Key Takeaways
- SDA collapse drove a 17% YoY revenue drop, but the other three segments grew ~60% vs their FY22 quarterly average, showing the underlying portfolio is not broken.
- SDA demand is expected to return in a phased manner: marginal improvement in Q2, stronger orders already booked for Q3, and full normalization from Q4, with management guiding FY23 SDA revenue at roughly 90% of FY22 levels.
- PTC hit its highest-ever quarterly revenue at ₹40.3 crore, up 79% YoY, driven by a new MNC customer and logistics investments that captured ~80% of that customer's volumes.
- Margins compressed on mix and a one-off forex loss: reported EBITDA margin fell to 17%, but excluding a ₹4.97 crore MTM forex loss, operational EBITDA was 23%, within management's sustainable range of 22–27%.
- What to watch next quarter: whether the promised Q2 SDA order improvement materializes, the pace of new product commercialization (flame retardant plant trial, metal extraction orders), and Dahej capacity expansion staying on schedule despite a 21-day construction strike.
SDA: The Demand Shock and Recovery Path
- The mechanics of the collapse: end-customers in Zeolites saw sales drop to 30–40%, stretching 6-month inventory to 15 months of cover, which caused them to stop buying completely even though their underlying business continued at reduced levels.
- Semiconductor and China linkages: the chip shortage and COVID lockdowns in China were the root causes; management expects the semiconductor shortage to ease by October/November 2022, with customers intending to resume smaller purchases from August/September.
- Phased recovery underway: marginal improvement expected in Q2 FY23, with "much more decent orders already being punched in for Q3"; one large Chinese customer expects demand to restart by November/December, though lockdowns make that unconfirmed.
- FY23 SDA revenue guide: management expects to end the year with SDA revenue maybe 10% below FY22, with Q3 and Q4 strongly covering up; Q4 is expected to be "fully functional as earlier."
- New SDA demand levers: a newly approved large customer has a full-scale plant trial confirmed for December 2022, with commercial supplies in FY24; a new SDA-based Zeolites catalyst for plastic waste recycling has been developed and is entering commercialization, expected to be another large-volume application.
Chintan Shah: "Let us hypothetically assume someone is carrying an inventory of six months and your sales is at 100% levels for which you are maintaining an inventory of 6 months. Now your sales for the Zeolites have dropped to almost 30%. So, your inventory which was hypothetically for six months has gone up to almost 15 months now. So typically, you stop buying the products completely though your business is running at 30%-40% levels."
Non-SDA Portfolio: Growth Engines Firing
- PTC delivered a record quarter: revenue of ₹40.3 crore, up 79% YoY, driven by commercial sales from a recently approved MNC and logistics investments (stocking inventory in Europe) that captured ~80% of that customer's business volumes.
- PTC growth is not repeatable at this rate: management cautioned that the 60% jump reflects previously constrained potential now being fully realized, and similar growth should not be expected next year for the PTC category.
- Electrolyte Salts exceeded full-year FY22 revenue in one quarter: Q1 revenue of ₹6.9 crore surpassed the entire FY22 figure of ₹5.68 crore, driven by rising commercial application of super capacitor and sodium/zinc ion batteries, plus a newly approved customer for energy storage devices.
- Energy storage trajectory accelerating: management sees applications being picked up "quite fast" and expects a robust future for the segment, noting things are moving faster than anticipated, though material contribution is not expected this year or next.
- PASC grew 28% YoY: full-scale commercialization of one product has begun with incremental volumes expected over the next few years; a new product for metal extraction has been formally approved with commercial supplies starting Q4 FY23.
- Non-SDA revenue baseline: management expects to continue with the Q1 average of ~₹80 crore per quarter across the three non-SDA segments for the remaining three quarters, implying ₹300–320 crore for FY23 from these categories.
Chintan Shah: "This is something exceptional at a rate because this is showing that we were compromising somewhere and now we are giving the full potential. So I would not say that in next financial year again we will see a 60% growth in this PTC particular category."
