Key Takeaways
- Strong FY23, 20% growth guided for FY24: Revenue grew 30% YoY to INR2,394 crores in FY23, and management expects approximately 20% sales growth in FY24 on the current base.
- Profitability surged on operating leverage and gold tailwinds: Q4 FY23 EBITDA grew 96% YoY and PAT rose 363% YoY, helped by a 3.8% margin expansion as gold prices bottomed near Diwali and then rose.
- Gold price mechanics cut both ways: Rising gold prices boost margins on ~50% of owned inventory, but the other 50% held via Gold Metal Loan (GML) exposes the P&L to market fluctuation, a risk that intensifies if rates keep climbing.
- Franchise expansion is the new growth lever: Management is working on a few franchise-model proposals and hopes to open a couple of stores in Q2 and Q3 FY23, with the model structured so the franchisee shoulders most working capital investment.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the 20% FY24 growth guidance holds as gold prices fluctuate, the pace of gross margin expansion beyond 11.1%, and any concrete franchise store openings.
Financial Performance
- Top-line momentum: FY23 revenue of ₹2,394 crores represented 30% YoY growth, driven by sales growth across all categories and strength in both gold and diamond segments.
- Q4 profitability surge: Q4 FY23 EBITDA grew 96% YoY and PAT rose 363% YoY, attributed to operational efficiency improvements and margin optimization.
- Margin walk: Q4 FY23 saw 3.8% margin growth; FY23 EBITDA margin reached 4.8%, described as a combination of gold price bottoming near Diwali (when huge business occurred) and higher gold rates in Q4.
- Customer traction: FY23 witnessed ~25% YoY growth in walk-ins, totalling over 2.5 lakh, reflecting legacy dedication and ability to create resonating jewellery.
- Collections response: Q4 FY23 launch of collections (HUES, Svara, Navya, Kavya) received overwhelming response with over 50,000 units working.
Sharma: "We are very positive to maintain our sales growth momentum. We foresee approximately 20% sale growth in FY '24 on the current level. The margin side, which is we have already clocked 11.1% margin in FY '23, and we believe that there is a scope of further growth in the margin. And we are committed to working towards it."
Gold Price Dynamics & Margin Mechanics
- Gold price impact on margins: Rising gold prices have a positive impact on margins on ~50% of inventory (paid inventory); the other 50% on GML requires absorbing higher gold cost at current rates upon sale, which compresses margin on that portion.
- GML is not a hedge: The company works on a natural hedging principle where quantities bought and sold are matched at the same rate on the day of sale. GML is a lower-cost buying method, not a hedge: in a rising rate scenario it hits the P&L, in a falling rate scenario it adds to the P&L.
- Risk threshold: Management stated that normal gold price fluctuation of 5%, 10%, or 15% may not impact growth; only a huge fluctuation poses downside risk.
- Inventory churn masks long-term gold gains: Inventory continuously replaces via a buying and selling cycle, with older designs melted and remade into new designs, making it very difficult to pinpoint how much comes from paid inventory versus GML.
Sharma: "GML is not a hedging. GML is a way of buying, which has a very, very lesser cost of fund, okay? GML in a rising rate scenario, we actually — whatever you bought on the GML is open to market fluctuation. In case of rising rate scenario, it hits your P&L. In case of falling rate scenario. It adds to your P&L."
Balance Sheet & Working Capital
- Leverage improving: Debt Equity ratio rationalized from 0.95% to 0.86% YoY; debt described as well within limits with further scope to utilize debt in GML facilities.
- Finance cost pressure: Higher finance costs in FY23 resulted from a huge increase in interest rates over the last year plus higher working capital utilization due to volume increase.
- Cost-side response: A conscious effort is underway to use more GML facilities than cash credit to reduce funding cost, and management expects an easing in interest rates in FY24 which will bring down finance cost.
- Inventory focus: Maintaining reasonable inventory levels has been a key focus supporting growth objectives; key FY24 priorities include optimizing inventory levels and increasing stock turn.
Franchise Expansion
- Store opening timeline: Management is working on a few franchise-model proposals and is hopeful of opening a couple of stores in Q2 and Q3 of FY23.
- Model structures under discussion: Various models are being evaluated: 50-50 investment with margin distribution accordingly; franchisee investing 100% in inventory with the company investing in capex; or 100% capex with 100% inventory by the franchisee. Margin sharing will differ per scenario.
- Capital-light design: The majority of working capital investment is expected from the franchisee partner; positive EBITDA is foreseen without further working capital investment from the company side.
- Pipeline: A couple of strong prospects are in hand as of now.
Unanswered Questions & Pushback
- Long-term growth trajectory: An analyst asked about factors that hindered the company's growth over the last 5 years; management declined to comment on the last 5 years, redirecting to current FY23 performance.
- Gold price appreciation not visible in net worth: An analyst asked why gains from own inventory, given a multifold gold price increase over 7–10 years, are not visible in net worth or profits. Management explained inventory continuously replaces and older designs are melted, making it very difficult to pinpoint how much comes from paid inventory versus GML, but the core question of why cumulative gold price appreciation has not visibly boosted net worth or profits over the long term was not directly answered.
- Malabar Gold stake: An analyst asked about Malabar Gold's continuous buying in the shareholding pattern and whether there is any understanding. Management declined to comment beyond stating there is no understanding and no discussion at any level with Malabar.
Sharma: "No, we don't comment on this. I just want to clarify that there's no understanding. There's no discussion with Malabar, they are buying as a normal investor who buys from the market. From a company side, there's no discussion at whatsoever level absolutely with Malabar."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Sales growth | Approximately 20% sales growth on current (FY23) level | FY24 |
| Gross margin expansion | Scope for further growth in margin (both gross and EBITDA) beyond the 11.1% gross margin clocked in FY23; committed to working towards it | FY24 |
| Finance cost reduction | Expectation that FY24 will see an easing in interest rates, bringing down finance cost | FY24 |
| Franchise store openings | Hopeful of opening a couple of franchise-model stores | Q2 and Q3 FY23 |
| Gold price risk | Normal fluctuation of 5%, 10%, 15% may not impact growth; only huge fluctuation poses downside risk | Ongoing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Total revenue | ₹464 crores, up 7.7% YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹30.3 crores, up 96% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 6.5% |
| PBT | ₹13.3 crores, up 368% YoY |
| PBT margin | 2.9% |
| PAT | ₹11.3 crores, up 363% YoY |
| PAT margin | 2.42% |
| FY23 total revenue | ₹2,394 crores, up 30% YoY |
| FY23 EBITDA | ₹115 crores, up 58.9% YoY |
| FY23 EBITDA margin | 4.8% |
| FY23 PAT | ₹40 crores, up 132% YoY |
| FY23 gross margin | 11.1% (management stated this was the margin already clocked in FY23, with scope for further growth) |
| FY24 revenue growth guidance | approximately 20% over FY23 |
| Debt equity ratio | 0.86%, improved from 0.95% a year ago |
| FY23 walk-ins | over 2.5 lakh, approximately 25% YoY growth |
| Inventory on GML basis | approximately 50% of total inventory |
| Own inventory funded by own work | roughly ₹600 crores as of March (per an analyst's math, not confirmed by management) |
| Store expansion plan | a couple of franchise stores expected in Q2 and Q3 FY23 |