Key Takeaways
- 14th straight quarter of PAT growth: PAT hit INR939 crores, up YoY, with all businesses contributing and full-year PAT crossing INR3,810 crores.
- Mundra breathes easy under Section 11: The plant now runs with full cost pass-through, removing a major overhang, and the regime is expected to extend beyond its June expiry.
- Renewables pipeline is deep but back-end loaded: Nearly 6,600 MW of projects are in the portfolio, but 2,669 MW are still in implementation with a 12-18 month completion window.
- Disclosure pullback raises an eyebrow: Management stopped breaking out Mundra and coal profitability, citing competitive misuse, which drew pushback from analysts who valued the earlier transparency.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether Section 11 gets extended past June, the pace of renewable capacity commissioning, and any further simplification of financial disclosures.
The Mundra Overhang Lifts
- Section 11 delivers full cost pass-through: The plant operates four of five units with all costs (coal, fixed costs, related costs) passed through, and management calls this the best-case scenario because it removes any recovery risk.
- Coal profit-sharing is limited: Only 30% of Tata Power's share of profit from KPC coal used at Mundra is passed to customers, and last year only about 15% of coal was sourced from KPC, so the impact is small.
- Extension expected: The current Section 11 directive runs to 15th June, but given past precedent and summer demand, management expects it to be extended to September or October.
- Receivables are manageable: Total Section 11 dues are about INR300-400 crores, with CERC ordering DISCOMs to pay 50%; net dues are not significant, LCs are held, and INR150-odd crores was received in April.
Praveer Sinha: "Yes, absolutely. Because Section 11 gives me a full pass-through of the cost without any issues."
Renewable Scale-Up: Ambition Meets Execution Timeline
- Portfolio is large but completion is back-ended: Of nearly 6,600 MW of renewable projects, 3,927 MW is installed and 2,669 MW is in implementation, with completion expected in the next 12 to 18 months.
- Solar EPC order book provides visibility: The order backlog stands at INR17,000 crores, representing 4 GW of projects, giving a multi-quarter runway.
- Rooftop solar is a breakout business: The company installed nearly 300 MW in Q4 alone, won 400 MW of new orders, and did 718 MW for the full year with revenue of nearly INR2,770 crores; the cumulative portfolio exceeds 1,600 MW, making it the largest in the market.
- Module manufacturing economics still work: When the plant was planned, module costs were $0.18 with 40% basic customs duty; current prices are $0.21-$0.22, so returns remain very good. The module line is expected by September-October, the cell line by year-end.
- One-off masked renewable revenue growth: Reported renewable revenue declined YoY only because last year included a one-off regulatory gain of about INR350 crores in revenue and INR182 crores in PAT; stripping that out, the business grew.
Distribution Turnaround: Odisha Is Cleaning Up
- AT&C losses fell sharply across all four Odisha DISCOMs, and PAT from the Odisha business rose nearly 30% in the quarter, with full-year PAT of nearly INR253 crores.
- Collections ran ahead of billing: Q4 collections hit 140-150% and full-year collections exceeded 100%, as old outstanding was largely cleared through ECL provisions and cleanup of billing records where customers no longer existed.
- Clean-up costs are now behind: The profit reported already absorbs these one-off cleanup items, so from next year no such impact is expected, and management says the real profit from Odisha will become visible.
Financial Health: Debt Down, Investment Up
- Debt reduced by INR2,800 crores in the quarter to INR35,328 crores, driven by healthy operating performance, equity infusion by a strategic partner, and working capital release.
- FY24 investment target set at INR12,000 crores, split roughly into INR3,000 crores for manufacturing, INR4,500 crores for renewables, and the balance for transmission, distribution, and FGD capex; most will be funded from internal accruals and operating profit.
- Other income spike is largely non-recurring: Other income jumped to INR870 crores from INR259 crores in Q4 FY22, driven by a INR512 crore dividend from the Arutmin mine sale and a INR183 crore one-off positive item, partially offset by a INR100-odd crore logistics penalty and INR232 crores of Tata Projects losses.
