at acquisitions, we look at value building. We look at growing our total addressable market as well as growing total shareholder returns. ... All I can say is that we are in active discussions. As and when something materializes, we will definitely come back, explain the rationale for what we are doing, if we are doing it, if it goes through and our plans for it going forward."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| India tea volume recovery | December was decent, January better than December; "hoping we are off to a good quarter" but fingers still crossed | Q4 FY23 (implied) |
| International EBIT margin improvement | "This quarter, you will see substantially more" beyond the 240 bps QoQ improvement already delivered | Q4 FY23 |
| International margins restored to accretive vs India | Structural cost actions and pricing in place to return international to EBIT margin accretive position | Next couple of quarters |
| Direct outlet reach | Target 0.15 crore (0.15 crore) direct outlets; currently close to 0.14 crore | March 2023 |
| DSR base expansion | Add 35-40% to total DSR base (~4,000 today) via split routes and semi-urban expansion | Next 2-3 months (for sub-distributor to distributor conversion) |
| Innovation revenue share | Exit FY23 at 3%+ of revenue from innovation (from 0.8% at start) | FY23 exit |
| NourishCo revenue | On track for INR 600 crores for the full year | FY23 |
| India tea and salt volume growth | Mid-single-digit volume growth over next 2-3 years; high single-digit value growth "undisputedly" | Next 2-3 years |
| Global entity simplification | Reduce operating entities from 43 to ~23-25; Tata Coffee NCLT leg expected to kick in by end of Q1 | End of Q1 FY24 (Tata Coffee) |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | ₹3,475 cr, +8% YoY; 9-month revenue crossed ₹10,000 cr, +10% YoY |
| Consolidated EBITDA | -2% YoY; YTD EBITDA +5% YoY; three-year CAGR +12% |
| Group net profit | ₹364 cr, +26% YoY; before exceptionals -5% YoY |
| Standalone revenue | ₹2,153 cr, +6% YoY (tea -5%, foods >+25%) |
| Standalone EBITDA | +17% YoY, margin expansion driven by cost initiatives and foods margins |
| India business revenue | +8% YoY; branded India +8%, international +2%, non-branded +22% |
| India business segment profit | +14% YoY, versus sales growth of 8% |
| International business segment result | ₹88 cr, -39% YoY from ₹144 cr; improved QoQ from Q2 |
| India Beverages revenue | ₹1,200 cr, -5% YoY; volume -5% |
| India Foods revenue | ~₹1,000 cr, +29% YoY; volume +4% |
| Growth businesses (Sampann, NourishCo, Soulfull, SmartFoodz) | +53% YoY; contribution moved from 6% in FY20 to 13% of business |
| NourishCo revenue | ₹119 cr, +66% YoY; on track for ₹600 cr for the full year |
| Tata Coffee revenue | +25% YoY, driven by coffee prices; volume negative on timing of sales |
| Starbucks store count | 311 stores, 11 net new stores in Q3; 65 added in last 12 months; present in 38 cities |
| E-commerce revenue | +34% YoY; modern trade +17% YoY |
| Total numeric reach | ~3.6 cr outlets across all categories; direct outlets close to 0.14 cr |
| International EBIT margins | +240 bps QoQ improvement; further pricing and cost actions expected |
| Salt market share | +90 bps gain, despite 33% price increase during the year |
| Exceptional items | ₹79 cr, accounting gain from conversion of Joekels JV into subsidiary in South Africa |