New Product Pipeline: Commercialization Milestones Stacking Up
- Flame retardants entering plant-scale trials: pilot trials successfully completed, special storage tanks installed, safety audit done; the first full-scale plant trial was starting the week of July 25, 2022, at a scale of 50–60 metric tons per month.
- Metal extraction product approved: a new PASC product for metal extraction has been formally approved by the customer; orders for one container each received, with commercial supplies to begin from October 2022, and full-scale commercialization expected December 2022 or January 2023.
- Zeolite-based catalyst for plastic recycling: development complete, piloting currently underway in the plant; expected to be another large-volume application area pushing SDA demand to the next level.
- MonoGlyme continuous flow process: pilot-stage equipment using continuous flow chemistry to be installed in Q2 FY2023, trials to begin soon; commercialization expected about eight to nine months post pilot trials.
- Continuous flow intermediate product: pilot plant and full-scale plant to become operational by end of Q3 at Dahej.
- Two more energy storage customers in the approval process across different geographies.
Chintan Shah: "We see that these applications for the energy storage systems is now being picked up quite fast and we expect this segment definitely I would not say in this very year or in next year, but we see a very robust future for this particular segment. So, things are moving faster than what we were anticipating."
Margins: Mix, Forex, and Tax Headwinds
- Reported vs operational EBITDA: reported EBITDA margin fell to 17% from 25% YoY, but excluding a ₹4.97 crore MTM forex loss on forward contracts (due to rupee depreciation from ~₹75 to ~₹80), operational EBITDA margin was 23%.
- Forex loss is an opportunity cost, not operational: management clarified that had they not hedged, profit would have been higher by ~₹5 crore; the loss is a book entry from mark-to-market on hedges.
- Product mix impact: the sharp drop in high-margin SDA sales (from 52% of revenue to 7%) changed the mix, compressing margins even on an operational basis.
- Tax rate increased: PAT margin fell to 11% from 22% YoY, partly because the Dahej SEZ facility moved from a 100% tax holiday to a 50% tax holiday starting Q1 FY23, and partly because more profit came from the non-export-oriented Ankleshwar unit since SDA was not running.
- Sustainable margin range: management stated 22–27% EBITDA is sustainable in the longer run, implying the current operational margin of 23% sits at the low end of that band.
- Freight and raw material relief emerging: in the past few weeks, reduction in freight costs observed and prices for certain raw materials are stabilizing.
Capacity, Capex, and Inventory
- Dahej expansion on track despite disruption: additional facilities at Dahej SEZ are on schedule with a target to commission by end of Q3 FY23; a 21-day strike in construction material availability across Gujarat was absorbed, and management is "absolutely sure" of completing the project by end of November.
- Capacity target: 3,000 metric tons.
- Capex outlook: after the current project completes, no major capex is expected in the next financial year (FY23); environmental clearance has been applied for (12–15 month process), with significant capex likely only in 2024.
- High inventory is strategic: management holds inventory that can run through at least one full quarter of full demand because SDA demand arrives in large volumes and being out of stock means losing the opportunity.
- Capacity fungibility: PTCs, electrolyte salts, PASC, and flame retardants all use multi-purpose fungible facilities; only SDA requires an absolute dedicated setup, which is why Dahej SDA capacity is currently ~90% unutilized.
- Flame retardant capex is modest: at 5,000 metric ton levels, special storage tanks require only about ₹3–3.5 crore.
Chintan Shah: "Most of the people have been asking me why you are running on such high inventories, but now this is the precise question that you have asked and this is absolutely the reason why we are running on such high inventories all the time because when there is a demand coming in from customers on SDAs it is always coming in larger volumes. So, unless and until you have this inventory you will not be able to take up that opportunity."
Demand Environment by Geography and Segment
- US demand in strong mode: management noted better demand from the US, while Europe is increasing but not as strong.
- SDA demand recovery timeline: customers intend to start buying at smaller levels from August/September 2022; semiconductor shortage expected to ease by October/November; full-scale demand expected from December 2022.
- One large Chinese customer still uncertain: expects demand to begin by November/December, but this is not yet confirmed due to ongoing lockdowns; once that kicks in, the business returns to a full-scale demand structure.
