Key Takeaways
- PAT nearly doubled YoY, rising ~90% on steady operational performance and a large coal mining profit boost from elevated coal prices.
- Renewables EPC margins took a hit from commodity prices and FX, but management has now fully hedged currency and expects margins to improve as older, lower-priced contracts roll off.
- Mundra resolution is the central swing factor: the plant is running under a temporary Section 11 order with full cost pass-through promised, and a permanent supplementary PPA with Gujarat is under negotiation.
- TATA Projects losses are being cleaned up: management provisioned for cost overruns on legacy projects and stated no further big losses are expected, calling this the end of write-offs.
- What to watch next quarter: the CERC tariff order for Mundra, progress on the Gujarat supplementary PPA, and whether the promised EPC margin recovery materializes.
Mundra Resolution: The Quarter's Defining Issue
- Section 11 dispensation: Three units have operated under the government's emergency order since 6th May, with a full pass-through of coal cost. The notification runs until October 2022, with an opportunity for extension, and management is confident it will convert into a long-term arrangement providing stable power to beneficiary states.
- Tariff principle: Under Section 11, all costs (fixed and variable) must be fully paid, plus a certain profit margin. Management expects CERC to apply this principle when determining the final tariff, with an order expected in the next few weeks.
- Supplementary PPA with Gujarat: Discussions are underway and will pave the way for a permanent resolution. Coal cost will be a full pass-through, not restricted to a certain HBA level, though other aspects remain under negotiation. A similar arrangement is expected with other procurers once the Gujarat deal is done.
- Interim billing mechanics: The company is currently billing at interim tariffs. Once CERC notifies the actual cost-based tariff, any difference will be trued up as a prior-period adjustment. Gujarat and Maharashtra have been paying; other states have not, waiting for the CERC order.
- Under-recovery gap: An under-recovery exists for the period 1st April to 5th May, before Section 11 took effect. Management did not quantify the figure on the call, stating details will be shared later.
Praveer Sinha: "The concept of Section 11 is that all costs have to be given. So, whether it is fixed cost or variable cost, there cannot be any deductions. In fact, there has to be a certain profit margin also, which has to be procured."
Renewables: Growth Ambition vs Near-Term Margin Pressure
- EPC margin squeeze: Profitability in the solar EPC business was hit by higher commodity prices (including solar cells and modules) and foreign exchange movements. The stress was concentrated in older projects booked over a year ago that are now being implemented, plus a "huge hit" from the exchange rate.
- Hedging fix applied: The company has shifted to 100% back-to-back hedging of currency exposures for solar EPC projects, having previously left some open space. Management stated that going forward, no major profitability swings are expected from FX.
- Contract manufacturing bridge: Tied up with a couple of domestic manufacturers for solar modules, benefiting from a 15% customs duty arbitrage (25% on cells vs 40% on modules). This tie-up will run for longer than 12–15 months because the company's own 4GW manufacturing capacity will take time to stabilize.
- Own manufacturing timeline: An MoU with Tamil Nadu was signed to invest ~₹3,000 crore for a 4GW solar cell and 4GW module plant in Tirunelveli District. Work is expected to start within one month, with the module phase commissioned by June next year and the cell phase by November next year.
- Order book momentum: Won 1.7GW of large-scale EPC contracts in Q1, bringing the total pipeline to 3.6GW. Commissioned 600MW AC solar capacity including India's largest floating solar project in Kerala backwaters.
Coal Mining Windfall and the DMO Obligation
- Coal cluster profit: The coal mining business delivered a ₹968 crore profit, driven by higher coal prices. The DMO obligation (25% of mined capacity) has been met, with heavy supplies made in January–February.
- Calendar-year alignment: Indonesia operates on a January–December calendar, so a large quantity of the DMO obligation was already completed earlier in the year. The balancing quantity will be spread across the remaining months.
- Regulatory uncertainty: Details on Indonesian taxes, royalties, and profit-sharing arrangements are still under calculation, with the Indonesian government yet to finalize the framework. Finality has not been reached.
TATA Projects: Cleaning Up Legacy Losses
- Provisioning rationale: Losses were booked in Q4 FY22 and Q1 FY23 on a cost-to-completion basis for certain older projects impacted by commodity price increases. The Board and Audit Committee examined each project where the cost of completion was on the higher side and took a stand to "clean up" all projects with a probability of losses.
- End of write-offs declared: Management stated explicitly that this is the end of write-offs and provisioning, and that TATA Projects will be making profits going forward. No further big losses are expected in subsequent quarters.
- Transmission synergy: TATA Projects serves as the in-house EPC partner for transmission bids, providing a competitive edge in a market with a large pipeline (₹42,000 crore over 10 years) but many competitors.
