Key Takeaways
- Volume recovery begins, cautiously: India tea volumes grew 3% and salt volumes picked up, but management says "we are not out of the woods as of yet" given inflation and rural stress.
- Distribution reset underway to fix a bottleneck: The common sales force that once helped is now a drag on growth; the company is splitting routes in all 10 lakh-plus towns and expanding direct distribution to 20,000-plus towns by mid-Q2.
- Growth engines delivered 53% FY23 growth: Sampann, NourishCo, Soulfull, and RTE/RTC now contribute 15% of India revenue, with NourishCo expected to turn profitable this fiscal.
- International margins are poised to recover: Pricing actions and structural cost restructuring are expected to flow through between Q1 and Q2, with international EBIT accretive to total company margins by at least 100 to 150 bps.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the distribution split and direct reach expansion translate into tea market share recovery, and whether international margin improvement materializes on schedule.
India Demand & Volume Recovery
- Tea volumes turned positive: India beverages volume grew 3% in Q4 after quarters of stress, driven by green shoots in northern and rural markets where the company is stronger.
- Salt volumes picked up: Sharp price increases will anniversary from Q1 onwards, so the pricing-led leg of growth fades; volume growth is now the driver.
- Medium-term volume expectation: Both tea and salt are expected to grow mid-single digits in volumes over the medium to longer term.
- Tea market share slipped: The company lost 50 bps volume share and 113 bps value share on a MAT basis, primarily to regional players, while the major competitor maintained value share. The portfolio skew toward mass-to-value segments hurt when those segments came under pressure in the North.
- Demand-side, not cost-side: The volume question is tied to inflation and rural stress, not tea prices or costs. Early green shoots are visible, and barring unforeseen macro events, volumes are expected to continue recovering.
- Salt margins normalized: Salt gross margin is back in the normative 32% to 37% range after price increases.
D'Souza: "I wouldn't say that we are out of the woods as of yet, but we have started seeing volume growth coming back."
Distribution Overhaul
- The bottleneck: The common distribution system created three years ago, where one salesman sells both tea and foods, is now a drag because the same person carries a far wider portfolio, causing "data overflow."
- The fix: Routes in all 10 lakh-plus towns are being split to carry two separate salesmen for food and beverage. Direct distributors are being appointed in all 50,000-plus towns and a significant number of 20,000-plus towns to plug share gaps in semi-urban and rural areas.
- Timeline: A significant expansion in Q1, and the 20,000-plus town rollout is expected to be finished by the middle of Q2. The short-term numeric reach target is 0.4 crore outlets, up from 3.8 crore as of March.
- Sampann offline push: Sampann is a market leader in some online portals; the challenge is getting it into offline stores. Splitting routes in large towns is expected to have a significant impact on Sampann growth.
- No timeline on bridging the tea gap: Management declined to give a timeline for closing the distribution gap versus competitors, saying "competitor also moves," but asserted the company will move at a far faster pace.
D'Souza: "We are realizing that now this is also becoming a bottleneck for our growth because it's the same salesman now selling a far, far wider portfolio and there is a, for want of a better word, I'll say data overflow on that end."
Growth Engines
- Scale achieved: Sampann, NourishCo, Soulfull, and RTE/RTC combined grew 53% for FY23 and now represent 15% of India business revenue. NourishCo grew revenue 80%; Soulfull doubled; Tata Copper grew 2.2x.
- NourishCo trajectory: Now present in 75% to 80% of the country, though not with real strength everywhere. Manufacturing footprint expanded 2x to 2.5x last year and will continue expanding. Targeting close to a four-digit revenue number (INR crores) in FY24.
- NourishCo profitability: Contributory margins are on par with the India business. As scale builds, A&P will not increase in line with revenue, so NourishCo is expected to turn profitable this fiscal.
- Sampann balancing act: Targets 30% growth but can target much more; the balance is between top line and margins, with margins moving into double digits.
- Margin profile: Soulfull is significantly accretive in contributory margins; NourishCo is about par; Sampann is slightly below total numbers. Growth will come primarily from distribution first, backed by A&P and brand building.
D'Souza: "Contributory margins on NourishCo are on par with the India business. Right now, as we build for A&P, there is a different profile for the NourishCo business. But remember, as we gain scale, it's not A&P will not increase in line with that trajectory. And therefore, we do expect NourishCo to start coming on a positive note in this fiscal itself."
International Business
- Stabilization underway: Revenue up 11% (1% ex-acquisitions). EBITDA in line with last year; EBIT margin roughly 100 bps off from the same quarter last year.
- US coffee volume decline: Eight O'Clock Coffee volumes fell roughly 20%, partly due to overall category decline and partly because the company used pack-price degramming rather than naked pricing. Despite that, revenue rose 6% and margins are back to normal. Market share was more or less maintained in bags and K-Cups.
- Margin recovery path: Pricing actions taken across markets, including a 15% price increase in the UK in February. Structural cost actions are still in process and expected to be completed by end of this month. Between Q1 and Q2, everything should flow through.