- Energy storage picking up faster than anticipated: while not material this year or next, the segment's trajectory is accelerating, with applications for energy storage systems gaining traction.
Chintan Shah: "Q3 can be a lot better and Q4 will be fully functional as what we have been doing earlier."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| SDA demand recovery | Marginal improvement in Q2; stronger orders already booked for Q3; full normalization from Q4 | Q2–Q4 FY23 |
| FY23 SDA revenue | Roughly 90% of FY22 SDA revenue, with Q3 and Q4 strongly covering up | FY23 full year |
| Non-SDA revenue baseline | ~₹80 crore/quarter sustained across remaining three quarters; ₹300–320 crore for FY23 from three non-SDA segments | Q2–Q4 FY23 |
| Dahej capacity expansion | Commissioning by end of Q3 FY23, targeting 3,000 metric tons; on schedule despite 21-day construction strike | End of Q3 FY23 (November) |
| Flame retardant plant trial | First full-scale plant trial starting week of July 25, 2022 | Q2 FY23 (immediate) |
| Metal extraction product commercialization | Full-scale commercialization after plant trial approvals | December 2022/January 2023 (Q4 FY23) |
| Large SDA customer plant trial | Full-scale plant trial confirmed; commercial supplies to follow | December 2022 (trial); FY24 (commercial) |
| MonoGlyme continuous process | Pilot trials in Q2 FY23; commercialization ~8–9 months post trials | Q2 FY23 (pilot); ~Q4 FY23/Q1 FY24 (commercial) |
| Continuous flow intermediate product | Pilot and full-scale plant operational at Dahej | End of Q3 FY23 |
| Sustainable EBITDA margin | 22–27% range | Longer run |
| Next major capex cycle | Environmental clearance expected by end of 2023; significant capex likely in 2024 | 2024 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue from operations | ₹88.4 cr, decline of 17% YoY vs ₹106.8 cr |
| EBITDA | ₹15.2 cr, decline of 42% YoY vs ₹26.3 cr |
| Operational EBITDA (excl. forex loss) | ₹20.17 cr, translating to operational EBITDA margin of 23% |
| EBITDA margin | 17% vs 25% in Q1 FY22; includes forex loss of ₹4.97 cr |
| Net profit after tax | ₹9.8 cr, decline of 58% YoY vs ₹23.1 cr |
| PAT margin | 11% vs 22% in Q1 FY22 |
| Exports | ₹56.4 cr, contributing 64% of total revenue |
| PTC revenue | ₹40.3 cr, historically highest quarterly revenue, 46% of total revenue, growth of 79% YoY |
| PASC revenue | ₹34.5 cr, 39% of total revenue, growth of 28% YoY |
| Electrolyte Salts revenue | ₹6.9 cr, 8% of total revenue; exceeded FY22 full-year revenue of ₹5.68 cr in this quarter alone |
| SDA revenue | ₹5.96 cr, 7% of total revenue, decline of 89% YoY; contributed 52% of revenue in Q1 FY22 |
| Non-SDA combined revenue (PTC, Electrolyte Salts, PASC) | ₹81.8 cr, growth of nearly 60% vs FY22 quarterly average of ₹51.5 cr |
| SDA demand revival expectation | Full demand revival beginning Q4 FY23; marginal improvement in Q2, orders placed for Q3 |
| FY23 SDA revenue guidance | ~10% reduction vs FY22 (₹224.8 cr in FY22), per management expectation |
| FY23 non-SDA revenue guidance | ₹300 to ₹320 cr from PTC, Electrolyte Salts, and PASC combined |
| Sustainable EBITDA margin range | 23% to 27%, per management |
| Tax rate (company level) | 18% to 20%; Dahej SEZ now at 50% tax holiday (down from 100% in prior years) |
| Capacity expansion (Dahej SEZ) | 200 kl additional reaction capability, targeting commissioning by end of Q3 FY23; total capacity ~480 kl post-expansion |
| Flame retardant plant capacity | 5,000 metric tons; plant-scale trial beginning in the week of July 25, 2022 |
| IPO proceeds utilized | ₹83.25 cr out of net proceeds of ₹207.2 cr as of June 30, 2022 |