Key Takeaways
- 15% EBITDA base achieved, more to go: India business margin expansion and international turnaround lifted consolidated EBITDA margin to the 15% level management had aspired to, which it now treats as a floor, not a ceiling.
- Two acquisitions reshape the portfolio: Capital Foods closed and front-end integration substantially complete; Organic India expected to close by early April. Together they are meant to take the growth businesses contribution from ~20% to a targeted 30% of India revenue.
- Tea volume growth sustained, salt share hits a record: India tea posted its fourth straight quarter of positive volume growth with premium outperforming, while Tata Salt recorded its highest-ever monthly value share in December.
- US coffee is the open wound: The category is soft, coffee price volatility is extreme, and the branded business is under pressure; management expects substantial margin progress in 6–12 months but offers no near-term fix.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the Capital Foods integration stays hiccup-free as distribution expands, the pace of NourishCo’s march toward breakeven, and any signal that coffee input costs are plateauing as forecasts suggest.
India Business: Volume, Mix & Market Share
- Tea volume trajectory: Fourth consecutive quarter of positive volume growth, with mass-premium and premium segments significantly outperforming popular and economy tiers.
- Tea market share: Volume share gained 30 bps and value share gained 16 bps quarter-on-quarter.
- Salt share record: MAT value share down 10 bps, but December alone clocked a 39-plus value share, the highest monthly figure ever recorded.
- Salt runway: The top five brands account for only 50–52% of the branded market; a large part of the landscape is no-name brands, giving Tata Salt, already at 39%, a long runway to keep gaining share.
- Shuddh solar salt: Targeted at geographies with lower share and where solar salt is the dominant category; doing well but still early days.
- Margin drivers: India business EBITDA margin expansion came from a better product mix, operating leverage, and softness in tea costs.
- Standalone margin: Premiumization mix, some commodity cost softness, and operating leverage all contributed to the improvement.
Sunil D'Souza: "Tata Salt recorded its highest ever, and ever is ever monthly share -- market share, in December '23"
Growth Businesses & New Launches
- Growth businesses target: Ending the year close to 20% of India business, growing at 30%; with Capital Foods and Organic India, the target rises to 30% contribution growing at 30%.
- NourishCo trajectory: Q3 is seasonally the slowest quarter; the season kicks in end of January/early February. Full-year revenue target remains INR900–1,000 crores, implying a substantially higher Q4.
- NourishCo breakeven: Targeting breakeven this year; profitability expected to improve as scale builds.
- NourishCo portfolio: Tata Copper Plus growing far faster than Gluco Plus; launched Gluco Plus Jelly, Himalayan provenance range, cold coffee; piloting sports drinks and energy drinks.
- Energy drink pilot: A Rs10 price-point proposition; still very early, needs distribution and marketing perfected before rollout.
- Sampann expansion: Expanded from pulses into spices, mixes, poha; growth driven by new categories and wider points of availability.
- Soulfull: Entered muesli and choco sticks; the strategy is simply getting product in front of more consumers.
- New launches: Sonnets cardamom, pepper, and honey; flavored and roasted dry fruits (online first, offline expansion planned); Black Salt; cold brew coffee cans. 45 new SKUs introduced in modern trade.
- Portfolio complexity management: New launches are not in general trade where confusion could arise; some not even in modern trade; the entire portfolio plays online without complicating front-end bandwidth. Dry fruits launched only online, then select modern trade, still not in general trade; Sonnets will remain online-only for the foreseeable future.
Sunil D'Souza: "Complexity is dealt with depending on how you structure your team to play on, right? So while you see a lot of new launches, etcetera, they are not on the offline business. They're not in the general trade because that is where the confusion can arise because of limited amount of bandwidth for the front end."
Acquisitions: Capital Foods & Organic India
- Capital Foods: Closed and integration started; front-end integration substantially complete with invoicing primary on Feb 1 and secondary on Feb 2; remaining integration work expected in the next 60–90 days.
- Capital Foods strategic fit: Complements the cuisine portfolio: Indian with Sampann, Western with Smith & Jones, oriental with Capital Foods; brings chutneys, dips, sauces, and noodles not previously in the portfolio.
- Ching's distribution impetus: In many parts of the country Ching's is not distributed; where already present, full-fledged integration is underway. About 7–8 days into integration, no major hiccups, only small niggles.
- Organic India: Announced, expected to close within 45–60 days (end of March or early April), then integrate into TCPL's distribution system.
- Organic India portfolio fit: Two parts: organic tea and supplements, plus the infusion space. Most tea is loose, a little in teabags under Tetley; Organic India is completely organic with a large infusion component, complementing the existing portfolio.
International: Turnaround & Pressure Points
- UK turnaround: Revamping the back-end, new sustainable packaging, upgraded product, improved execution, and higher A&P started to deliver; gained value market share. Category growth led by pricing, with volume growth starting to return.
- Canada: Revenue flat but continuing to grow share; ethnic portfolio getting strong traction; has always delivered very strong margins and continues to do so.
- US coffee pressure: Category under demand-side pressure; huge volatility in coffee prices, spiked up, came down, now seeing an upswing in the last 2–3 months. The branded business is soft, in line with or slightly worse than the category.
- Coffee price dynamics: From July 2021, Arabica rose, then Robusta ran up; around March/April 2023 prices started coming down; from September, driven by Brazil issues and Vietnam crop not reaching market, Robusta prices climbed again and Arabica climbed in conjunction. Forecasts suggest plateauing or softening toward the end of the calendar year, but management cautions a forecast is just a forecast.
