Key Takeaways
- Subdued quarter, self-critical tone: Revenue grew ~5% YoY to ₹424.7 crore, but management called performance that of a "dead man walking" and set a far higher internal bar, unsatisfied despite improvement over prior years.
- Margins squeezed by costs and a notional forex hit: EBITDA margin dipped 50 bps YoY to 17.1%, while a ₹10 crore non-cash mark-to-market loss on unhedged euro debt dragged PBT.
- Chennai greenfield goes live: The new plant achieved production stability this quarter, depreciation began, and it opens a South India customer base the company was not previously tapping.
- Export weakness is cyclical, not structural: Slack in exports is attributed to end-consumer economic factors, not share loss; management expects recovery eventually but gave no timeline.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether domestic demand momentum sustains into the festive season, the pace of Chennai plant fill-up, and any resolution of U.S. tariff uncertainty that has stalled the China Plus One pipeline.
Demand Environment
- Domestic recovery taking hold: The domestic segment grew well this quarter after one to two years of sluggishness, and management sees still more room for demand to increase as the festive season begins.
- Export markets turned soft: Slack in the last few months is not a fundamental issue or share loss, but reflects overall economic factors at end consumers; management expects exports to come back eventually.
- Creative Offset unit improving: Demand is increasing from a very low base, with high double-digit growth continuing from last year; the unit is expected to turn positive this year on an improving job mix.
- Liquor decartonization hope, not a plan: The trend began during acute paperboard and ethyl alcohol inflation when controlled liquor pricing made the carton an easy cost to cut. Now that robust volume growth has settled, management hopes customers return to cartons to drive premiumization, but explicitly refuses to plan for it.
- U.S. tariff uncertainty a setback: The China Plus One trend had accelerated in the last six months with active movement to India; the tariff situation is a setback if unresolved, though management and the people they speak to view it as a temporary negotiating tactic.
Akshay Kanoria: "I think this is more like a negotiating tactic kind of thing. And eventually, things will settle at a more reasonable level. But the uncertainty is not helpful for anyone."
Chennai Greenfield & Capacity
- Plant operational, depreciation begun: The new greenfield facility achieved production stability this quarter on lease premises, with investment much lower than the ₹100 crore figure an analyst estimated; depreciation is fully in the system from Q1 FY26.
- South India customer access unlocked: Most of the plant's capacity will serve existing customers or small customers whose major requirements were in South India, which the company was not tapping earlier; only 10-20% will come from shifting production from other plants.
- Fill-up target is this financial year: The goal is to fill the first line ideally within FY26; real returns will come once two lines run at healthy utilization, but no further capex is foreseen this year.
- No flexible packaging addition planned: Management prefers to grow the existing flexible packaging facility to maximum potential before adding flexible lines in Chennai.
Margins & Financials
- EBITDA margin dipped 50 bps YoY: The 17.1% margin reflects higher fixed and variable costs alongside lower revenue growth.
- Forex loss is notional, but real in the quarter: A ₹10 crore mark-to-market loss on euro-denominated term loans hit PBT, driven by the euro strengthening against the rupee while the dollar did not, breaking the natural hedge assumption. The loss is taken in one quarter under Ind AS, while the gain from a stronger euro is realized over many quarters.
- Debt headroom preserved: Debt levels are stable at 1:1 or sub-1:1; the company has headroom to take on more debt for a good opportunity and is not averse to raising equity for a reasonably substantial one.
Strategy & New Initiatives
- Gravure facility on track: The gravure unit remains scheduled for the December quarter this year, with no new update.
- New segments under evaluation, quietly: The company is actively exploring synergistic and related or slightly unrelated fields but does not discuss them prematurely, and is very picky about strategic fit.
- Export market development is slow-burn: Sampling and pricing approval takes months, not weeks; the company is constantly exploring Southeast Asia, the Middle East, Africa and Europe, with very small penetration in all markets.
- Overseas plant case never closes: Management has repeatedly evaluated opening plants outside India, such as in the UAE, but has never been able to decide because the advantage seems to be in making in India and exporting; the business case must make a lot of sense and the operation must be run in a manner that justifies it.
Akshay Kanoria: "Yes, so we have looked at this in the past and we keep looking at it, but never able to decide one way or the other, because we feel that the advantage is to make in India and export, whereas if you are local, then you incur all the cost and disadvantage of being local. So, never able to square that circle."
Management Tone & Self-Assessment
- "Dead man walking" sets the internal standard: Management acknowledged that performance looks positive only against a few years of poor results, and the real benchmark is far higher; the company has "a long way to go" and must "start running."
- Candor on liquor hopes: When asked about a liquor carton recovery, management explicitly warned against projecting hopes onto reality and declined to give an answer that might mislead, calling it "a difficult one."
- Transparency boundaries are firm: Management repeatedly declined to provide export breakup by region, customer industry-wise sales splits, the euro loan value, specific capex guidance, and Middle East segment details, citing confidentiality.
Akshay Kanoria: "The dead man is walking now, so everything looks positive. But we have to start running. So, we have a long way to go. I am not happy although it looks very nice compared to a few years of poor performance. So, our standard is low."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Chennai plant first-line fill-up | Fill up the first line | Ideally this financial year (FY26) |
| Gravure facility commissioning | Facility to go live | December quarter this year |
| Long-term growth trajectory | Continue mid-teens to high-teens growth rate, if not exceed it | Ongoing, no endpoint stated |
| Capex trajectory | Typically ₹100-150 crore per year; debt stable at 1:1 or sub-1:1 | Similar trajectory expected |
| Creative Offset unit turnaround | Unit to turn positive | This year |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY26 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | ₹424.7 cr, almost 5% YoY growth |
| EBITDA | ₹72.6 cr |
| EBITDA margin | 17.1%, lower by 50 bps YoY |
| Forex loss (MTM on Euro loans) | ₹10 cr, reflected in finance cost |
| Capacity utilization | ~70% |
| Domestic volume growth | Encouraging, per management; domestic demand improved vs prior years |
| Export demand | Slack in recent months; no fundamental share loss, expected temporary |
| Chennai greenfield facility | Operationalized in Q1; depreciation commenced this quarter |
| Capex run-rate | ₹100–150 cr per year typical; average about ₹150 cr |
| Debt-to-equity ratio | 1:1 or sub-1:1, stable on a ratio basis |
| Paperboard raw material prices | Slight increase of a few percent in the quarter |
| Creative offset facility (acquired) | High double-digit growth in FY25, continuing into FY26; trajectory positive |
| Sale of material to TCPL Middle East (FY25) | ~₹450 cr, ~30% YoY increase |