Key Takeaways
- PAT nearly doubled, driven by coal and Mundra: PAT grew 85% YoY in Q2 and 87% YoY in H1, powered by strong performance across generation, hydro, coal, and coal mines on the back of high coal prices.
- Mundra is the swing factor: An interim CERC order ensured full fixed-cost recovery, with ₹461 cr recognized in the quarter; a final order on full coal cost pass-through is expected in November and could unlock material further upside.
- Solar EPC margins rebounded sharply: Margins improved sequentially as loss-making projects were deferred by mutual consent to capture falling module and steel prices, and a provision write-back from re-estimated costs provided a further lift.
- The growth capex cycle is fully underway: Work has started on the manufacturing facility, the NRSS transmission project, and a 1.8 GW renewable pipeline; management expects to hold net debt ratios steady despite this spend.
- What to watch next quarter: The CERC final order on Mundra coal pass-through, the pace of old receivable liquidation, and whether the solar EPC margin recovery sustains without further provision write-backs.
Mundra: The Regulatory Overhang Nears Resolution
- Interim order delivered full fixed-cost recovery: The CERC interim order required states not scheduling power to pay fixed costs because availability was demonstrated; Gujarat had been paying only ₹0.70 paisa per unit, so the reversal of the ₹0.20 paisa difference was booked in Q2.
- Total recognition included a prior-period catch-up: Of the ₹461 cr recognized in the quarter, ₹151 cr pertained to the previous quarter, making the underlying run-rate lower than the headline number suggests.
- Final CERC order on coal pass-through is imminent: Management expects the order in November; the principle is near-about cost pass-through, and once the principles are laid, final discussion and negotiation with Gujarat will take place around that framework.
- Competitiveness strengthens the negotiating position: Even with the present pass-through cost, the plant is still very competitive in Gujarat compared to alternatives at much higher prices, so management expects Gujarat will want to schedule power from it.
- Section 11 extension provides a bridge: The existing arrangement has been extended to 31st December 2022; management expects Gujarat will have similar power requirements next year and during summer, and will come to some arrangement to continue supply.
- Management declined to quantify the potential upside: Asked for the gap between interim and final tariff, or a separate Mundra profit breakup, management said it is premature and complicated, and asked investors to wait for complete clarity before the next quarter call.
Management: "It's kind of not entirely appropriate in giving you a breakup because it's a bit complicated now. And it's better to wait for the complete clarity to emerge. And I'm very sure before the next quarter call, we'll have a complete idea as to the exact under-recovery or to what extent we're losing or gaining."
Solar EPC: A Margin Rebound With Caveats
- Deferral of loss-making projects drove the recovery: Some projects were deferred by mutual consent with counterparties to benefit from falling cell, module, and steel prices (steel down 25%), which improved the margin profile of the remaining portfolio.
- Provision write-back provided a one-time lift: Re-estimation of cost-to-completion on the deferred projects resulted in a write-back of provisions, which boosted Q2 margins; management declined to quantify the write-back, citing many projects and various factors.
- Bidding discipline is returning to the industry: Bids are now coming in the ₹2.50 to ₹3.00 range depending on location, land availability, and generation profile, a sharp improvement from the earlier ₹1.99 to ₹2.00 levels that proved unviable; management sees more seriousness and credibility in the bidding process.
- Project execution timelines average 18 months: The typical range is 12 to 18 months, so the margin benefit from deferred projects will flow through over that horizon.
Management: "I think the players are the same. Only thing is what we are seeing is that the bids are coming at a much higher rates, unlike earlier when it went up to INR 1.99 and INR 2, they are now all in the range of INR 2.50 to INR 3... So I think there is much more seriousness and credibility that is coming in the bidding process rather than many who are coming and bidding a number which they are finding it difficult to reach."
Growth Capex: Manufacturing, Transmission, and Renewables
- Manufacturing facility is moving from planning to execution: Work has started at the site and ordering of main equipment has taken place; the first module is expected by July-August next year, and the first cell by December next year.
- Transmission portfolio is scaling: The company took over the South-East UP Power Transmission Company through the Resurgent platform during the quarter, and work has started on the NRSS transmission project; all projects are expected to be completed progressively over the next 6 to 12 months.
- Renewable capacity addition is accelerating: Management expects to add a large quantity of big projects across different parts of the country, including hybrid projects, not just pure solar or wind; most of the 1.8 GW under development will be commissioned by March 2024, with the timeline being 12 to 18 months.
- Rooftop solar and solar pumps are scaling rapidly: The rooftop business is expected to grow many times over the previous year based on the present order book; the company expects a major presence in most states with more than 80,000 solar pumps across India.
- Net debt ratios are expected to hold steady: Despite the large planned capex in renewable, transmission, and distribution, management expects to maintain net debt to EBITDA and net debt to equity at current levels going forward.
Distribution Business: Odisha Turnaround and Smart Meter Rollout
- Western Odisha Discom delivered strong performance: The improvement was driven by better AT&C loss reduction, billing efficiency, and collection efficiency; the Discom benefits from a higher proportion of industrial consumers driving consumption growth.
- Meter replacement is the operational backbone: Nearly 20 lakh legacy electromechanical meters have been replaced in Odisha, improving billing efficiency; results of this replacement program will start showing in subsequent quarters.