- Ambition: The intent is not only to return to historical net EBIT margins but to improve from there. International business is expected to be accretive to total company EBIT margins by at least 100 to 150 bps.
D'Souza: "I would expect international margins to come back solidly, if not better than where they were before we started off."
Margins & Profitability
- Consolidated EBITDA margin: 14.3% for the quarter. Standalone EBITDA growth was more than proportionate to top line. International profitability decline was arrested, with absolute profitability in Q4 roughly in line with the previous year.
- India EBIT improvement: India business EBIT improved 100 bps versus the same quarter last year, driven by volume growth while keeping costs under tight control. Gross margins on both tea and salt are broadly in the normative range.
- Operating leverage building: Other expenses as a percentage of sales have been coming down; other expenses excluding manpower have roughly halved versus three years back. People expenses as a percentage of sales in India have come down about 50 bps from where they started.
- A&P not the margin lever: The improvement in India EBITDA did not come from squeezing advertising. A&P does not include discounts and trade promotions, which are captured in net sales. Quarter-to-quarter movements will fluctuate, but the intent is not to cut advertising to drive the bottom line.
- Free cash flow: Conversion from EBITDA was close to 99%.
Portfolio & Strategic Updates
- Starbucks: Crossed INR 1,000 crores in revenue; added a record 71 stores to reach 333 stores across 41 cities. A moonshot pilot fine-tuned four options: enhanced beverages, Pico size, revamped food, and refurbished interiors. Aggressive expansion planned. Management declined to increase disclosures, saying the business is not significant yet.
- Global simplification: Reducing the number of international entities and delisting/merging Tata Coffee. The NCLT process is expected to complete in Q2, after which international entity consolidation begins.
- Bangladesh JV terminated: The company is setting out on its own. South Africa stake increased to majority control.
- Digital infrastructure complete: Fully on cloud, single instance of SAP, entire front end digitized, supply chain on Blue Yonder IBP systems, dashboarding across functions.
- Innovation: Will continue to move the innovation percentage up from 3.4%. Plans to leverage data pipelines for data-driven NPD, web crawling, social listening, and AI/ML for procurement and revenue growth management.
- Coffee strategy: Still small; the game is to continue building the brand and distribution. Expanded entry-level INR 2 packs, launched Tata Coffee Gold, and launched a full coffee mixture in the North with a separate red pack.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Direct distribution expansion | Reach 0.4 crore outlets; appoint direct distributors in all 50,000-plus towns and significant number of 20,000-plus towns | By mid-Q2 FY24 (September) |
| Sales route split | Split routes in all 10 lakh-plus towns to separate food and beverage salesmen | Underway |
| International margin recovery | Pricing and structural cost actions to flow through; international EBIT accretive to total company margins by at least 100 to 150 bps | Between Q1 and Q2 FY24 |
| NourishCo revenue | Close to four-digit number (INR crores) | FY24 |
| NourishCo profitability | Turn profitable | FY24 (this fiscal) |
| Sampann growth and margins | 30% growth target; margins moving into double digits | Ongoing |
| Tea and salt volume growth | Mid-single digits | Medium to longer term |
| Global simplification | Complete NCLT process for Tata Coffee, then begin collapsing international entities | NCLT by Q2 FY24 |
| Tea pricing | Slightly downward trend expected; will move prices to balance volumes and margin | Going forward |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | ₹3,619 cr, +14% reported, +12% constant currency |
| Consolidated EBITDA | ₹518 cr, +13% YoY |
| Consolidated EBITDA margin | 14.3% |
| Group net profit | ₹290 cr, +21% YoY |
| EPS (full year) | +28% YoY |
| India beverages volume growth | +3% YoY |
| India foods volume growth | +8% YoY |
| India foods revenue growth | +26% YoY |
| Salt volume growth | +8% YoY |
| Salt revenue growth | +26% YoY |
| Salt market share change | +76 bps on a MAT basis |
| Tea volume market share change | -50 bps on a MAT basis |
| Tea value market share change | -113 bps on a MAT basis |
| US coffee volume growth | -20% YoY |
| International business EBIT margin change | ~100 bps below same quarter last year |
| Growth businesses combined revenue growth (FY23) | +53% YoY, now 15% of India business revenue |
| Tata Sampann revenue growth | +35% YoY |
| NourishCo revenue growth | +80% YoY |
| Starbucks store count | 333 stores across 41 cities, +71 stores added |
| Starbucks revenue milestone | Crossed ₹1,000 cr for FY23 |
| Modern trade revenue growth | +21% YoY, now 14% of revenue |
| E-commerce revenue growth | +32% YoY, now 9% of revenue |
| Innovation (NPD) contribution to revenue | 3.4% for FY23, up from 0.8% |
| Free cash flow conversion from EBITDA | ~99% |
| Dividend increase | +40% YoY |
| Cash on books | ~₹3,000 cr |
| Direct distribution reach | 0.15 cr outlets |
| Numeric reach | 0.38 cr outlets as of March, targeting 0.4 cr by September '23 |
| Value-added salts mix | 5% of salt portfolio, up from less than 1% in FY20 |