- International margin ambition: International margin has to be accretive to India; directionally started to move into that space but still has a decent amount of runway.
- US margin timeline: Over the next 6 to 12 months, management expects to see substantial progress on margins.
- Non-branded margin boost: Non-branded EBITDA grew 54% largely due to high coffee realizations; the same high coffee prices adversely impact the branded business, particularly US coffee.
Margins: The 15% Floor & Headroom
- 15% EBITDA base: Management had aspired to deliver 15% EBITDA margins and is now there; that level becomes the base from which to target higher.
- Headroom: Even at 15%, the company is still not in the middle of the heap among its peer set; management sees no reason not to get to peer levels and believes there is a decent amount of headroom to grow margins while continuing to deliver double-digit growth.
- Margin drivers going forward: Commodity costs have been benign; tea costs are cyclically priced and compared to the same quarter last year are largely benign; gross margins of tea and salt are broadly where they should be given historical numbers; growth businesses are on a strong trajectory; adding businesses without adding costs on the bottom line; advantage of scale and operating leverage.
- Exceptional item: UK pension past service costs from 1990s regulations and case law not properly given effect to in the scheme; a one-time hit. Management is looking to remove the pension liability from the balance sheet in the next year or two.
Sunil D'Souza: "I think overall as a company, now 15% EBITDA margins is something which we had aspired to deliver. Now we are there. Now that becomes the base. From here on, we will be continuing to target higher."
Starbucks & JV Performance
- Starbucks pressure: A quarter of pressure in line with other QSRs; top line grew only 7%.
- JV losses: Starbucks losses higher because of expansion and accounting standards, softness in the market, lower tea costs, and wage increases. Amalgamated Plantations North India performance was lower than the previous year.
- Starbucks store target: 1,000 stores by FY28.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Growth businesses contribution | Exit close to 20% of India business, growing at 30%; with acquisitions, take it to 30% growing at 30% | FY24 exit / post-acquisition close |
| Capital Foods integration | Front-end substantially complete; remaining integration work finished | Next 60–90 days |
| Organic India closing | Deal close, then integrate into TCPL distribution | Within 45–60 days (end of March / early April) |
| NourishCo breakeven | Achieve breakeven | This fiscal year |
| NourishCo full-year revenue | INR900–1,000 crores | FY24 |
| Starbucks store count | 1,000 stores | By FY28 |
| UK pension liability | Remove from balance sheet | Next year or two |
| US coffee margins | Substantial progress on margins | Next 6–12 months |
| EBITDA margin trajectory | Continue to target higher than the 15% base; get to peer levels | Undated but stated as ongoing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | ₹3,800 cr, +9% YoY, +8% in constant currency |
| 9-month consolidated revenue | ₹11,279 cr, +11% YoY |
| Consolidated EBITDA | +26% YoY, margin expanded 190 bps |
| Consolidated EBITDA margin | 15%, now the base from which to target higher |
| PBT before exceptional items | +27% YoY |
| Group net profit before exceptional items | +31% YoY |
| Reported PAT | ₹300 cr, -17% YoY, impacted by exceptional costs of ₹92 cr vs income of ₹79 cr last year |
| 9-month EPS growth (before exceptional) | +22% YoY |
| Net cash on balance sheet (9 months) | ₹2,945 cr, +40% vs same quarter last year |
| India business revenue | +10% YoY |
| India business EBITDA | +22% YoY |
| India Packaged Beverages tea volume | +2% YoY, fourth consecutive quarter of positive volume growth |
| India Packaged Beverages tea revenue | +4% YoY, 4-year CAGR at 8% |
| India Foods volume | +5% YoY |
| India Foods revenue | +13% YoY |
| India growth businesses revenue | +42% YoY, now 17% of total business, up from 13% last year |
| NourishCo revenue | ₹160 cr, +34% YoY; 9-month growth +41% |
| Tata Sampann revenue | +40% YoY, 4-year revenue CAGR at 29% |
| Soulfull revenue | +47% YoY, vast majority from base portfolio |
| Dry fruits revenue | +70% YoY |
| Value-added salts revenue | +23% YoY |
| Salt 4-year revenue CAGR | 16% |
| Salt value market share (December 2023) | 39%-plus, highest ever monthly share |
| Tea MAT volume share (QoQ) | +30 bps |
| Tea MAT value share (QoQ) | +16 bps |
| Innovation as percentage of revenue | 5.3%, up from ~3% in same quarter last year |
| International business revenue | +11% YoY, +6% in constant currency |
| International business EBITDA | +19% YoY |
| International business EBIT | +23% YoY |
| UK revenue | +14% YoY, gained value market share |
| US revenue | -9% YoY, branded coffee category under pressure |
| Canada revenue | flat YoY, record black tea share of 61.5% in December |
| Tata Coffee revenue | +3% YoY, volume +6% |
| Tata Coffee plantations revenue | +44% YoY |
| Non-branded business revenue | +4% YoY |
| Non-branded business EBITDA | +54% YoY, driven by high coffee realizations |
| Tata Starbucks store count | 392 stores across 55 cities, 22 new stores added in Q3, 59 added YTD |
| Tata Starbucks revenue | +7% YoY for the quarter, +14% YTD |
| E-commerce channel contribution | 10.7%, revenue growth +37% |
| Modern trade Sampann and Soulfull revenue | +49% YoY |
| Direct reach | 0.15 crore outlets |
| Total reach | 0.39 crore outlets |
| A&P investment | +6% YoY |
| Working capital | reduced by 7 days |
| Standalone EBIT margin | 15.6%, up from 13.5% last year |