- Smart meter coverage is targeting near-universal reach: Management expects to cover virtually all customers in Delhi, Mumbai, and Odisha within the next three years.
- Legacy receivables are beginning to liquidate: Andhra Pradesh and other states have started paying in installments, including disputed amounts; management expects all old outstanding amounts will get liquidated in the next few quarters.
- Working capital quality remains intact: While receivables are elevated because energy costs and revenues are high, receivable days are well within control and the quality of debtors has not deteriorated; DSO and debtor aging remain in check.
Coal, Shipping, and the International Price Outlook
- International coal prices are expected to stay high: Management expects coal prices will remain elevated for at least the next 12 months as imported coal stays in demand as a global energy substitute; whether prices hold at present levels or come down slightly cannot be predicted.
- The shipping subsidiary swung to a loss on a one-time base effect: TERPL reported a ₹29 cr loss in Q2 FY23 versus a ₹214 cr profit in Q2 FY22, because the prior-year quarter included a one-time forex gain of approximately ₹200 cr from the sale of shipping assets.
- Shipping profitability will be determined by actual costs: Billing is based on the CRC Index; the final profitability will be known once the actual cost of shipping is determined.
Management: "Still as globally the coal prices have been very high. And we do not expect that it will reduce at least for next 12 months. So we expect that the coal prices will remain high. Now whether it will be at the present level or little lower than this, I cannot predict that."
EV Charging: Building Infrastructure Ahead of Demand
- The vision spans home, public, and bus charging: The objective is a seamless customer experience covering home chargers for personal vehicles, intracity public charging, and bus charging infrastructure for public transport.
- Business models vary by segment: Home chargers and bus charging operate on a cost-plus basis, while public chargers follow a fee or subscription model.
- Public charger utilization is low today: Most EV owners still use home chargers, and EV penetration has not yet reached scale; the company is creating infrastructure over the next two years in anticipation of demand catching up.
Management: "The consumption of that or the utilization of public chargers is much less today because most of the people still continue to use their home chargers. Also, the penetration of electric vehicle has not happened to that extent. So we are creating an infrastructure for that over the next two years."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Mundra CERC final order | Final order on full coal cost pass-through expected; principle is near-about cost pass-through | November 2022 |
| Mundra Section 11 arrangement | Existing arrangement extended; Gujarat expected to come to some arrangement to continue supply if not extended further | Current extension to 31 Dec 2022 |
| Manufacturing facility first output | First module from the plant | July-August 2023 |
| Manufacturing facility first cell | First cell from the plant | December 2023 |
| Renewable capacity commissioning | Most of 1.8 GW under development to be commissioned | By March 2024 |
| Transmission project completion | All projects to be completed progressively | Next 6–12 months |
| Smart meter coverage | Virtually all customers in Delhi, Mumbai, and Odisha covered | Next 3 years |
| Old receivable liquidation | All old outstanding amounts liquidated | Next few quarters |
| Net debt ratios | Net debt to EBITDA and net debt to equity maintained at current levels despite large planned capex | Going forward |
| International coal prices | Expected to remain high | At least next 12 months |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹14,163 cr, up 49% YoY from ₹9,502 cr |
| EBITDA | ₹2,043 cr, up 18% YoY from ₹1,732 cr |
| PAT | ₹935 cr, up 85% YoY from ₹506 cr |
| H1 FY23 Revenue | ₹28,939 cr, up 49% YoY from ₹19,076 cr |
| H1 FY23 EBITDA | ₹4,150 cr, up 1% YoY from ₹4,097 cr |
| H1 FY23 PAT | ₹1,890 cr, up 87% YoY from ₹971 cr |
| Net debt | ~₹39,000 cr, below ₹40,000 cr; net debt to equity improved to 1.32x from 1.55x QoQ |
| Net debt to underlying EBITDA | 3.5x, improved from 3.6x last quarter |
| Capital investment (H1 FY23) | More than ₹3,000 cr |
| Mundra fixed-cost recognition | ₹461 cr recognized in Q2, of which ₹151 cr pertains to previous quarter |
| Utility-scale renewable capacity | 5,660 MW total (3,870 MW operating, 1,790 MW under implementation) |
| Renewable projects won (Q2) | 850 MW |
| EPC order book | ~₹15,000 cr, nearly 3,800 MW |
| Rooftop capacity commissioned (Q2) | 138 MW |
| Rooftop orders won (Q2) | 330 MW, totalling ₹1,233 cr |
| Cumulative rooftop portfolio | ~1,150 MW |
| Solar pumps installed (Q2) | ~6,000, cumulative total ~17,000 |
| Public EV chargers added (Q2) | 722, total now more than 3,000 |
| Home chargers | ~23,000 |
| Smart meters installed | ~4 lakh across Delhi, Mumbai, Odisha |
| Dividend from subsidiaries to parent (Q2) | ~₹1,100 cr |
| Dividend from subsidiaries to parent (H1 FY23) | ₹1,800 cr |
| H1 FY23 net cash flow from operating activities | ₹2,148 cr, down from ₹2,412 cr in H1 FY22 |
| Average debt cost | ~7%, risen from ~6% YoY |