Key Takeaways
- Resilient quarter despite headwinds: Revenue grew 8% YoY driven by higher flexible packaging volumes and exports, offsetting subdued domestic demand and the pass-through of lower raw material prices.
- Margin expansion on better mix: EBITDA margin improved 64 bps YoY to 16.5%, supported by a favorable shift toward value-added packaging and exports, which carry structurally higher margins.
- Liquor de-cartonization is a contained drag: The liquor segment has declined to an insignificant level, with the impact from major brands phasing out cartons now fully absorbed since July/August of the prior year.
- Export engine is the standout performer: Exports outperformed the domestic business and are heading toward the same growth rates seen over the last three to five years, with initial entry into the US market opening a large new addressable opportunity.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the Innofilms value-added film ramp-up materializes in Q3 as guided, the pace of Creative Offset’s revenue scale-up, and any early traction in the newly opened US export channel.
Revenue Drivers & Volume Dynamics
- Volume offset lower realizations: Pricing per ton was lower due to raw material pass-through, but higher volume growth fully offset the decline to deliver the 8% top-line increase. Breaking out volume and price credibly is challenging because of product mix complexity.
- Flexible packaging led the quarter: Revenue growth was driven by higher sales volume from the flexible packaging division and exports, countering subdued domestic demand.
- Alcohol exclusion masks underlying strength: Excluding alcohol volumes, the carton industry would have had a very, very good quarter, per management.
- Value-added trend is structural: Embellishment and better-quality raw material adoption is an ongoing trend, with most brands upgrading most of the time, supporting year-on-year improvement.
- Volume outlook for the rest of the year: Volumes are expected to continue offsetting lower realization, similar to the pattern seen this quarter, as customers face no inflation to pass on.
Export Outperformance & US Entry
- Exports outperformed domestic business: The export segment did very well this quarter and generally carries a higher margin, which was the principal reason for robust margins in a declining domestic carton business.
- Growth trajectory intact: Export growth is currently heading toward the same rates seen over the last three to five years.
- US market entry is a new vector: TCPL has started initial exports into the US, a market it was never in before. Management describes it as a massive market but also a very tough operating environment due to distance and customer expectations.
- Double-digit export growth expected: Management affirmed an expectation of double-digit growth in the export business going forward.
Saket Kanoria: "Yes, we are looking at newer markets. We have now started initial exports into the US, that we were never doing and it represents a big opportunity as you know the US is a massive market. So, it is also a very tough operating market because of the distance and their expectations. So, early days, but if we can do a good job there, then I feel that we have a very big potential."
Margin & Profitability
- EBITDA margin improved 64 bps YoY to 16.5%: The improvement was supported by a more favorable product mix and proactive cost management.
- Export mix is the margin lever: Exports generally carry a higher margin, which was the principal reason for robust margins in a quarter where the domestic carton business declined.
- Management declined to give margin guidance: When asked if EBITDA margin could increase 50 bps every year for two to three years, management said it is very difficult to give guidance because margins depend on competitive factors, raw material, and product mix.
- Inventory loss is present but contained: Notional inventory loss always exists when raw material prices are falling, but the majority of the impact is already factored in because inventory is often covered for customers and pricing is reset after that inventory is utilized.
- Asset turn improvement is structural: Asset turn has increased due to older equipment being depreciated, more value-added packaging flowing through, and general inflation making base material values higher than five years ago. Management sees some further headroom from current utilization levels.
Saket Kanoria: "These questions have been asked to me in previous quarters also and my answer to this has always been that it is very difficult to give a guidance on what the margin would be, because it depends on so many factors, competitive factors, raw material, the product mix."
Capacity Expansion & Capex
- Two new lines on track: Installation of a new line at the Haridwar plant and establishment of a third line at the flexible packaging plant in Silvassa are both confirmed as on track.
- Haridwar line timeline: Expected to be commissioned toward the end of September or early October.
