Key Takeaways
- Weather-marred quarter, but underlying drivers intact: Power consumption grew just +1.5% as cyclones and heavy rains suppressed demand, yet management points to a strong recovery in Q2 and beyond, anchored by group captive renewables and EPC margin uplift.
- EPC margin inflection is the near-term catalyst: Legacy orders and module price benefits are set to flow through from Q2, with the full impact visible in Q3 and Q4, marking the end of a drag on the solar EPC business.
- Group captive renewable opportunity is materializing now: Tata Group’s own expansion in electronics, batteries, semiconductors, and EVs creates a captive pipeline for virtually 100% renewable supply, with EBITDA contribution expected by year-end.
- Mundra remains a managed overhang: The plant operated under Section 11 with restricted losses, but one unit was down all quarter; a transformer failure and delayed start cost 15 days of operations, though availability is set to improve drastically in Q2.
- What to watch next quarter: The pace of EPC margin recovery, the start of group captive EBITDA, and any clarity on a supplementary PPA for Mundra once the Section 11 period ends.
EPC Business: The Margin Inflection Story
- Q1 was the trough: Legacy orders rolled over from March into April/May, depressing both topline and margins; management stated the worst is behind the EPC business.
- Module price benefit is about to land: Ordered modules will start arriving from September onwards, so the full benefit of lower cell and module prices will reflect in Q2, and more substantially in Q3 and Q4.
- Rooftop margins already improved: Margins in the rooftop business improved tremendously in Q1, as the company shifted emphasis from volume to profitability after establishing a presence in 460+ cities with channel partners.
- Solar pumps on hold by design: The company is going slow because KUSUM program orders have not come and earlier margins were very low; it is waiting for the revised KUSUM program before committing fully.
- EPC strategy is internal-first: The first priority is meeting Tata Power’s own 2-2.5 GW annual requirement; third-party EPC opportunities will be pursued only if margins and returns are attractive, and the company now prefers projects where the owner provides the land.
- Cell and module manufacturing competitiveness: With BCD protection (40% on modules, 25% on cells), PLI benefits, and state incentives, management expects to be very competitive versus imported modules, especially as raw material costs like wafers have halved from ₹90/kg to ₹40/kg.
Dr. Praveer Sinha: "by design, we are going slow because the orders under the KUSUM program have not come. Also, the margins in the KUSUM program in the earlier ones were very low and hence we have decided that we will wait for the revised KUSUM program to come before we go full out."
Group Captive & Renewable Growth
- Tata Group pipeline is the anchor: New Tata Group plants in electronics, batteries, semiconductors, and the Tata Motors EV plant in Sanand create a captive demand base; management expects virtually 100% renewable supply to all these customers, with the group captive business this year being quite substantial.
- EBITDA visibility by year-end: Management expects some group captive projects to be operating and contributing visible EBITDA by the end of this financial year.
- Annual capacity addition target: The company is targeting nearly 2.5 GW of renewable capacity installation this year, partly for its own portfolio and partly for third parties, with nearly 4 GW of orders under execution, some spilling into FY25.
- Bidding discipline protects returns: The company operates within a defined band, bids pure solar or hybrid solutions but not pure wind, and finds that returns in complex hybrid solutions with storage are much better than vanilla solar or wind.
- Pumped hydro storage unlocks complex bids: With 2,800 MW planned at just two of six existing reservoirs, the company can offer combined solutions with storage; because reservoirs and dams already exist, the cost will be less than ₹5 crores, and management expects to be one of the first to bring pumped hydro online.
Dr. Praveer Sinha: "you would find that all the new plants of Tata Group which are coming... everywhere you will find that we will have a huge opportunity and we will virtually be having 100% renewable supply to all these customers."
Mundra Plant: Managed Overhang
- Section 11 operations continued: The plant operated under Section 11 during Q1 and the direction continues till 30th September, with cost-reflective operations keeping losses very restricted; management is optimistic the direction will be extended if heat conditions persist.
- Availability was impaired: Only 4 of 5 units operated during the quarter because one unit was down due to a transformer failure; additionally, Section 11 operations started only from 15th April due to a delay from the procurer side, missing the first 15 days of the quarter.
- Q2 availability set to improve drastically: All four operating units are running, and the plant is low-cost and most efficient on the merit order, being scheduled ahead of other Gujarat plants.
- Supplementary PPA deferred: Management will look at a supplementary PPA only after the Section 11 period ends; when asked at what coal price Mundra would operate without Section 11, management deflected, saying discussions are ongoing.
Odisha Discoms & Weather Impact
- Extreme weather hit operations: Heavy rains, cyclones in Gujarat, and Kalbaisakhi in Odisha suppressed power consumption growth to just 1.5% in Q1, well below expectations based on February trends.
- Odisha discoms stabilized despite disruption: Billing and collection efficiencies were impacted by heavy restoration activities over three tough months, but the discoms have stabilized to a large extent; management stressed that AT&T losses should be viewed on a 12-month rolling basis, not quarterly.
