Key Takeaways
- Profitability surged on mix and margin gains: PAT grew 293% Y-o-Y to INR11.4 crores, driven by a 342 bps gross margin jump and a richer diamond-studded product mix.
- Gold demand hit by price, diamond shines: Gold jewellery demand declined over 8% as high prices bit, while the diamond business grew 20%, lifting its revenue share to 25%.
- Kalpavruksha scheme revamped to drive loyalty: A new consumer-friendly version with flexible exit options launched, aiming to deepen the recurring customer base.
- Franchise push is real but unsized: Management is in active discussions and hopes to open a few stores around Diwali, though it declined to fix an annual store addition target.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the promised gold demand revival materializes in the wedding season, the pace of franchise store signings, and if the 25% diamond mix can hold or inch higher.
Profitability & Margin Drivers
- Gross margin leap: The 342 bps Y-o-Y improvement to 13.9% came from a combination of gold price benefits, a shift in product mix toward higher-margin diamonds, and better sourcing margins in both diamond and gold categories.
- Mix shift to diamonds: The diamond revenue ratio increased to 25%, up from a lower base, and management is committed to pushing this ratio further, with significant work underway to grow the diamond studded share.
- Cost discipline holds: Management emphasized cautious cost optimization, stating costs may not increase in the same proportion as revenue, which helped convert the gross margin gain into a 243 bps EBITDA margin improvement.
- Margin sustainability signal: Gross margin printed at 14.2% in Q4 FY23 and 13.9% in Q1 FY24; management expects this 13-14% range to be sustainable and to only increase from here.
- ROE trajectory improving: ROE has stayed above 10% for three consecutive quarters, supported by margin improvement and inventory rationalization, with gold inventory down 5-7% QoQ. Management expects ROE to be "much better" going forward.
Sharma: "I do believe that, it may not be up to your expectation. But yes, we are continuously working towards it. And we are hopeful that, the next year or so, we should be able to be placed among the right valuated companies."
Demand & Product Mix Dynamics
- Gold: price shock, then normalization: Gold jewellery demand declined more than 8% in Q1 as consumers reacted to higher prices, leaving gold revenue flat. Management sees this as temporary, citing a historical pattern where demand settles at the new price level and then picks up, as seen during COVID when prices jumped 50-60%.
- Diamond: 20% growth on trust: The diamond business grew over 20% in Q1, driven by consumer trust in TBZ's designs and pricing. Management stated demand for natural diamonds is intact and increasing.
- Lab-grown diamonds dismissed: The company does not deal in lab-grown diamonds and will not enter the business, seeing no threat from the category. Management believes Indian consumers do not believe in lab-grown diamonds and that "the love for the diamond will never fade."
- Mix commitment with a caveat: Management believes the 75% gold / 25% diamond mix can be maintained with 1-2% variation, and is committed to the diamond ratio going up. When pressed, it acknowledged the ratio is hard to predict but reiterated the directional intent.
Sharma: "We don't see it a threat. See, diamond is a diamond, however much lab-grown. In India, it hasn't picked-up also. Indian consumers do not believing in the lab-grown diamond. So the love for the diamond will never fade. That's our belief. And we are not going to get into this business at all."
Customer Acquisition & Loyalty
- New customer engine firing: 45% of Q1 customers were new, driven by the brand's aspirational value, festival-related value angles, the Kalpavruksha scheme, digital leads, and social media followers.
- Kalpavruksha revamp as a moat: The scheme was made more consumer-friendly with additional exit options from the fifth instalment onwards, allowing customers to enter and exit at their own convenience. Management believes this flexibility is unique in the market.
- Footfall tracking is granular: Every store has security-counted footfall documented under various categories and fed into the company's IT system, though the manual method counts one person even if they walk in four times during the day.
Sharma: "Lot of more exit options we have given to our consumers. So they can enter into Kalpavruksha, they can exit at their own convenience from the fifth instalment onwards, which I don't think so there is any in the market."
Store Network & Expansion
- Franchise model taking shape: A couple of franchise discussions are ongoing, with management hopeful for a few store openings around the Diwali season. The long-term idealistic scenario is a 50-50 split between own stores and franchise, but no specific number is fixed currently.
- Own-store strategy is relocation-led: Over the last 2-3 years, the focus has been on backend improvements, margin enhancement, and efficiency, shifting a few stores to new locations within the same city by closing old ones and opening fresh ones, which yielded positive results.
- No geographic focus declared: When asked about specific geographies for expansion given the company's sub-scale presence, management stated there is no specific geography, demand is across India, and expansion depends on capital and returns.
- Mix of formats ahead: Future expansion will be a mix of company-owned and franchise stores, with the search on for newer markets or locations in the same city. Own stores are not ruled out even as the franchise network grows.
Sharma: "See, in the idealistic scenario in any retail business it would be a 50-50, of own stores and the franchise network. But I am not fixing any number as of now."
Sourcing & Inventory
- Gold jewellery sourcing is design-led: Gold jewellery sourcing is a mix of TBZ's in-house gold order department working on designs, for which the brand is known, and vendors coming up with designs.
- Raw material strategy unchanged: There is no change in the raw material sourcing strategy, though continuous improvement in jewellery sourcing occurs.
- Inventory rationalization underway: Gold inventory is down around 5-7% quarter-on-quarter, part of a working capital rationalization effort that feeds into the ROE improvement story.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue growth | 15% to 20% growth | FY24 |
| PAT margin | Above 2.5%, with gold price challenges acknowledged as potential pressure | FY24 |
| Gross margin range | 13-14% sustainable, expected to only increase | Ongoing |
| Diamond mix | Maintain 25% ratio, committed to the ratio going up | Ongoing |
| ROE | Continue above 10%, "much better" than current number | Coming quarters |
| Franchise stores | A few stores opening | Around Diwali |
| Valuation placement | Placed among "right valuated companies" | Next year or so |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | Flat in gold business; overall revenue growth outlook 15% to 20% for FY24 |
| Gross profit | ₹ not stated, +30.7% YoY |
| Gross margin | 13.9%, +342 bps YoY; Q4 FY23 was 14.2% |
| EBITDA | ₹32.2 cr, +72.6% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | Not stated as a percentage, +243 bps YoY |
| PAT | ₹11.4 cr, +293% YoY |
| PAT margin | 2.5% (FY23 actual); FY24 outlook above 2.5% |
| Product mix (gold vs diamond) | 75:25 (gold:diamond), vs historical 80:20 |
| Diamond business growth | >20% YoY in Q1 |
| Gold jewellery demand | Declined >8% in Q1 per World Gold Council, due to higher prices |
| New customer acquisition | 45% of customers were new in Q1 |
| Marketing spend | ~1.8% of revenue on a yearly basis |
| Store count | No new stores added; franchise discussions underway, possible openings around Diwali |
| Store capex | ₹2–2.5 cr for a 2,500 sq ft store on average |
| ROE | >10% in each of the last three quarters |
| Gold inventory | Down 5–7% QoQ |
| Promoter stake | 75%, maximum permitted by SEBI |