Praveer Sinha: "We took a stand last quarter and this quarter also that we need to clean up all the projects where we have probability of having losses."
Distribution Business: Steady Operational Improvement
- Odisha Discoms turnaround: Technical losses reduced by nearly 1% to 3%, and AT&C losses reduced by 4% to 9% versus Q1 FY22, driven by focused operations leveraging Mumbai and Delhi experience.
- Seasonal QoQ blip: AT&C losses rose QoQ (e.g., CESU at 35.7% in Q1 FY23 vs 29% in Q4 FY22) due to seasonality: summer months bring higher supply and demand, so the benefit of loss-reduction efforts takes time to reflect. Management stressed that distribution should be evaluated on a 12-month cycle, not quarterly.
- Profitability timeline: Management described FY24–25 as a "more than meaningful" profit year for the Odisha Discoms, with Capex incurred in recent months delivering benefits once capitalization happens in subsequent quarters.
- Growth ambitions: The company aims to be the biggest player in distribution in the country, looking to take up opportunities in other states through private sector opportunities or licensing. It is already the largest private sector player with 1.2 crore customers, equal to the sum total of all other private players.
- Smart metering push: Implementation underway in all four Odisha Discoms, and the company intends to become a big player for other state Discoms under the government's RDSS scheme.
Praveer Sinha: "In the distribution business, we are the largest in the country with 1.2 crore customers. That is sum total of all the other private sector players in the country."
Balance Sheet: Receivables Spike and Debt Comfort
- Receivables surge: Receivables rose 40–50%, driven by three factors: old payments not received from Andhra Pradesh and Tamil Nadu (a court order has now been received), a large quantum of solar modules imported in March to avoid Basic Customs Duty from April (now being liquidated), and a large quantity of coal bought for Mundra at higher prices causing cash flow stress.
- Debt metrics manageable: Net debt inched up in line with earlier guidance on growth Capex, but debt-to-underlying-EBITDA improved from 3.9x to 3.6x due to healthy growth in operational profit. Net debt to equity rose slightly to 1.55x from 1.53x. Management believes it can maintain a healthy debt-to-equity ratio given growth aspirations.
- Renewable transaction proceeds: CCI approval was received on the evening of the call, and the first tranche of ₹2,000 crore is expected in the next few weeks.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| CERC tariff order for Mundra | Cost-reflective tariff under Section 11 principle (all costs plus profit margin) | Next few weeks |
| Gujarat supplementary PPA | Full coal cost pass-through, not restricted to HBA level; permanent resolution for Mundra | Under discussion, no date given |
| Solar manufacturing plant | First phase (module) commissioned; second phase (cells) commissioned | June next year; November next year |
| Renewable transaction first tranche | ₹2,000 crore inflow | Next few weeks |
| TATA Projects profitability | No further big losses; return to profit | Subsequent quarters |
| Solar EPC margin recovery | Newer orders at updated prices, 100% FX hedged, contract manufacturing tie-up | Coming quarters |
| Odisha Discoms meaningful profit | "More than meaningful" profit year | FY24–25 |
| Old Andhra/Tamil Nadu receivables | Payment following court order | This quarter |
| Section 11 Mundra operation | All 5 units (3,800MW) offered daily, paid fixed cost; no loss if arrangement continues | Valid till October 2022, extension opportunity |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹14,776 cr, +48% YoY |
| Reported EBITDA | ₹2,107 cr, vs ₹2,365 cr in Q1 FY22 (which included a one-off impact of ₹302 cr from a Mundra tariff order) |
| Reported PAT | ₹884 cr, +90% YoY vs ₹466 cr in Q1 FY22 |
| Net debt | ~₹42,000 cr at quarter end |
| Net debt to equity | 1.55x, vs 1.53x in Q4 FY22 |
| Debt to underlying EBITDA | 3.6x, improved from 3.9x in Q4 FY22 |
| Capex incurred | >₹2,000 cr during the quarter, mainly in renewables and Odisha Discoms |
| TPSSL large-scale EPC order book | 3.6 GW, worth nearly ₹15,000 cr (1.3 GW owned projects, 2.3 GW external orders) |
| Rooftop solar revenue growth | 4x over Q1 FY22 |
| Solar pump business revenue growth | 2x over Q1 FY22 |
| EV charging points | ~2,400 public charging points across 437 cities, plus >240 E-bus charging points |
| Odisha Discoms AT&C loss reduction | 4% to 9% reduction vs Q1 FY22 |
| Odisha Discoms technical loss reduction | ~1% to 3% reduction vs Q1 FY22 |
| Mundra units operated under Section 11 | 3 units since 6th May, full declared capacity of 3,800 MW offered daily |
| Coal cluster profits | ~₹968 cr |