- Tata Projects stake diluted, profitability expected: Tata Sons infused INR1,500 crores, reducing Tata Power's stake from 48% to 31%; against a full-year loss of INR480 crores in FY23, management expects some profit from Tata Projects in FY24.
- Credit rating upgraded: S&P Global Ratings lifted Tata Power's consolidated rating from BB to BB+ and standalone rating from BB- to BB, both with stable outlook.
Sanjeev Churiwala: "I think Tata projects kind of looks like have been able to clean up a lot of past losses, legacy losses... we are looking forward to Tata projects making some profit in F '24. So against a loss that we have booked of INR480 crores in F '23 full year, we are expecting some profit to come in next year."
Disclosure Pullback: Less Granularity on Coal and Mundra
- Coal profitability and Mundra operating parameters are no longer broken out, a deliberate change management says is to prevent numbers being misused by competition; the data is now folded into consolidated JV profits and Tata Power's own results.
- Analysts pushed back, noting the disclosures had been provided for several quarters and that Tata Power was known for strong transparency; management offered to share details offline via email but stood by the simplified presentation.
- TPSSL revenue declined because the company was selective in executing projects, deferring those where module costs were higher, a decision that protected margins and allows benefit from lower costs in future periods.
Sanjeev Churiwala: "Yes, you're right, Girish, but we don't want the number to be misused by the competition on the..."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Module manufacturing line ready | Module line operational | September-October 2023 |
| Cell manufacturing line ready | Cell line operational | By end of calendar 2023 |
| Renewable projects completion | Balance 2,669 MW in implementation completed | Next 12-18 months |
| Tata Projects profitability | Some profit expected vs INR480 cr loss in FY23 | FY24 |
| Odisha profitability clean-up | No further impact from one-off cleanup items; real profit visible | From FY24 onward |
| FY24 investment | INR12,000 crores, mostly from internal accruals | FY24 |
| Arutmin transaction closure | Remaining $27-28 million received | "Very soon" |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹56,000 cr (full year), +32% YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹3,101 cr, +38% YoY |
| EBITDA (full year) | ~₹10,000 cr, first time crossing this mark |
| PAT | ₹939 cr, higher than last year |
| PAT (full year) | ₹3,810 cr |
| Net debt | ₹35,328 cr, reduced by ~₹2,800 cr in the quarter |
| Other income | ₹870 cr, up from ₹259 cr in Q4 FY22; includes ~₹512 cr dividend from Arutmin and a net one-off positive of ₹183 cr |
| Share of profit from JVs and associates | ₹179 cr, fell sharply from the first three quarters of FY23; includes ~₹200 cr loss from Tata Projects |
| Renewable capacity installed | 3,927 MW; total portfolio 6,600 MW with 2,669 MW under implementation |
| Renewable order backlog (EPC) | ₹17,000 cr, comprising 4 GW of projects |
| Rooftop solar installations (Q4) | ~300 MW; new orders of 400 MW won in the quarter |
| Rooftop solar installations (full year) | 718 MW, with revenue of ~₹2,770 cr |
| Rooftop solar order backlog | ~468 MW, worth ~₹1,900 cr |
| Solar pumps installed (cumulative) | ~97,000, with ~4,000 installed in Q4 |
| EV chargers (public and semi-public) | 3,778; plus ~39,000 home chargers |
| Odisha DISCOMs PAT (full year) | ~₹253 cr, with Q4 PAT up ~30% YoY |
| Odisha DISCOMs collection efficiency (Q4) | 140% to 150%; full year collection >100% |
| FY24 capex guidance | ~₹12,000 cr, including ~₹3,000 cr for manufacturing, ~₹4,500 cr for renewables, and ~₹3,000–3,500 cr for T&D |
| Tata Projects stake dilution | 48% to 31% in April 2023, following ₹1,500 cr equity infusion by Tata Sons |