- Weather events are not force majeure: The Odisha weather events did not qualify as a declared cyclone, so CAPEX for restoration is incurred as part of the annual plan and performance impact must be caught up within the 12-month period; only declared extreme weather conditions are considered by regulators.
- Future quarter performance expected to be much better in Odisha.
Financials & One-Time Items
- Coal profitability improved sequentially: Profit from coal companies increased versus Q4 due to higher sales quantity, lower production costs from cost minimization by the coal JV partner, and substantially reduced losses from Tata Projects, which fell from approximately ₹240 crore last year to hardly anything this quarter.
- Maithon income of ₹100 crores: This came from a tariff adjustment related to the COVID period; management does not classify it as non-recurring, arguing that similar items arise across thermal plants every year.
- Receivables rose on seasonal cycles: Receivables increased QoQ because summer consumption in distribution areas peaks in May/June while payments arrive in July/August, and some material stocking cycles also affected the figure, though receivable days have reduced drastically over time.
- Debt increased due to CAPEX: Working capital improved, and all financial metrics remain within plan.
- Tata Projects stake dilution: Tata Power did not participate in a rights issue where Tata Group infused ₹1,500 crore of additional equity; its stake fell from 47.78% to 30.81%, and a non-cash exceptional item was booked in the P&L because Tata Projects is an associate, not a subsidiary.
- Credit rating upgraded: ICRA and CARE upgraded the rating from AA stable to AA positive.
Dr. Praveer Sinha: "it's not non-recurring, I would say this is the nature of the business... normally every year you will have something or the other coming up, right? So, we don't classify this as a non-recurring."
Wind Performance & Bidding Discipline
- Wind PLF declined year-on-year: Wind speeds in June were very bad this year versus very good last year, but July has improved; on a 12-month rolling basis, management sees no structural change in wind patterns, only extreme weather causing month-to-month variation.
- Bidding strategy protects margins: The company avoids pure wind bids and operates within a defined band; management noted that competitors who bid aggressively low are now struggling to execute and their margins are impacted.
- PSU vs non-PSU EPC risk: The company prefers PSU counterparties because they pay on time; non-PSU developers often do not, and no one shares project risk except through change-in-law provisions.
Dr. Praveer Sinha: "People who have gone and done crazy numbers, they are struggling to execute those projects and the margins are impacted."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| EPC margin recovery | Improvements start in Q2; most reflected in Q3 and Q4 | Q2 FY24 onset, Q3/Q4 full impact |
| Mundra availability | Drastic improvement with all four operating units running | Q2 FY24 |
| Group captive EBITDA | Some projects operating and EBITDA visible | By end of FY24 |
| Renewable capacity installation | Nearly 2.5 GW targeted (partly own, partly third party) | FY24 |
| Section 11 operations | Continues; optimistic about extension; supplementary PPA discussion only after it ends | Till 30th September 2024 |
| Odisha discom performance | Future quarter performance will be much better | Q2 FY24 onwards |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹15,003 cr, virtually flat compared to ₹14,776 cr |
| EBITDA | ₹3,005 cr, 43% growth compared to ₹2,107 cr |
| Reported PAT | ₹1,141 cr, compared to ₹884 cr; 15th consecutive quarter of PAT growth |
| PAT before exceptional items (core business) | ₹906 cr, compared to ₹884 cr |
| Debt-to-equity ratio | 1.1 |
| Net debt to underlying EBITDA ceiling | 3.5 |
| Credit rating | AA positive, upgraded from AA stable by ICRA and CARE |
| Planned CAPEX for FY24 | ₹12,000 cr |
| Renewable capacity addition target (FY24) | ~2.5 GW, mix of own and third-party |
| Renewable order book under execution | ~4 GW, some rolling into FY25 |
| Orders won last year (renewables) | ~2.6 GW, mostly hybrid orders |
| Mundra plant availability | ~54%, one unit down due to transformer failure; operated under Section 11 from 15 April |
| Mundra variable cost per unit | ~₹5 |
| EV public chargers | ~4,400 |
| EV home chargers | ~50,000 |
| EV bus chargers | ~1,200 |
| Pumped hydro planned capacity | 2,800 MW across two existing reservoirs |
| Pumped hydro capital cost (with existing reservoir) | Less than ₹5 cr per MW, versus ₹7–8 cr for Greenfield |
| Tata Projects stake | 30.81%, down from 47.78% after not participating in rights issue; ₹1,500 cr equity infused by Tata Group |
| Tata Projects book value per share | ₹110 |
| Maithon income | ~₹100 cr, tariff relief received; not classified as non-recurring |
| Basic customs duty on solar modules | 40% |
| Basic customs duty on solar cells | 25% |
| Wafer price | ₹40 per kg, down from ₹90 per kg six months prior |