Key Takeaways
- Profitability over revenue, deliberately: Revenue declined as management cut low-margin corporate sales and gold prices surged, but gross profit rose 13.5% YoY and EBITDA margins expanded.
- The margin reset is working: Product mix optimization and cost-cutting drove a 17.31% YoY gross profit jump in 9M FY24, and management expects EBITDA margins to sustain above 6.5% going forward.
- A pivot back to growth is coming: After two years of profitability focus, FY25 will target both revenue and profitability, with same-store sales growth guided at 15% to 20%.
- Franchisee model is the new store engine: Two FOFO stores are in the pipeline for late Q4 or early Q1, with 5 to 8 more expressions of interest under active negotiation, while own-store openings stay opportunistic.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the January traction converts into the promised good Q4, the pace of FOFO store signings, and any concrete FY25 revenue ambition beyond the same-store target.
Profitability Reset & Margin Story
- Revenue degrowth was engineered: Management deliberately cut low-profit corporate sales, while a post-Diwali gold price surge reduced the quantum of gold sold, and a 15-day shift in the marriage season pulled some demand out of the quarter.
- Gross profit surged despite the top line: Gross profit rose 13.5% YoY in Q3 and 17.31% in 9M FY24, driven by product mix optimization toward higher-margin studded jewellery and internal supply chain efficiencies.
- Diamond studded share climbing: The diamond studded jewellery mix improved from 20% to 23% YoY in Q3, supporting the margin uplift.
- Cost discipline is structural: EBITDA margin expansion came from cost-cutting measures embedded into operations, not one-off gains, and management expects the improvement to be sustainable into the next financial year.
- Supply chain work is real but opaque: Internal supply chain optimization initiatives contributed to the gross profit improvement, though management declined to detail the specific changes, calling it "very difficult to answer."
Store Strategy: FOFO First, Own Stores Opportunistic
- Franchisee-owned stores are the priority: Management is placing more focus on the FOFO model, with two stores under process and expected to open in the latter part of Q4 FY24 or early Q1 FY25.
- A pipeline is building: Five to eight FOFO expressions of interest are under active negotiation, and management expects momentum to build through FY25.
- Own stores stay selective: Management declined to commit to any number of new COCO stores, saying it will open them only if the right opportunity arises, and explicitly refused to deny or confirm any analyst estimate.
- The Vapi experiment is working: The new Vapi GIDC store, a smaller-format experiment, is already profitable and seeing good traction, validating the leaner store model.
Sharma: "We want a profitable market share, rather than opening store every nooks and corner of the country. So we are very selective that way. And we believe we'll have a robust growth rather than opening stores everywhere."
Demand & Gold Price Dynamics
- Wedding season held up better than feared: Demand during the wedding season was flattish due to high gold prices, but the outcome was not as bad as management had initially worried.
- January traction signals a good Q4: Management reported a YoY increase in January and expects the positive trend to carry through the fourth quarter.
- Gold price sensitivity is the wildcard: The surge in gold prices after Diwali directly reduced the quantum of gold sold, a dynamic that remains outside the company's control and could swing demand in either direction.
- Macro backdrop is supportive: Management sees the Indian economy on an upward trajectory and expects revenue growth and momentum to continue, with no election-related impact anticipated unless policy changes materialize.
FY25 Pivot: Revenue Returns to the Agenda
- Two years of margin repair are done: FY23 and FY24 were dedicated to profitability improvement, with less focus on revenue. Management now believes enough work has gone into the margin structure to shift gears.
- FY25 will chase both revenue and profitability: The explicit commitment is to focus on both metrics in the coming year, correcting the deliberate revenue underemphasis of the past two years.
- Same-store growth is the anchor metric: Management guided to same-store sales growth of around 15% to 20%, even as it declined to provide an absolute revenue target for FY25, calling revenue guidance "difficult and tricky" in the jewellery sector.
- No revenue guidance, by design: When pressed for a ballpark FY25 revenue figure against an analyst estimate of approximately ₹2,300 crores for FY24, management refused, offering only the same-store growth target as a directional signal.
Sharma: "In FY '23, '24, we have more focused on the profitability. And less focus on the revenue side, which will get corrected in FY '24, '25, we would be focusing both on the revenue because a lot of work has already gone into the improvement of the margin."
Franchisee Economics & Unanswered Questions
- Franchisee margin model remains undefined: When asked for expected gross margins on franchisee stores, management gave a general answer about the model varying by region, inventory size and inventory turn, but provided no specific margin figure.
- Supply chain details stay internal: Management declined to elaborate on the specific supply chain changes driving the gross profit improvement, offering only a high-level acknowledgment that initiatives were taken.
- Own-store count is a black box: No commitment was made on the number of COCO stores planned for FY25, with management explicitly stating it would not comment on any number for the own-store side.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| EBITDA margin | Sustain above 6.5% | Immediate quarters and into next financial year |
| Same-store sales growth | 15% to 20% growth target | FY25 |
| Revenue focus | Shift to focus on both revenue and profitability, correcting FY23-FY24 underemphasis | FY25 |
| FOFO store openings | 2 stores under process | Late Q4 FY24 or early Q1 FY25 |
| FOFO pipeline conversion | 5 to 8 expressions of interest under active negotiation; momentum expected | FY25 |
| Q4 FY24 performance | Good traction in January with YoY increase; expect a good quarter | Q4 FY24 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ~₹2,300 cr expected FY24 close (per an analyst's math) |
| Gross profit | ₹292.33 cr, gross margin of 12.46% |
| Gross profit growth | 13.5% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 6.1%, up 77 bps YoY |
| 9M FY24 EBITDA margin | 5.98%, up 158 bps YoY |
| Gold to diamond ratio | 77:23, diamond share up 3 ppt YoY from 80:20 |
| Same-store sales growth target | 15% to 20% |
| New showrooms opened | 1 (Vapi, GIDC) |
| Franchisee expressions of interest | 5 to 8 under negotiation |
| Expected new FOFO stores | 2 in Q4 FY24 or early Q1 FY25 |
| EBITDA margin outlook | Above 6.5% in immediate quarters |