- New flexible line timeline: Expected in the latter part of Q3.
- Innofilms value-added film delayed to Q3: The line is operational but awaiting parts for the value-added film capability; parts are expected in the first half of next month, so the ramp-up impact will be felt in Q3, not Q2.
- Capex run-rate: Currently looking at approximately ₹100 crore capex this year, with no very significant plans currently but firming them up as they go along.
- Metallizer decision pending: Management has not yet taken a final call on installing a metallizer.
- TCPL Innofilms merger: TCPL Innofilms is being merged into TCPL Packaging.
Saket Kanoria: "We are already operational, it is not that the machine is shut or anything, but it is just that the value-added film is the problem and that we are waiting for these parts and no sooner do they come, we are hopeful that we can get going on it. So, the impact will be felt in the third quarter, not in the second quarter."
Creative Offset & Rigid Packaging
- Currently a margin drag: Creative Offset’s margin is very low due to high overhead relative to its small scale; the first priority is to expand revenue.
- Customer base is electronics-focused: Marquee customers include Samsung and other smaller mobile phone manufacturers, plus electronic equipment manufacturers for wearables, watches, and headphones.
- Ramp-up efforts underway: Management has expanded the marketing setup, is meeting new customers, has broadened the customer base, and has modernized the plant. The subsidiary is still losing money on a standalone basis.
- Revenue target not confirmed for this year: The ₹8–10 crore per month revenue goal was previously indicated as a strategic objective, but management cannot say if it will happen in the current financial year.
- Positive outlook on electronics growth: With growth in the electronics segment in India, management feels very well poised to capture part of it and describes the outlook as very positive.
- iPhone represents a future opportunity: Apple is serious about expanding in India and currently procures from its global vendor, but management believes Apple is likely looking at broad-basing, which could be a good future opportunity for companies like TCPL.
Saket Kanoria: "iPhone represents a huge opportunity, and Apple seems to be very serious about expanding its presence in India. So, far, they are procuring from their global vendor, but I'm sure that they are looking at broad basing that. So, in the future it could be a very good opportunity for people like us."
Balance Sheet & Capital Allocation
- Leverage has declined significantly: Debt has gone down significantly in ratio terms and current cash flows are quite comfortable.
- Not targeting zero-debt: Management thinks aiming for zero debt is not very wise and believes the company should carry some amount of debt.
- No immediate stock split or bonus: Management may consider it at a point but has no immediate plans, noting they do not think these things really work in the long run.
- Folding carton utilization has headroom: Utilization can go up to 90% at peak, but management cannot say when the current facility will reach optimum because this keeps changing.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Innofilms value-added film ramp-up | Parts expected in first half of next month; impact felt in Q3 | Q3 FY24 |
| Haridwar new line commissioning | Installation on track, commissioning expected | End of September / early October |
| New flexible packaging line (Silvassa) | Third line establishment on track | Latter part of Q3 |
| Export growth | Double-digit growth expected | Ongoing |
| Volume vs. realization dynamic | Volumes expected to offset lower realization | Rest of FY24 |
| Capex | Approximately ₹100 crore | FY24 |
| Near-term demand | Current and next quarter positive, order book not bad; festive season with late Diwali provides extra time | Q2-Q3 FY24 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹371 cr, up 8% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 16.5%, up 64 bps YoY |
| EBITDA growth | 13% YoY |
| PAT | ₹23.6 cr |
| Cash profit | ₹48.4 cr |
| Revenue CAGR (past two decades) | 18.4% |
| Folding carton capacity utilization | ~70%, slightly lower than previous quarter |
| Flexible packaging capacity utilization | 75% |
| Rigid packaging (Creative Offset) capacity utilization | less than 50% |
| Net working capital days | ~89 days |
| Capex guidance for FY24 | ~₹100 cr |
| FMCG customer volume growth | 3% to 5% |
| Folding carton peak utilization capacity | up to 90% |